13 ms·
The Oatmeal fights back, snaps photo of cash, sends money to charity
- Vivtek 14y agoCarreon's wife sounds even crazier than Carreon himself, apparently saying that there is a conspiracy of actual grammar Nazis killing Americans and that the Oatmeal is part of it. You can't make this stuff up, folks.
- shrikant 14y agoUm, I ventured on over to the bulletin board on her website, and she's basically the only poster on it, with loads and loads of posts in various discussion threads. Which are incidentally all about conspiracy theories. For some reason, the tone and structure of the wife's writing reminds me of the LoseThos situation. [1] [1] http://qaa.ath.cx/LoseThos.html http://qaa.ath.cx/LoseThos.html
- Vivtek 14y agoI guess that's a lot less funny if she's actually mentally ill.
- MartinCron 14y agoWow, I just read up on the LoseThos thing and it's heartbreaking. Call me a bleeding heart killjoy if you must, but I've recently come to the conclusion that just like prison rape and developmental disabilities, mental illness just isn't something you can make tasteful jokes about.
- Splines 14y agoWhat's even more heartbreaking is that he's quite active on HN even though he's banned. If you read his comments there's something definitely wrong with him (I hesitate using that phrase, but I don't know how else to say it). He's a talented individual with a strong work ethic, hopefully he gets the help that he needs.
- MartinCron 14y agoYes, I've seen his [dead] comments before, and had a flash of recognition reading the article. You're hesitant to use the phrase "something definitely wrong with him". That made me think of other terms, like "disturbed", "unhinged", "unbalanced" or the clinical "mentally ill" and I can't find anything that doesn't sound demeaning, judgmental, or moralistic. I think that says something about our ability to understand and help these people.
- MaysonL 14y agoSomehow, the idea that a joke can be both tasteful and gut-bustingly funny is oxymoronic. As Lord Buckley was wont to say: "If you must tell the truth, be sure to leave them laughing. Remember what they did to Jesus."
- MartinCron 14y agoToo soon. That joke is in very poor taste.
- gms7777 14y agoRight? Reading the second response by his wife was particularly disturbing. "...Just look at their cartoons. They like to kill. They think it's fun to kill. They think their friends will admire them if they kill. Without mercy! ...They are stupid, silent people, who are absolutely worthless to our society. Really, what good is their life, but a burden to the planet?" She is accusing "these people" of being murderers? Honestly, from the following comments, I'm quite a bit more concerned that this whole story will end with her going on a killing spree. I'm slowly becoming more and more convinced that this is one majorly elaborate practical joke, concocted by the oatmeal and funnyjunk to raise tons of money for charity. Because I'd rather believe that than believe that people this dense actually exist.
- edwardy20 14y ago"Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former." -Albert Einstein
- vibrunazo 14y ago> Because I'd rather believe that than believe that people this dense actually exist. Oh, just ask any hardcore religious right-winger why they think women should have no birth control or why gays shouldn't marry. The world is filled with these brain dead crazies who can't put 1 + 1 together if their life depend on it. We just don't see them too much during our day-to-day, if we're too busy inside our work routine on our little tech bubble. That we tend to forget about them. But they're all over the place.
- gms7777 14y agoHaha, you raise a valid point. And as an lgbt female, I can't say that I ever forget about them. And yes, its that same exact feeling of complete disbelief when someone that closed-minded speaks to me. However, its a bit more difficult to write it off as an elaborate hoax.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoSadly, even those these people are outliers, they still exist. One need only visit the topix message boards or the anonymous comments section of a national web site to see it. It is one of the less useful aspects of the Internet that it amplifies the small crazy voices along with the small useful ones.
- slig 14y agoSeriously. This has got to be a very elaborated troll. [1] [1] http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/06/funnyjunk-lawyers-wife-wades-into-fray-calls-critics-nazi-scumbags/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/06/funnyjunk-lawyers...
- medinismo 14y agopriceless
- brandoncor 14y agoThis quotation is particularly scary: "It's not the first time we've been targeted as sacrificial victims," Tara wrote. "We were targeted by the entire Buddhist community when I told them to go fuck themselves, for being nihilists, elitists, and authoritarians."
- minikomi 14y agoIndeed you cannot. Try browsing their personal site for a while... Mind bending. http://www.american-buddha.com/index.htm http://www.american-buddha.com/index.htm (warning, gets NSFW very quickly.)
- DigitalSea 14y agoSurely what his wife is saying could be classed as defamatory as well? Stupid move on her part, I hope she goes down as well and taints the case even further.
- DanBC 14y agoShe -or someone claiming to be her- has directly linked Inman to real Nazis in Europe. (The account joined in 2008, but web forum software is notoriously insecure and there are many ways to fake or hijack a profile. So it might not be her.) (http://www.naderlibrary.com/bulletin_board/viewtopic.php?p=18321&sid=8581b2830eedb58cab916ba97100af19 http://www.naderlibrary.com/bulletin_board/viewtopic.php?p=1...) > His mother is a psychic, who does palm reading, angel communication, tarot, channeling, psychometry, aura readings, and mediumship. She says she comes from "a line of readers, mystics in Europe." I wonder if her family associated with the Blavatsky Nazi crowd. Most of the medium/psychic whackos did. She studied with a Tibetan Shaman in Nepal. Wow. A totally crazy woman. Matt Inman has crazy parents on both sides. No wonder he's crazy, too. I'm not sure what I expect from a thread titled "Charles Carreon vs. The Illuminati and Matt Inman".
- nthitz 14y agoWait so where are the photos?
- Strallus 14y agoThat's exactly what I was wondering. Ars writes an entire article purportedly about the picture, yet they don't even have the picture.
- ch00 14y agoSeems like the Ars headline is inaccurate. Inman posts in his blog that the money is still with IndieGoGo pending a restraining order to have it transferred. "Once the money is moved, I still plan on withdrawing $211k in cash and taking a photo to send to Charles Carreon and FunnyJunk, along with the drawing of Funnyjunk's mother." http://theoatmeal.com/blog/fundraiser_update http://theoatmeal.com/blog/fundraiser_update
- sillyrabbitses 14y agoAccording to Inman's affidavit on PACER, he states "I still plan on sending a photograph of the money along with the satirical comic to FunnyJunk. However, in order to avoid having this lawsuit interfere with my expression and to avoid jeopardizing the funds from the campaign in any way, I withdrew funds from my own personal account and photographed those funds."
- JackpotDen 14y agoAnd where is that photo?
- danielweber 14y agoYesterday, IndieGoGo filed documents, revealing that 1. the money donated by PayPal was already in Inman's hands. 2. the money donated via credit card was already sent to the charities. Oddly, Inman's blog isn't as up-to-date as the court filings. Inman's filing is here: https://www.eff.org/sites/default/files/filenode/OatmealOppTRO.pdf https://www.eff.org/sites/default/files/filenode/OatmealOppT...
- necenzurat 14y agodon't wanna be a 9gag supporter but even 9gag gives some source/credit
- richardv 14y agoIt is really hard to understand how Carreon and his wife don't realise that they are digging themselves into their own hole. They even went out and bought the shovels themselves. Getting involved in a battle which isn't yours and then stretching it this far is beyond belief. It's as if they have never heard of the internet before, and expect everyone to side with them. It's pathological ignorance.
- freehunter 14y agoShooting off your mouth about an ongoing case is just asking for trouble. All of this could be brought into the courtroom, with Tara being an associate of Charles. It wouldn't be the first time a judge has ruled on a case partially due to professional behavior outside the courtroom.
- danielweber 14y agoOn the evening of June 14th, Carreon told Forbes that he didn't know what was wrong but he'd find something. “California code is just so long, but there’s something in there about this.” That evening around 9pm he donated $10, and then filed his suit the very next day claiming he had been misled.
- freehunter 14y agoYeah, because he needed standing to request an emergency restraining order. It would be much harder to prove damages if he wasn't involved.
- travisp 14y agoSadly, he's probably right. Many estimates suggest that the average American is unknowingly committing multiple felonies every day due to vague criminal statutes.
- protomyth 14y agoTry getting a definitive list of state or federal laws. No such list for the Feds and most states.
- Bobby_Tables 14y agoAm I the only one who thinks Carreon wants to be the new Jack Thompson?
- dougabug 14y agoThat's exactly what I was thinking. How long before they disbar this clown for abusing the legal system with frivolous, vindictive lawsuits?
- bravura 14y ago"One man’s vulgarity is another’s lyric." -Inman's lawyer This is going into my quotes file.
- inthewoods 14y agoThis is starting to feel like one of those fake hip-hop artists fights (recognizing that The Oatmeal is clearly in the right imho). I wonder if FunnyJunk is now just continuing this for the publicity.
- nicholassmith 14y agoIt left FJs hands a while ago now, this is all on Carreon. Unsurprisingly FJ haven't mentioned anything for a while.
- danielweber 14y agoGiven his previous attempt to drum up public outrage over Mattel's failure to take him up on his offer to represent them over another trademark dispute, there's a good chance that this whole thing was entirely Carreon's idea. "Hey, you should get a trademark, and then let me file a contingency suit against that guy who is more successful than you."
- jnsaff2 14y agoLet me quote Humphrey Bogart for you: "The only reason to have money is to tell any SOB in the world to go to hell."
- macey 14y agoTara and Charles are most clearly mentally ill. At least they have each other.
- eridius 14y agoI didn't even realize until this article that Carreon had actually donated to the campaign, apparently expressly for the purpose of then claiming that Inman was going to use the funds in a different way than promised? Except I have no idea how he can possibly argue that taking the picture of the funds is somehow wrong, when that was kind of the main objective of the fundraising (with the secondary objective being to then distribute the funds to the 2 charities).
- ww520 14y agoSo does he has entrapment in mind by donating a small amount?
- eridius 14y agoEntrapment is only illegal when performed by cops. Besides, it isn't entrapment. Carreon did not induce Inman to perform the activity which Carreon claims is wrong.
- tfm 14y ago> different way than promised Once the originally-planned $20k had been exceeded, Inman suggested that he would find some more charities that might benefit from the cash. This thought was abandoned shortly after Carreon cried foul about the "different way than promised". So, good-good for the bears, they'll get a bigger money pit to roll around in.
- eridius 14y agoI'm not sure what bearing that has on taking a picture of the cash. Nor do I see how this could be related to the current lawsuit if Inman abandoned that idea.
- specialist 14y agoAbout that hate speech... Tara Carreon responded: "There is now plenty of proof that Matt Inman is one of a gang of people who promote the same type of ideas that inspired Jared Loughner to try and kill Gabrielle Giffords," she wrote. "Mark Potok of the Southern Poverty Law Center, who studies hate groups and hate speech, examined Loughner's sites and concluded that his material on grammar, in particular, likely came from the writings of far right activist David Wynn Miller. If you Google Matt Inman + grammar, you will find a similar obsession. And similar hate." Citing SPLC suggests Tara Carreon is left leaning. But her misunderstanding / misuse of "hate speech" is very right wing. Kind of like how trogs don't grok that Colbert is making fun of them. Hate speech is wishing harm on your opponents for political reasons. Calling people names is not hate speech. Neither is making fun of people. That's just being a dick. Alas, wingers don't get that distinction. I suspect the root cause (mental failing) also explains trogs rampant false equivalency (e.g. Clinton got a blow job == Bush allowing 9/11, illegally invading a foreign country, killing 100,000s of its citizens, making refugees out of a few million, and using depleted uranium to convert much of the formerly inhabited areas into Superfund sites). I once had a winger tell me that the Rodney King riots in LA were an example of left wing hate speech. The stupid, it hurts. I honestly can't decide if trogs say ridiculous non sequiturs because they're thick or if it's merely to distract and enrage (a la Limbaugh, Beck, Coulter). I've decided to simply judge people by their actions, vs their intent. The grandma having sex with a bear is obviously funny. To you and me. But the trogs can't see it that way. Any mocking is a direct personal attack demanding a defensive response. Inman didn't know the Carreon's were mentally impaired. But for future, just know that trogs will misunderstand, misinterpret, twist, assume the worst, distort, etc. No one can control the audience's reaction. But in my mocking, I do try to avoid borderline humor which can be labeled "hate speech". No sense giving the trogs another chew toy. And there's no shortage of funny stuff to say.
- jongraehl 14y agoYou come close to smearing roughly half of all people with the comical stupidity of the worst within that half. All of what you say seems true, but even describing reality along those lines (even without your epithets) arouses passion+stupidity.
- runamok 14y agoIt's rather difficult for most of us to accept criticism but at some point most sane people would try to take a step back and conclude that if thousands upon thousands of people think you are behaving poorly it might be prudent to at least consider their viewpoint is valid.