6 ms·
Why World War WordPress Will End with a Zombie Fork
- whalesalad 2y agoSomeone needs to leverage WASM and other container methods to build an entirely new version of WP with a solid architecture that can still leverage the existing ecosystem by isolating/sandboxing popular themes and plugins and making them think they are running in WP.
- mmaunder 2y agohttps://wasmlabs.dev/articles/wordpress-in-the-browser/ https://wasmlabs.dev/articles/wordpress-in-the-browser/
- whalesalad 2y agoI mean more of a new core that is non-php, non-wordpress that can leverage these ancillary things at the perimiter via something like this. So method calls to `wp_get_archives` would still work, but that would be redirected under the hood to a cleaner arch on something like Python, or Golang, or Rust, or whatever.
- appendix-rock 2y agoThis sounds like some sort of attempt at Ultimate Scope Creep. How did we get from ‘licensing faux-issue’ to ‘a complete rebuild with a very complex architecture just to support the plugin ecosystem’?
- whalesalad 2y agoWP has needed this for a very long time, this is just the proverbial straw breaking the camels back.
- bigiain 2y ago> WP has needed this for a very long time Said no-one using WP for their website ever. To a first approximation, about zero people/companies have a problem they need solved which boils down to "I need a replacement for WordPress using a significantly more modern and better architected codebase." By far the most common problem people are solving by using Wordpress is "I need to be able to fix website errors/typos without calling up a web development agency and waiting 2 weeks and paying $1000, and I need to be able update my homepage or add new pages which then fit into the menus and site navigation easily". Second most common problem they're solving is "I need a website which is easy and affordable to employ or contract experience people to edit and manage it for me". Not a single WPEngine or wordpress.com customer has ever chosen or rejected them because they asked themselves "Is this run on a mess of legacy early 2000s vintage PHP and badly designed MySQL databases, or does the backend run beautifully architected and formatted Rust/Haskel/Go?"
- whalesalad 2y agoI don’t want to hear it. I’d posit I’ve been working with WP longer than you. Ask yourself: why did WP engine come into existence?
- bigiain 2y ago> I’d posit I’ve been working with WP longer than you. Perhaps? Maybe I'm older than I look... I've never specialised in WP, but my earliest WP work was on 2.5 back in 2008-ish after I jumped ship from a gruelling (and failing) startup. I was doing mostly WP sites at an agency during 2010-2013 almost all using cPanel shared hosting. In 2014 I moved to a place using Wordpress on Plesk shared hosting which had several really bad downtimes and performance problems, and searching my email the first WPEngine invoice came when I migrated a bunch of those sites to WPE in 2015. I've been happily using and recommending them ever since. Sure there are lots of people with more year's experience, but I've got a good 15 years or so, and I think that means my opinions are at least based in the real world. WPEngine came into existence, at least from my point of view, because there was so much _bad_ Wordpress hosting available at the time. My experience with 7 years of shared cPanel/Plex hosting on random ISPs or some generalised everything-to-everybody domain registry, domain registrar, web hosting company, SEO consultants, internet security snake oil salesmen like GoDaddy or Dreamhost, compared to specialist WP hosting with WPEngine - has been night and day. Where I work now, we happily refer clients looking for $5/month web hosting away to a few sole trader web devs we respect who handle those sorts of customers, and anyone who doesn't bat an eyelid at WPEngine's prices (plus our markup) gets hosted there with all the performance, uptime, and value add benefits they bring to the table. I'm sure other people have different experiences. IU;m sure there are other dedicated WordPress hosting companies out there these days who are as good or better than WPEngine at least for some use cases. I'm sure there are other companies with as good or nearly as good offerings for less money than WPEngine. For me though, they are absolutely worth the extra cost for all the value add they bring alongside WP core and wordpress.org repos - except for people looking for lowest possible cost and are prepared to accept worse performance and less good hosting tools.
- bigiain 2y agoNo. Not from my point of view, as someone who has a couple of dozen WordPress clients. "Someone" needs a CMS that's able to be securely, performantly, and professionally managed by hosting companies, and that is as easy for small and medium businesses to use and as easy to find experienced staff and agencies to help run. We do not recommend as use WordPress because of it's "solid architecture" or "isolation/sandboxing" or it's FE Dev buzzword de jour use of "exciting" "new" technology. We recommend it because the Widget Factory owner can probably get one of his grandkids or niece/nephews to act as website editor for him, or the piano teacher can get one of their students to help out with their website in return for discounted lessons, or the online store owner can easily employ someone with WordPress admin experience to get themselves off eBay/Marketplace and onto their own website. Or the lawyer/plumber/accountant/whoever's office manager or "that young staff member who's good with computers" can run Wordpress - perhaps with assistance of their existing outside IT consultants to install/manage it and perhaps setup/customise it initially. None of those people care about whether it's written in Rust, or uses WASM, or is dockerized and autoscaling. Their #1 problem is "can I quickly update my website if I find an error or if I have to put an important message to my customers on my homepage?" #2 is "can I easily learn how to do simple edits to my site, and can I easily find employees can work with it, and can I finb contractors/agencies who'll be able to help with more complex changes/updated?" and somewhere down below #1 is "is my site at least reasonably secure from being hacked, and if it is hacked can I get it restored/repaired rapidly". There are dozens or hundreds of "better technology choices" that WordPress these days. It's really hard to find a "better business choice" for a lot of projects though.
- whalesalad 2y agoAll of your arguments go out the window when the foundation disappears. That’s what is happening now. Wordpress isn’t good in and of itself. It’s good due to the community of developers working on it, and likewise the plugins they have painstakingly created (despite the terrible programming environment) That’s gone now.
- bigiain 2y agoYes. and that's sad. Very sad. Having said that, it seems that many people (me included) have been assuming things about "the WordPress Foundation" that are not true. It apparently is _not_ the steward of the wordpress.org repository of 3rd party themes and plugins the "community of developers" painstakingly created, and that have made WordPress "good" for so many different people. As far as I can tell, "the foundation" does whatever it does on a tax filing declared budget of around $22,000 (so, not much?) - and it exists mostly as a non profit "owner" of some trademarks that it immediately exclusively and irrevocably licensed for commercial use back to Automattic the same day they got given them. I'm pretty sure "the foundation" could have disappeared anytime in the last decade, or could remain to exist for another decade or two to come, and either way wouldn't make the slightest bit of difference. It's not the foundation that's gone, it's the trust in the Wordpress core development leadership, the trust in the wordpress.org theme/plugin leadership, and the trust that the WordPress trademark is safe to use in perfectly normal and legal ways without the treat of being extorted if you start making too much money.
- upwardbound 2y agoReminds me a little bit of Arduino LLC vs Arduino SRL. (which was ultimately resolved amicably) https://hackaday.com/2016/10/01/arduino-vs-arduino-arduino-won/ https://hackaday.com/2016/10/01/arduino-vs-arduino-arduino-w...
- andyjohnson0 2y ago> Doing so would not only enrich affluent lawyers but damage the brand of WordPress worldwide, resulting in regular folks and small businesses looking for the exits. I seriously doubt this. Even the majority of tech people are unaware of this dispute. And most businesses are too busy to care.
- p1necone 2y ago> Even the majority of tech people are unaware of this dispute. And most businesses are too busy to care. I still don't understand what the hell is going on and I see posts about it on HN every couple days. Who is the original wordpress and who is the fork. Is there a clear "bad guy" in this?
- throwup238 2y ago> Is there a clear "bad guy" in this? It’s more like dumb and dumber than good vs bad.
- FireBeyond 2y agoI'm at a loss - what exactly has WP Engine done that is "dumb"? As far as I can see, it's an umbrella for "will not cave to Matt's every wish".
- atonse 2y agoI’m honestly not sure what they’ve done wrong (or illegally). But it seems like Mullenweg has alienated a lot of people by what seems to be very erratic behavior. I am curious to see what many WP employees think of all this.
- anonymoushn 2y agoMullenweg is the CEO of Automattic. WP Engine is the other party in the current drama.
- Apreche 2y agoWhat's the difference between a zombie fork and just a regular old fork?
- kaptain 2y agoThe article explains it as a fork that just blindly copies the changes in the original source to avoid legal complications but not add any new technical value.
- Apreche 2y agoDoes that mean they merge the actual code from upstream? If they do that, I wouldn't call that a fork. I'd call it a mirror. I'm not exactly sure how that provides any of the benefits the author suggests. Do they look at the changelog of upstream and have engineers re-implement the same things only with original code? That seems like a significant waste of resources just to try to duplicate someone else's efforts.
- pests 2y agoThe idea being the project is the same, the management is not. > Do they look at the changelog of upstream and have engineers re-implement the same things only with original code No, but they may selectively ignore features or changes that might have caused the fork in the first place.
- bigiain 2y ago"Mirror"? Maybe? I'd argue that what WPEngine sells (rents?) is perhaps closer to a "distro" in the Redhat/Ubuntu/Arch/whatever sense. They use WordPress core the way Ubuntu uses the Linux kernel. They use the GPL themes/plugins the way they use all the gnu utils. They use paid/pro plugins and themes like Ubuntu uses restricted and multiverse repos. If they feel the need, they can customise the kernel/core within the restrictions and obligations of the GPL however they choose to. And WPEngine then wrap WordPress core in a whole bunch of what they and their customers consider "value add". Easy and automated backup/restore, one click dev/staging versions of the site and the ability to promote those into production when desired, automated provisioning and renewal of ssl certs, curated plugin backlists, monitoring and affected customer notifications of security updates across 3rd party plugin/themes as well as core, platform level WordPress specific optimisation, managed OS and web server and database security patching and updates. And like RedHat, they provide a "single neck to tread on" when something goes badly wrong: a support department that's both experienced and capable of solving pretty much any WP disaster 24x7, with a platform that can quickly and easily use to provide the needed help, and a pre existing business/financial relationship so both sides of that disaster and recovery are at least partially coincident it'll be charged and paid fairly and promptly. For every single one of our WP clients, all that value add is totally worth the price jump from $5/month on GoDaddy et al. to $25/month of WPEngine. And for us, WPEngine has a better offering for what we value than wordpress.com.
- throwaway19972 2y agoMaybe we can have a better world if we don't try to make money off of software development.
- seanw444 2y agoHave fun with less/no good software. I'm one of the biggest proponents of FOSS software you can find, but eliminating moneymaking schemes entirely for everyone is just fantastical.
- throwaway19972 2y agoCertainly with that attitude! People these days truly have no imagination. Incredibly depressing. It's very difficult to have any hope for computation while we have to beg misanthropic morons for money.
- throwawaymaths 2y agoIs this really the case? Maybe I'm missing something, but yhe WordPress codebase is still available, what is not is the one repository for convenient one shot downloads. You could create an equivalent repo off of one of the existing mirrors or put it together yourself off of the codebase. So maybe someone will fork the repository? But hosting is expensive, especially if you're going to get hit by something at the scale of WPEngine.
- ValentineC 2y ago> You could create an equivalent repo off of one of the existing mirrors or put it together yourself off of the codebase. https://www.reddit.com/r/AspirePress/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AspirePress/
- johnchristopher 2y agoHey, they have a new logo !
- bigiain 2y ago> You could create an equivalent repo off of one of the existing mirrors Can you though? And if so, for how much longer? Matt is already not letting developers log into wordpress.org without disclaiming any relationship with WPEngine. He is 100% going to demand the same from people mirroring that repo as soon as he thinks of it. > But hosting is expensive, especially if you're going to get hit by something at the scale of WPEngine. CloudFlare offered to do that for free. Matt said "Fuck you! I'm destroying WordPress instead, for the communiteeeeeeee!"
- jongjong 2y agoWatching people fight over this crummy old tech is like watching pigs wrestling in mud.
- gehsty 2y ago…if the mud was millions of dollars
- ValentineC 2y agoMore like billions of dollars. Automattic themselves supposedly have half a billion in revenue — the entire pie is much bigger than that.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gman83 2y agoI've been looking for an alternative that let's me set up a site for non-technical users but I haven't found any open-source alternative. With Wordpress I can install something like GeneratePress & Blocks, set up ACF and add some custom fields, and anyone can manage the site. End users don't want to be writing React and Tailwind to edit their site.
- lrae 2y agoPayload 3 (currently beta) doesn't look bad, but a site still needs some work from somebody who can at least somewhat code, and it's not just installing wordpress, generatepress and ACF. Same for Directus. But again, not a 1-to-1 WP replacement.
- g8oz 2y agoI think any sort of headless CMS or at least one with a decoupled presentation layer would work well these days. directus, webflow etc.
- bigiain 2y ago
- yapyap 2y ago[flagged]
- bigiain 2y ago> who cares Almost nobody. Except the people who are responsible for or manage 40+% of the websites on the internet. The ones who are aware of how early they might become "acceptable collateral damage" to Matt's deranged "nuclear" "war" on WPEngine, and the business ramifications of "waiting till the war settles" if that means significant website downtime or emergency website migration to avoid it. Which, if the numbers I've seen bandied around are accurate, is something like $400mil annual revenue to WPEngine, representing over a million WPEngine websites who are _directly_ in danger of Matt's current supply chain attacks. And with dozens or hundreds of smaller WordPress hosting companies looking on in horror wondering if they and their customers are next in Matt's extortion war. And probably tens of thousands of web dev firms and digital agencies who're all thinking "WTF?" and making contingency plans for all their WordPress clients no matter where they're hosting them.
- huskyr 2y agoI doubt many developers will get on a WP Engine fork of WordPress. Maybe if they funded an independent non-profit foundation that would take care of a fork that could work, but you still need the traction of the community to make it a success.
- zeronine 2y agoAll a new foundation needs for traction is a policy against admin dashboard spam
- mbreese 2y agoI don't know about that. I think there are many different definitions of success here. WP Engine would want to make sure that it's customers are well taken care of and have a solid web hosting experience. That would be success to them. I'm not sure how much they would care about outside users or developers (they might care a lot, but I don't know). But, the real question is -- would a fork benefit their customers? If the answer is yes, then I expect to see a fork happen quickly. That may be the only way (or best way) for them to keep some degree of control over their system.
- skmurphy 2y ago"WP Engine would want to make sure that it's customers are well taken care of and have a solid web hosting experience." This is certainly one of their goals, if only to prevent or reduce churn. But WP Engine is now owned by Silver Lake, a private equity firm, they no doubt have aggressive growth and profitability targets. Anything that injects confusion into their branding or increases costs is counter to their goals The real question is the 8% "contribution" that WP is asking for cheaper than other alternatives. The lawsuits are cheaper if they win, but a dead loss if they don't.
- runako 2y agoIf it were WPE only, that is true. But right now there are some very large companies also in the crosshairs as possibly next on the list: - GoDaddy - Amazon (AWS) - Bluehost - Dreamhost and about a thousand smaller hosts, all of whom would be very unhappy to suddenly have to pay 8% of revenue to Automattic. A real community-owned fork could quickly get a lot of traction.
- asar 2y agoWPE's core business is "hosting for WordPress websites". If they were to change this to "ForkPress", they'll have to rebuild the brand and search volume behind it. So I'm not convinced that this is a viable solution to their current problem.
- itsdrewmiller 2y ago“WorkPress” so they don’t have to change their name.
- lolinder 2y ago> A WordPress fork is also something Automattic fears, as it was oddly mentioned in a term sheet... Matt has explained that that language was actually addressing allegations that WP Engine forked the WooCommerce Stripe extension and replacing attribution. For whatever Matt's explanations are worth these days. The language of the term sheet certainly could have been read as preventing them from forking WordPress as well, so it's possible that was an ulterior motive. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41726622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41726622
- MBCook 2y agoI’ve been wondering if this will end up with another Jenkins or LibreOffice, where a fork is made and quickly gains mindshare. Given the complexity and importance of UI in the project, LO may be the better example.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lofaszvanitt 2y agoJust someone release a trojan that zeroes all wordpress sites and every repo that contains the source code. Let them recreate that abomination again.
- Log_out_ 2y agoThe free janitor rebellion shallbe put down and free lunch restored .