5 ms·
Profit margins for insurers are pretty low on a percentage basis. The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) imposed a minimum medical loss ratio on commercial payers.
by nradov 2y ago
Profit margins for insurers are pretty low on a percentage basis. The Affordable Care Act (Obamacare) imposed a minimum medical loss ratio on commercial payers. You can read the financial statements for those that are publicly traded. Some of the largest insurers such as Blue Cross Blue Shield Association members are non-profit.
The NHS isn't really a "single-payer system" in any meaningful sense. In the UK, most healthcare providers are employed directly by the government and their wages are fixed below the market rate to control costs. There are internal financial transfers but there aren't really arms-length negotiations and payments between separate payer and provider organizations.
If the USA was to adopt a single-payer system like the various "Medicare for All" proposals that politicians have floated that wouldn't do much to reduce costs. Any meaningful cost reduction for the system as a whole would require driving down provider wages, rationing care, and ending the way that we subsidize drug development costs for the rest of the world. Those measures might be good things to do on balance, but they aren't politically popular.
- bozhark 2y agoFor profit non profits exist. There is no “metric” for how much a 501(c)(3) must ratio in order to be considered tax exempt. They must follow their own discipline set in their founding documents. Calling blue cross blue shield nonprofit is disingenuous as they made $749,000,000 in 2022. Per their 990’s: https://www.causeiq.com/organizations/view_990/135656874/101e210d488d1ec5d98cfa6e592a75a1 https://www.causeiq.com/organizations/view_990/135656874/101...
- wahern 2y ago$749 million is revenue. Revenue less expenses (i.e. profit) was $57 million, which admittedly is a decent 7.5%. But as a nonprofit there are no shareholders or partners to siphon off that profit. The common argument is that management siphons off that money through salaries, and I can't say they don't, but if you look at their assets & liabilities it seems like some significant amount of their profit is going into savings. Anyhow, the Blue Cross/Blue Shield system has a very complex structure so if you're looking to find where the real money is being siphoned off it's unlikely to be at the top. BC/BS affiliates are independent, that's why the org at the top for a system insuring over a hundred million people pulls in less than a billion dollars in revenue.
- abound 2y ago"Nonprofit", at least in the US, is usually shorthand for having received a 501c3 (or similar) designation from the IRS. It has little bearing on your ability to make money as an organization (with caveats like the public support calculations) Source: Ran a nonprofit for a few years that made money doing software consulting
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoThis is so misleading. What you are saying it technically true, but also why our system is broken. If I can only make 10% profit (or whatever the law is), what is my incentive to keep healthcare costs down? The ONLY way I can grow my income if it healthcare costs go up. 10% profit on a $100 medication is way less than 10% profit on a $1,000,000 medication. The road to hell is paved with good intentions. Another disingenuous argument on non-profits. Is all of Blue Cross Blue Shield non-profit or only the certain parts you want us to look at? A 'Pay no attention to the man behind the curtain' argument. Final disingenuous argument is you just asserting 'meaningful cost reduction'. There is no way ambulance rides went from $200 to $10,000 because of EMT pay.
- FireBeyond 2y ago> There is no way ambulance rides went from $200 to $10,000 because of EMT pay. Absolutely not. EMT pay can be as low as $12 an hour.
- wahern 2y ago> If I can only make 10% profit (or whatever the law is), what is my incentive to keep healthcare costs down? The ONLY way I can grow my income if it healthcare costs go up. You're missing the step where you also have to increase premiums, i.e. price. And what normally keeps any seller from increasing their prices whenever they want is competition--some other insurer will get your business. That begs the question of how competitive the insurance market is. Let's assume it's woefully uncompetitive. But in that case I don't see how the ACA 80/20 rule on administrative overhead changes incentives and the evolution of price inflation one way or another. At best it temporarily disrupted existing inflationary schemes, at worst it does nothing.
- nradov 2y agoI'm not asking you to look at anything. Many US healthcare payers are private non-profit corporations. That includes some (but not all) Blue Cross Blue Shield Association licensees. The BCBSA isn't a payer itself and merely provides some shared services to their independent licensees. Outside of the Blues system there are other large non-profit payers such as Kaiser Permanente, HCSC, Geisinger, EmblemHealth, etc. This isn't secret information, you can just go look it up instead of arguing. Commercial health plans have conflicting financial incentives. Most of them no longer provide much insurance (in terms of bearing financial risk) but rather primarily act as administrators for self-insured employers. So while payers can potentially boost short-term profits by paying out higher claims, employers comparison shop between competing health plans every year. Your HR department would happily switch from Aetna to Cigna (or whatever) next year if their analytics forecast shows that would save a few dollars on expected claims. Ambulance fees are a mess but those represent a tiny fraction of overall US healthcare spending. Some reform there would be a good idea but that wouldn't do much to reduce costs. Significant systemic cost reductions will require some mix of lower provider wages, care rationing, and reduced spending on new drug and device development. Countries with more socialized healthcare systems are more financially efficient in some ways but they also just do less stuff: less drug development, longer queues for advanced treatments, underpaid doctors (relative to market wages), care restrictions based on QALYs (or similar metrics). Complaints about payer profits, while perhaps somewhat legitimate in certain cases, are largely a distraction from more fundamental problems. That's just basic math dictated by the cashflows. There are no simple solutions and we're eventually going to have to make hard choices. No one wants to face this reality.
- whoitwas 2y agoThis is nonsense. Health care costs about twice as much in US as everywhere else and only the rich can afford it. Health insurance companies fight against doctors and patients to subvert health and profit as much as possible.
- nradov 2y ago92% of Americans have health plan coverage, so we're not talking only about the rich here. There are certainly problems that we should fix but spreading misinformation about basic facts doesn't help anything. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhis/earlyrelease/Quarterly_Estimates_2024_Q11.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhis/earlyrelease/Quarterly_Es... It's easy for populists to demonize health insurance companies. But even if we somehow magically cut all payer profits to zero that would only marginally reduce total system costs. Much of what they do in fighting against doctors by negotiating lower reimbursement rates and denying claims that don't meet coverage rules actually helps to control costs for their main customers, the large self-insured employers that purchase health plans for their employees. At the national policy level, one change that would probably help would be breaking the linkage between employment and health plan coverage in order to better align incentives. Other countries that spend less on healthcare also have lower provider wages, longer queues for advanced treatments, rationed care based on QALYs (or similar metrics), and less innovation in drugs and medical devices. Maybe that would be better overall but let's not pretend that there aren't severe trade-offs. You can't have your cake and eat it too.
- whoitwas 2y agoSo what if they have health plan coverage if they can't afford to use it? Insurance is wildly out of control and needs to be reformed out of it's current form of existence. Health insurance companies act in bad faith against patients and doctors and many people with insurance go bankrupt anyway. What percentage of bankruptcies are from medical bills? It's impossible to objectively defend unless the goal is to make money at the cost of human health.
- nradov 2y ago