8 ms·
An exoskeleton let a paralyzed man walk, then its maker refused repairs
- ChumpGPT 2y agohttp://archive.today/cKeCi http://archive.today/cKeCi
- wiskinator 2y agoAnd this is why right to repair laws are a thing. Also, genuinely I’d be interested in helping this guy hack his exoskeleton to let it work again.
- kleiba 2y agoThat depends on how exactly a right to repair law is going to regulate things. Will a company have to provide parts for older models forever? Because in the article it says that he was going to fix it himself but couldn't find the part that connects the battery to his controller watch.
- jjk166 2y agoThey shouldn't be making such unnecessary proprietary components. For cases where there really is no way around using custom hardware, at end of life the specifications should be made public so that a third party can manufacture them. In this specific case, the real issue is just the incredibly short service lifetime. While different medical devices are going to have different lifetimes, manufacturers need to continue to provide support for at least 36 months after reporting that they plan to discontinue support, which is 60% of the lifetime of this product. Typically medical devices are supported for much longer.
- tedunangst 2y agoIsn't five years longer than 36 months?
- jjk166 2y ago36 months is 60% of five years.
- bastawhiz 2y agoTo play devil's advocate: > They shouldn't be making such unnecessary proprietary components. Perhaps not, but that's not right to repair. Pretty much everything in any modern smartphone is completely proprietary. And as the article said, the battery wasn't proprietary. The missing part was the battery connector. That doesn't even suggest to me that it's wildly proprietary, just that it can't be found anymore. Lots of components that are easily sourced now would be challenging for an ordinary person to source in a decade. > at end of life the specifications should be made public so that a third party can manufacture them. This also isn't right to repair. In fact, it probably doesn't help much at all: a sufficiently specialized part on a specialized medical device is going to be so niche that the cost of an aftermarket part will be huge. There's probably what, twenty of these things in the wild? A hundred? How many aftermarket manufacturers will even pick up the phone for a one-off custom part, spec or no? > manufacturers need to continue to provide support for at least 36 months after reporting that they plan to discontinue support, which is 60% of the lifetime of this product The device was supported for the regulatory limit of five years, and the owner has been using it for ten. Assuming they did give three years of support after discontinuing the product, it's now two years beyond that. For a product only approved to be sold for five years by a regulator, I think the fact that the only piece that couldn't be serviced after double that time is a battery connector is pretty impressive (all things considered). Customer service aside, I'm not sure how much more you could possibly ask from this company.
- justinclift 2y ago> How many aftermarket manufacturers will even pick up the phone for a one-off custom part, spec or no? That would depend entirely upon the part. With (detailed) specs being available, quite a lot of skilled repair techs would be able to bodge something competent together (!) to meet those specs. Re-manufacturing completely 100% good parts could be a thing sure, for sufficient volumes. But real world situations for low volumes tend to be "lets get it working well enough using the tools we have available". Creativity is required. ;) The results for those situations are improved dramatically if there's detailed, good quality docs easily accessible to the people working on it.
- Dylan16807 2y ago
- cptaj 2y agoNot sure about the US but in some countries this is regulated for cars. Companies are required to provide parts for a certain amount of years after discontinuation of the product. It seems abundantly reasonable that a similar requirement be imposed for prosthesis. And it would also be very reasonable for the required period to be longer than that of cars. So yeah, not forever, but definitely not a a short period either.
- rootusrootus 2y ago> Not sure about the US I think this was something that used to be regulated but is not now. There's plenty of financial justification for supporting cars 10 or more years by making parts, since most last longer than that. For niche products that are practically one-offs, I can see where it might need to be regulated because the economics won't encourage it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- readthenotes1 2y agoI had to buy a mirror for my 23 year old car on eBay. There ought to be a law /s
- rascul 2y agoThe local AutoZone stocks mirrors for my 22 year old Oldsmobile. I don't know if there's a law.
- ars 2y agoHe's not being blocked from repairing it, and he doesn't need to hack it. He just needs a part. (They did eventually send it to him.) If they had not, he doesn't need the right to repair it, rather would need someone to manufacture the part.
- rkhassen9 2y agoBut is a compelling reason to have solid right to repair laws.
- financetechbro 2y agoOne could imagine a solid industry of 3rd party parts providers if devices are built under a right to repair framework
- yellers 2y agoOnce again, that thing falls under FDA regulations. You’re telling us about a world with 3rd party mix and match components, all FDA approved in any and all combinations on 5 year plus old devices?
- justinclift 2y ago> under FDA regulations. That's just (!) under current FDA regulations though yeah? It's not like they're forever unchangeable.
- bastawhiz 2y agoI'm supportive of the right to repair in every sense, but even the strongest right to repair laws would not have helped improve the outcome in this case.
- justinclift 2y agoThe strongest right to repair law would probably require detailed schematics, BOMs, and (sufficiently detailed) manufacturing steps being available for all the parts. That would enable people to organise getting replacements manufactured themselves. :)
- yellers 2y agoHang on, what about the part where the FDA only approved the thing for a 5 year use and essentially pushed the manufacturer into liability if they worked on it after that period? Maybe that’s the issue that needs repairing first.
- tomrod 2y agoYour point is valid, and is improved when we recognize it's not an either/or blame game when acknowledging the parts of the system that need improvement for failures like this person experienced.
- akira2501 2y agoIt doesn't sound like a hard and fast rule. It seems like it's whatever the manufacturer asks for in terms of "intended working life." This _seems_ to be the original FDA certification for the device: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/reviews/den130034.pdf https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/cdrh_docs/reviews/den130034.p... The problem here, of course, is it's not the device itself, but the simple remote control peripheral that is designed to switch device operating modes. The FDA should force manufacturers of "two piece" systems like this to have backup controls on the device itself and to exclude these non-medical components designed for control from any regulation covering "intended design life." It seems like a daffy middle ground that the FDA lets exist and manufacturers take advantage of when they can.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoThere is no part two to the certification? Edit: Seems odd that the loophole is big enough to allow not even uploading the full documentation.
- generalizations 2y ago> It seems like it's whatever the manufacturer asks for in terms of "intended working life." I would guess the FDA makes their certification easier or harder to pass based on how long the device is expected to last. If the 5 year lifespan is what hits the middle ground for that company between cost-of-certification and useful-product-life, then it's up to the FDA to make a longer lifespan feasible to get certified.
- squarefoot 2y ago> And this is why right to repair laws are a thing. Yes, and also why products should be open sourced and documented when they're declared obsolete by their manufacturer, or the manufacturer cease operations. Let people be responsible for all repairs they do to their devices; this man would probably not give a damn about regulations if the alternative was essentially to become paralyzed again.
- dumbfounder 2y agoBut he did have the right to repair... right? He just couldn't get the part. The article title is misleading. They don't support old medical devices, they were following the rules. Yes, they should have handled the customer service better. Escalated it. But it doesn't sound like some big evil company locking people out of their legs because they tinkered with them. Let's not lump it all in the same category. Also, this line is beyond ridiculous: "Straight’s path to paralysis started in the 1990s at the Saratoga Race Course".
- fargle 2y ago> "Straight’s path to paralysis started in the 1990s at the Saratoga Race Course". why is that ridiculous? seems tragic to me; not to mention the horse broke his neck as well.
- Ekaros 2y agoMy understanding of the issue was that he did not know what the part was. It was a connector and there is dozens if not hundreds different families of them. So very likely with suitable bill of materials which right to repair would have provided it could have been found ordered and replaced by third-party.
- seb1204 2y agoSo in the end it was a mix of bad company actions and regulations that made this repair a struggle for him. I heard from a mobility scooter technician that there is barely any second market for the as typically the health insurance will get you a new one every few years. So similar to the companies response to just buy the newest model.
- krisoft 2y ago> was a mix of bad company actions and regulations We actually don’t know the second part. What we know is that the company claimed that regulations were involved. Might or might not be true. Wouldn’t be the first time when a company didn’t want to do something for financial reasons and they decided to read the regulations in a way which made them more money.
- jkestner 2y agoAs for needing to provide parts into the future, a friend's company does aftermarket service for many expensive pieces of government equipment. Presumably they're able to make what's needed because the government requires it of the original manufacturer. The government could require that manufacturers either supply replacement parts or specs for someone else to manufacture them. I suppose the latter would be required to avoid gouging. It'd be interesting to think about the secondary effects—if you can't make a lot of money off of service, will you make longer-lasting products and charge appropriately?
- seanthemon 2y agoOr just get this man a 3d printer so he can make these little parts himself. All he needed was a part that connected the battery to the watch
- dataflow 2y agoWhy in the world did the reporters not try to investigate the FDA rules that supposedly prevents this, instead of trying to shame the company? Either the company is wrong, or that's the real story here.
- Me000 2y ago[flagged]
- fakedang 2y agoMy thoughts exactly. But then again, journalists have long ceased to be investigative or technologically versed.
- jonny_eh 2y agoIt's almost like there's no money left in the profession, so there's no more expertise or time available to do proper investigating or writing.
- thaumasiotes 2y agoIf that were true, the job would be done by someone who took a personal interest in the subject and didn't need to be paid for reporting it. This is the opposite; it's someone doing a bad job because there's money in the profession and they want to get some of it without actually doing the work that would earn it.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoPerhaps. Yet more likely that they're pressured into publishing so often they have little time for thorough investigations. If there were more money in it more people could afford to do it full time, and quality could improve.
- kevinventullo 2y agoSo by that logic, public defenders are your best bet if you get arrested?
- m3kw9 2y agoI wonder if he posted the part on Reddit they could have helped him
- aucisson_masque 2y ago> Medicare said it would start paying for 80 percent of exoskeletons, which at Lifeward cost about $100,000. > And although that coverage doesn’t extend to paraplegics who have injuries to their spine as high up as Straight Oh man, i feel for everyone who live in the USA and require any sort of medical help. Either you spend all your hard earned money or you got to get in a though fight with the medical administration.
- exolymph 2y agoWhile the US healthcare system does suck in numerous ways, is this kind of thing even available elsewhere, via socialized medicine? (Maybe the answer is yes, which would be great!)
- aucisson_masque 2y agoYes it does. https://www.francetvinfo.fr/sante/politique-de-sante/sante-la-revolution-des-exosquelettes_5627849.html https://www.francetvinfo.fr/sante/politique-de-sante/sante-l...
- yesco 2y agoOftentimes the big issues with the development of new Medical Devices are pre/post market studies and data collection for those studies. The regulatory path for this ends up quite complicated & contradictory when juggled with HIPPA, GDPR and the various rules around how these studies are executed. This means there is a lot of tricky nuance to what markets a Medical Device company might try to target. While I certainly wouldn't call myself an expert on this, having worked within the industry I've been able to make the following observations: - Novel medical devices are often created by very small startups, who in essence exist solely to create a PoC. A larger Medical Device company then buys them to actually start walking through the regulatory hurdles which will bring them to market. - The market it gets initially released in is rarely connected to the location it was invented (ex: Invented by European startup but released in the US is weirdly common). But if a product is successful enough then an even larger Medical device company with access to more international markets might swoop in and purchase the mid sized company. - European regulatory agencies will oftentimes be lenient on products that have received FDA approval, but the reverse is less clear cut. So going through the FDA first can be more efficient, especially when considering the market size of the US along with the fact that you only need to support one language. In practice this pushes out the timeline for the first European release of a device. - GDPR is actually not very different from HIPPA, perhaps not even as strict, but it is more ambiguous and that's a problem. The key difference is that, right now, everyone knows exactly how to follow HIPPA but the reverse is not true for GDPR. Some things that might be allowed by one might subtly contradict the other and there is no third party Medical Device companies can throw money at that will absorb the liability of this by saying whether or not they are GDPR compliant. - Since Medical Device companies live & die on their study data, this data collection paradox has further pushed out timelines for when medical devices are first released in Europe. - A European might see a cool new Medical device from a startup in their local newspaper but then never actually gain access to it for another 20 years. So personally I'd say it largely reduces down to the regulatory environment + market size. The US can be among the strictest, but not only is getting past that worth it for market access, but by passing those strict hurdles, releasing to other international markets becomes much easier since you got the hard part over with. Not to mention the fact that, in a similar way a popular programming language might have more "community resources" and a larger hiring pool, the same could also be said for navigating regulatory environments. So popularity has a self-amplifying effect.
- from-nibly 2y agoRight to repair should cover things like putting locks on devices that are illegal to unlock to repair. Making it illegal to do whatever the Frick you want to something you bought. Making it illegal to make parts yourself or have 3rd party companies make a part. It should not force companies to build parts for you. Forcing people to do work they do not want to is insane. That kind of talk would prevent me from building anything and letting my neighbor borrow it. And no, saying "it wouldnt apply to you just <insert demographic>" doesn't make me feel any better about that.
- Sakos 2y ago> It should not force companies to build parts for you. If a company is unable to provide long-term support in the form of replacement parts, then they shouldn't be allowed to sell it to consumers. For decades, and for most devices, it was trivial to find replacement parts and/or swap out identical parts, even if they weren't made by the original manufacturer. You can get replacement parts for cars made in the 90s, 80s, 70s. It should not be acceptable to buy something as important and life-changing and expensive as this exoskeleton, and the manufacturer just fucks off and provides no way to maintain it long-term. Freedom doesn't exist. Every corporation is bound by laws and regulations. "Forcing people to do work they do not want to". We aren't talking about regular people like you or me. We're talking about corporations. They're regularly "forced" to do things they don't want to, to the benefit of their customers and society as a whole. You need better arguments if you want to argue against regulating companies.
- from-nibly 2y agoSo just no exoskeletons ever then.
- jwagenet 2y ago> For decades, and for most devices, it was trivial to find replacement parts and/or swap out identical parts… This seems like a stretch for anything other than cars, pcs, and large appliances. I doubt this has been true for a long time for anything under $100 and more electrically complicated than a switch and a motor.
- throwaway48476 2y agoIn other news Microsoft abandoned the surface duo after 1 yearly android update. If you don't control the software you don't really own the device, whether it be a phone or an exoskeleton.
- bastawhiz 2y agoHe needed a battery and a battery connector, I doubt his exoskeleton was even connected to the Internet.
- dangsux 2y ago[dead]
- Animats 2y agoThe manufacturer wants them to "upgrade" to a new model. It's not like the eye implant where the vendor exited the industry.
- Eric_WVGG 2y agoIt's related, though. This is incredibly valuable, incredibly expensive equipment turning to e-waste.
- langsoul-com 2y agoGiven the mechanical complexity of such devices. Would it ever be profitable to continue producing parts for them? Unless the company has stagnated, the tech and parts would improve overtime where they no longer match. But also, would you want a third party to continue producing the parts? Seems like a security leak there.
- WorkerBee28474 2y ago> Given the mechanical complexity of such devices. Would it ever be profitable to continue producing parts for them? For most repair parts, no. Especially not since need for such a device is anticorrelated with earnings. The article's complainant, being a disabled former jockey, probably make <40K in the years leading up to his accident and little to none in the years since.
- Eric_WVGG 2y agoSo here's my dumb little fantasy law, I'd love for anyone to tell me if this is stupid. 1. In the event of a bankruptcy proceeding, all source code for a hardware product shall be open-sourced. 2. In the event of a hardware product that is dependent upon cloud services being discontinued, instructions for "rooting" the product, and the firmware source code shall be open-sourced. 3. Companies that acquire the rights to patents of bankrupt companies and discontinued products must keep the cloud servers going or open-source blah blah. The only serious counter argument I can think of here is the tangle of patents, to which I retort, the price of keeping the patents is keeping the furnaces powering the cloud servers running. Am I crazy here?
- para_parolu 2y agoI don’t fully understand how bankruptcy works but isn’t it just gives whatever you have to creditors? Source code and hardware designs fits into assets. No?
- ajb 2y agoYes, thats the current law in most places. The op is proposing that not all agreements made by a company should be void on bankruptcy. Really, there are cases where this is obviously a change that needs to happen. Eg, if a company holds personal data, the agreements that allowed a company to obtain it should live across bankruptcy with the data, not be terminated if it is transferred. This sort of arrangement is common in real property. For example, if you buy a house where you have to access it via some other private land, the agreement that you can do so is arranged in such a way that it can't be voided when that land is sold, even during bankruptcy. You can't do that for data AFAIK (would love for a lawyer to comment). It needs to be enabled and made mandatory in cases like this. There is some limited ability to do this: creditors can get a "charge" registered against intellectual property, so theoretically in the OP's case one might be able to design a legal construct that would cause a bankruptcy court to give rights to some special purpose vehicle that is set up (in advance) to represent the patients. But I don't know if that would work in all cases
- dangrossman 2y ago
- edm0nd 2y agoFor anyone curious, the older models cost between $69,500 - $85,000. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReWalk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ReWalk Now they seemingly cost $100k+
- 0dayz 2y agoI'm curious as to why we can't have a similar structure for medical devices that we have for military equipment. Essentially that the government would put out contracts based on studies that have been extensively peer reviewed. People/hospitals then can buy them as needed.
- pvaldes 2y agoIf I'm understanding correctly, would the maker accept to repair the structure will be breaking the law. In this case is understandable. The only thing worst than being paralyzed is being paralyzed while burnt alive by charging a broken battery too old. At some point the risk is just too high for the maker. Maybe those devices should be just leased for a month fee, so the company is supported and can keep the lights on. Insurance and government could support the man paying a part of the bill.
- lando2319 2y agoI don't see where they'd be breaking the law. > He said that the company is no longer repairing exoskeletons older than five years because the Food and Drug Administration, which regulates the devices, has approved their usage for that timespan.
- jhanschoo 2y agoFrom the article and the remedy the CEO provided, it seems to be that working on the device themselves would open the manufacturer to liabilities or breaking regulations imposed FDA regulation. The CEO shipped the dude a replacement part so that they could carry out the repair themselves.