6 ms·
Trying Out a Far Infrared Heated Poster
- adamc 2y agoPretty good discussion of why something that sounds useful ultimately is much less so than you'd think.
- deng 2y agoGood article about the downsides of infrared heating. These things can be useful. They are very light, safe and easy to install, and they can really make a difference in tight spaces like a caravan. However, with 425W, of course you cannot expect this thing to heat a larger room (to be fair, the article also does not claim this). The theory that you can direct this thing at yourself so that you feel warm but the rest stays cold is nice in theory, but as the article says, this is really difficult to achieve and usually not worth the trouble. And of course, these things only make sense in your home if you happen to get electricity very cheaply (which the writer of the article apparently does).
- BlueTemplar 2y agoI mean, the two main issues here seem to be : poor placement and bad thermostat control, both of which seem (?) to be fairly easy to solve (at least for manufacturers) : place one horizontally over the top of the TV, focused on the sofa (since it's basically a big lamp, would it work better with a parabolic shape and/or a reflector ?), and don't use a thermostat so dumb that it can only do on/off, but instead one that slowly modulates power output %. (The expensive electricity point is also kind of moot in case that's your only heating option.)
- smeej 2y agoI'm also wondering about the potential for hyper-localized heating. Like, could I have a family picture printed 8"x10" and place one on my desk? Could I then stay comfortable in a much colder office? I'm only ever in one place at a time, and both my house and workspace are compact, so I'd be up for moving one around with me if it meant saving on propane for the "real" heater. I'd also happily place one under my sink or wherever to keep my pipes warm without having to heat the rest of the room when I'm not in it.
- donclark 2y agoIf you find this small device for purchase, please let me know. I would like one as well!
- donclark 2y agoThe poster could be placed on the floor... $68 FIR Heater - Infrared Wall Eco Portable Heating Electric Panel 3000 BTU w/ High Quality Picture "Flowers" Folded Efficient Indoor 41''x 24'' https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/1104443023/heater-infrared-wall-eco-portable https://www.etsy.com/uk/listing/1104443023/heater-infrared-w...
- Scoundreller 2y agoGet a heated mouse (those exist), heated mouse/desk pad (those exist), heated chair(pad), heated footpad (often bought for animals), some IR thingy for the head and you're covered. Any mask over your nose/mouth will retain a lot of warmth and humidity. This is the same logic for electric cars where heat is expensive: conduction>>> convention. Heat the occupant(s) and not the air with heated steering wheels & heated seats. Some ICE gear shifter knobs would get warm from transmission conduction! At one point in life, I had a heated mattress pad so I could turn the heat off a lot. I just ran it before I went to bed so it wouldn't be frigid when I got in. In the morning I'd just run into the shower and leave for the day. My place was western facing (in northern hemisphere) so I got a lot of afternoon sun and would return to a warm place in the afternoon.
- smeej 2y agoI'm not going to go through the list individually, but I can't use a mouse for ergonomic reasons (literally have bones where I shouldn't, so these are fairly unique ergonomic problems), and my laptop already doesn't ventilate very well, so I'm still a lot more interested in something very subtle, like a picture frame on my desk, that wouldn't make me look as weird as I'd look with half a dozen wired things in different places. It's not freezing in my workspace, just a few degrees cooler than I would like, and something inconspicuous like this seems like a great idea!
- 2y ago
- Mistletoe 2y ago425w is about as much as having two 50 inch plasma tvs on. So it might ever so slightly increase the temp in the room but not if it is cold outside at all really.
- supportengineer 2y agoAt a previous employer, we did in fact use a large plasma TV as a space heater on chilly mornings.
- _yb2s 2y agoI think this overall makes a good point that any type of directly heating people is much more efficient than heating an entire building. I hope electrically heated clothing catches on soon... as it already exists and works pretty well. For example, you can get lightweight vests for fairly cheap that will keep you warm all day long from a USB battery in your pocket. Heated blankets and mattress pads of course have also been around a while and work great.
- mschuster91 2y ago> I think this overall makes a good point that any type of directly heating people is much more efficient than heating an entire building. It is, but if a building cools down below the dew point (and it will, unless you're somewhere near the equator), any humidity e.g. from the air you breathe out or from plants will just crash out and condense on the walls, resulting in mold.
- _yb2s 2y agoBecause of the effect you’re talking about, the outdoor dew point is never above the outdoor temperature- so the air even indoors gets really dry when it’s cold outside, and you only need to keep the inside slightly warmer to keep this from happening. I am into sailing and often sail in cold climates without cabin heat- and find that my body heat alone is enough to prevent this from happening in a small sailboat cabin.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoI'm not sure if this makes sense - even if you had very efficient personal heating, you'd probably still want to maintain your house at a certain temperature(for times when you're not wearing your personal heating, or for pets, or visitors, so your pipes don't burst, etc), meaning you should be investing in good insulation/air gap sealing, etc. Once you pay that cost, the cost of heating the house a few extra degrees isn't that big.
- BlueTemplar 2y agoFor a not so small minority, it's more of a if you can afford that cost (ironically, probably more of an issue in places without pipe-freeze-busting temperatures). (And they probably cannot afford redoing insulation of where they live either, assuming they even own rather than rent.) P.S.: The hot water bottle is pretty great, in particular when sick.
- the8472 2y agoYep, the 0/100 duty cycle of FIR panels is not ideal. Buying a panel at a lower power rating and running it at 100% is more comfortable. At high power it will also lead to dry skin/eyes if it's in your field of vision, another reason to use a lower-powered one. IME mounting it behind a mesh backrest works best.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoIsn’t 75 C already way too hot for any surface that you could accidentally bump into? Which suggests the ‘poster’ should be a lot bigger too.
- the8472 2y agoAfaik they're closer to black-body radiators than some narrow band emitter like LEDs, so they have to operate significantly above room temperature.
- MichaelZuo 2y agoHmmm, that seems like a significant disadvantage compared to fan heaters then. Where at least the fancier ones have a ‘cool touch’ design.
- emchammer 2y agoThey can be dimmed with a rheostat or any incandescent light dimmer.
- Nition 2y agoDoes the heater only project the heat forward? Or is it also projecting heat back into the wall that it's lying up against?
- the8472 2y agomostly forward
- imp0cat 2y agoIn this particular case, he could just get some extra fans, mount them under radiators and achieve much better heating for a lot less money. Something like https://www.speedcomfort.com/en https://www.speedcomfort.com/en - just attach the fans and the thermal sensor to your radiator and plug it in. From then on, anytime the radiator gets warm, fans start and circulate hot air everywhere in the room.
- donclark 2y agoIt does not appear that they sell those devices in the US? I did find them on ebay: https://www.ebay.com/itm/405285386735?_trksid=p2332490.c101875.m1851&itmprp https://www.ebay.com/itm/405285386735?_trksid=p2332490.c1018...
- imp0cat 2y agoHmm, you're right. While there are multiple options available in Europe, I was only able to find "ecoCalm Radiator Fan Booster with Smart Heat Sensor and 5 Upgraded Fans" on amazon.com (this one https://www.amazon.com/ecoCalm-Radiator-Upgraded-Ventilator-Efficiency/dp/B0CDGH8KRZ https://www.amazon.com/ecoCalm-Radiator-Upgraded-Ventilator-... ) and it's sold out.
- nlawalker 2y agoFor anyone else for whom the term is new - it's not "an infrared heater that can heat you from far away", it's "heating that uses far infrared radiation". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Far_infrared https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Far_infrared
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- mikewarot 2y agoI don't understand the assumption that the heat output is going to be directly out of the poster, only orthogonal to it, like a columnated beam of heat. Clearly, like any black body source, it's going to radiate in all directions. Or am I mistaken somehow?
- hi-v-rocknroll 2y agoI'm still a little worried about the toxicity of graphene-based products that they might turn out to be another "asbestos".
- bryant 2y agois there any reason to be concerned about graphene that wouldn't apply to common pencil lead (graphite)?
- BizarroLand 2y agoAsbestos is entirely safe as long as it is non-friable. If graphene has similar risks it should also have similar safeties. Don't huff graphene dusts.
- IWeldMelons 2y agoChicago train stations have overhead heaters, you press button the heat you up with infrared, but they look more like 10KW devices.
- CamperBob2 2y agoSeems that any space that's a candidate for this is an even better candidate for a heat pump, which can exceed 100% efficiency if judged in the same terms as a resistive heating element.