3 ms·
What actually is this circle-lang site, and who runs it? The main page seems to just redirect to example.com, and I don't recognize the name of the author.
by zahlman 2y ago
What actually is this circle-lang site, and who runs it? The main page seems to just redirect to example.com, and I don't recognize the name of the author.
- steveklabnik 2y agoCircle is a C++ compiler by Sean Baxter, with various extensions. One of those is an implementation of the Safe C++ proposal I’ve linked downthread.
- crote 2y agoDoes the Circle compiler see any real-world use? I keep hearing about it, but it seems like it is a one-person project which hasn't seen significant activity in about a year. On paper it does sound quite promising, but looking at the Github repo I can't help but shake the feeling that it is more talk than action. It seems to have basically been abandoned before it ever saw any adoption?
- pjmlp 2y agoAt least Circle is real, something that one can download, validate its ideas, what works, what does not. Most of the profiles being argued for C++ only exist in PDF form, there isn't a single C++ compiler where you can validate those ideas, but trust the authors, the ideas will certainly work once implemented.
- steveklabnik 2y agoIt’s not open source. The GitHub activity is purely for documentation. I don’t know about real world adoption, nor do I think it’s really about what I’m saying. The proposal was made public a few weeks ago. There hasn’t been much time for real world projects to adopt it, if that were even the goal. The point is that it does exist today, and you can try it out. It’s more than just a design on paper.
- catskul2 2y agoI'm surprised you've not heard of the author (Sean Baxter). He's pretty well known among people who are interested in c++ standards proposals. He single handedly wrote his own C++ front-end and then proceeded to implement a butt load of extensions which other members of the committees poo-pood as being to hard to implement in the compiler. Every couple of weeks he implements something new. He's a real joy to follow.
- zahlman 2y agoI'm familiar with C++ and used to use it a fair bit, but I'm way out of date with it. Python has been my primary language almost since I picked it up, nearly 20 years ago.