5 ms·
TikTok Live became 'a strip club filled with 15-year-olds' (2022)
- cute_boi 2y agoi have watched tiktok regularly for 2-3 years, and till this day I only get pandas/ hippo videos. It seems it depends on viewer nature.
- TheFreim 2y agoWhen TikTok showed up on my radar a few years ago I decided to download it and see what it was all about. Within just a few minutes (3-5 iirc, certainly less than 10) I was presented with a video of a gaggle of what looked like 12-14 year old girls "dancing" wearing almost no clothes. That was enough for me, I deleted the app and haven't looked back. Perhaps it was a fluke, but it was severely off-putting.
- 39896880 2y agoMy theory is that TikTok is optimized similarly to YouTube in that it uses viewing time as a signal of interest. So, you could open TikTok, see underage people dancing, turn your phone to your spouse and say "can you believe this is what this app shows?" and the app will take the fact that you played the video as a sign you want to see more. I don't remember if there's even a downvote button. I had the same experience you did, but in the opposite direction gender-wise, and it took a bit longer to get too young, but it got there.
- robrtsql 2y agoDeep within the settings, there's a "Don't show me things like this" button in TikTok. Maybe someone should make a TikTok competitor where you swipe left or right on a video to indicate your approval.
- echelon 2y agoThere's no need to have a dislike button. Your behavior is enough. If you dislike something and watch it, that's engagement. They'll of course want to show you more of it. Rage and anger are engagement too. They're perhaps the best forms of engagement.
- tivert 2y ago> There's no need to have a dislike button. Your behavior is enough. Literally right after you said that, you described why a dislike button is necessary: > If you dislike something and watch it, that's engagement. They'll of course want to show you more of it. > Rage and anger are engagement too. They're perhaps the best forms of engagement.
- echelon 2y agoThat's not the platform's problem. It would likely make the platform less successful if they were to follow your advice. Your suggestion was, > Maybe someone should make a TikTok competitor where you swipe left or right on a video to indicate your approval. The audience for this would be small. Social media platforms have found that users engage with content they "don't like". If showing users content they don't like resulted in less overall engagement, the platforms would rewrite their algorithms in a heartbeat. A competitor to TikTok already faces an enormous uphill battle. If such a platform chooses to remove a proven strategy for traction and engagement, then it's doubling down on the headwinds and infirmities. I wouldn't count on it being a successful venture.
- tivert 2y ago> That's not the platform's problem. It would likely make the platform less successful if they were to follow your advice. If you're looking to start a competitor, you need to differentiate somehow. Not using "rage and anger" to drive engagement would be pretty appealing to a user. It's also worth noting that the context of this thread was two users who deleted the app because it showed them stuff they did not want to see. And the wider context has been TikTok has been utterly clueless handling concerns from the public and regulators, so I don't think reasoning from the assumption that whatever TikTok does is necessary is the right way to go. And if you are right, it's just more proof that modern capitalism doesn't incentivize making things people want, rather it incentivizes making the things that exploit them most effectively. The appropriate political adjustments should be made to beat those companies until their users' morale improves. > Your suggestion was, Wasn't my suggestion. I think the source of your confusing is that you wandered into a conversion between users while thinking you were a platform.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 2y agoThis article is about TikTok Live, a separate part of the product. I don't use TikTok, but I think it's a little less short-video feed, and a little more Twitch Hot Tub streamers (https://blog.twitch.tv/en/2021/05/21/lets-talk-about-hot-tub-streams/ https://blog.twitch.tv/en/2021/05/21/lets-talk-about-hot-tub...). I think the target market and how discovery works in the product are quite different so it's quite possible you've never ventured into it if you're there for the short videos and not the streamer worship.
- neilv 2y agoThat Twitch link is interesting. My read is that they're disingenuously trying to spin obviously intentional sexual content as, rather, a matter of interpretation of the wide range of imaginations of the viewers. And they experimentally made a "Pools, Hot Tubs, and Beaches" swimwear category, while they figure out how to keep milking the intentional sexual titillation content, while still keeping advertisers happy. (Related: The Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue wasn't about sports, nor about travel, nor about anything else other than the obvious.)
- danpalmer 2y agoI have no comment on the way Twitch handled this, was only providing the link for context. I find the culture around this fascinating. We've got platforms trying to find the right balance of moderation in an attempt to not appear to be porn sites because that would be perceived as bad by society, while taking as much of that traffic as they can and normalising this type of content at the boundary, and while also trying to appease their own sources of moderation such as advertisers and payment processors. We've got content creators who may well not identify as sex workers, convincing themselves that they're different because of some boundary, and children looking for attention and emulating the increasingly normalised behaviour at the encouragement of a platform that prioritises views and exposes harmful metrics.
- quitspamming 2y agoThis article isn't about people being offended at seeing sexual material on TikTok. It's about how TikTok _knew_ that children were being paid in TikTok livestreams to engage is sexual behavior. It is good that _you_ didn't consume it, but many were, andd TikTok knew that many were and let it happen to profit from it.
- debit-freak 2y agoCan you quote the evidence here? The link is paywalled.
- quitspamming 2y agohttps://archive.is/XCx6E https://archive.is/XCx6E
- debit-freak 2y ago[flagged]
- lunatuna 2y agoThis is whataboutism. Doesn’t work here.
- krageon 2y ago[flagged]
- quitspamming 2y agoSo unless Forbes investigates literally every social media site and app they aren't allowed to report on one, or else they're jingoistic xenophobes? That poor argument aside, they DID in fact report on other social media sites, the same year, a few months earlier than the even did on TikTok. https://archive.is/J1kjN https://archive.is/J1kjN
- bigtones 2y agoThis post is over a year old: https://archive.li/LrMBo https://archive.li/LrMBo
- 39896880 2y ago(2022)
- debit-freak 2y agoIs there any materially demonstrable evidence that tiktok is worse than other social media networks?
- yapyap 2y agoNo, well at least not anymore since they have all implemented the infinite scrolling portrait mode feed; YouTube, Snapchat, Instagram, Spotify, Netflix I’m not sure about Twitter
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 2y agoWhat's "social" about Netflix? I agree that their UI is terrible, but it doesn't fit in the list
- foolfoolz 2y agoit’s just the most popular. they are all the same. it’s less about the technology and more about why so many humans feel the need to spend so much time using it
- pragmomm 2y agoFormer TikTok exec: Chinese Communist Party had “God mode” entry to US data https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2023/06/former-tiktok-executive-says-chinese-communist-party-members-had-god-mode-entry-to-tiktok-data https://www.malwarebytes.com/blog/news/2023/06/former-tiktok... Two academic studies argue that TikTok favors Chinese government views, and a new analysis says TikTok's parent firm is entangled with government propaganda organs. https://www.nbcnews.com/investigations/tiktok-says-not-spreading-chinese-propaganda-us-says-real-risk-rcna171201 https://www.nbcnews.com/investigations/tiktok-says-not-sprea...
- mistermann 2y ago"evidence is worse than". Excellent start on one side of the story though.
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pfannkuchen 2y agoOne interesting thing I’ve never seen discussed is how puberty shifting earlier in modern times clashes with human sexual instincts and related cultural norms. Absent abuse situations, pre-pubescent humans have basically no interest in sexual behavior, and, except in very rare cases of truly deranged individuals, adults have basically no sexual interest in pre-pubescent minors. Historically, I believe puberty roughly coincided with the age of marriage for girls. One can argue about the mental maturity of a 17 year old and whether they are ready to make important life decisions, but there is clearly a huge mental difference between a 17 year old and a 13 year old, and puberty shifting earlier did not come with a forward shift in mental development. So now we have essentially mental children who are interested in sex and related behavior (e.g. suggestive dancing), in a way that I believe is probably unprecedented in all of human history. Also, while it is gross to consider, I’m guessing that many viewers of these 15 year olds are actually adult men of all ages. This problem is significantly amplified by a shift to earlier puberty, since I’m guessing in a counterfactual where the dancing girls are pre-pubescent, these men would feel disgust and move on instead of guiltily lingering.
- onetokeoverthe 2y agoModern early puberty is a total fallacy. Basic research shows the age as being 10-17 depending on nutrition and the environment. For thousands of years. Article: Children are entering puberty younger than before, according to recent studies, raising concerns that childhood obesity and hormone-contaminated water supplies may be to blame. However, our archaeological research suggests that there’s nothing to worry about. Children in medieval England entered puberty between 10 and 12 years of age – the same as today. In England, just before the industrial revolution, historical sources suggest menarche occurred between 12-14 years. By the 1840s, girls had their first period between 14-17 years. Author: Mary Lewis Associate Professor in Bioarcheology, University of Reading And that's not to negate Tiktok/Bytedance's negatives.
- pfannkuchen 2y agoHead: meet sand So what if it’s caused by changes in nutrition? That has no impact on the practical effects of the change. Average height has increased significantly due to nutrition. Would you say that modern height increases are a total fallacy? I’m not making any claims about chemicals or whatever people on the internet often ramble about.
- LAC-Tech 2y ago[flagged]
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago(2022) Current relevant discussion: The TikTok documents: Stripping teens and boosting 'attractive' people https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41832903 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41832903
- tijgfgjj 2y agofuck off there sexy so i love watching them strip i wanna have sex qith them