6 ms·
Firefox-Passwords-Decryptor: Extracts and decrypts passwords saved in Firefox
- java-man 2y agoFirefox is using TripleDES??
- hulitu 2y ago> Firefox is using TripleDES?? What's wrong with it ? /s
- penguin359 2y agoI would mostly say that it's just slow and AES is a much more modern and faster (partly due to hardware acceleration built into modern chips) that is already built info Firefox to support TLS anyways. There are some known attacks against 3DES now, but nothing that completely breaks it yet. And, since this is just for local storage, primarily, it shouldn't be as vulnerable as using 3DES for TLS channel encryption.
- N-Krause 2y agoThanks, even tho the comment above signaled sarcasm, the explanation was helpful for me, as I really had no idea what 3DES means and why it could be problematic.
- Dalewyn 2y agoI shudder to think that even a simple Google query leading to a Wikipedia article was too much effort here... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triple_DES https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triple_DES
- b112 2y agoAny "simple" Google query now means pages of nonsense answers, promoted sites, AI "help", before you even get to a cogent result. Much better to just talk to others than use Google.
- Scoundreller 2y agoReddit, got it. and Google and quora are in cahoots, right?
- echoangle 2y agoWhen I google „TripleDES“, the first result is a box showing the Wikipedia article on Triple DES. Click on that and you’re done.
- lupusreal 2y agoCreate a search keyword for Wikipedia. Then you can type "wiki whatever" into your address bar and be taken right to Wikipedia without the google middleman.
- andrepd 2y agoAgree with the sentiment, but that's a Wikipedia link. Wikipedia is (as of yet) immune to LLM slop
- nneonneo 2y agoMeh...not immune, just resistant. There's unfortunately a big difference. LLM slop is coming in at the corners, typically on articles that are less well-patrolled.
- dspillett 2y ago> promoted sites, AI "help" I've been experimenting with Kagi for those reasons (amongst others) and finding it works well. Far from ideal for all as it isn't free after 100 queries, but it seems to be a workable solution to the problem for me for now.
- N-Krause 2y agoThe problem wasn't that a google search was to much effort, I just happened to be in the comments and saw this right with an explanation below it. I actually read up on it quite a bit afterwards. Feels very unwarranted to just assume laziness into a simple thank you for information spreading.
- wtallis 2y agoFor a password manager, whether a cipher is fast or slow could mean something entirely different than for something that has to encrypt and decrypt large amounts of data. Cycles per byte is probably completely irrelevant here and I'd expect performance to basically be a function of how many cache misses (both data and code) are incurred to decrypt a single password.
- captn3m0 2y agoThe README is surely LLM slop.
- dlenski 2y agoWhat…?
- TheChaplain 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slop_(artificial_intelligence) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slop_(artificial_intelligence)
- dlenski 2y agoI’m familiar with _the term_ and the phenomenon, but I am incredulous at the evidence-free claim that the project’s README is AI slop.
- jackjeff 2y agoIt uses both AES and TripleDES If you glance at the code there's a single "key encryption key" in the whole SQLITE file (in the 'metadata' table). That key is decrypted using AES with the PBKDF2 derived secret. Then each password is in turn encrypted using TripleDES. The "data encryption key" for each these records is in turn encrypted using the aforementioned "key encryption key". My suspicion is that the TripleDES format must be really old, and when they migrated the crypto layer to use AES they just re-encrypted the top layer (the "key encryption key" later) to use AES. It's much faster (and safer) to just re-encrypt all the TripleDES keys with the new AES than go and mess with "all" the records in the database. It's inelegant and lazy but you effectively get "AES level" of security without having to do all the work, so to speak… https://github.com/Sohimaster/Firefox-Passwords-Decryptor/blob/main/recon/browser/firefox/passwords.go https://github.com/Sohimaster/Firefox-Passwords-Decryptor/bl...
- alexey-salmin 2y agoI don't know about the particular case of TripleDES+AES but I think in a general case you can't claim that A+B encryption is always at least as strong as B alone. The A part can result in e.g. first bytes of input being the same enabling a crib-type attack.
- jackjeff 2y agoI'm not defending this choice, and I think you're right in general. In this case, the only thing encrypted with TripleDES is the password itself, so the practicality of a crib or other known plaintext attacks is debatable in my opinion. If you use the same (or similar) password everywhere, then you have bigger worries than Firefox use of TripleDES. Password stuffing based with leaks from poorly hashed password DB (cough facebook cough) is likely the most practical attack vector in this case. If all your passwords are like q@qrG#Z4ARYm^qjeTEMN2Kh45v^p7L# then crib like attacks are impractical. There are other weird/debatable choices in the Firefox encryption layer: - Why bother with CBC? Things like AES-GCM or other authenticated* encryption mode would be nicer. Not sure it's a flaw here (google the cryptographic doom principle of Moxie Marlinspike) - Why not wrap the encryption keys with some kind of "key wrap" mode instead. There are such things as AES-KV for instance. - Why do the weird PBDKF2 derivation here? It's not based on a password the player enters, so there's nothing to "strengthen"? Seems oddly unnecessary (or I don't understand and there's a password somewhere). - If there's a password then PBKDF2 is really really shit compared to scrypt or even better one the variant of argon OWASP said you should use.
- dlenski 2y agoThere are a large number of similar projects out there. I implemented login credential extraction for both Chrom* and FF-based browsers in the somewhat shambolic but generally-useful `browser_cookie3` Python module last year: https://github.com/borisbabic/browser_cookie3/compare/master...dlenski:browser_cookie3:login_credentials https://github.com/borisbabic/browser_cookie3/compare/master...
- NotPractical 2y ago> Safari listed as supported Interesting, does this work on the latest releases? If so you might want to let this fellow know to adjust their threat model accordingly :) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41912226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41912226
- dlenski 2y agoMy personal threat model for all Apple products is that I don't care about them at all: http://dlenski.github.io/macOS_nope.html http://dlenski.github.io/macOS_nope.html
- NotPractical 2y agoLove the brutal honesty! Even as a macOS user I admit that it's difficult to justify learning the Apple-proprietary tech needed to port apps to it (and automated testing is indeed a nightmare). Curious as to your thoughts on Android?
- reddalo 2y agoIs it even safe to use browser-integrated password managers? I think they're so much easier to use than external solutions such as KeepassXC, but if it's so easy to decrypt their databases...
- mrweasel 2y agoI never found a way to lock the password manager in Firefox with its own password. They probably aren't bad, but they are also way behind on features and general usability, as compared to standalone password managers. If you have passwords that are used outside the browser, putting them into the browsers password manager, getting them out feels a little cumbersome. Related to the tool: Why not just click the export button in Firefox?
- eesmith 2y agoWhat is your risk model? An attacker who can install cameras in your house to see your PIN/password? An attacker with a blunt object and the clear intent to harm you if you don't unlock your phone? Your spouse who you trust enough to loan your device to look at a cat pic?
- reddalo 2y agoMy threat model is accidentally installing malware that reads the database of my passwords. I trust my KeepassXC database because I use a strong and long password, so even if malware can read my KeepassXC file, it won't be able to extract the passwords. I feel like Firefox is not as safe.
- _7acn 2y ago[flagged]
- maqp 2y agoNO ONE should trust a website delivering JS that could do who-knows what the next time they skip reading the code. Like, send the inputs to a third party. Please delete this project and your comment. If you want to be helpful, write native code that user can read, compile, and install, and persistently use without risk of backdoor-out-of-the blue.
- Matumio 2y agoDo you read your password manager's code every time it updates? Probably not, because you trust the author's reputation. I wouldn't trust this page with my passwords either, but not because of the reasons that you mention. I haven't checked, but maybe it is simple enough to read the code in its entirety and then self-host? If so, nothing wrong with that.
- DatenF 2y agoIt's hosted on GitHub Pages so you don't need to check if the code has changed. Just look for any commits. From what I can see, the last one was three months ago
- rerdavies 2y agoThat assumes that the code was honorable in the first place. I think you have to assume that this was not posted by someone with honorable intentions.
- 0points 2y agoI forge git commits now and then so I know this but maybe it is not common knowledge. Git commits can be forged. Content and dates can be changed.
- de_elusive 2y agoVery rude comment imho. Do 1password/lastpass extensions not include remote code/resources? Of course they do.
- freitzzz 2y agoThe additional features this tool brings (port enumeration, list usb devices, system info), makes me thing the tool was not designed for good/ethical reasons, but to ease the life of infostealers that are usually distributed via Discord.
- Fokamul 2y ago[flagged]
- 0points 2y agoIn the grown up world where people can hold a respectful discussion, there's a difference between being able to use stock code in your malware and distributing ready-to-be-used code.
- brnt 2y agoYou are aware that satellite guided surface to air missile systems are not a mere git clone away? There are good reasons for controlling weapons, while still letting everybody be free to study them.
- notachatbot123 2y agoNo one is talking about a satellite guided surface to air missile system.
- icf80 2y agoNo Primary Password ?
- nikolayasdf123 2y agodoes Chrome doing this better?
- de_elusive 2y agoYou still need access to the key to decrypt it regardless of the browser.
- bdash 2y agohttps://security.googleblog.com/2024/07/improving-security-of-chrome-cookies-on.html https://security.googleblog.com/2024/07/improving-security-o... talks a little about improvements Chrome has made on Windows to make it harder for malicious software to access the encryption key used to encrypt cookies and passwords on disk.
- mambo45 2y agoIs this some AI generated bullshit?
- mambo45 2y agoIs this some AI generated rubbish or actual code that works? If this is code that works, does setting a primary password protect against this decryptor?
- rkangel 2y agoI would love to hear any suggestions for how to remove all my stored passwords in Firefox. I used to use Firefox password manager but moved to Bitwarden. It has been surprisingly difficult to remove passwords completely as I'm using Firefox Sync, and they just get restored from one of my devices.
- gtirloni 2y agoYou have to sign out of all devices and choose to delete the local data while you do so. Another option is to delete your Mozilla account and recreate it, if you're not using it for anything other than Firefox Sync.