9 ms·
The global surveillance free-for-all in mobile ad data
- drawkward 2y agoAdvertising is a virus that eventually infects all ecosystems.
- antiframe 2y agoAnd that is why I use exclusively open source software that respects the user.
- m463 2y agothat sounds suspiciously like an ad. :)
- pixelpoet 2y agoGovernments and big tech/media try to brand anyone knowledgeable about privacy measures as pedophiles, and it's incredibly effective because they control the laws and narrative. Doesn't help that a huge fraction of people conflate having something to hide with not wanting everything be public, and in the vast majority of cases are blissfully and willfully ignorant so long as they get their Instagram or TikTok. At a societal level we fully deserve all this because apparently we can't be fucked to care about basic rights anymore (cf. "everyone gets the government they deserve"), too lost in Huxley's dystopian future of infinite dopamine distractions.
- photonthug 2y ago> And that is why I use exclusively open source software that respects the user. We're all proud of you but this is barely related to avoiding ads. You can build your own car too, and you'd still have to look at the billboards on the highway. Or you could build your own phone and never giving anyone the number, then you'll still get to enjoy 5 spams/day during election season when someone decides to simply call every phone number in the region. Ads are the new certainty besides death and taxes. If they aren't in your face yet, be assured that whole legions of shitheads are very busy trying to make it happen.
- EGreg 2y agoThe city of Sao Paolo would like a word: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/travel/destinations/sao-paulo-the-city-with-no-outdoor-advertisements/amp_articleshow/36441208.cms https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/travel/destinations/sao-...
- realusername 2y agoEven if you would never see an ad in your life somehow, you would still have to pay for it on the products you buy. The advertising industry is so large that it's basically private taxation, except that you get nothing in return from it.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoThe best concert I ever saw was one I only knew was in town because of an ad. My interests align with advertisers to an extent. I do want to know what products are out there. I'm an adult, I won't forget that their descriptions of their products are biased. Surveillance advertising is a bad thing, but it doesn't help to take the most extremist position possible. Advertising is information, and it's not difficult to use that information to your benefit.
- n_plus_1_acc 2y agoBillboard ads don't yell as you at least. They are like two orders of magnitute less annoying than video ads
- drawkward 2y agoI follow the bands I care about seeing. There are other, less intrusive modalities for communication than advertising.
- realusername 2y agoThat kind of old-school vision of advertising is a vision from the 80s, it's been a long time that advertising isn't about information anymore. The big spenders are in the game for brand awareness (there's not even a product being shown sometimes) and then there's a parallel world of which I would call scams which went on top of it (less than half of the Youtube ads I see look legal) If you remove those two, I'm not sure how long the advertising industry would survive.
- shiroiushi 2y agoI use open-source software too, but it (by itself) doesn't stop me from seeing annoying and intrusive ads on internet websites. An ad-blocker like uBO does, mostly (but not completely), though it's much less effective with paywalled sites. The problem with online ads is mostly orthogonal to FOSS. Of course, it does help to not use an OS with ads baked into the Start menu...
- mixmastamyk 2y agoThose are getting compromised too—not a complete solution.
- strogonoff 2y agoAdvertising is the engine of free market. Advertising in Web and apps is used for evil purposes, just like cash (or almost anything else) is also used for evil purposes. Regulation exists to try to minimize those, but it’s always a workaround for human malice.
- drawkward 2y agoMaybe it was in days when only broadcast media existed. Now, we have the ability to search for answers to our needs. Our information paradigm has changed; so should advertising. Let consumers seek out new products, if they wish to.
- strogonoff 2y agoIt hasn’t changed. To know to search for X you must first know X exists. (If you search for “the best ways to Y” and find an article that tells you about X, congratulations—chances are, you are reading an advertisement.)
- drawkward 2y agoThat's a weak argument. Stores are not advertisements.
- strogonoff 2y agoAdvertisement is the engine of free market. The technological progress made possible with free market and advertisement as its integral part is evidence supporting my argument—yes, the very device you are reading this on is the evidence. You have not provided a viable argument so far. I can’t say you failed to provide supporting evidence, because you have not even made a claim. Inventing a meaningless term like “information paradigm” and implying it has somehow changed is not one. You either lack a point to make, or are struggling to express one.
- drawkward 2y ago
- aucisson_masque 2y agoAs a previous self employed man, advertising is good. It helps small companies compete against the big ones that are well known. However no one need this amount of data, all advertiser need is : you search for a pair of shoes on Google, show you ads for shoes. That's good advertising and sometimes it can be useful for the user.
- Intralexical 2y agoStalking is bad. Lying and manipulating is bad. If you look at old ads for random products from e.g. the turn of the (last) century, they seem to often give this slight "wall of text" impression. Image of the product, surrounded by prices and descriptions of what it was and what it (purportedly) did. The motivating belief seemed to be that if a company communicated the benefits of buying from them, they would attract customers. It seems like at some point the focus shifted away from expressing factual information, and to creating vague associations and implications. I think that's still fine on its own, and in fact quite fun and the source of a lot of creativity, but it also created the opportunity to mislead in new ways. E.G. most famously harmfully maybe, the very mid-20th century idea that cigarettes are "cool". In modern times this seems to have gone even further towards exploiting basic quirks in human psychology— A dancing bear, chocolate man, or screaming celebrity has nothing to do with selling a product, but it's bizarre and surprising and therefore memorable, so by making an ad around it you're cluttering the viewer's brain with useless information designed to redirect mindshare to your capital-B "Brand". So at that point it becomes dishonest and manipulative. But at least it's still broadcasted, e.g. on radio, TV, in newspapers and magazines. It's predatory, but everyone gets the same thing. You can still sorta avoid or ignore it. It doesn't single anyone out. That's changed now with the Internet. The mass collection of location and personality data, identifiable to individual profiles and paired with tools allowing those individuals to be targetted with a combination of terrifying granularity and omnipresent scale— That adds an entire new dimension to "advertising", and it would still be wrong, because it would still comprise many violations of privacy and basic decency, even if it weren't being actively exploited for commercial gain. If any one individual knew as much about you and had as many tools for trying to influence you as Facebook and Google have built on an industrial scale, they would be either a stalker deserving of a restraining order, or some kind of a (probably malevolent TBH) supernatural spirit. So "advertising", in terms of "informing the market of a product" and "connecting customers to businesses in mutually beneficial transactions", is fine I guess. Good, even. Stalking, lying, manipulating, and rent-seeking through dominance are wrong. And with technology centralizing power in the hands of a few organizations, the modern practice of "advertising" seems to be less about "informing people" these days and more about dominating the information space in order to manipulate human behaviour with neither the consent nor the knowledge of your targets. No wonder it's apparently being abused by law enforcement. ...To be clear, I use the word "you" only as an indefinite pronoun here. Small businesses that use ad networks aren't the ones to blame for a large system having messy incentives and malicious central actors.
- sandworm101 2y agoMany worry about how these tools will be used to persecute people such as women seeking reproductive medical services. That is a problem. But what will people think of those same tools being used to enforce protection orders, to spot parole violators? I know where my opinions fall, but I also realize that the bulk of the population would trade in their privacy for any perception of increased safety.
- jcgrillo 2y agoIf I were in law enforcement, had no morals, and just wanted to convict as many people as possible I'd build a system that automatically assembles a virtual dossier on everyone using these data streams. Then I'd implement detection heuristics that look for interesting dossiers. These could be used as the "classified" component of a case built by parallel construction[1]. [1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction
- potato3732842 2y agoNot even. It's worse. They aren't even useful for that. They've tried that approach but it's actually less efficient than "good old fashioned police work" because it turns out that 99/100 of your hits are gonna be lawful weirdos, 1/100 is gonna be a petty drug dealer and the career advancing prosecution you actually wanted would have been much easier to find by using normal methods like inferring that a dealer has a supplier, a spy has a handler, etc, etc and trying to suss out who those people are. The NSA figured all this out post 9/11 when they were building data haystacks in search of terrorists. What the data haystacks do get used for is dragnet policing wherein an agency picks some crime they're gonna go hard on, pulls up a bunch of results of people who probably did it, tosses all the people who are likely to pose any risk to them (e.g. you don't see the ATF knocking on doors asking about Temu glock switches in bad parts of Detroit) and kicks in the doors of whoever's left. The data haystacks are also really useful for witch hunts when they get egg on their face and need to make someone pay, like that time they prosecuted anyone and everyone who they could construe as having done anything to help the kid who bombed the Boston Marathon, and the January 6 people of whom a great number were certainly just hapless. And this is in addition to the usual "opposition research" like the FBI bugging MLK and all that sort of crap.
- mdaniel 2y ago> such as AccuWeather, GasBuddy, Grindr, and MyFitnessPal that collect your MAID and location and sell that to brokers. Welp, that's the final straw I needed to nuke that fucking GasBuddy app from my phone. Goddamn I hate them so much
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoIt's a damn shame. I've stopped using pretty much all apps because I can't trust any of them. My phone is practically stock.
- mdaniel 2y agoI would _guess_ that the systemic solution to this problem is one of those whole device VPNs that doesn't choose to hide your location but rather blocks access to ad and tracker networks. I actually have DDG's Privacy Pro VPN <https://duckduckgo.com/duckduckgo-help-pages/privacy-pro/vpn/app-tracking-protection/ https://duckduckgo.com/duckduckgo-help-pages/privacy-pro/vpn...> but my life experience has been that it breaks more things than it helps but I guess it's time to at least try it
- casenmgreen 2y agoIt's worse than you think. There are popular third-party libraries, used by apps, offering whatever functionality. Those third-party libraries do deals with whoever, to include into the library whatever code it is the whoever wants to get out onto a ton of phones. I worked for a company in Germany, who wanted to get some Bluetooth base station detection functionality out into phones, so they could track people. Company put Bluetooth base stations into a bunch of locations, and then paid a major third-party library to include their code. Bingo. One week later, millions of phones being tracked. When you install an app, you are in fact installing God knows what from shady friend-of-a-friend-of-a-friend, who's got money. Do not install commercial apps. Only install open source apps. Anything else, you're going to be abused, whether you know it or not.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y ago
- reaperducer 2y agoThe first time I ran into the concept of having my mobile phone data sold to a third-party was in 2003, when I went to the Czech Republic. Right after I crossed the border from Austria, my U.S. cell phone started lighting up with spam SMS messages. At first, it was from the local cell phone carrier welcoming me to .cz. A few minutes later, a message from T-Mobile letting me know I was roaming in another new country. Then a few minutes after that, SMS spam for hotels, then restaurants, then casinos. All of this in a time before "smart" phones. I'm not surprised to see it's gotten so much worse.
- dylan604 2y agoA few years ago, I visited Detroit, and the next morning I received the messages from the Canadian (assuming Rogers) telecom welcoming to Canadia. I was spared the rest of the spam. Though it was the first time that I had ever considered the tech issues of being near a border and receiving multiple national signals like that must be a "fun" challenge.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoI flew to somewhere else in the US last month and I started getting political sms spam dependent on that location. It took a good two weeks after I got back for my sms spam to normalize.
- nyarlathotep_ 2y agoWait this is a thing now? I assumed this was only based on voter registration party-spam. That's awful.
- smcin 2y agoWhich state? Was it one of the 2024 battleground states (MI, PA, NC)? And did those political SMSs honor opt-out requests or not?
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoUse and Configure Pi-Hole[0] [0]:https://jeffmorhous.com/block-ads-for-your-entire-network-with-a-raspberry-pi/ https://jeffmorhous.com/block-ads-for-your-entire-network-wi... Also a video for those more YT inclined: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCA24qJBG8Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCA24qJBG8Q
- nickburns 2y agoThis does nothing for a mobile device that either concurrently maintains its cellular 'data' connection together with its Wi-Fi connection (and whose apps are permitted to access both)—or leaves the LAN without connecting remotely via a force-tunneled VPN. And even with such a VPN, the cellular NIC continues to maintain baked-in alternate routes on both Android and iOS. All that's before we even get into specific Pi-Hole and LAN config, not to mention DoH. Krebs and everyone else he cites is right—it's time for Apple and Google to eliminate MAID altogether. ETA: Do not downvote this parent! Use trustworthy ad blockers anywhere and everywhere you can!
- samename 2y agoNextDNS is a great alternative for mobile devices https://nextdns.io https://nextdns.io
- squaresmile 2y agoIf self-host is your thing, there are blocky [0] or Adguard Home [1]. I self-host DOH using blocky so my Android devices can use it via "Private DNS" that is active on both wifi and cellular. [0] https://0xerr0r.github.io/blocky/latest/ https://0xerr0r.github.io/blocky/latest/ [1] https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome https://github.com/AdguardTeam/AdGuardHome [2] https://adguard-dns.io/en/public-dns.html https://adguard-dns.io/en/public-dns.html how to configure
- nyarlathotep_ 2y ago> the cellular NIC continues to maintain baked-in alternate routes on both Android and iOS How do you know this is the case? (I believe it to be, would like to verify) Also worth mentioning many apps hardcode DNS servers or fallback to other DNS providers when they fail to resolve hostnames. I see this all the time on my network. (I have a PfSense box that redirects to upstream NextDNS when this happens)
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoThis turned into a hell of a rant, I apologize but I'm still kind of proud of it. -- We made surveillance capitalism the default method of financing every free-at-point-of-use service on mobile devices before we understood what that meant, and people now have zero perception of the worth of mobile-based software. People happily pay for desktop software but the decades of everything on a phone being free by default despite the economics of that making no sense have made it borderline impossible to sell software to people for their phones. At the same time government has been completely asleep at the fucking wheel with regard to any regulation to protect consumers. Consumers shouldn't have to know the "tradeoffs" of free software, they shouldn't need to vet vendors of software on app stores for privacy policies. People should be protected by default. This "informed consumer" garbage is why we can't get anything done in a regulatory sense because these companies will make the argument that users consented when talking to any layperson user of MyFitnessPal will have you understand they really did not within 5 goddamn minutes. Could people read terms of service? Yes. Do they? No, because people have shit to do and nobody aside of an activist or someone with an interest in it is going to read 110 pages of terms of service each from the 50 services they're currently using and it's unreasonable to suggest that they should, and that's JUST the reading, even if they read it, do they understand it? Because most people according to a stat I saw recently about the United States read at about a sixth grade level, which is going to be a struggle to get through any legal document. And 4% apparently are completely illiterate. I don't mean to rant here but this pisses me off so much. Our entire society is constructed around a set of assumptions about people who are at least some level of educated, with decent english literacy, who have the time and energy to dedicate to managing these various things, and yeah, if you're that theoretical person, you can probably do quite well for yourself in the United States. But what if you aren't? What if you're one of the millions who have to work three fucking jobs to survive and don't have time to read the terms of service for twitter, and just want to relax? What if you're illiterate? What if you're disabled in some way that impedes your ability to read, or your ability to understand what data harvesting is or means? Does your inability to meet the standard I've outlined above just mean you're fodder for the scummy business alliance, ready to be taken advantage of at every single turn by everyone who can, because it's more profitable that way even if it means you will be broke, exposed, and/or otherwise exploited at every single turn and probably have a pretty miserable life? I am long tired of living in a society that is clearly, bluntly, at every turn designed for companies to live and thrive in and not people. I'm tired of people being hung out to dry because "freedom." Nobody needs or wants the freedom to be recklessly and hopelessly exploited to the ends of the goddamn earth, and I'm sick of pretending there's no way for us to know that difference. /rant
- vmaurin 2y agoI worked 12y the ad-tech industry, and 3y in a company using this kind of data to measure performance of "drive to store" campaigns: doing online campaign, then seeing if people visit the actual real store based on geo data. The company was actually controlled by the CNIL (French regulator) according GDPR, so we were "anonymizing" data, meaning hashing one way the IFA (unique phone id for advertiser) and storing location within a 300mx300m square I put some quote around anonymizing because geo data from your phone in the evening/night is enough to know where you live (with 300m precision). The rest of the industry in France and Europe was still a far west though (around 2020)
- kevinventullo 2y agoI can’t imagine that 300m precision is all that useful for measuring store visit campaigns.
- janalsncm 2y agoWe can go back and forth on whether police should have access to this data and what regulations should be put on how/why it should be accessed. I think reasonable people can disagree about details, and cultural expectations around privacy and safety probably means there isn’t a single best answer. But I don’t think anyone can honestly say the right amount of regulation is zero, which is what we have now. It is absolutely bonkers to me that anyone off the street should be able to gather such highly granular data about any other person as long as they can pay.
- burningChrome 2y agoI remember back in the early days of wireless data when AT&T had an app you could use on their phone where you logged in and it effectively used the GPS data of people signed in on app to tell you if they were near you or not. They marketed like you were downtown and got some free baseball tickets and needed to find someone to go with you. The app would tell you where your friends were and you could offer them to go over their simple chat app. It completely bombed out because people were so freaked out about a device knowing where you were. I also remember when Nextel came out with an enterprise tracking app for delivery companies where you could track the vehicle and make sure it was on time making its deliveries and could alert a person monitoring the software back at the office if say the van was sitting too long somewhere which indicated they had broken down or something similar. Two companies tried to install on their vans and there was so much push back from so many people in one company, they canceled their order. The other company did install it and then they had three lawsuits from employees who claimed the software was a breach of their privacy - while in the employment of said company and on said companies time. The company voluntarily removed it after only a few months. Its just so strange to me that we went from not wanting any of this, to just freely handing over any and all private information to these companies.
- rightbyte 2y ago> Its just so strange to me that we went from not wanting any of this, to just freely handing over any and all private information to these companies. I don't think the nature of the data collection was clear and have been creeping up on us. It took a while for me to realize. E.g. I didn't notice Google was spying on me and stalking on non Google sites until I finally realized it.
- alexashka 2y agoBanning advertising would fix it the corporate level. Philosopher kings would fit it at the political level.
- pnw 2y agoCan someone explain how this works on iOS post Apple's removal of IDFA? The advertising ID (MAID) in any specific app is relevant only to that app, so it seems like it would be useless for profiling? I don't see how apps can access any other identifiers on iOS. Even the wifi MAC address is randomized. If you've gone one step further and disabled location access for apps and disabled the global ad id, it would seem difficult to do the searches described. The article refers to "25 percent of Apple phones". Is that just legacy phones running older versions of iOS prior to removal of IDFA?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 2y agoI think the 25% is referring to the users who willingly select the option to allow tracking. It sounds like this report actually corroborates Apple's claims of the impact of this decision.
- JohnMakin 2y ago> One unique feature of Babel Street is the ability to toggle a “night” mode, which makes it relatively easy to determine within a few meters where a target typically lays their head each night (because their phone is usually not far away). There are very few reasons in my mind that anyone, especially law enforcement, would need this "feature" and they're all pretty dark.
- jcgrillo 2y agoI could see this being extremely valuable to law enforcement if they're planning on making an arrest. They're a lot more likely to not get shot by the suspect if they know they're asleep. It's also the sort of thing that's not germane to making their case against the suspect--it's tactically relevant but strategically irrelevant. So we need something more than the 4th amendment here? That's actually a question I'm not a lawyer and don't know what this actually implies. Naively, it seems to me that if information is inadmissible in making their case, law enforcement should have no access to it and, probably, neither should anyone else.
- JohnMakin 2y agoThat only would matter on no knock warrants, right? That’s the best case I can think of (still bad imo, I think no knock warrants are abused and lead to bad outcomes more often than good ones).
- jcgrillo 2y agoYeah I agree it all adds up to nothing good.
- Intralexical 2y ago> They're a lot more likely to not get shot by the suspect if they know they're asleep. Are they even? Or, can they know that? If the suspect has a gun, they'll wake up scared, confused, and with every reason to believe somebody's illegally breaking and entering.
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoIf the insane micromanagey level of tracking were legally designated by its proper practical result, which is stalking, it would be a crime. And since the modern zeitgeist is ruled by the Ruthlessness Gap, anyone who works in "advertising"/tracking ought to have their personal information and whatever they used their surveillance techniques to snoop on gets broadcast in a public database. That could be one great application for Google Glass... watching the watchers.
- amarcheschi 2y agoIf I use an ad id on android, is this id the identifier I can use to make a gdpr request to brokers regarding accessing and deleting my data? I don't have an ID but I'd be curious about doing that, in a similar way to xandr with its uuid2 (although xandr does just looks bad and not this terrible)
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoIt's worth a try. However, expect the brokers to claim that they cannot be sure that you're the only person using the phone and therefore, for privacy reasons, they can't share the data. You can complain to the Irish DPA (because that's where the broker is likely hiding, pro-forma), which will respond within a year or two with a request for more information. If the broker made the mistake to be domiciled in a location with a more competent DPA or you are willing to drag them to court, you might stand a better chance.
- cookiengineer 2y agoAdditionally to an OpenWRT [1] Wi-Fi router or Adguard Home [2] DNS proxy that you can run for yourself, there's also this excellent app firewall project called NetGuard [3]. The developer got kicked out of the Play Store for bogus reasons, and had to continue to develop it as an externally funded effort. Support him, buy a pay what you want license, and give him a couple bucks for it if you value open source software like this. (I'm not affiliated with the project, I just love the app and it runs on all my degoogled devices) Additionally, degoogle your phone by installing an open source ROM like GrapheneOS [4] or LineageOS [5], and install only the most essential apps on your phone. There's also App Warden [6] which audits installed apps, by scanning them for malicious libraries and adtrackers. It's based on the dataset provided by Exodus Privacy [7] where you can search for Apps or their APK identifiers and find out what kind of fingerprinting libraries they're using. For example, this is what the Facebook App uses behind the scenes [8]. Don't install gapps and neither the google play services. If you want an app store for the convenience of updates of open source apps, there's also f-droid [9], a libre app store for Android. Additionally you should keep in mind that every app that needs google play services to run is spyware, by definition of what these services offer as APIs. Websites that require you to install their app to "verify" you are usually spying on your activity. [1] https://openwrt.org/toh/start https://openwrt.org/toh/start [2] https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/services/dns/adguard-home https://openwrt.org/docs/guide-user/services/dns/adguard-hom... [3] https://netguard.me/ https://netguard.me/ [4] https://grapheneos.org/ https://grapheneos.org/ [5] https://wiki.lineageos.org/devices/ https://wiki.lineageos.org/devices/ [6] https://gitlab.com/AuroraOSS/AppWarden https://gitlab.com/AuroraOSS/AppWarden [7] https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/ https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/ [8] https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/reports/com.facebook.katana/latest/ https://reports.exodus-privacy.eu.org/en/reports/com.faceboo... [9] https://f-droid.org/ https://f-droid.org/
- wepple 2y agoCare to clarify what these things do and why it’s relevant to the posted article?
- cookiengineer 2y ago
- idunnoman1222 2y agoThe ad knows nothing more than my ip, not exactly accurate location data. Not sure what android gives out wrt gps
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoThe web ad knows at least your IP, what site you're currently looking at, and likely an extensive history of these things linked through tracking cookies. Your ID + other people's IDs seen from the same non-CGNAT IP establish a link, i.e. they also have part of your social graph. And if one of the web site requests location permissions to e.g. show you where that shop's nearest branch is, I wouldn't put it beyond the ad networks to detect and abuse that to add your location to the above data pile. Of course, all that becomes entirely moot once you have a single application with ads installed on your phone that has location permissions...
- idunnoman1222 2y agoSocial graph? I live in a big city hitting the same cell phone tower does not friends make. Only app that needs location permissions is Google maps which doesn’t serve ads. of course, both Google and Apple could easily assassinate me, but I’ve accepted that Actually thinking about it a bit more with 5G being so short range I can see how a social graph could be made. I do have 5G turned off on my phone though because I don’t know what benefit it gives me because if the 4g tower is already not overloaded bc other people are on the local 5g
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoCell tower IP data is likely useless. However, your friends using your WiFi, or your coworkers and you using the work WiFi, provides a link.
- idunnoman1222 2y agoI mean work Wi-Fi… doesn’t that show you that targeting advertisement wouldn’t work without identifier you’d be getting shit from your coworker and the cubicle over the whole fucking system would collapse and we have to pay a lot more for Internet
- jmward01 2y agoI had a discussion with someone that worked on some of google's ad stuff and he swore that this type of tracking wasn't in use there. I suspect that even within these companies they try to hide the level of tracking they engage in. The only way we are going to stop this is to hold companies accountable for the things that happen as a result of the data they collect. I don't care if it is sold, stolen or given away, if data that is collected by a company gets used inappropriately then the company that collected it should face consequences.
- verisimi 2y agoYes. But what of the governments which take on the data too, allowing it to be collected, legalising collection, surreptitiously collecting it themselves? All large corporate and governmental entities love the data. Industries (tech, finance, etc) and planned future governance (technocracy) are based on it. So, it is baked into the plan that days will be collected. It's just whether the individual will know about it.
- Intralexical 2y agoIt's an often used quote, but because it bears keeping in mind: "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." A look at data for how many people were aware the whole time during any scandal, and how often abuse and crime gets covered up or exploited instead of reported or opposed, will leave you with a very banal impression of malice. "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." …Idk, companies are just groups of people. Maybe people also need stronger incentives to not let the "company" do antisocial things. At least the execs. Maybe it's the companies that hide it. Maybe it's the people that lie to themselves. I'm sure they're smart enough; they can probably figure it out. At some point ignorance becomes wilful.
- analog31 2y agoI think that over time, it will become more apparent that the only solution is to criminalize possession of the data, with a process for collecting statutory damages upon discovery. A precedent exists in the recording industry, where sharing of copyrighted songs results in automatic damages without the need to quantify the actual harm. That process already has fair provisions for willful and accidental use. This in turn would lead to an industry that hunts for evidence on a contingency basis.
- aucisson_masque 2y ago> they estimate they could locate roughly 80 percent of Android-based devices, and about 25 percent of Apple phones. And that's why I gave my mother my iphone and went back on the wasteland that is Android. She, as a normal person, doesn't understand all of these and go with the default settings. With apple it means she has 75% chance of being protected, with Google 80% chance of being tracked. Me, as a nerd, i know about advertising id and I even root my phone to have afwall firewall. This is why Google is just bad, they always technically allow you to do the right thing but it's buried under a ton of sub menu and convoluted settings. On purpose of course, their goal is to make money.
- aembleton 2y agoYou could just set the DNS of her android phone to dns.adguard-dns.com
- akimbostrawman 2y agothe number is actually 100% of any device that connects to the phone network regardless of OS.
- tdullien 2y agoXoogler here (2011-2018). At some point I proposed making it easy for people to "lie" to an app (if it asks for location, provide fake data etc.). This would preserve true customer choice about anonymity. The reaction to that idea taught me a lot about incentives.
- rangerelf 2y agoYou can't just leave us hanging here, what happened? I mean, unless you're handcuffed with an NDA or something like that.
- tdullien 2y agoConfidentiality agreements are usually part of employment agreements. I haven't checked expiry dates etc.; and tbh I'm not sure they'd apply here, but I'd rather check ;)
- 11101010001100 2y agoThe most effective effective altruism requires zero anonymity.
- Intralexical 2y agoRelated discussion: Location tracking of phones is out of control (arstechnica.com) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41930818 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41930818 Related comment: 486sx33 8 hours ago | next [–] About 2 years ago, an isp we use for one of our operations in Canada called R… which is also a media company and an advertising company… came to us and said hey! We have this amazing new technology , all you do is geofence your competitors and then we will retarget anyone who visits their location with your web ads for as long as you want! Since they are also the isp for mobile data , they just force replaced ads for the targets web browser. (Basically they inject ads) They also made it clear their system is not at all dependent on your phone location services or even your advertiser ID, since they are the isp and the cell provider they just use your SIM ESN to track you. ( cell towers know where their users are, with better accuracy than ever now ) It worked, but it’s darn scary. This has been around for awhile.
- Kim_Bruning 2y agoThe combination of everyone in the synagogue + knowing where they sleep is particularly chilling. People used to risk their lives to try to erase much less data. eg. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1943_bombing_of_the_Amsterdam_civil_registry_office https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1943_bombing_of_the_Amsterdam_...