3 ms·
> You can't exactly shop around The vast bulk of health care is by appointment, not a dash in the ambulance.
by WalterBright 2y ago
> You can't exactly shop around
The vast bulk of health care is by appointment, not a dash in the ambulance.
- globular-toast 2y agoEven so, when was the last time someone needed cancer treatment but said "ooh, that's pricey, nah, I'd rather buy a new car instead". This is my main argument against private healthcare: there's no real choice involved. Without even getting into what a free market is and perfect information etc, the main advantage of a capitalist society is you get to choose what you like. Nobody chooses healthcare (at least, not the super expensive part).
- tastyfreeze 2y agoA large portion of healthcare could be free market. Insurance should be for unlikely events not every single thing deemed "medical". My home and auto insurance don't cover regular costs for maintenance. Why must health insurance cover a checkup with the doctor?
- SoftTalker 2y ago> This is my main argument against private healthcare: there's no real choice involved. Is your argument that there is choice involved in public healthcare? Or simply that it's not even a question?
- WalterBright 2y agoThere are many options for cancer treatment, with different prices, efficacy, misery, etc. > Nobody chooses healthcare Yeah, they do. Root canal vs implant vs dentures, for example. Ozempic vs diet+exercise, for another.
- davkan 2y agoYou’re still significantly limited by your insurance carrier’s network and also the consolidation of the healthcare industry. I used to live in a city of 1 million that had essentially two hospital networks that bought everything. You could not find a specialist not associated with those two companies. Pre-natal, allergy, cardiac, two choices. When my seventy year old doctor who ran a practice out of his house retired he sold the practice to one of the two. It’s not shopping for a tv. You can’t choose not to buy. It’s often time sensitive even if by appointment. Pricing is incredibly complex as are the details of the product. Your average person does not have the information necessary to navigate the market.
- Pikamander2 2y agoEven more fun is when your doctor refers you to a specialist that's in-network, but your insurance comes up with a bunch of reasons to deny it. How did we collectively decide that it's okay for insurance companies to overrule medical professionals?
- gruez 2y agoAFAIK the overruling is done by a "medical professional" as well, albeit one that's on the insurance company's payroll.
- jandrese 2y agoThat "medical professional" has literally 90 seconds to review your case and say yes/no. They've never met you. They don't know your doctor. All they have are some notes on the case, a billing code, and a quota to reach every day. They get bonuses based on how much money they save the insurance company. All of that cost savings makes US healthcare cost double what it does anywhere else in the world.
- nradov 2y agoI think you're a little confused about causality. All healthcare systems, including fully socialized ones, perform similar types of case review to ration care and hold down costs. US healthcare costs might be high now but would be even higher if the payers (including the Medicare / Medicaid government payers) paid every claim that came in without denying those that fail to mean plan coverage rules. If we want to hold down costs then we'll have to put a greater focus on preventative care, stop expensive treatments for terminal patients, impose price controls on providers, and stop subsidizing drug development for the rest of the world. None of those measures are politically popular.
- WalterBright 2y agoPrice controls always result in shortages.
- ddfs123 2y agoEven for non-emergency, the short amount of time before a health issue turn serious means that it's already hard for you to take second opinion.
- yellottyellott 2y agoother than normal doctor’s office visits, i have no idea what i’m going to pay when i get a small procedure done. a basic heart ultrasound cost me over $1k while my vasectomy cost me a $60 copay. i was expecting those prices to be flipped. and don’t get me started on labs. i’ve gotten bills for basic screens years later for thousands of dollars. you can’t shop around if you don’t know what you’ll pay until months after it happens. if you call the insurance company beforehand you wait on a static filled line with a call center in india, and even with the CPT code they can’t give you a straight answer.
- WalterBright 2y ago> i have no idea what i’m going to pay when i get a small procedure done. All you gotta do is ask.
- jandrese 2y agoThey don't know. Nobody does until the bill is processed. There are a thousand factors that might affect your coverage. This is the nightmare I'm living through right now. Even if you have the code and doctor and patient the help desk at the insurance company can't say for sure if they will cover it or not. That comes down to the discretion of the claims adjuster. You won't know if something is going to cost $100 or $10,000 until after it is done.
- WalterBright 2y ago> They don't know It works every time I asked.
- jandrese 2y agoThe provider or the insurance company? The provider can give you the cash price, but that's a made up number with no relation to reality. The Insurance company can give you what the standard discount would be on that procedure, but they can't say if they'll cover it, give only that discount, give nothing, or anything in between.