3 ms·
I don't think they're going to win. But I do worry a bit about Flock, which is extraordinarily popular (for some good reasons and some bad ones). I've posted h
by tptacek 2y ago
I don't think they're going to win. But I do worry a bit about Flock, which is extraordinarily popular (for some good reasons and some bad ones).
I've posted here before about this, but: we did a give-to-get in my local municipality. The police (and voters), concerned about a wave of carjackings, wanted a Flock deployment. Activists opposed the cameras. There was a board fight, which came down to a tie-breaking vote from the board president.
In exchange for a pilot deployment of Flock, we ultimately:
* Disabled automatic sharing of Flock data to out-of-state entities (I tried getting sharing disabled altogether, but we solved a murder with shared access to another muni's cameras)
* Revised the police department's General Order regarding ALPR cameras to get a bunch of privacy/security stuff added (mandatory 2FA, use exclusively from PD computers, monthly audits of Flock stops, etc). The General Order we approved also forbade the use of Flock cameras for non-violent crimes.
* Got the ACLU's CCOPS model ordinance enacted, which mandates board approval of any new surveillance technology --- we're the first muni in Illinois to do that (put us on your silly maps, ACLU!), and, finally
* Forbade the police department from using Flock to stop "stolen" cars (the Illinois "hot list" of stolen cars is surprisingly bad, with months sometime passing after cars reported stolen being removed when it turned out they weren't); we instead monitor for stolen license plates (for which there are no innocent explanations).
None of this is perfect. The activists certainly aren't happy! On the other hand, we probably have the most tightly restricted ALPR deployment in the country, and we were up against an electorate that, if it had to choose between no cameras and 5x as many cameras with zero restrictions, would have sided with the cameras. So I'm calling it a huge win.
- Onavo 2y ago> The General Order we approved also forbade the use of Flock cameras for non-violent crimes. What's the point of a surveillance system if you are not going to use it to solve property crimes? The biggest issues with liveability in a lot of "nice" US cities like SF are property crime and law enforcement choosing to go after "easy" white collar crime like traffic and parking violations instead of the blue collar crimes that affect safety and property.
- dghlsakjg 2y agoTraffic enforcement is down 95% in SF over the past decade https://sfstandard.com/2024/04/08/sfpd-traffic-enforcement-cost/ https://sfstandard.com/2024/04/08/sfpd-traffic-enforcement-c... That isn't limited to SF either: https://www.npr.org/2023/04/06/1167980495/americas-roads-are-more-dangerous-as-police-pull-over-fewer-drivers https://www.npr.org/2023/04/06/1167980495/americas-roads-are...
- blendo 2y ago“The city already has more than a dozen red light cameras that automatically ticket motorists who run the red. Since 2019, those cameras have been used to issue over 56,000 citations, according to Sernoffsky. That figure, which isn’t included in SFPD’s data on traffic citations and may help explain why citation revenue hasn’t dropped as dramatically as the moving violation totals would seem to predict, will continue to grow as the city installs more cameras.” SF is also planning to install dozens of speed enforcement cameras.
- consteval 2y agoAs they should. It's trivial to install these and is safer across the board for everyone, cops included. It's cheaper too. Not to mention without cops pre-occupied with simple traffic violations, they can commit to more elaborate operations. It's easy to catch someone speeding, it's a lot harder to crack down on, say, cat thefts.
- tptacek 2y agoA fun thing I learned only this year: in Illinois, you need a population exceeding 1,000,000 residents to install traffic enforcement cameras (the kind that automatically issue tickets). If we could roll out red light cameras villagewide, I'd sign on.
- qingcharles 2y agoYeah, there's a surprising number of laws in Illinois that have that >1m barrier to make them only apply to Chicago/Cook County. I remember when the bodycams were coming in, Chicago fell under one of those >1m exemptions which I think gave them more time to implement?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- eth0up 2y agoThis seems kindof heroic to me. I really appreciate such conscientious diligence with this subject and the comparatively fair, well-considered compromise of privacy vs slime control. I wish such fights and compromise were more common, rather than the furtive implementations and blind acceptance that is standard.
- tptacek 2y agoIt is, and I am not making this up or exaggerating in the least, literally a version of HN where instead of karma you get ordinances passed. Way more people here should do it. I keep meaning to write a post about it. Also, HN is like the prison planet Salusa Secondus comparatively; if you're comfortable operating here, and you can read a room even a little bit, you may find that you're more or less unstoppable out there. If you live inside the borders of a huge city, it's probably a different story (somebody go report it out). But I live in an inner-ring suburb of Chicago, and I think what I'm saying is probably true for basically all suburbs.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Forbade the police department from using Flock to stop "stolen" cars (the Illinois "hot list" of stolen cars is surprisingly bad, with months sometime passing after cars reported stolen being removed when it turned out they weren't); we instead monitor for stolen license plates How is it identifying the car without the plate? VIN?
- tptacek 2y agoIt's all based on plates; we just key off reported stolen license plates rather than reported stolen cars (stolen with their plates). Car thieves in Chicagoland swap plates after cars are taken, as a way to get past ALPRs; the theory is there's no innocent explanation for a car driving with reported stolen plates.
- qingcharles 2y agoI'm not so totally pessimistic about their chances of winning. That 4th Cir. case is interesting. Carpenter touched on this subject. So did Jones in 2012. Nobody thought that Jones would be decided the way it was because practically every court had swung in favor of the cops. Obviously the makeup of the court was different, but I'm not sure this is a partisan case?
- tptacek 2y agoJones relied on the fact pattern of a physical intrusion on private property (the police placing a sensor on a car). Here, the only difference between Flock and the closed-circuit cameras that have blanketed America for decades is the fact that a computer is looking at the images.