4 ms·
Apple's macOS Sequoia lets you snap windows into position
- OtherShrezzing 2y agoFinally, the UX on the Mac is perfect.
- aliasxneo 2y agoAlmost. Compared to the existing third-party tiling managers, this seems to cover the bare-bone basics and nothing more. But that probably also satisfies a large portion of the userbase.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agoWhat is it missing?
- lhousa 2y agoTry rectangle and you'll see
- ListenLinda 2y agoTry AeroSpace.
- thiht 2y agoRectangle does much more, but it actually lacks the one feature I need with window snapping: the ability to resize both snapped windows at the same time. The native Sequoia snapping does it. I only ever use snapping for left/right snapping (I never used 1/3 snapping or corner snapping or other Rectangle features) so I’m glad I finally need one less third party app.
- yndoendo 2y agoAll models are flawed, some are still useful. Cars are a great example of this. The majority of them have an underline design flaw but people keep buying them with said flaw. The door entry is not designed for parking lots / car parks.
- nkmskdmfodf 2y agoFinally the UX on mac is almost half as good as a 15 year old linux window manager.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hu3 2y agoit's pretty far still. I don't think Apple prioritizes power users much. Their products tend to cater for less tech savvy folks.
- jwells89 2y agomacOS has plenty of power user affordances, they're just Apple/NeXT-flavored rather than Windows/Linux-flavored and might not be as immediately obvious to users coming from other platforms.
- hu3 2y agoI used and still use macOS, Windows and Linux. For decade(s). Because of consulting. macOS breaks a bunch of my stuff in every update. Window management still atrocious. Many functionalities present in other OS by default require third party tools and subscriptions. Apple hashes every executable I run and sends to their servers. I prefer working with Linux/x86 platforms. I get to enjoy faster hardware and predictable, customizable software.
- jwells89 2y agoThat preference is totally legitimate. There are however many types of power users, including those who extensively customize and augment their desktops and sync their dotfiles, as well as those who know all the key shortcuts, tips and tricks, etc but run mostly-stock configs. I’m in the latter camp and it’s exceptionally rare that major OS updates break anything for me.
- MrHamburger 2y agoCan I finally change the Enter behavior in Finder? Or do I need to be forced to rename everything still?
- webkike 2y agoIt’s better. But not great. The margins are far too large, and resizing is pretty poor.
- Benjaminsen 2y agoMargins can be turned off in settings.
- bitcurious 2y agoWhere in settings?
- crazygringo 2y agoSettings > Desktop & Dock > Windows > Tiled windows have margins > (turn off)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- js2 2y agoSettings > Desktop & Dock > Windows > Tiled windows have margins. https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/change-window-tiling-settings-on-mac-mchl118087b0/15.0/mac/15.0 https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/change-window-tilin...
- webkike 2y agoEven with the setting to turn them off, they are too large
- cassianoleal 2y agoWith the setting off, there are no margins. How is 0 too large?
- webkike 2y ago
- datadrivenangel 2y agoRectangle is an app that allows you to do window snapping!
- thih9 2y agoThe article references Rectangle: > It’s packed with every feature you could possibly want, though I think Magnet is a little more intuitive to use.
- stackedinserter 2y agoNah it does too little to justify the hassle of installing it and memorizing its shortcuts. Just give me iTerm-like split windows, I'm dying.
- tgv 2y agoI use it too. I immediately switched off the new snapping feature. Snapping it to half the screen is just not right. I like my browser, email program and code editor considerably wider.
- yokoprime 2y agoNot great, not terrible
- voisin 2y agoAre there hotkeys for these?
- codesnik 2y agothere are, even with defaults. Look in "Window > Move and resize" menu of any app.
- _fat_santa 2y agoI don't run MacOS anymore but based off the comments it sounds like the window snapping is not that great yet. Makes me wonder, why not just buy Magnet or one of the many other apps that do this and integrate the source into MacOS.
- thiht 2y ago1 less third party app to install and rely on. The only snapping features I use are snap left, snap right, and resize both snapped windows at the same time (which Rectangle doesn’t do). Sometimes less is more, I’m more happy with Sequoia native snapping than with Rectangle/Magnet
- thih9 2y agoWhy not build own version? Current approach sounds best to me, Apple gets to implement a (relatively simple) feature exactly how they want, power users and existing users can rely on third party apps.
- nkmskdmfodf 2y ago> Why not build own version? Probably because it costs like 10k per line of code for apple to implement anything decent. (not claiming that magnet is decent)
- thih9 2y agoDo you have a source? Preferably one that also says that Apple doesn’t spend that much when using code from companies they have bought?
- aranchelk 2y agoI imagine this situation is kind of unique. Once a company finds out the features they sell will be integrated into the 1st party platform, and they have a chance to get out of the business, and they know they’ve got competitors that Apple could turn to next, I imagine Apple would be getting a steep discount. Especially if it’s an aqui-hire — peace of mind the employees will be taken care of.
- iqandjoke 2y agoAt least it is working with Stage Manager...
- js2 2y ago> Note: unfortunately, there aren’t any specific keyboard shortcuts for moving windows into the quarter sections of the screen. I'm surprised The Verge apparently doesn't know that you can create keyboard shortcuts for any Mac menu item, either specific to an app or across apps. You can even override existing shortcuts: https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/create-keyboard-shortcuts-for-apps-mchlp2271/15.0/mac/15.0 https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/create-keyboard-sho...
- roopepal 2y ago> I'm surprised The Verge apparently doesn't know Really? Personally, at this point, I'm generally more surprised when they do.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lelandfe 2y agoExcept when Apple implements their apps poorly, like Find in Apple Music, whose hot key does not activate the menubar item and thus Cmd-F cannot be rebound. This also makes a lot of Electron apps’ hot keys unable to be rebound as well; VS Code faces this issue.
- js2 2y agoI don't know what's going on with Apple Music. I can rebind Cmd-F to any of its menu items if I do it for all applications, but not if I target Music specifically.
- jwells89 2y agoMusic on macOS is really weird architecturally. Parts are native, parts are WebViews, and I wouldn't be surprised if there's even still some bits of code leftover from the days Music/iTunes was still known as SoundJam MP. They're likely doing something funky to implement its shortcuts because the standard way wouldn't work everywhere in the app. Ironically, at this point the cleanest implementation of Apple Music might actually be the Windows version, which as far as I can tell is a fresh codebase written exclusively in WinUI/WinAppSDK. Many hoped that the transition from iTunes → Music.app would turn out to be a blank-slate AppKit rewrite on macOS but that's not what we got.
- davepeck 2y agoRectangle (OSS), Moom, and Magnet are all good options if you want to go beyond what Sequoia supports. I've used Moom for years and particularly like its behavior when external monitors are added/removed.
- CraigJPerry 2y agoRaycast ftw - I can set margins and add entirely custom window positions and it all hooks into the same keyboard shortcuts mechanism. I kinda like the ratpoison or i3 approaches to window management (which I’d characterise as “don’t worry about it, I’ll just do the right thing until you tell me to resize or rotate or whatever”) better though.
- jwells89 2y agoAnother vote for Moom here. By default it doesn't have any Aero Snap style drag zones and only presents itself as a hover-popover attached to the green button, which is perfect for my use of snapping which is only occasional. Its ability to divide your screen into a grid of your choosing is nice too. Yes it's not free, but it's a cheap one-time purchase and I've been using the same license for a decade now, so it's close enough to free that the difference is moot.
- j_crick 2y agoDon't forget SizeUp too!
- nkmskdmfodf 2y ago[flagged]
- DonHopkins 2y agoWindow management is a perfect application for pie menus, since many of the directional items can be arranged in obvious layouts, and you use them frequently, so you learn them well and can use them in "expert" mouse-ahead style quickly and efficiently, saving a lot of time overall. For example, the NeWS tabbed window frame pie menus placed the common "front" and "back" commands up and down, had a "grab" submenu with eight directions to drag the four corners and four edges, and a "move" submenu with vertically and horizontally and unconstrained mode, etc. They worked really well with mouse-ahead gestures (with PacMan feedback @ 8:35)! The HyperTIES hypermedia browser had multiple windows in left and right panes, and right-clicking on a link would bring up a pie menu to open it in the left or right pane. Sorry in advance about the terrible video quality! Someday I hope to track down the equipment to read the original dv tapes, and upload better versions. Don Hopkins and pie menus in ~ Spring 1989 on a Sun Workstation, running the NEWS operating system: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Fne3j7cWzg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Fne3j7cWzg User Interface Strategies (UIS) 90 - Ben Shneiderman - Applications sections and demos: NeWS HyperTIES Space Telescope Demo, showing left/right pane link pie menus: https://youtu.be/1uyO-xUTt6Y?t=761 https://youtu.be/1uyO-xUTt6Y?t=761 The tab pie menus in the PSIBER Space Deck visual PostScript programming environment had directional submenus that would let you customize the layout, pull out to configure the scale, move the tabs to different edges, etc: https://youtu.be/1uyO-xUTt6Y?t=1484 https://youtu.be/1uyO-xUTt6Y?t=1484 https://donhopkins.medium.com/the-shape-of-psiber-space-october-1989-19e2dfa4d91e https://donhopkins.medium.com/the-shape-of-psiber-space-octo... X10 Pie Menu Window Manager: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJhvB6kwmog https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IJhvB6kwmog NeWS Tab Window Demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMcmQk-q0k4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMcmQk-q0k4 PSIBER Space Deck Demo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iuC_DDgQmsM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iuC_DDgQmsM HCIL Demo - HyperTIES Browsing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZi4gUjaGAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZi4gUjaGAM Kando is open source and cross platform, and it now lets you make your own window management and many other kinds of pie menus, with custom themes defined in CSS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVbnLsMnTYQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GVbnLsMnTYQ
- osigurdson 2y agoIt never seems like any solution comes close to the ergonomics of having two screens.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoI'm a bit weird on this front but years of working in coffee shops, co-working spaces, etc. have trained me out of relying on more than just the screen that comes with my laptop. I don't have a fixed office that I go to every day and I actually prefer it that way. The big advantage is that I can just sit down anywhere with my laptop and have everything that I need to be productive. It's gotten to the point where it's just confusing to me to have multiple screens on the rare occasion I plug one in. I'm constantly look at the wrong screen and usually I just end up unplugging the external screen because it's just easier for me. Another factor is that most screens are kind of underwhelming in terms of contrast, resolution and colors relative to what comes with a mac book. They aren't very pleasing to look at and most offices seem to settle for cheap Dell 2K screens or something similarly dreary. Ergonomically, I like laptops and not having to get a neck cramp looking up at some screen. I use my laptop on my lap quit often. Couches are great for that. Mostly I use applications maximized and just alt+tab between them as needed. Because of the notch, using applications full screen is kind of pointless. Effectively the space around the notch is only usable for the menu. So, the choice is really whether you want a menu or not. In my case, the answer is yes I want the menu there. Full screen is one of those features that became an anti-feature. Apple should just get rid of that. So these new features are wasted on me. I don't see why I would want to split the screen between two apps. I only use one at the time mostly.
- ruined 2y agoit's kinda wild to see decades-old linux desktop features finally arrive on the platform regarded as the pinnacle of UX
- amelius 2y agoApple isn't very good at UX. They just have the manpower to fix things until the CEO stops complaining. Three things come to mind regarding bad Apple UX: 1. USB ports on the back of a screen 2. No separate Copy/Paste keys, or Undo/Redo keys. 3. Magic mouse with a USB port on the bottom (so you can't use it while charging). 4. Sideways traffic light on top of windows 5. Maximizing windows to full screen is hard to do.
- thiht 2y ago> No separate Copy/Paste keys, or Undo/Redo keys. What?
- charrondev 2y agoI don’t quite understand what you mean by number 2? AFAIK my PC doesn’t have “dedicated” copy paste keys. The only difference is CMD+C/V vs CTRL+C/V
- ruined 2y agosure, i didn't say you regarded them or that i regarded them, but you must agree they are generally regarded
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- johnofthesea 2y agoDoes it tile windows automatically like Yabai for example?
- evanjrowley 2y agoIt's OK, but far from enough for a power user. After trying it out, I decided to go back to using the open source Rectangle: https://rectangleapp.com/ https://rectangleapp.com/
- newaccountman2 2y agoWould like to shoutout Lasso here Also, Windows Fancy Zones is very good in this area, fwiw (obvs not available on Mac, just saying, it's extremely good). Bento for Mac tries to be like Fancy Zones, but it falls short for some reason I don't recall, some key feature they don't support (I think maybe it was ability to have different splits for different monitors, will have to try it again)
- drooopy 2y agoDoes Microsoft still own a patent for window snapping? Could this be why windows on Sequoia don't snap exactly at the screen border but leave a gap of a few pixels?
- jwells89 2y agoAs noted in another comment thread, there's a setting to disable margins when tiling so that's probably not an issue. IIRC Microsoft and Apple have a patent-sharing agreement (which is why MS Surface products have MagSafe-cousin power plugs). It probably has more to do with how tiling with no margins with rounded window corners looks kinda awkward and entirely obscures the desktop, which is a bit more of a pillar UI element on macOS than it is on Windows and Windows-analogue DEs.