13 ms·
Higgs Boson Explained by Cartoon
- ColinWright 14y agoFound via midko's comment here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4193517 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4193517
- runn1ng 14y agoI still don't get it. I still don't get how they jumped from "We have this Higgs field" to "and hey, the field is a particle."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- retube 14y agowave-particle duality. All fields have an associated particle: e.g em field - the photon.
- runn1ng 14y agoo....k. So, there is one Higgs field in the world which belongs to one Higgs Bosson, and there are no more Higgs bossons in the world? Or does it mean that there are more Higgs fields in the world (and, thus, every particle can have a different mass depending on in which field it is) and there are therefore more Higgs bossons?
- nilaykumar 14y agoThere is a single Higgs field. But the Higgs field can be excited in many different places! Same for anything else, like an electron - that's why we say that two electrons are indistinguishable from each other. Fundamentally, they're made of the same "stuff": the electron field that permeates the universe. Particles get mass by "coupling" to the Higgs field. I.e. the excitations of the electron fields - electrons - interact with the excitations of the Higgs field - Higgs bosons. This, through a complicated process described by quantum field theory (that I don't admit to fully understand), gives the particle what we call mass. Different particles couple to the Higgs with different strengths, yielding various particle masses. The Higgs even couples to itself (rather incestuously), which is why it has mass!
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThis explains it well http://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_Boson http://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higgs_Boson
- nilaykumar 14y agoQuantum theory is based on the concept of wave-particle duality. Think of the ocean. The water as a whole is pretty wave-y and non-localized (i.e. it's not in one place). But the crests of the waves (the "excitations") can be thought of as particles because they're localized fairly well. So really all a Higgs boson is, is an excitation of the Higgs field.
- scott_s 14y agoOne page explanations written by physicists: http://www.fsc.ufsc.br/~marilena/higgs.htm http://www.fsc.ufsc.br/~marilena/higgs.htm edit: As the links are down, here they are from the Wayback Machine: http://web.archive.org/web/20080209000844/http://www.phy.uct.ac.za/courses/phy400w/particle/higgs1.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20080209000844/http://www.phy.uct... http://web.archive.org/web/20110724100137/http://www.phy.uct.ac.za/courses/phy400w/particle/higgs2.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20110724100137/http://www.phy.uct... http://web.archive.org/web/20110724100208/http://www.phy.uct.ac.za/courses/phy400w/particle/higgs3.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20110724100208/http://www.phy.uct... http://web.archive.org/web/20100202022203/http://www.phy.uct.ac.za/courses/phy400w/particle/higgs4.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20100202022203/http://www.phy.uct... http://web.archive.org/web/20100323013823/http://www.phy.uct.ac.za/courses/phy400w/particle/higgs5.htm http://web.archive.org/web/20100323013823/http://www.phy.uct...
- runn1ng 14y agoThe links don't lead anywhere. edit: Web archive to the rescue. Thank you.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jcarreiro 14y agoThis is called Quantum Field Theory. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_field_theory.
- kmm 14y agoDon't worry, don't worry. This one of the most complicated theories in physics (apart from string theory) to grasp intuitively. I'm a physicist and I could try to help you. Think of an excitation of the field. One of the "axioms" of quantum field theory is that the energy of an excitation is related to the inverse square of the wavelength. Don't ask me why, it's just like that. Think of UV radiation or X-rays, which are just light with a higher frequency and you know those radiation is more damaging to the human body than for example radio waves. Now, are you familiar with Fourier decomposition?[1] It's the idea that all functions are the sum of a waves (sines and cosines). We do the same thing in quantum field theory, we have our quantum field and we write it as the sum of our elementary wavefunctions, which are called plane waves[2]. When you look at a wave packet[3], you can't really say what its wavelength is. Wavelength is not a local concept, as for example the height of the wave, but the wave differs from place to place, so it's impossible to give it just one wavelength! We don't have that problem with plane waves. Because they're the same all over the universe, they have a clear wavelength and thus a well-defined, unique energy. This concept, an excitation of a field with a well-defined energy (and thus a well-defined mass!) is what particle physicists call "a particle". When a collision happens in a collider, we're actually preparing two plane waves and pointing them in the same direction. As they collide, the wavefunctions of the various fields become incredibly complex. We humans can only "see" excitations with a well-defined mass, or better yet, our detectors can only detect excitations with a well-defined mass. And thus instead of a complicated field, we see a mess of particles going in different directions and having different masses, energies and speeds. Does that make it any clearer? [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_series http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourier_series [2]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plane_wave http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plane_wave [3]: http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b0/Wave_packet_%28dispersion%29.gif http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b0/Wave_pack...
- Diederich 14y agoYes, somewhat. Thank you very much. I've enjoyed pondering this stuff since the 70s when I was a child. How much I've 'gotten' it has varied over the years, but it's never been very deep. Your description, I think, deepened my understanding a good bit.
- 14y ago
- tdskate 14y agowaste of my fucking time
- ColinWright 14y agoI'm not sure why you would take time out of coitus, obviously an activity you would enjoy, and watch this instead. Would you care to explain further?
- alan_cx 14y agoMade worse by the time you took to type that. Clearly you don't value your time. And clearly neither do I.......
- hazov 14y agoI watched it here some months ago: http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1489 http://www.phdcomics.com/comics.php?f=1489
- retube 14y agogreat cartoon, shame about the cafeteria audio.
- biot 14y agoI thought it added a nice "at the scene" ambience, as if you were in the cafeteria yourself overhearing a great explanation between two researchers. It gave it a great university feel to it.
- jalanco 14y agoAll I want out of it is an anti-gravity device.
- fromdoon 14y agoCan someone explain or point to sources where the implications of finding/not finding the Higgs Boson are clearly quantified? Or is it that they are not sure what they would do with it when they find it. Further, how would this discovery affect the modern day/upcoming tech?
- nine_k 14y agoCurrent theory predicts that Higgs boson exists. If it is found, the theory is deemed 'correct' (that is, reinforced, not disproved). Then we're a step closer tho the 'general theory of everything'. If Higgs boson is clearly not found where the theory predict it, then the theory is deficient and has to be seriously rethought or thrown away altogether! It would be exciting time of uncertainty, crazy ideas, and new and interesting stuff to try (like it was with quantum mechanics). Or maybe not — the new and interesting effects may lie far away from the range of masses and energies of daily life (e.g. we don't usually directly see any effects of general relativity).
- jerf 14y agoActually, if the existence of the Higgs boson exists and it is right where we expected it, we are zero steps closer to a theory of everything. To get closer we really need to find something unexpected. Finding something we expected merely further confirms the Standard Model and gives us nothing to work with, even as we know something must be wrong with it. We need clues about how it is wrong, not more confirmation it is correct.
- tspiteri 14y agoIt's not as simple as that. Confirming something will make it more attractive to build on and extend. And it will save time that would be spent looking for fundamentally different theories.
- tatsuke95 14y agoSlightly off topic: I admire this method of conveying ideas and information (animation). It's a great way to consume these clips. The RSA has a whole series of 10 minute lectures which they animate on a whiteboard in this style. The illustrations are brilliant. http://comment.rsablogs.org.uk/videos/ http://comment.rsablogs.org.uk/videos/ (search for RSA Animate)
- swordswinger12 14y agoNeat site, thanks for the link. I got all excited thinking they were going to be videos about crypto though... I guess The RSA is different from RSA.
- brittohalloran 14y agoThose are fantastic. This would be a great way to do a budget "about" video for a startup. Get a decent voiceover with a script, then have your designer do one of these videos.
- adrianhoward 14y agoI have a very minor claim to fame in that I appear in the background of one of the RSA animations (at about 6:45 in http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJmGrNdJ5Gw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nJmGrNdJ5Gw - and the nasty words about Perl coming out my mouth are not mine :-)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- seanalltogether 14y agoSo if I've got this right, mass shouldn't be thought of as the "bulk" of a thing, it's simply thought of as a charge within that thing. So a photon is a particle of substance that contains no mass charge on it, despite the fact that it has some amount of volume?
- nilaykumar 14y agoElementary particles have no volume! (think about that one, it's kinda mindblowing) They can only have "effective size" that arises due to say, electromagnetism. The electron has an effective radius that is measured by bouncing other charged "test" particles off of it. You don't get an answer of zero only because your test particles are attracted or repelled by the electron. Mass should be thought of as something intrinsic to a particle, just like charge or spin. There's really no good way to visualize it - it's just something different particles have in different amounts.
- dedward 14y agoMight be totally wrong here - photons have no volume yet can exhibit mass. (I don't fully understand that particular one yet.. need to read more. Whether or not photons have mass is a complex question it seems - or rather, multi-faceted)
- nilaykumar 14y agoPhotons can have momentum, which, when doing relativity, blends together with energy into the momentum 4-vector [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-momentum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-momentum]. Relativity also asserts that energy and mass are related [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy%E2%80%93momentum_relation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy%E2%80%93momentum_relatio...], so you can imagine how we could talk about the "mass" of anything with energy or momentum. Fun fact: One of the ways physicists are looking for Higgs is by looking for bumps in the "invariant mass" spectrum of LHC events with 2 photons!
- dedward 14y agoThanks - I'll read up. I've long interpreted E=mc^2 to mean not just that energy and mass are interchangeable, that energy and mass are one and the same. What I can't quite get my head around yet (just need to read up more) is how they figured out something about the rest mass of a photon - something about using superconducting rings or something like that. (Because photons aren't generally at rest, and they don't accelerate, right?)
- elorant 14y agoAnother particle, another Nobel prize.
- DanBC 14y agoDepressingly this cartoon is more complex than almost all of the BBC science output. Broadcasters with the BBC's remit need to have science programmes that are far beyond my understanding. Almost everything on the BBC can be followed by a reasonably smart 14 year old.
- tikhonj 14y agoWhile I would like advanced science programming, I think the BBC is not the right medium. Particularly, as the material gets sufficiently advanced, it targets a progressively smaller audience. At some point, it is better to have this on the internet than on TV. It's the same logic as to why there aren't any interesting TV programs about, say, programming languages, but you can find good content on Channel 9 (not really a channel :P) or Google Tech Talks.
- DanBC 14y agoI agree with you, until I start comparing the amount of heavy duty arts programming on the BBC. So, on BBC radio 4 you'll have A day set aside for "Bloom's Day", heavily promoted before hand, with James Joyces' Ulysses newly dramatised and broadcast over five and a half hours, in seven slots from 9:00am to midnight; and the cross-promotional stuff. (http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01jl7l9 http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01jl7l9) This is a considerable amount of time and money on a well known (but little read) book. And when you hear arts items on news programmes no-one stops to patronise the audience[1] yet anything that goes beyond very simple science on news is handled very gently, as if all the audience are idiots. I don't even mind that so much - but it's the lack of any programming at all that goes beyond the curriculum that a 15 year old would study that is problematic. Of course, there are notable exceptions, and I know that it'd be as bad or worse in other countries. [1] They'll mention names of artists but not bother explaining any context; you're just expected to know that this person is a scupltor or has won some award or whatever; and you're expected to be aware of some of the main themes in their work.
- tikhonj 14y agoHmm, that's a fair point. And I have seen some programs about art history from the BBC that are probably rather advanced. Perhaps it's a fundamental difference in the two fields? For something like Renaissance art, you can get away with not knowing too much about other sorts of art; on the other hand, for any sort of even moderately serious physics, not only do you need a good grasp of related physics but you also need a strong grasp of relatively advanced mathematics. Also, thinking about it, it seems that CS is even more underrepresented than other sciences. At the very least, you see some shows about physics and cosmology and biology, however basic. But I've never seen even a painfully basic show about CS. There are shows about robotics, but more from an engineering standpoint than a CS standpoint. Math also seems rarer than the sciences, but I recall some math shows. Of course, I watch any sort of TV very rarely, so I have a small sample with a distinct selection bias (namely, I mostly watch what other people in my family are interested in). This bias trivially explains the disproportionate amount of art history (my mother is an art teacher) but does not explain the complete dearth of CS.
- elorant 14y agoWhat I don’t understand about quantum mechanics is the reason nature had to make things so damn complicated. What was the fundamental problem that led to the solution of quantum entanglement, or the duality of the wave-particle situation.
- robertfw 14y agoMy gut tells me that the underlying reasons are elegantly simple; it is our imperfect understanding - and a long chain of knock on effects - that leads to complication
- aidenn0 14y agoArguably having separate waves and particles would be more complex, since there would be more entities.
- elorant 14y agoYes but why you need to have a wave function in the first place? Why can't we just have particles with a single state?
- eevilspock 14y agoWhat do you mean "reason nature had to make things so damn complicated"? Nature has reasons? And even if it did, why does this "reason" have to be simple? Does it even have be something humanly comprehensible or even observable? Could an ant ever comprehend or even "see" a microwave oven? Nature is what it is. We may only ever get glimpses. And a bias toward simplicity may be more a function of human limitation than some fundamental truth.
- elorant 14y agoOf course nature has reasons. Natural selection is the prime example. The reasoning doesn't have to be simple but there must be a pretty good explanation of why it is so complicated. Lets not forget that even Einstein thought that something must be wrong with quantum physics because it doesn't make sense. Nature is what it is but that doesn't mean that we can't question what's happening and seek answers to every single aspect of life. That's the basis of science.
- temp1337 14y agoGo ahead and downvote me for being off-topic. I put in several honest posts, and have no moderation or replies to them. Frankly, I'm left to conclude that this place is just like a bar. People venting, and not actually working. Except perhaps you people feel like this is part of your work. I know code has to compile, and there is downtime, but there are also wonderful books that are available for free. But I guess that doesn't feed ego. Nearly all of you want to become billionaires--have fun trying. I'm going to hug my dog now.
- kcima 14y agoFrom the video around :30 seconds in, "...this is when surprises might happen. Any day could be the day that changed the world." I am still looking for an answer as to how the world could be changed by the discovery of the Higgs Boson particle. What are some possible outcomes for society? I do not doubt that it will change, and I agree fully with it's value, however, I can't find any specifics in what ways it might change or what new technologies might be created with or without the Higgs Boson. Also, at a 9 Billion USD price tag, how were our governments convinced? There must be something beyond scientific intellectual curiosity. Those of us with this curiosity may be happy to pay for it, but how were politicians convinced? What value will this provide to the governments of the world who made the decision to purchase this answer. I'm sure it's not this... Scientists: "We need 9 Billion to find out if the Higgs Boson particle exists." Governments: "OK, here is your 9 Billion." ... 15 years later Scientists: "The answer is yes. The Higgs Boson does exist." Governments: "Oh, that's really great." Update: I understand and agree fully with the value of this research. I am asking if there are any specific technologies that are expected to be advanced or if it is just added knowledge that could lead anywhere. I am also wondering how it was explained to politicians who don't have specific interest in science.
- sophacles 14y agoAt a 9 Billion USD price tag, what are our governments buying for us? There must be something beyond scientific intellectual curiosity. Those of us with this curiosity may be happy to pay for it, but how were politicians convinced? What value will this provide to the governments of the world who made the decision to purchase this answer. False dilemma. When we spend trillions of dollars a year to kill people in the name of stopping violence, 10^-3 of that for curiosity is not something that is rational to attack. Particularly when exploration for curiosity's sake has led to plenty of demonstrably beneficial results.
- protomyth 14y ago"Your wasting a lot of money here, so you shouldn't mind wasting a lesser amount here" Government funding needs to justify itself, not against other uses for the money. The bills have come due and we need to cut out what isn't vital. 9 billion could have paid a lot of health insurance policies. I'm glad they valued this, but it needs to be valuable based on its own merit.
- SonicSoul 14y agolove this! it's like khan academy on steroids. It must have taken a lot of work to create. great way for Jorge Cham to get his name out. I'll be subscribing to PHD Comics
- eevilspock 14y agoShy physicists explain dating and relationships in extremely roundabout way.
- josscrowcroft 14y agoFantastic animation, but doesn't give any indication as to why it's such an important search!
- Zaheer 14y agoAwesome video! I had Daniel Whiteson as a Physics professor at UC Irvine last year. My favorite professors ever. Very great at explaining concepts and makes the class fun.
- Jun8 14y agoMy takeaway from this: CERN's cafeteria beats the shit out of ours! Years ago I had the chance to visit there and didn't, talk about the road not taken.
- femto 14y agoIt seems as if a Higgs confirmation announcement is going to happen in about 12 hours [1]. A video was briefly up on the CERN site, before disappearing behind a password. Apparently it is part of preparations for an announcement at the International Conference on High Energy Physics, which started today in Melbourne, Australia. [1] http://www.smh.com.au/technology/sci-tech/weve-observed-a-new-particle-leaked-video-reveals-apparent-god-particle-confirmation-20120704-21g63.html http://www.smh.com.au/technology/sci-tech/weve-observed-a-ne...
- smeg 14y agoSo if mass and charge are both just attributes of particles, what is the "charge equivalent" of the Higgs boson? And if there isn't one, then why is it assumed the HB exists? Why cant particles have a innate "mass charge" in the same way they have an "electric charge"?
- modernise 14y agoI has it. heep://jessecrockett.com
- modernise 14y agohttp://jessecrockett.com http://jessecrockett.com ? ...
- krrrh 14y agoIf this is still too advanced for you, and you need to brush up on the atom, proton, neutron, and electron, this video of Venus Flytrap explaining the concept in 2 minutes might be a good place to start. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hhbqIJZ8wCM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hhbqIJZ8wCM
- mietek 14y agoThe cartoon says "Interestingly, you can't have negative mass, or repulsive gravity." It would be interesting to hear why.