3 ms·
> I strongly believe we should be taxing the absolute shit out of people and working hard to flatten society We wouldn't have SpaceX or Tesla with that policy.
by WalterBright 2y ago
> I strongly believe we should be taxing the absolute shit out of people and working hard to flatten society
We wouldn't have SpaceX or Tesla with that policy.
> I genuinely believe SpaceX wouldn't be achieving nearly what it is without him
It simply wouldn't have existed without him and the conventional wisdom would instead be that what he's accomplished is impossible.
> insane people
Musk is the sane one. It's the rest of us that are insane.
- skellington 2y agothere is that very famous quote: "The reasonable man adapts himself to the world; the unreasonable man persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man," by George Bernard Shaw.
- stouset 2y ago> We wouldn't have SpaceX or Tesla with that policy. Neither you nor I have no idea what we’d have or wouldn’t have under a completely different set of policies.
- WalterBright 2y agoYeah, we do, because we've seen flattened societies and the results.
- stouset 2y agoWe’ve also seen the results of societies with extreme economic disparity. Neither seem to work out great.
- WalterBright 2y agoIn the US, we've seen enormous prosperity as a result.
- stouset 2y agoFor a small and ever-decreasing share of the population, since the seventies.
- nickpp 2y agoThe poorest people of today's developed countries are countless times richer than the kings of old - in terms of the products and services they have access to. Medicine, communication, transportation, entertainment - we can't even compare.
- whymememe 2y agoThe poorest? So the homeless opiate addict living under a city bypass is better off than King Henry VIII? Someone should tell them.
- nickpp 2y agoYes. All he has to do is walk into a hospital or detox center and he’ll have access to medical care King Henry VIII could not buy with all his riches. > opiate addict Indeed, we don’t have the technology to save people from themselves, yet. I am sure kings of old didn’t either and addicts of their time fared even worse.
- whymememe 2y agoI understand your point but all the resources and material goods in the world don’t matter if you can’t access them. > Indeed, we don’t have the technology to save people from themselves, yet. The plight of the poorest in today’s societies is far more of a social and political issue than a technological one. An issue America is particularly bad on, despite all its affluence.
- thot_experiment 2y agoYou can't seriously think that the incredible defensibility and natural resource wealth of the USA would suddenly go away if we taxed the shit out of rich people. Norway is rich and effective and much flatter than the USA so I think perhaps flatness isn't as rigidly tied to negative outcomes as you seem to think.
- nickpp 2y agoVenezuela is one of the most oil-rich countries on Earth - and they had gas shortages. It isn't enough to have resources in the ground. They are worth zero until extracted and turned into products and services. And for that you need technology, companies and entrepreneurs. When you tax "the shit out of rich people" that's what you lose. You can do it exactly one time - next time you won't have what to tax.
- thot_experiment 2y agoThis is such a ridiculous argument. You can't equivocate the USA to Venezuela. The USA has SO SO much more going for it. The USA wouldn't suddenly turn into Venezuela if we taxed the hell out of rich people, don't be absurd. The GINI coefficient of Venezuela is WORSE than the USA, it is LESS flat. Venezuela is stupidly corrupt, has had like a million coups, has it's affairs constantly meddled with by other governments. The Netherlands, Finland, Norway etc are much flatter than the USA and weirdly they haven't turned into Venezuela.
- nickpp 2y ago> You can't equivocate the USA to Venezuela Many other socialist experiments happened in the world during the last 100 years. Take your pick - they all failed miserably compared to the amazing increase in prosperity of the USA. > The USA wouldn't suddenly turn into Venezuela I never said that, please re-read my post. > Netherlands, Finland, Norway [...] haven't turned into Venezuela They haven't turn into the economic power house the US is right now either. In fact, the whole EU is waking up to the fact that they're being left behind. And they haven't "taxed the hell out of rich people", just slightly more. But coupled with just slightly more regulation, turns out the more socialism you impose on your economy, the less competitive it is. And we're talking about much smaller countries, too - but not that flat actually. Sweden is ahead and Norway is just 3 spots behind USA in the billionaires-per-capita ranking, with Finland and Netherlands not that far behind.
- snailmailman 2y agoWe landed on the moon with taxpayer money. We just don’t prioritize NASA as much anymore.
- WalterBright 2y agoAnd after landing on the moon, NASA's budget was cut.
- survirtual 2y agoWe would have even better. Elon Musk is a single man. There are a million "Elon Musks" on planet Earth crushed by the oppression of the system here, who weren't fed with a golden spoon of a rich family. In a society that provided opportunities to people that are unconnected, we would have zero reliance on such personalities. Simply because the general population lacks the vision to understand this and accepts these sort of hacks as extraordinary, does not make it true. SpaceX and Tesla would thrive without such narcissistic leaders.