4 ms·
> but now that renewables are the cheapest form of energy, I believe this huge, well-funded demand will accelerate the growth of non-carbon energy sources I th
by ben_w 2y ago
> but now that renewables are the cheapest form of energy, I believe this huge, well-funded demand will accelerate the growth of non-carbon energy sources
I think the renewables would have been built at the same rate anyway precisely because they're so cheap; but nuclear power, being expensive, would not be built if this bubble had not happened, and somehow nuclear does seem to be getting some of this money.
- atomic128 2y agoI want to point out to anyone who's interested in the nuclear angle that even before the AI data center demand story arrived, the uranium market was facing a persistent undersupply for the first time in its many decades of history. As a result, the (long-term contract) price of uranium has been steadily rising for years: https://www.cameco.com/invest/markets/uranium-price https://www.cameco.com/invest/markets/uranium-price After Fukushima (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41768726 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41768726), Japanese reactors were shut down and there was a glut of uranium available in the spot market. Simultaneously, Kazatomprom flooded the market with cheap ISR uranium. The price of uranium fell far below the cost of production and the mining companies were obliterated. The few miners that survived via their long-term contracts (primarily Cameco) put their less efficient mines into care and maintenance. Now we're seeing the uranium mining business wake up. But after a decade of bear-market conditions the miners cannot serve the demand: they've underinvested, they've lost skilled labor, they've shrunk. The rebound in uranium supply will be slow, much slower than the rebound in demand. This is because uranium mining is an extremely difficult process. Look at how long NexGen Energy's Rook 1 Arrow mine has taken to develop, and that's prime ore (https://s28.q4cdn.com/891672792/files/doc_downloads/2022/03/0000-BA00-RPT-0002_2-compressed.pdf https://s28.q4cdn.com/891672792/files/doc_downloads/2022/03/...). Look at Kazatomprom's slowing growth rate (https://world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Kazatomprom-lowers-2025-uranium-production-expecta https://world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/Kazatomprom-lowers-2...), look at the incredible complexity of Cameco's mining operations: https://www.petersenproducts.com/articles/an-inflatable-tunnel-seal-stops-flooding-of-the-worlds-largest-undeveloped-uranium-mine.html https://www.petersenproducts.com/articles/an-inflatable-tunn... Here is a discussion of the uranium mining situtation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41661768 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41661768 (including a very risky method of profiting from the undersupply of uranium, stock ticker SRUUF, not recommended). Note that Numerco's uranium spot price was put behind a paywall last week. You can still get the intra-day spot uranium price for free here: https://www.yellowcakeplc.com/ https://www.yellowcakeplc.com/
- ben_w 2y agoUranium, at least the un-enriched kind you can just buy, was never the problem. Even the peak of that graph (136… er, USD per lb?) is essentially a rounding error compared to everything else. 0.00191 USD/kWh? Something like that, depends on the type of reactor it goes in.
- atomic128 2y agoYou are correct. This is one of the advantages of nuclear power. The fuel is a tiny fraction of the cost of running the plant. See discussion here, contrasting with natural gas: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41858892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41858892 It is also important that the fuel is physically small so you can (and typically, do) store years of fuel on-site at the reactor. Nuclear is "secure" in the sense that it can provide "energy security".
- ben_w 2y agoIt would only be an advantage if everything in the power plant else wasn't so expensive. And I'm saying that as someone who finds all this stuff cool and would like to see it used in international shipping.
- atomic128 2y agoDiscussed at length here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41863388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41863388 I already linked this above, twice. I know it's a hassle to read, it's Sunday afternoon, so don't worry about it. It's not important whether you as an individual get this right or not, as long as society reaches the correct conclusion. Thankfully, we're seeing that happen, a worldwide shift toward the adoption of nuclear power. Have a pleasant evening!
- synergy20 2y agobased on my reading nuclear power is much cheaper overall compared to wind solar etc?
- atomic128 2y agoYes, that's right. See the recent discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41860341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41860341 Basically, nuclear fission is clean baseload power. Wind and solar are not baseload power sources. They don't really compete. See discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41858892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41858892 Furthermore, we're seeing interest (from Google and Amazon and Dow Chemical) in expensive but completely safe TRISO (HALEU) reactors (https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/triso-particles-most-robust-nuclear-fuel-earth https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/triso-particles-most-robu...). These companies want clean baseload power, with no risk of meltdown, and they're willing to pay for it. Here's what Amazon has chosen: https://x-energy.com/fuel/triso-x https://x-energy.com/fuel/triso-x TRISO (HALEU) reactors use more than 1.5 times the natural uranium per unit of energy produced because the higher burnup is offset by higher enrichment inputs (see page 11 at https://fuelcycleoptions.inl.gov/SiteAssets/SitePages/Home/182926.pdf https://fuelcycleoptions.inl.gov/SiteAssets/SitePages/Home/1...), and the fuel is even more expensive to manufacture, but they are completely safe. This is a technology from the 1960's but it's attractive now because so much money is chasing clean baseload nuclear fission for data centers. These "impossible to melt down" TRISO small modular nuclear fission reactors are what Elon Musk was talking about on the campaign trail last week, when he said: ELON MUSK: "The dangers of nuclear power are greatly overstated. You can make a nuclear reactor that is literally impossible to melt down even if you tried to melt it down. You could try to bomb the place, and it still wouldn't melt down. There should be no regulatory issues with that. There should be significant nuclear reform." https://x.com/AutismCapital/status/1847452008502219111 https://x.com/AutismCapital/status/1847452008502219111
- ViewTrick1002 2y ago> Basically, nuclear fission is clean baseload power. Wind and solar are not baseload power sources. They don't really compete. This means you don't understand how the grid works. California's baseload is ~15 GW while it peaks at 50 GW. New built nuclear power is wholly unsuitable for load following duty due to the economics. It is an insane prospect when running at 100% 24/7, and even worse when it has to adapt. Both nuclear power and renewables need storage, flexibility or other measures to match their inflexibility to the grid. See the recent study where it was found that nuclear power needs to come down 85% in cost to be competitive with renewables, due to both options requiring dispatchable power to meet the grid load. > The study finds that investments in flexibility in the electricity supply are needed in both systems due to the constant production pattern of nuclear and the variability of renewable energy sources. However, the scenario with high nuclear implementation is 1.2 billion EUR more expensive annually compared to a scenario only based on renewables, with all systems completely balancing supply and demand across all energy sectors in every hour. For nuclear power to be cost competitive with renewables an investment cost of 1.55 MEUR/MW must be achieved, which is substantially below any cost projection for nuclear power. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306261924010882 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626192... > These companies want clean baseload power, with no risk of meltdown, and they're willing to pay for it. Here's what Amazon has chosen The recent announcements from the hyperscalers are PPAs. If the company building the reactor can provide power at the agreed price they will take it off their hands. Thus creating a more stable financial environment to get funding. They are not investing anything on their own. For a recent example NuScale another SMR developer essentially collapsed when their Utah deal fell through when nice renders and PowerPoints met real world costs and deadlines. https://iceberg-research.com/2023/10/19/nuscale-power-smr-a-fake-customer-and-a-major-contract-in-peril-cast-doubt-on-nuscales-viability/ https://iceberg-research.com/2023/10/19/nuscale-power-smr-a-... > with no risk of meltdown Then we should be able to remove the enormous subsidy the Price Anderson act adds to the industry right? Let all new reactors buy insurance for a Fukushima level accident in the open market. Nuclear powerplants are currently insured for ~0.05% of the cost of a Fukushima style accident and pooled together the entire US industry covers less than 5%. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear_Industries_Indemnity_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price%E2%80%93Anderson_Nuclear...
- rsynnott 2y ago> but nuclear power, being expensive, would not be built if this bubble had not happened, and somehow nuclear does seem to be getting some of this money Eh, it's generally SMRs, which remain kinda vapourware-y. I'd be a little surprised if anything concrete comes of it, tbh; I suspect that it is mostly PR cover for reactivating coal plants and the like. (The one possibly-real thing might be the Three Mile Island restart, but that in itself isn't particularly consequential.)