8 ms·
Windows 11 24H2 hoards 8.63 GB of junk you can't delete
- Daunk 2y ago"since the rollout on October 15" I love articles from the future.
- reaperducer 2y agoAt least it gives Microsoft a few days to fix it before time catches up to them!
- wolf550e 2y agoIt updated my corp laptop a few days ago
- arp242 2y agoWindows 11's big 2024 update leaves behind 9GB of undeletable files - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41802912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41802912 - Oct 2024 (26 comments)
- coreyh14444 2y agoyes, this has been posted several times already
- numpad0 2y agothere do seem to be more dupes lately...
- radicalbyte 2y agoOh Windows is worse than that: basically every patch or installer you've ever run is also kept on your system. In addition to the files it installed. Remove them and it leads to lots of pain with updates & de-installations.
- eviks 2y agoindeed, such a poorly designed wasteful system, "amazed" it's still not fixed
- nickpsecurity 2y agoNew feature for overlay file systems: tricking Windows into thinking the 8.63GB of junk you deleted is still there.
- accrual 2y agoI hope we don't get overlay file systems in Windows. Such a headache to debug low disk space issues.
- password4321 2y agoAre there any ideas to make low disk space issues with overlay file systems easier to debug? Perhaps another read-only virtual drive that accurately mirrored the actual underlying space used? I wonder if something like this would help vs. cloud storage overlays like Dropbox, OneDrive, etc.
- ape4 2y ago... and that's just in the registry (joke attempt)
- BikiniPrince 2y agoThe micro distribution devs found that Replay is now a dependency for explorer. They have to install it and then disable it. Seems MSFT really wants those screenshots.
- shams93 2y agoYeah thought I needed a new laptop but with XFCE instead of bloated windows I can code as much as I want now with almost 50% more drive space with XFCE than windows.
- LinuxBender 2y agoIt was possible to disable it vs. removing using ShutUp10 in July. Have they since patched that away? If so could one create a scheduled job that runs in the same security scope that would truncate all the files? Or maybe add a RAM disk overlay? There must be a way to put an arrow in it's knee. [1] - https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10 https://www.oo-software.com/en/shutup10 [freeware]
- rererereferred 2y agoIs this Replay the same as Recall? The take a screenshot every 5 seconds AI thing? I saw disabling Recall would revert explorer to an older version. Personally I don't care for the changes to explorer, but how much will the system break if I leave the old version up.
- bee_rider 2y agoWhatever happened to Microsoft? Did they become like this because they have trouble attracting decision-making talent post, like, 2010 or so? Or were they always like this, and the bar was just incredibly low when they were taking over the world?
- chongli 2y agoEnshittification! Microsoft used to earn a lot of revenue from selling perpetual software licenses (like any software company in the 1990s). Now they've pivoted over to services, SaaS, and ad-driven freemium software (Windows itself). They're not seeing any growth in Windows installs (and haven't in years), so in order to continue growing they've got to enshittify the existing install base!
- Scharkenberg 2y agoWe just began testing the upgrade to 24H2 this week and haven't noticed the issue on any of our test machines (about 80 amd64 devices and VMs so far).
- betaby 2y agoLinux on desktop is a thing. No need to suffer abuse from MS.
- eknkc 2y agoI try to completely get into Linux desktop at least once a year.. Been more than 20 years I've been doing that. There is always some blocker. Had 2-3 months of exclusive linux use a couple of times but never stuck. My latest main issue btw: Fractional scaling does not work reliably. It just results in different type of fuckery for different apps. Yeah yeah I know wayland x11 this that. No. There are workarounds for different apps, env vars, cmd line flags. Some simply do not cooperate (JetBrains...) It is complete shit show. It is just not worth it. I'm fine with macOS desktop and Linux on servers. And I salute all the masochists running Linux on their desktops.
- boltzmann64 2y agoAt this point, I am afraid that you will never be able to switch to Linux completely. You know what they say, can't teach old dog new tricks. Linux has it's issues and Windows also has it's own issues. You have to choose which ones you can live with one you cannot. For me, I use a FHD display where 100% scaling looks the best and also it's the small things I cannot live without, like Super+drag to drag/scale windows from anywhere, middle-click paste, powerful POSIX shells (yes, yes I know PowerShell, too old to learn a new shell), etc. But I cannot live with Windows privacy nightmare, mouse-heavy desktop environment. Just do use what you like. Just have fun computing.
- layer8 2y ago> mouse-heavy desktop environment Ironically, Windows still being the best system for keyboard GUI usage is an important reason why I continue using it. With Cygwin for my POSIX shell needs.
- wilsonnb3 2y agoI am on Windows for the same reason but KDE finally has fractional scaling that works just as well as Windows. AFAIK, it is the only Linux DE that has it though.
- ryandrake 2y agoThis shouldn’t be a huge surprise. Microsoft’s Windows has a long and proud history of using users’ hard drives as their own dumping ground for trash, and for package management that fails to entirely clean up after uninstallations and updates. No respect whatsoever for the user’s filesystem.
- Mountain_Skies 2y agoStarting to get the feeling that Microsoft puts all of their best devs and managers on Azure, and perhaps BI/Dynamic, with legacy products like Windows getting people they're going to PIP out the door eventually.
- 7bit 2y agoTrust me, they dont. Many Things in Azure are Buggy as hell or idioticslly desogned
- javcasas 2y agoThe guys at Azure aren't the best at all. My last Azure surprise: you can create custom attribute types for users. But you cannot update or delete these custom attribute types. So if you create one for testing because you are trying to figure out the UI, expecting to delete them, well FU the attributes are staying there forever.
- ck2 2y agoLTSC FTW https://old.reddit.com/r/WindowsLTSC/wiki/index https://old.reddit.com/r/WindowsLTSC/wiki/index
- LeifCarrotson 2y agoLTSC eliminates so many antifeatures present in 11 and 10 Home, and also solves the problem of the EOL for 10 next year - Win10 IoT Enterprise LTSC is good through 2031. Grab the "en-us_windows_10_iot_enterprise_ltsc_2021_x64_dvd_257ad90f" ISO, sha1 begins 76c3c10e, from Microsoft: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows10 https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/software-download/windows10 (Note that you have to set your user agent to something other than Windows.) Run the activation script from Github: https://github.com/massgravel/Microsoft-Activation-Scripts https://github.com/massgravel/Microsoft-Activation-Scripts And enjoy a Windows that feels like your own PC again, not Microsoft's. I have to run a number of CAD programs and proprietary IDEs in a Win10 VM, this is the only way it's usable for me.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThat’s way too complicated for the average person or business, who probably doesn’t even know recall is spying on them. We need to regulate and to break up or heavily tax megacorps like Microsoft
- tavavex 2y agoIf Recall is all that needs to be fixed, it can just be disabled pretty easily from systems that have it (I presume that most don't, and it doesn't even exist on my current Windows PC). LTSB/LTSC is very much viable for businesses that can obtain it legit through bulk licensing as a build of Windows Enterprise. The complicated process above is intended for individuals, who can't get buy it directly. Even then, it's more oriented towards HN users and such, not the average person.
- dartharva 2y agoThat still won't fix Windows.
- xiaodai 2y agodisk swap files?
- accrual 2y agoOn Windows the swap file is usually C:\pagefile.sys, and the size is configurable (even to zero if needed).
- EasyMark 2y agoI always set it to something like 4GB min/max for nostalgia, I don’t even know if it matters any longer, but that’s what I do on my friends’ computers when they ask me to clean it up a bit; glad I exited windows years ago though.
- RaiausderDose 2y agoBleachbit is very good (with community cleaup file even more) to get rip of trash remains of installs, temp files, game saves, Steam Cache etc.
- throwaway918299 2y agoSo glad I switched to MacOS for my desktop system a few years ago. Microsoft will never get another penny from me.
- wwweston 2y agoThe funny thing is that I'd been looking at switching to Windows from MacOS in the last 5 years -- main thing is Microsoft's tradition of backwards compatibility, which respects user investment in software, something that much of the industry is briming with contempt for, and the kindest thing I could say about Apple on this particular topic is that they're not the worst offender. So, bought a Windows Laptop and a Surface Pro, explored that for a bit, and it was ... OK. I could see my hopes getting some kind of payoff with enough work, when I got around to the work. Until this OS-level surveillance stuff went down. And that's it. I can't imagine investing in their platforms. I can't imagine trusting that the product stakeholders are even capable of learning to act with user interests in mind, or that executive management that created a team making decisions this bad is capable of learning either. MacOS and Apple have their issues, but they haven't crossed that threshold yet and I can probably fix my backward compat issues with VMs. (Some responsibility for trusting MS has to fall on me given the "fool me twice" principle, it was clear that they were fundamentally untrustworthy at least as far back as the 90s antitrust trials, now also seems clear that the recent image rehab was exactly that: image, nothing more.)
- queuebert 2y agoApple is pretty bad. They nuked all 32-bit support at some point, which made almost my entire Steam library unplayable until I cobbled together a Windows box. When coupled with the idiotic UI design direction they have taken the last 10 years, MacOS is no longer a contender for me.
- wwweston 2y agoThe 32 bit support nuking was in fact the source of my macOS concerns too, and why I was looking over the fence to see if Windows offered me some shelter from the tech treadmill. Current plan is to see if I can run 10.14 in a VM for 32 bit apps and finally ditch the hardware I’m keeping for them.
- Technetium 2y agoThis feels like clickbait, and also may be a duplicate.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- rbanffy 2y agoHow is it even possible to have files a user with admin privileges can’t delete?
- isoprophlex 2y agoThis makes more sense when you realise that you're not the user of your computer, but a resource to be exploited.
- mmh0000 2y ago`Administrator` isn't the most powerful user on Windows, `SYSTEM` is[1]. Those lingering files are likely created/owned by SYSTEM [1] https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/identity-protection/access-control/local-accounts https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/identity-...
- pzmarzly 2y agoDoesn't Administrator account have permission to register new system services (e.g. in services.msc) and have them run as SYSTEM account? I thought it is the case but never tried.
- spijdar 2y agoYes, this is precisely how the (now owned by Microsoft) Sysinternals PsExec [1] tool can spawn a shell as SYSTEM — it creates a service which spawns a shell in your current desktop session. [1] https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/downloads/psexec https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/downloads/pse...
- out-of-ideas 2y agoits worse than that; for instance in w10 the registry will have a whole slew of SYSTEM owned items, but only the TrustedInstaller (still SYSTEM) has permissions to traverse the registry tree; sadly the specfics escape me at the moment (im pretty sure the last ASUS laptop i'll ever own corrupted the nvme drive; so replicating that project that produced the results i was seeking is on the backburner) i was using NSudo for elevation to that scope when needed (wow looks deprecated now in favor of new tooling, neato)
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41802912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41802912
- rsp1984 2y agoNot trying to sound like a dork, but 9 GB -- that's nothing. MacOS routinely eats 30-40 GB of HD space in Volumes/Preboot and "macOS Install Data" for god knows what. Plus even a bare bones XCode installation will cost around 20 GB, much more if you actually want to run your code on connected devices. But of course saving disk space is not exactly #1 on Apple's priority list when the 512 GB and 1 TB disk upgrades sell at 80% margin.
- saagarjha 2y agoAn Xcode install is 12 GB.
- vetinari 2y agoThat's apparent size; the size taken on disk is ~5 GB (including command line tools).
- tombert 2y agoI agree. I don’t run Windows, but even a relatively cheap laptop will have a 1tb disk. It seems silly to worry too much about an extra 9 gigs used by the OS.
- dfasdfast4 2y agoI run windows on a 150gb partition for a couple of games, rest is linux for work. 9gb doesn't seem like much but it's wasted space I get to pay for but am not able to use.
- jeffbee 2y agoIs that a lot?
- shepherdjerred 2y agoNot really. Some dislike the idea of wastefulness, others want a reason to hate on Microsoft, and a minority are actually on 128gb/256gb drives where 9GB can actually be meaningful.
- EasyMark 2y agoIt’s a lot on a MacBook but not on a windows laptop where it’s easy to swap out to a much bigger drive :) . I still prefer my apple/linux world however and glad that all the software that I need to use currently lives there.
- millzlane 2y agoLuckily Microsoft is upfront about the storage requirements in the specs.
- 486sx33 2y agoHaha oh I thought you meant all the other crap windows hordes that you can’t delete like, copilot, weather, news, internet explorer, Skype, teams, new teams , old teams F you Microsoft , what does any of this garbage have to do with an operating system ??
- Unbefleckt 2y agoI had copilot suddenly appear last week, but I just right clicked and uninstalled it?
- apatheticonion 2y agoMy ROG Ally cries