4 ms·
could I resell just the part of a GPL distribution that did not include the source code? No. GPL software is copyrighted. Law (ie not contracts, actual acts an
by rmc 14y ago
could I resell just the part of a GPL distribution that did not include the source code?
No. GPL software is copyrighted. Law (ie not contracts, actual acts and laws) says you cannot distribute a copyrighted work unless you have permission of the copyright holder. In the case of the GPL, the copyright holder only gives you permission to distribute if you include the work under the GPL.
what license does that resold portion now fall under?
The GPL.
since Copyleft is derived from Copyright
In reality, copyleft is copyright. "Copyleft" is just a term to appear different. It is, legally, copyright, but giving people more than is commonly given (e.g. the permission to make derived works etc.)
A lot of confusion is from the mixing of copyright law and contract law. EULA-type "licences" are contract law, and you must agree to them, like a contract. The GPL, despite "licence" in it's name, is not a EULA-type licence, but merely a statement of what rights the copyright holder gives you. You do not have to click "I agree" to be bound by the GPL.
- pbhjpbhj 14y ago>The GPL, despite "licence" in it's name, is not a EULA-type licence // Sorta. A EULA is also a license from a copyright [license] holder. Resale of an item does not obviate copyright law. The creator (or successor in title or licensee) still holds the IP rights - they have only exhausted their right to control the particular copy instance that was sold. Thus a license like the GPL is still a valid part of the license of use for the copyright work. So for the GPL it means the same as it does for other lawful licenses applied by copyright holders, very little. You can resell a GPLed work but you can't modify it and strip the GPL from it or unilaterally alter the creator's license. In the same way the lawful terms in a EULA will still apply. You can't sell a work on to a third party and buy it back in order to somehow nullify license terms. IANA(IP)L