5 ms·
Solar power from space? it might happen in a couple of years
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoPlenty of reasons to want this to work. Ground-based solar has so many flaws - ecological, legal, social, even efficiency is poor. And we aren't making any more open ground near cities to put square miles of solar farms. Space-based is becoming more attractive every year. Lift costs, panel weight and cost, computing power are all going in the right direction to improve the space-solar economic equation. As for space, a few square miles is trivial to find a place for. Further, the usual bugaboos about "How do you get it down here?!" (microwaves to high-capacity receivers) can be circumvented entirely if you use the power in space e.g. in AI-training compute centers also in orbit.
- akira2501 2y ago> even efficiency is poor. Not really. The atmosphere does reduce solar energy at the surface, but the fact we're 1 AU from the sun is the major reason we receive so little power. The costs of putting things into orbit and maintaining things in orbit are unlikely to ever overcome the atmospheric difference. Plus, on the surface of the Earth, you get convective cooling in atmosphere "for free." Good luck keeping your panels cool on orbit.
- bloedsinnig 2y agoGround based solar has very little flaws. Its cheap (its just silicium plates), we will have organic based systems in the future. You will be able to print it in the future. Efficency is huge. We have so much unused roof space, its ridicoulous. parking spots, house roofs, commercial building roofs. Why would you think its smart to send computers, which need cooling, up to use the energy over there? Do you know how hard it is to radiate heat away in space?
- scotty79 2y ago> commercial building roofs. And southern walls.
- geraldcombs 2y agoAnd canals: https://www.tid.org/current-projects/project-nexus/ https://www.tid.org/current-projects/project-nexus/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- euroderf 2y agoSpace-based will by necessity be centralised. Some businesspeople like that kind of thing.
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoAll the usual 'obvious' points; all wrong. Rooftop solar is pointless. Roofs don't scale; roofs are not optimally placed; roofs are hard to reach; roofs are not engineered to support the load or hardware. Open cheap unobstructed ground near a grid with clear access are optimal. Roofs are exactly zero of those. Efficincy is 50% at best - the daily occurrence of the terrestrial eclipse known as 'night'? Remember? Any panel argument is the same in space. Don't know what that point was about. Using energy near the generation point is optimal. The heat argument is good; it goes double for a planet that's already heating up and causing problems. Get that shit away from our ecosystems. Any advantage of ground-based solar is eroding daily with advances in lift cost, land price rises, congestion in cities. It's only a matter of time and money.
- dekhn 2y agoWe don't need open ground near cities to put square miles of solar farms. Why would you do that? We have long-distance transmission lines. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_DC_Intertie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_DC_Intertie is 3GW from The Dalles Oregon to Los Angeles (as well as other parts of the west). Putting AI training in space is daft. Heat dissipation is the problem (on top of gravity)
- mbreese 2y ago> can be circumvented entirely if you use the power in space e.g. in AI-training compute centers also in orbit. In addition to power requirements and data transfer, I always thought that the main logistical issue with in-orbit computers was heat dissipation. If you have a need for compute in orbit (let’s assume this is true), you’d still need a way to dissipate heat. But this isn’t something that can happen easily in space. (But it makes me wonder if you could have a Peltier generator attached to a hot chip to remove heat and “recycle” some of that energy back into electricity… not that it would help too much with the other issue with compute in orbit - data transfer)
- schmidtleonard 2y agoPeltier gives you energy in exchange for making heat transfer worse. Or you can make heat transfer better by paying a bit of energy. The exchange rate is very poor in both directions.
- mbreese 2y agoI know they are very inefficient, but are they more inefficient at heat transfer than the alternative of radiant cooling? I have no idea. I know they are used for electricity generation on some other spacecraft, but I always thought it was because it was a method of last resort. But I had never considered if a Peltier would work for cooling.
- schmidtleonard 2y agoPeltiers are never an alternative to radiant cooling. They do not get rid of heat, they pump it from one side to another (if you apply power) or resist its flow (if you extract power -- this is what RTGs do). You still have to get rid of the heat when it reaches the other side of the Peltier.
- brianbreslin 2y agoforgive my ignorance on this q. I always assumed based on movies that the temperatures in space were very cold (like near absolute zero). So wouldn't putting a hot data center in space just dissipate heat? Do shuttles and space stations not radiate heat?
- JoeAltmaier 2y ago...and today somebody posts a WSJ article on exactly this subject.
- bloedsinnig 2y agoThats just not realistic at all. Its so far away from realistic, i'm not sure why arstechnica is posting this VC ad. You need the size of the area you want to shine it up which is HUGE. Why do we entertain this? How do people get funding for doing this? Are people so ignorant?
- cooper_ganglia 2y ago10 years ago, having a reusable rocket booster was not realistic. 5 years ago, catching a rocket booster with a tower was not realistic. The past 150 years has been wild, I'm not too sure I think anything is unrealistic anymore.
- bloedsinnig 2y agoHow about we plaster our existing area full of PV and than in 10 years we talk about space?
- jandrese 2y ago> it might happen in a couple of years Narrator: It will not happen. The only place space based solar makes sense is on things that are in space.
- mechagodzilla 2y agoI think there probably is an actual niche for space-based solar, depending on how retarget-able it is. Imagine being able to beam 24/7 power to remote mining or military installations, or if you could really steer it, beaming it the receiving station with the highest power prices. If it's competing with diesel that needs to be flown in (or trucked through hazardous terrain), it would be much easier for it to be competitive.
- czbond 2y agoGood counter points, thanks for sharing those.
- idontwantthis 2y agoSo you would build a solar array in space at enormous cost and then need to truck or fly in a receiver, and build it. Versus trucking and building a solar plant with batteries on site. I still don’t think that it’s ever going to make sense.
- feoren 2y agoHave you seen an EIS (Environmental Impact Statement) for a new mine in pristine wilderness? They take tens of millions of dollars and the better part of a decade. Mining companies would throw money at you if you could turn "ship in and burn a bunch of diesel on-site" or "clear 200 acres of wilderness for solar panels" into "build a small collector on-site one time" in their EIS. That being said, there aren't that many new mine sites going up in the world. I suspect we could get collectors pretty small and efficient if they were optimized.
- jandrese 2y ago
- Ajedi32 2y agoThe article is extremely light on details, and I'm highly skeptical of the economics, though I do think its cool that they seem to be actively planning a demonstration mission. If nothing else, it would be neat to see the concept demonstrated in a real spacecraft. I listened to a podcast[1] a few months ago which proposed the (IMHO) more innovative idea of using giant, ultra-light foil mirrors in space to sell sunlight to existing solar farms at night. Aetherflux seems to be using the more traditional solar panels + IR laser approach, which seems harder to justify the cost of compared to batteries. [1]: https://firstprinciples.fm/episodes/8-ben-nowack-selling-sunlight-to-solar-farms-after-dark https://firstprinciples.fm/episodes/8-ben-nowack-selling-sun...
- sapphicsnail 2y ago> I listened to a podcast[1] a few months ago which proposed the (IMHO) more innovative idea of using giant, ultra-light foil mirrors in space to sell sunlight to existing solar farms at night. What would that look like from Earth? I can't imagine star-gazing with a giant mirror shining down on me.
- Ajedi32 2y agoI think the idea is it would look a bit like daylight, but only if you're in the area being lit (e.g. standing next to the solar farm), otherwise you wouldn't see it at all. But in practice, I'm not sure. I could imagine light leakage being an issue.
- d--b 2y agoA mobile receiving station? Uh? That sounds really bad, right?
- ChoHag 2y ago[dead]
- josh11b 2y agohttps://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/space-based-solar-power-is-not-a-thing/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/space-based-so...
- cryptonector 2y agoThis had better not heat the atmosphere...
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThese satellites also shade the Earth.
- feoren 2y agoIn Geostationary orbit? Only for something like 3% of the time. The rest of the time they're off to the side. They'd mostly be catching light that would otherwise never hit Earth.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe proposed satellites are in LEO.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- euroderf 2y agoThat's not a bug, that's a feature.
- jmyeet 2y agoI'll keep saying this until I'm blue in the face: solar power is the future. It is the only form of power generation that directly genreates power rather than turning a turbine. As such it has no moving parts (apart from, maybe, an array that gets tilted to face the Sun for higher efficiency but that's optional) and has no emissions. The cost of solar power has plummetted in the last 2 decades and nobody is quite sure where this will bottom out. Now obviously sometimes it's night time and sometimes it's just cloudy. You have a number of options for this, in increasing level of engineering and technological difficulty: 1. Do nothing. Just take power when it is available. This works surprisingly well for a lot of our power usage. Power usage peaks in daylight hours so solar reduces your baseload requirements. Sometimes you can simply do things when the weather doesn't permit (eg data centers). 2. Store excess power in another form. This could be batteries but it could also be things like sequestering carbon from the air into a hydrocarbon form you can later burn for power. This is carbon neutral by definition. This method currently isn't economic. In some cases that doesn't matter (eg in cold climates where current batteries aren't particularly effective). 3. Power satellites that bean down power. A solar collector in space would produce ~7 times as much power as a terrestrial collector because there's no day/night or weather interruptions nor atmospheric loss. It is technically feasible to beam down power. 4. Build an orbital ring. Attach solar collectors to it. Run cables to the ground. Obviously this is more far future. More [1]. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBCbdThIJNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eBCbdThIJNE
- euroderf 2y agoWon't your #2 be economic when photovoltaic power is basically free ? The day is coming.
- mprev 2y agoDid we learn nothing from Sim City?
- brianbreslin 2y agoSurprised no one has mentioned the classic Sim City 2000 microwave power plants that tended to erupt into flames. [1] [1] https://simcity.fandom.com/wiki/Microwave_Power_Plant https://simcity.fandom.com/wiki/Microwave_Power_Plant
- godelski 2y agoDon't hold your breath on this one. I expect it to take a lot longer, but not for technical reasons. The truth is that however you do this you are developing weapons. At best, your allies will be on your side but your enemies will play this up, discussing how versions of whatever you do can be used against them. And even if exaggerated (and boy will it be), there will be grains of truth. These are the hardest lies to fight because they're half lies. The problem always lies in how you get that energy down to Earth. There's no way to do this that can't also be used in a way that can be destructive. Even this proposal at 1kW you can do some damage. They're doing IR because this is fairly transmissible through the atmosphere but it can still be damaging. These range from a directed energy weapon (likely aimed at electronics) to a more denial of service attack (you'd need higher energy than 1kW). There's another proposal about just redirecting light[0] and I think it is easier to imagine how this is a weapon. Could you imagine someone just making you, in your house (or worse, it follows you around), always live in daylight? It would drive you crazy. I know the Nords, Alaskans, Canadians, and others will tell you there's challenges to living in perpetual daylight. But you can destabilize crops, which need night, insects and wildlife, and I'll let your imagination run wild. But this is also true for IR light, you just won't see it with your eyes. That still affects many insects, snakes, fish, and other animals, not to mention plants. IR is heat, and it doesn't take much heat to disrupt things. On a different point: > told me he wants to reinvent the idea of space-based solar power beginning with a relatively small investment—likely a bit north of $10 million > That physicist is Baiju Bhatt, who co-founded the electronic trading platform Robinhood in 2013 He's asking for $10m? Why? Can someone help me with this? Forbes has him at $1.7bn net worth[1]. $10m is nothing to this guy, right? Even if he doesn't have that cash liquid it should be very easy for him to get a very low interest rate loan where the maturity is upon death that will give him access to this level of money. So why does he need the investment? What am I missing? [0] https://x.com/colecallinan/status/1826683972207661499 https://x.com/colecallinan/status/1826683972207661499 [1] https://www.forbes.com/profile/baiju-bhatt/ https://www.forbes.com/profile/baiju-bhatt/
- bryanlarsen 2y ago200 w/sqm is not a weapon. It's barely enough to keep you warm in the winter time.
- johnea 2y agoDoesn't ALL solar power come from space?
- highflux7 2y agohttps://spectrum.ieee.org/space-based-solar-power-2667878868 https://spectrum.ieee.org/space-based-solar-power-2667878868