4 ms·
> How could an effect precede a cause if there were no speed limit to causality? > No matter how fast an effect propogates, it is always after the cause (with
by andsoitis 2y ago
> How could an effect precede a cause if there were no speed limit to causality?
> No matter how fast an effect propogates, it is always after the cause (with an infinite speed, I guess effects happen instantaneously, but not before).
If everything happens instantaneously then there is no real cause and effect, and the universe would be over before it really got started.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThis is the experience of a photon.
- amelius 2y agoNo speed limit does not mean that everything goes infinitely fast.
- lazide 2y agoIf the speed limit is infinite, what else would you expect to happen?
- amelius 2y agoLight traveling at infinite speeds, atoms and such not.
- andsoitis 2y agoIf effects were instantaneous then atoms would not exist.
- amelius 2y agoThere can be many types of effects in a hypothetical universe. Imagine a universe like Conway's way of life, where only neighboring cells can be affected in one timestep. Now add to it a rule that all blocks have a color, and the color of all blocks are changed when one block changes color. Now you have a universe with both immediate and non-immediate effects.
- jodrellblank 2y agoBut what is “One time step” in that universe? We have the idea of a light clock - light bouncing between two perfect mirrors in a vacuum - as an ultimate clock. The distance between the mirrors is a number of meters. A meter is based on how far light travels in a second. How long it takes light to go between them is based on the speed of light. Speed, distance and time are connected. If we untether the speed of light and it’s unlimited, then in some sense there is no way to say how long it takes light to bounce between the mirrors - it doesn’t take any time. And there is no way to say how far apart the mirrors are, if light passes between them instantly that implies there must be no gap to cross. If light crosses no distance in no time then it also bounces back covering no distance in no time, ahh does lots of bounces in no time. There goes the concept of a time step and any concept of “non immediate effects”. If you try and add time as a separate thing, then you have some kind of Conway’s game simulation - but that gives you a way to track where light is (which simulation cell it’s in) and therefore a kind of distance (how far the mirrors are apart in simulation cells) and then you lock down how light moves in “simulation cells travelled per timestep” which brings you back to a fixed speed of light again.
- lazide 2y agoA ‘one level of cells in one timestep’ is a speed limit, and a very slow one actually.
- andsoitis 2y agowhat assumptions have to be true for such a universe to exist? did it just appear fully formed with N number of cells and defaulting to a color? a hypothetical universe is mostly worth discussing seriously if there's a physics that is coherent, not just a mathematical landscape. At least it isn't that interesting in the discussion of universes, but might be in discussing mathematical ideas, but those do not necessarily mean there's a universe represented by it.
- dcow 2y agoWolfram would disagree.
- tremon 2y agoYou're saying that an atom's decay rate is a function of the speed of light? What proof do we have of this? Does Newton's law of momentum also erroneously leave out the c component?
- lazide 2y agoIf decay rate is related to the elements composition (seems to be true), and the forces holding elements together include Electromagnetism and the Lorentz Force which also seems to be true, then yes. [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_electromagnetism_and_special_relativity#:~:text=The%20theory%20of%20special%20relativity,frame%20of%20reference%20to%20another https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_electromagnetism_a....] See also [https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_four-potential https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_four-potenti...] Notably, light is a form of electromagnetism, so this shouldn’t be as surprising as it is. c is an explicit part of many formulas, interestingly. And electromagnetism was the first thing tackled in special relativity.
- simonh 2y agoAbsence of a speed limit doesn't mean all speeds are infinite. It's just the picture everyone assumed before relativity.
- bryanrasmussen 2y agoold grannies driving at 30mph on the freeway, me at infinity. on edit: not everything travels at the speed limit, if the speed limit right now is the speed of light - then why doesn't everything travel at the speed of light? People say if the speed limit was infinite that everything would happen instantaneously - but they still need to explain why everything should go at the speed limit in this other universe, when not everything goes at the speed limit in ours.
- lazide 2y agoAlmost everything (electrical fields, atomic radius, even speed of sound in materials) seems to derive in some way from the speed of light and related effects.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bryanrasmussen 2y agoperhaps this is an effect of having a speed limit in a universe, if a universe does not have any set speed limit (which is somewhat different than the phrasing speed limit is infinite) perhaps the discussed derivation of other speeds would not exist in the way it does in our universe.
- lazide 2y agoAnything is possible if anything is possible. In this universe, fundamental forces like electromagnetism directly contain things like c, so if c is infinite, everything is going to work very differently.
- jncfhnb 2y agoThe speed limit being infinitely large does not intuitively imply that anything should be able to go at infinite speed.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoAgreed, an infinite speed was just the most extreme edge case of having no limit.
- kazinator 2y agoBut that case can be explicitly ruled. There being no highest speed doesn't mean that there is infinite speed. No edge, no edge case.
- withinboredom 2y agoI'm having trouble with this assertion. Light travels slower in water than in air, by your assertion that light is the limit of causality; then surely we can create a paradox with ftl right in a pool.
- coldtea 2y ago>Light travels slower in water than in air, by your assertion that light is the limit of causality The limit of causality is the light speed limit in vacuum, not "whatever happens to be the max speed of light in some medium". Light (as in visible light) is also irrelevant to this, it's just an example of something moving at that speed.
- withinboredom 2y agoI fail to see how a vacuum permits violations of casualty. Care to explain?
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoThe vacuum has nothing to do with causality. It's just that light (if there is nothing in its way, so in a vacuum) will travel at the max speed of causality. Causality violation can happen in general relativity when something moves faster than the max speed of causality (which is the same speed as light in a vacuum).
- andsoitis 2y ago> Causality violation can happen in general relativity The only theoretical case I’m aware of are closed timelike curves (CTC) which are paths in spacetime that loop back on themselves, allowing an object to return to its own past. A famous example is the Gödel metric, a solution to Einstein’a field equations. It should be noted, however, that these solutions are generally regarded as unphysical because they require conditions that don’t seem to exist in our universe (such as a globally rotating universe).
- 2y ago