8 ms·
US Navy X-47B Robot Fighter Jet Completes First Phase Of Testing
- simanek 14y agoImpressive, but seems like a really, really bad idea.
- droithomme 14y agoThese sorts of weapons move the balance of power to where the only reasonable defenses against the US are nuclear and bioweapons, and therefore that is where you should start investing your research efforts in if you are not an ally.
- ghostfish 14y agoHow does this type of aircraft shift the balance of power? It doesn't appear to do anything "better" than a manned aircraft aside from not having a pilot to lose onboard.
- breidh 14y agoIt can ostensibly disable an adversary's satellite.
- protomyth 14y agoUhm, I might be off, but are you thinking of the X-37B? The US has had satellite shoot down capability for a while.
- velodrome 14y agoHowever, disabling (or altering) the satellite without the adversary knowing about it is an even greater advantage.
- breidh 14y agoSorry, you're right. I was thinking of the x-37. However, I wasn't aware there was air-to-low-earth-orbit shoot down capability. Only ground launch capability.
- protomyth 14y agoThere was http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_F-15_Eagle#Anti-satellite_trials http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonnell_Douglas_F-15_Eagle#An... and http://www.navy.mil/submit/display.asp?story_id=35015 http://www.navy.mil/submit/display.asp?story_id=35015
- mkaltenecker 14y agoThe only consequences I can think of are that the cost for the military is potentially decreased and that advocating war gets easier. The first one is a maybe. I’m willing to bet that you still need a lot of people to make those things fly, they are also potentially more complicated machines and I’m not sure how the cost of pilots (and replacing them if one is killed) figures into this. The second one seems significant to me. It seems that drones already make it pretty sure you are nowhere safe if the US don’t like you – even if you are a relatively low priority. Presidents (especially Obama) have become extremely willing to use them for just about anything.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Dove 14y agoYou can attempt a lot more of the type of mission in which both your target and your aircraft are destroyed. I've heard folks who work on drones say that once you've fired all your munitions, you have one munition left.
- mbenjaminsmith 14y ago1. With in-air refueling, a greatly increased time in the air vs manned aircraft. 2. Ability to outmaneuver any manned aircraft by exceeding the human g limit. 3. Greatly lowered cost in both manufacture and pilot training (or lack of). 4. When fully realized, AI that is superior to human pilots -- increasing overall combat effectiveness and reducing error.
- velodrome 14y ago5. Reconnaissance 6. Stealth 7. Autonomy 8. Cost of pilot death (human loss) 9. Reduced training time
- antidoh 14y ago0. No risk of losing a human, which makes it easier to decide to attack or go to war, and so you look more bad ass in the balance of power. The increased willingness and ability to attack is a bad thing.
- kiba 14y ago1. With in-air refueling, a greatly increased time in the air vs manned aircraft. Not unique to unmanned aircrafts. On the other hand, pilots need to go to the restroom, get hungry, and tired. 2. Ability to outmaneuver any manned aircraft by exceeding the human g limit. Only useful if human pilot have low latency access to aircraft, or if AI is good enough to fight. Otherwise, you're good as owned. 3. Greatly lowered cost in both manufacture and pilot training (or lack of). Useful, when nobody is trying to shoot down your drone. 4. When fully realized, AI that is superior to human pilots -- increasing overall combat effectiveness and reducing error. In 30 years, maybe.
- forgotusername 14y agoThese are still vulnerable to electronic countermeasures, not to mention plain old missile attacks on their requisite communications infrastructure (satellites presumably). I imagine if any modern power got into a real fight with the US, the first volley of missiles would be headed for space.
- protomyth 14y agoThe US Navy has a massive superiority over every other navy in the world for a good many years. This is just the next step. The recently release radar information (tracking raindrops) was probably a bit of a warning telling others that their new generation of missiles was not going to work as well as they think. Probably much like NASA showing people underground rivers was designed to tell others hiding ICBMs was a waste.
- samstave 14y agoWhat is the underground rivers thing you mention?
- protomyth 14y agoI remember an old story about NASA giving a detailed map of the underground parts of some river system via ground penetrating radar to a country thus telling the USSR that building large underground facilities was not really going to hide them. I thought it was the Nile and Egypt, but I am probably wrong on that. It was in one of the history books I was reading in the 90's and they are in a storage garage about 400miles away.
- antidoh 14y ago"It was in one of the history books I was reading in the 90's and they are in a storage garage about 400miles away." As much as I hate ereaders, there's an excellent example of why ebooks are a good thing.
- mikeash 14y agoWMD or insurgency has been the only realistic way to militarily oppose the US for a long, long time now. That's nothing new.
- gmrple 14y agoLeast ways not in an offensive manner. Though that could be a faulty assumption, we (the US) haven't had any real military attacks on our soil in a while.
- molmalo 14y agoActually, in conventional war, as Millennium Challenge 2002 clearly showed [1], using smart tactics a technologically inferior army can effectively defeat the US military. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennium_Challenge_2002
- adventureful 14y agoNo, that only works if the US can't keep coming at you. In that case, you have to be able to sustain massive damage to your economy and military and keep fighting indefinitely (which then guarantees a shift to guerrilla tactics).
- molmalo 14y agoThis is not 1945. This is what I think would happen if the events of MC2002 were real: If an entire fleet and more than 20000 people were killed in a single day of combat, I bet that the US would have a significant political turmoil, much worse than that of Vietnam, and massive protests. Moving an entire fleet to replace the one lost, could take months, hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars, loss of morale in troops, and an economic disaster (the markets would simply tank to the lowest). And of course, moving a fleet to replace the one lost, would mean that you have to lower your guard in another front, which itself introduces new kind of problems. Just as an example, moving the 7th fleet would pave the way for China to invade Taiwan. At the same time, China or Russia would be selling more equipment to the other party. Right-wing groups would ask for a full retaliation, or more possibly, asking for allies to get involved, but that could rapidly escalate to a regional or global conflict, as other countries would try to support the one playing "David" here. At that point, with the markets falling apart and clamoring for heads to roll, it would simply be unfeasible to continue. There's even the possibility that some allied economies (Germany?, France?) would probably refuse to help, as the balance of economy tips in their favor, while US markets tank. Wars are not only resolved with bullets today.
- mixmax 14y agoactually with the adversaries the US is currently engaged with the most reasonable defense (from the point of the adversaries) is terrorism. It's cheap and effective, and arguably no more unfair than bombing civilians that don't stand a fighting chance against a drone controlled by an operator thousand of miles away. This is the major downside of modern American one-sided warfare.
- mindslight 14y agoNot only from the point of the adversaries, but to anyone who's thought about the actual role each "side" is playing. But don't worry fellow Americans, just keep supporting the intractable and autonomous government.
- vibrunazo 14y agoThe most efficient military defense countries are engaging in is developing economic relationships. The number one reason why the US start a military war against China in the foreseeable future. Is not because of their super advanced autonomous airships. But because doing so would be shooting their own foot. As both US and China are highly dependent on one another. Plenty of small countries around the world have very little military but are completely safe from US attacks because of economic relationships. Modern economics are the most powerful weapon for peace. Not autonomous vehicles nor terrorism.
- droithomme 14y agoChina has a gigantic arsenal of functioning nuclear warheads sitting atop of maintained and ready ICBMs that are pretargetted at key american targets. Military action against China by the US is simply not possible. The US doesn't bully China. It bullies people who don't have working nukes and ICBMs. One of the main arguments against the US building a network of "star wars" missile defense stations capable of stopping mass ICBM attacks is it would dangerously shift the balance of power with China, requiring them to pursue other means of preventing the US from attacking them. The Chinese are extremely smart so targetted bioweapons that only infect people with smallpox who don't have asian ancestry are not out of the question as a reasonable project to look into next. It would be better for all of us if they do not pursue this line of research. Not having a missile defense system maintains the usefulness of their nuclear arsenal. It is therefore better than having a missile defense system which makes their nuclear arsenal useless.
- ferringham 14y agooh really? Ever heard of tactics called terrorism? A pistol is not my weapon of preference when trying to kill a fly. Generals as usual are fighting the last (cold) war.
- Gustomaximus 14y agoI would think this is going to increase the push into cyber warfare. In the same way we saw a done being hijacked recently through GPS I would think taking more complete control of your enemies drones, or at the least disabling their sensors and ability to operate will become a big military push.
- sien 14y agoNo, the reasonable defense against the US is already working. Debt.
- angstrom 14y agoSo how many G's can one of these pull? I imagine it's much higher than any human fighter since the upper limit is what can safely hold the craft together.
- joeguilmette 14y agoI wouldn't imagine it needs to pull very much at all. There are no more dogfights anymore, it's just electronic countermeasures vs electronic detection, jamming and spoofing.
- Dove 14y agoI would imagine it's designed to take a lot of g's. Not for dogfighting, but for carrier landings, which can be pretty rough. I know that involves completely different stresses on the airframe than maneuvering, but Google up some of the drop tests they put other aircraft through. Intense stuff!
- antidoh 14y agoDodging SAMs could involve a lot of Gs.
- angstrom 14y agoThat's more along the lines I was thinking. Don't fighters still do evasive maneuvers? Of course, the SR-71 Blackbirds had one of the most effective solutions. Fly fast and unpredictable vectors. Anything on an interception vector would be miles off by the time it reached it's predicted location.
- shareme 14y agoWhat many of you might not realize; 1. Drones because of no human pilots have longer uptimes and longer in-flight distances. That means that if US carriers are deployed in the Pacific that these drones can cover MiddleEast, Asia and European targets without moving the carriers. 2. Last major bombing actions for stealth bombers were at close to 24 hours flight time round-trip which is not sustainable for human pilots in high amounts of missile launcher encounters. Making it robotic where you can hand it off to teams of pilots per several hour shift alleviates that concern.
- gcb 14y agoMost disappointing title ever. It's just an unmanned jet. was expecting something like robotech/macross
- ygmelnikova 14y agoShouldn't that title read "Cyberdyne Systems X-47B"?
- ThomBush 14y agoSuper high tech, advanced-robot fighter jet... not able to retract landing gear? (from video). Did that bother anyone else?
- russell 14y agoI imagine it can retract its landing gear. It was probably left down for the test; one less thing to fail.
- protomyth 14y agoGenerally, the first test flights won't have an aircraft raise its gear. http://www.upi.com/Business_News/Security-Industry/2011/02/07/Navy-flight-tests-new-UAV-for-carriers/UPI-66291297084580/ http://www.upi.com/Business_News/Security-Industry/2011/02/0...
- smallblacksun 14y agoThe article has a picture of it with it's landing gear up.
- antoinevg 14y agoEliezer's unfriendly AI does not need to be smarter necessarily, just better armed.
- KwanEsq 14y agoI wonder how they develop the code for these systems. You'd hope it might be something approaching the standards, rigours, and processes of the people who write the Space Shuttle code, but I have the sad feeling it probably isn't.
- ThomPete 14y agoI am pretty sure it is pretty strickt. As far as I understand code for airplanes in general is much more encapsulated to do one thing well without any resuability of the code as such. It's in other words strictly causal. Fighter jets might have more of an abstract layer for all the AI stuff so this might leave more room for an actual OS to reprogram and optimize on top off.
- ThomPete 14y agoIt might be perfectly possible that I am completely off on this. But my understanding from reading about it is that software is written very differently in airplanes than in most other fields. Down vote is fine if I am wrong. But would appreciate to learn how I am wrong then.
- dexen 14y agoJoint Strike Fighter programme (produced F-35) C++ coding standard: http://www2.research.att.com/~bs/JSF-AV-rules.pdf http://www2.research.att.com/~bs/JSF-AV-rules.pdf Been posted to HN before: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3967316 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3967316 From a cursory read, it mostly boils down to ``don't do anything funky or too smart'', with the `too smart' bar is held somewhat low. Still, it asks programmers to use some decent stuff like the RAII idiom, for example (AV Rule 79).
- voodoochilo 14y agoahh, more weapons! the one solution to all problems in the world that requires the least brain capacity. congrats.
- kemiller 14y agoIn The Terminator, Skynet is supposed to have achieved sentience and turned against its masters. But if you look at something like this from the point of view of someone in a part of the world where the political structure is not aligned with US hegemony, the difference between an advanced AI which has "turned" and a robotic army that is ultimately still controlled by humans is probably academic. I suppose that in the latter scenario there is still in theory some humanity to appeal to, but I somehow doubt that's what's running through your head when you're being chased by a faceless killing machine. Then again, a closed-cockpit jet fighter isn't exactly a cuddly sight regardless.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoThe difference between an AI-flown jet, Predator drone, ICBM, or even human-flown jet is mainly academic if they're headed in your direction and you lack the ability to defend against them.
- molmalo 14y agoHumanity? http://www.iraqwarlogs.com/2010/10/23/us-commits-%E2%80%9Cwar-crime%E2%80%9D-as-apache-helicopter-cleared-to-gun-surrendering-insurgents/ http://www.iraqwarlogs.com/2010/10/23/us-commits-%E2%80%9Cwa... No, no humanity. http://www.channel4.com/news/iraqs-secret-war-logs-surrender-and-die http://www.channel4.com/news/iraqs-secret-war-logs-surrender... Watch the second video. US Military considers that it is not possible to surrender to aircrafts. So, if someone tries to surrender, they are still valid targets, and then eliminated. So, basically, it's the same as fighting with a totally autonomous machine. There's no humanity in that kind of fight.
- kemiller 14y agoWell, that's the point, right? People are worried about hostile AI, and how scary it would be to be confronted by an enemy possessing overwhelming resources and no emotional common ground. But much of the world already has that experience.
- zokier 14y agoFighter? Hardly: >The mission of the Navy Unmanned Combat Air System (UCAS) Aircraft Carrier Demonstration (UCAS-D) is to mature technologies for a carrier suitable, low observable relevant, unmanned air system in support of a potential follow-on acquisition milestone for an unmanned air system capable of providing persistent, penetrating surveillance, and penetrating strike capability in high threat areas. Primarily a recon craft with strike capability.