7 ms·
The Fifth Generation Project in Japan (1992)
- varispeed 2y agoIt's like binary system was "invented" like 300 years before it actually has been used, most likely the Japanese idea will actually happen at some point, just that when they were trying to develop it, the technology was not advanced enough for it.
- bruce511 2y agoWhile it's certainly interesting to read about this sort of thing - and I'm interesting in all the computer history - it's worth pointing out that some very large percentage of all computer systems, from every country and every era failed. So it would be a mistake to read too much into this project being Japanese, or indeed criticize their goals and failures. Like all of their contemporaries they boldly went where no-one had gone before, and like the vast majority of their contemporaries (and most everyone since) discovered limitations in both the technology of the day, and their own abilities. The important thing is not that they failed. The important thing is that they tried.
- duxup 2y agoYeah until we got a sort of core dominant systems, late 90s? There were a lot of creative attempts at new systems and ideas. They were either going to surpass the existing systems or fall on their face entirely.
- Dalewyn 2y ago>So it would be a mistake to read too much into this project being Japanese, As a Japanese(-American) I can tell you why this project failed and more broadly why Japan's computer industry has failed outside of vidja gaemz (and that too is on its way out). So why did the Japanese fail? It's very simple: Lack of cooperation. The article describes the project "was a collaborative effort of the Japanese computer industry" but the results could not put any more mud on that thought. Japanese companies HATE cooperating, they will not create nor utilize common standards nor share knowledge with each other. Japanese companies will strive at every turn to create a captive market, hoping that once you've set foot in their little quagmire you will stay stuck with them. If you ever wondered why Canon camera lenses do not work on Nikon cameras and vice versa, why Kenwood microphones do not work with ICOM radios and vice versa, why Sony insisted on Memory Stick over SD card, why Toshiba threw out NAND flash technology, and so on then this is why. Try naming even a single international industrial standard to come out of Japan, you probably can't and I don't blame you. Sharing is not in Japan's DNA. Contrast the US computer industry where our companies besides Apple can and will cooperate to create and utilize common standards and push the market wider and forwards. PCI is a foremost example, but the very foundation of the industry is built on IBM PC-compatibles. All this means Japan will always be stuck with a bunch of small, individual pies nobody will care about, losing to the rest of the west who cooperate (and nowadays China who force entire industries at gunpoint) for a much bigger pie. You can't win when you're all trying to drag each other down in a zero sum game.
- AlbertCory 2y agoYou might well be 100% right. I'd like to see the Japanese succeed, actually. However, it was simply not possible for anyone to succeed at AI in the early 80's. It took some Nobel-prize-winning software, a change of approach, and a massive increase in compute power to finally break through.
- llm_trw 2y agoThe only thing we needed was the compute. Everything else had been discovered by the 80s.
- philipkglass 2y agoI think that we also needed a much larger training corpus than was available in the 1980s. Back then the largest textual data sets were orders of magnitude smaller.
- adastra22 2y agoUsing neural nets. The approach taken towards AI in the 80’s was much less compute intensive.
- anon-3988 2y agoWhat do you attribute this to?
- tkgally 2y agoNot to disagree with you or the commenters pointing out other Japan-specific factors, but I think there is one more possible explanation for the project's failure: its top-down, government-bureaucrat-led nature. I've lived in Japan for forty years and have worked at a national university for the past twenty. The government regularly launches initiatives, sets goals, and promotes catch phrases that are supposed to lead to greater progress and prosperity. But, because the initiators and funders are often only tenuously connected to the complex and dynamic reality, the projects become rigid and wasteful, and eventually wither and die, more often than not.
- komali2 2y agoI've lived in Taiwan for a while, not nearly as long as you have in Japan, but long enough that I have a couple observations I'd be interested in your take in, about "old hats" such as yourself. The first is that the folks that immigrated decades ago tend to hold on to the perception they had upon arrival to the country, and the various impressions, for the rest of their lives there, and these impressions inform all future observations they have about the country. For example in Taiwan a lot of older American immigrants will talk about things like crime or the police as if it was still the KMT era when Taiwan was basically a different country, and their thoughts are really strange to hear when considering modern taiwanese police (who are basically teddy bears) or crime rates (extremely low). The second is that, having spend decades in the country to which they immigrated, which is probably longer than they lived in their origin country, they seem to view everything that strikes them as odd, inefficient, or bad, as unique to their new home country. In this case such as your perception of Japan as being lead top-down by bureaucrats, when that description to me applies to basically every liberal democracy on earth. Thus: > The government regularly launches initiatives, sets goals, and promotes catch phrases that are supposed to lead to greater progress and prosperity. But, because the initiators and funders are often only tenuously connected to the complex and dynamic reality, the projects become rigid and wasteful, and eventually wither and die, more often than not. imo, this is true for most government-led initiatives in nearly every country on earth. Not that I'm arguing against government-lead initiatives because they do result in sometimes incredible things like train infrastructure, spaceships, the internet, medical breakthroughs etc, but for the most part it seems politicians make big pitches to get elected and then just maintain status quo. Obviously Japan has some uniquely bureaucratic things about the culture as a whole (lol faxes), but on the other hand this doesn't seem to be an obstacle considering they have some of the safest pedestrian-friendly streets in the world, some of the best public transit, an excellent healthcare system, low crime rates, low homelessness, low unemployment, etc. On the ground they're doing much better than many countries. What do you think? You probably know much more about such things given your time in Japan as well as the fact that you work at a university.
- RaftPeople 2y agoI remember when this project was announced and I rolled my eyes. It has nothing to do with which country or who announced it, it was a typical grandiose announcement around things that are difficult to accomplish, probability of success was low.
- anigbrowl 2y agotbh the Wikipedia article is a lot better https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Generation_Computer_Systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Generation_Computer_Syst...
- airstrike 2y agoRelated: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41872982 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41872982
- sabareesh 2y agoRecently came across this video which goes into history of Japanese computers by Asianometry https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEtgzO-Im8w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CEtgzO-Im8w
- coreload 2y agoThis project was attempting to spin up relatively exotic hardware and software concurrently. The Lisp folks had less exotic software already more or less established but attempted to spin up corresponding hardware. The 5th generation project failed faster due to its greater ambition. Both failed ultimately due to commodity hardware greatly outpacing the ability of exotic hardware to keep up.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AlbertCory 2y agoIt's somewhat appalling that they don't mention that there's a book with this title: https://www.amazon.com/Fifth-Generation-Artificial-Intelligence-Challenge/dp/0201115190/ref=sr_1_1 https://www.amazon.com/Fifth-Generation-Artificial-Intellige... As for "The important thing is that they tried" : would you give them credit for "trying" to invent real-time, neuron-by-neuron brain imaging, in 1982? And giving billions of taxpayer Yen to the effort? How about quantum computers? Or would you have been justified in saying that there are projects with a better prospect of success right now, and we shouldn't waste the taxpayers' money on things guaranteed to fail? So what ARE your limits? Or are there any?
- mindcrime 2y agoAs for "The important thing is that they tried" : would you give them credit for "trying" to invent real-time, neuron-by-neuron brain imaging, in 1982? And giving billions of taxpayer Yen to the effort? How about quantum computers? For me, I'd say: 1. Yes 2. Taxation is theft 3. Yes Or would you have been justified in saying that there are projects with a better prospect of success right now, and we shouldn't waste the taxpayers' money on things guaranteed to fail? See again: taxation is theft. But regardless of how you fund research, it remains the case that "you don't know what you don't know" and "hindsight is 20/20". I'm certainly not going to slag the Japanese for the effort they put into the 5th gen project just because things didn't work out as favorably as they might have. And also, while the project might not have met their immediate goals and is deemed a "failure" that doesn't necessarily mean that the research they did is value-less. Speaking for myself, I actually recently went on a bit of a buying binge, buying a bunch of books on the 5th gen project (read that Feigenbaum & McCorduck book ages ago) and related ideas (eg, concurrent prolog). Because I have a hunch there's a kernel of something useful there still waiting to emerge. Now my research may lead me nowhere, but that's OK. And at least in my case I'm spending only my own money.
- AlbertCory 2y agoLet me just repeat: So what ARE your limits? Or are there any? So I guess you're saying there are no limits? Every project should be funded to the max? and since you're against taxation, does that mean ordinary people are to be compelled to "voluntarily" fund them? Or where is the money supposed to come from?
- SSJPython 2y ago> The Japanese Fifth Generation project was a collaborative effort of the Japanese computer industry coordinated by the Japanese Government > In a sense, Japan's ability to stay the course in pursuit of a long-term payoff-- usually considered one of the country's strongest assets-- turned into a liability. Japan is an expert at public-private partnerships. Their entire economic development story was based on the government and private enterprises working together. They didn't take an ideological approach to development. They ignored both the neoliberal route and the socialist route.
- bobthepanda 2y agoWell, they’re certainly very good at favoritism, which is basically what the keiretsu-led model ended up being. And favoritism and picking winners only really works as long as you’re able to pick the right winners. This model works well to supercharge initial growth if done correctly, but eventually you can’t really become richer through exports alone and have to pivot towards more consumption, which can be difficult to pull off.
- 082349872349872 2y agocome to think of it, early ARPA was pretty much about picking the right winners
- BubbleRings 2y agoIf you happen to click the link at the bottom of the page "HOME PAGE OF applet-magic" like I did, you get one of the fake virus web sites. Just do Ctrl-Alt-Del (on Windows), select Task Manager, sort on Name if you have to, right click on Google Chrome (or whatever your web browser is), and choose End Task. Or just cold start your computer. But hey lets keep web sites with links like that off Hacker News, what do you say?
- foco_tubi 2y agoIt's a long expired domain that originally belonged to that SJSU professor, I doubt he will ever update the links on these articles. That doesn't negate the value of the article itself.
- BubbleRings 2y agoA hundred dollar bill crawling with Ebola virus is still worth a hundred dollars, yes. But I would really prefer if nobody tried to hand it to me.
- bee_rider 2y agoEbola doesn’t live very long outside the host, so I think you could probably have them put the hundred dollar bill aside for a day or so and then come back and grab it.
- userbinator 2y agoThat page did absolutely nothing with JS off; just shows a blank page. Now I know it's not worth turning JS on for either, like the majority of the stuff I come across.
- numpad0 2y agoThe title is somewhat intriguing but the content is extremely light, and on top contains this: <!-- ZoneLabs Privacy Insertion --> <script language='javascript' src='http://127.0.0.1:1026/js.cgi?pcaw&r=14945'></script>
- cen4 2y agoIts not a coincidence that the Japanese Economy imploded around the same time. If your country has 40% of global corporate market cap value and then it drops to 8% after an asset bubble bursts, how many ambitious long term projects you can sustain drops too. The US came really close to following the same trajectory with the 2008 bubble bursting. If the banks hadn't been kept afloat and there were alternatives to Wall St a large chunk of the tech sector would have tanked or moved out. There is no global tech leadership possible, if there is no global Finance domination.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>a large chunk of the tech sector would have tanked or moved out Where exactly would the tech sector have moved to? There's no other country that's really able to absorb high-skill immigrants the way American can and put them to work in that field.
- alephnerd 2y ago> Where exactly would the tech sector have moved to It would have been much more decentralized. Entire generations of Indian, Korean, Chinese, Canadian, Israeli, and European origin founders and executives helped build the US tech industry. Heck, a lot of prominent Chinese and Indian startups got their start due to the GFC era layoffs and hiring freezes in the tech industry. Look at Flipkart and Ola in India, ByteDance in China, and Coupang in SK/US for example COVID and the recent layoffs had a similar impact on the startup scene as well.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>Entire generations of Indian, Korean, Chinese, Canadian, and European origin founders and executives helped build the US tech industry. Yes, but they would not have built such companies if they were stuck in their own countries. There's a reason they left those countries. Europe, for instance, is notorious for being extremely unfriendly to startups. >Look at Flipkart and Ola in India and ByteDance in China for example I've never even heard of the Indian companies here. As for ByteDance, TikTok is likely to be banned in the US and maybe elsewhere because it seems to be a tool for the CCP. It would be difficult to impossible for any Chinese tech company to achieve the status of Google or Microsoft for this reason. Companies in these countries may be able to do well inside their own countries, but they can never achieve real global dominance.
- readyplayernull 2y agoWhat would have been the expected 5th gen computer? An OS with natural language prompt instead of command prompt? So, we finally made it with LLMs.
- twoodfin 2y agoThere’s a somewhat heterodox theory that rather than some kind of AI moonshot, the Fifth Generation project was an attempt to build an alternative interaction model to Latin alphabet keyboards feeding teletypes. The idea (supposedly) was that ideographically centered Japan could not compete in a software market dominated by alphanumeric text I/O; “smarter” systems that could leverage arbitrary natural language (written or spoken) would level the playing field.
- mindcrime 2y agoI gotta side with anigbrowl - the Wikipedia page[1] on the Fifth Generation Project is a much better read than this article. I'd encourage anyone interested in this topic to give it a look. For even more detail, consult the Feigenbaum & McCorduck book[2] mentioned by AlbertCory. It's a very interesting story. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Generation_Computer_Systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_Generation_Computer_Syst... [2]: https://www.amazon.com/Fifth-Generation-Artificial-Intelligence-Challenge/dp/0201115190 https://www.amazon.com/Fifth-Generation-Artificial-Intellige...
- contextfree 2y agoOne of the researchers involved (I think) also maintains a "Fifth Generation Computer Systems Museum": https://www.ueda.info.waseda.ac.jp/AITEC_ICOT_ARCHIVES/ICOT/HomePage.html https://www.ueda.info.waseda.ac.jp/AITEC_ICOT_ARCHIVES/ICOT/... As the OP article mentions much (most? all?) of the software developed in the project was freely released (under an MIT-like license? https://www.ueda.info.waseda.ac.jp/AITEC_ICOT_ARCHIVES/ICOT/using-IFS-E.html https://www.ueda.info.waseda.ac.jp/AITEC_ICOT_ARCHIVES/ICOT/... ) and it seems to be available for download (in source form) from here: https://www.ueda.info.waseda.ac.jp/AITEC_ICOT_ARCHIVES/ICOT/Museum/IFS/HomePage-E.html https://www.ueda.info.waseda.ac.jp/AITEC_ICOT_ARCHIVES/ICOT/... most of it would only run on the prototype computer they wrote, but some of it was ported to Unix.
- mindcrime 2y agoWow. This is amazing. I can't say how happy I am that you posted this. I've never seen this site before... and I explicitly went looking for something like this a while back, and somehow did not find this. I've been fascinated by the FGCS stuff for a long time, and had always thought there must be an archive of that body of knowledge somewhere, but other than a few books on Concurrent Prolog I had not managed to scare up much of it. Now, I find that more or less all of it is online and available? All the Technical Reports, all the Technical Memoranda, and even the software? Amazing. Now if only I read Japanese...
- lenerdenator 2y agoIf only the Japanese had been willing to make some of our companies' devices for cheap, then they would have found out that we'd be perfectly willing to ship them all of our IP for the promise of a good quarterly earnings call, regardless of what it'd do to our nation's economic and political future.
- numpad0 2y agoIIUC, the Fifth Generation Computer project was more of James Bond style hallucination than something worthwhile. The project was supposed to produce a completely novel tech stack from hardware to user interface, one such that leapfrog and obsolete all conventional computer systems: it would run on custom AI-optimized parallel CPU designed for a futuristic post-C parallel programming language for all-custom AI inference OS and applications. It was of course all proudly national made with all kinds of scientific theories and inputs from scholars worldwide incorporated into it. It's like trying to make Star Wars technologies happen by sheer cash flow and technological optimism. All fever dreams.
- csomar 2y agoKinda similar to the current AI bubble, don’t you think?
- geysersam 2y agoNah the AI hype doesn't seem similar 1. It hasn't really required or designed new computer architecture. Instead it repurposed hardware that was designed and tuned over years by the game industry. 2. It's more empirical. Little to no theory building and more "throwing stuff at the wall to see what fits" 3. Not really "proudly national made" right? I don't think Washington minds being world leading on AI, but from where I'm standing it doesn't seem to be something that's been championed nationally. That's not to say it's not a bubble
- morninglight 2y agoI agree with your assessment. Through the 1980's, corporate Japan seemed to be on a more cooperative path. However, there were major changes during that decade. It's difficult to pinpoint any particular cause, but I think it can be linked to the decline of MITI's influence. MITI was a key to Japan's dominant role leading up to the 1990's. I believe that MITI's success made it a political target, and politics can kill anything. My friends from MITI tended to share a similar opinion.
- fnord77 2y agohmmm > MITI bureaucrats attempted to deny fledgling Sony the $25,000 the company needed to license transistor technology from Western Electric.
- dang 2y agoRelated. Others? Fifth-Generation Programming Language - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36080365 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36080365 - May 2023 (1 comment) The Fifth Generation Computing Project - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20569098 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20569098 - July 2019 (49 comments) 'Fifth Generation' Became Japan's Lost Generation (1992) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16630174 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16630174 - March 2018 (47 comments) The Fifth Generation Computer Project in Japan - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8256961 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8256961 - Sept 2014 (3 comments)
- PeterStuer 2y agoThe fifth generation story was hyped to the gills in European (and I assume US) AI research circles at the time to increase public funding. It was a bit funny as we were all knees deep into 'nouvelle AI' as a reaction to the crafted reasoning/logic from before, so a thin line had to be walked between 'we need to fund this emergence/embodied/subsymbolic research because the logic/symbolic reasoning stuff is a deadend' and 'those Japanese with their logic/symbolic reasoning approach are going to eat our lunch if you do not give us more money'. Good times were had.
- openrisk 2y agoVery interesting story (more context in the related wikipedia entry). Makes you wonder where we are today in terms of computing "generations". > It seemed that logic programming was a key missing connection between knowledge engineering and parallel computer architectures This is still missing. And both ingredients, "logic programming" and "parallel computing" are rather arcane and underdeveloped, so many decades later. The current AI hyperventilation illustrates the impact quite nicely (algorithms and models have no connection to "ground truth", they need expensive and hard to use HPC hardware etc.) On the other hand we had in the meantime the internet and mobile revolutions. While those are not so fundamental from a pure computing perspective, they have increased the utility of the digital domain tremendously. It is conceivable that a fifth generation architecture is lurking somewhere in the chaotic mess that is the current technical landscape. E.g. the internet does enable a certain form of massive parallel processing on commodity hardware. And overtures toward "logic programming" are even long-time W3C standards... But in the end we know by now painfully well that digital technology is not progressing monotonically. By its nature it gets embedded deeply into societies and thus its state reflects progress (or regression) of society as much as technical breakthroughs.
- zozbot234 2y agoThe modern take on "logic programming" is just database query, and that can definitely be parallelized. The issue there is that non-trivial logical inference over a knowledge base (the kind of thing that was popular wrt. expert systems and "fifth generation" proposals) turns out to be computationally challenging unless you heavily restrict the kinds of "inferences" that can be done. I'm not sure that this was clearly understood back in the 1980s or so.
- fedeb95 2y agodon't aim at some far goal, aim at being prepared for whatever comes next.
- ggm 2y agoSome of my first work (as a very junior programmer and researcher) in the UK was in part funded and instantiated in the reaction to the 5th generation initiatives. The research community in the UK reacted to what was called "the Alvey report". It led to an explosion of inter uni collaborative projects, the newer GEC 400 (?) Series computer was often deployed in this work. I think it wound up almost exclusively in defence deployment like AWACS roles in the nimrod project. It had a bit of an overheating problem and led to many fine "halt and catch fire instruction" jokes. The idea that both the 5th generation projects in Japan would work and that without the alvey projects we'd somehow "lose the race" was compelling pressure to seek funds and do things. It didn't turn out that way.
- rjsw 2y agoThe GEC Series 63 [1] was used in the Alvey programme. I was a founder of a startup that used a 63/40 to provide a (pre-internet) online service over X.25 links. It was a bit too different to a VAX to be able to easily port standard AI software to it. The GEC 4000 series was what was used for the Nimrod AEW and for other real-time applications as well as for X.25 networking around the UK. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEC_Series_63 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEC_Series_63
- sub7 2y agoThe Japanese made Topre switches and they have already greatly increased my happiness.
- ruthrohrer 2y ago[dead]