6 ms·
'Nearly unusable': Calif. police majorly push back on Tesla cop cars
- finikytou 2y agothey had over 100K BUDGET to make the car ready for police work but somehow they did not find a way to reproduce the "hide behind the engine". sounds like they hired the wrong engineers to do the job. I think even GPT 2 can come up with a solution to this for less than a few thousands
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoWeight matters. They can add a bunch of armor but then the cars range is shot and it's too slow. It's already a heavy vehicle.
- lallysingh 2y agoThe $150k budget included the price of 2 cars. They probably didn't get base models. $35k was for modifying both. They have to bootstrap the r&d for armoring Teslas. They could only find a performance shop that mostly does fiber aero kits. That's the actual issue - no existing armorers. For the "engine block hide", though, would keeping some extra vests in the frunk do the job? Perhaps they're better off with an EV Blazer?
- mingus88 2y agoThis does not sound unreasonable at all. The crown Vic and explorer have had kits for decades and ford designers know the requirements This department bought retail consumer teslas and had to get custom fittings to bring them up to spec Of course it’s going to be expensive. Getting out of ICE vehicles is going to have a sticker shock and it’s our own fault for waiting this long to get started
- ezekg 2y ago> However, "the Tesla presented challenges due to the small interior space, 'smart car' features, and low vehicle profile limiting maneuverability (e.g., jumping curbs, off-road use)." Should've picked the Cybertruck.
- Thrymr 2y agoThe F150 Lightning actually worked for the purpose, if you read the article.
- ezekg 2y agoI did read it. The purpose of the article seems to be a Tesla hit piece.
- add-sub-mul-div 2y agoIs there evidence for that, or is that just ingrained now as something we say when an article hurts our feelings?
- ezekg 2y agoNot really. I have no incentive to defend Tesla. I do not own one, and I do not want one. I own a Ford Expedition. I was merely saying that Cybertruck would have been a better choice (or even a larger Tesla!), and them plugging a Ford EV at the end seemed like a paid hit piece brought to you by Ford.
- scottyah 2y agoIrvine did, looks like it's working for them: https://ngtnews.com/tesla-cybertruck-ready-to-help-enforce-the-law-in-irvine-california https://ngtnews.com/tesla-cybertruck-ready-to-help-enforce-t...
- andrewla 2y agoI expected much more of a hit piece, but the findings of the police departments seem very well thought-out and explored. Police vehicles require extensive after-market work to meet the unique requirements of police forces, and there's not a long track history of how to do this with Teslas. The initial forays into this space are going to be pretty dicey and expensive until there is sufficient know-how to make the changes. Or Tesla itself could engage with this and work on a police model Tesla, but that is not likely to happen for a while. I do wonder if the choice to use the Model 3 sedan was the right one; it feels like one of the SUVs would be a better choice because many of the complaints revolve around having sufficient interior room.
- bwanab 2y ago>> I do wonder if the choice to use the Model 3 sedan was the right one I don't think you need to wonder. I have one and I love it, but if I were a cop, it wouldn't be my choice. I don't even think the Model Y would cut it. They should be using the Model X. OTOH, I see cops driving a lot of Dodge Chargers around here (New England). Having rented one at one point, I can tell you that they don't have a whole lot of back seat room either, so I'm not sure about that point that one of the chiefs made. But, yeah, I think it should be obvious to the most casual of observers that when you're trying to outfit a newish car that wasn't built for it to achieve a special purpose there's going to be growing pains. I couldn't find any solid quotes for police cars, but I seem to remember seeing that the average one was pushing $100,000 so the numbers they mentioned for the Teslas didn't sound that outrageous.
- bongodongobob 2y agoWell they make their own requirements so it's like me telling my job I need dual GPUs, 64GB RAM and 10TB to send my emails and make charts in Excel. Yeah, we do need a server/workhorse but not everyone needs one. Chromebook will due for most.
- diggan 2y ago> Furthermore, officers reported “autopilot interference,” which caused “a delay when officers shift into drive” and also triggered an automatic stop when officers tried to pull over to the side of the road, possibly because the car assumed the vehicle was wrongfully veering off course. It sounds like the police, just like Tesla and the Cybertruck, are testing these things out in the public?! Wouldn't these issues be discovered before these cars were actually deployed, like in a simulated road stop or something? Seems a bit bananas that they discovered these issues once officers use these cars in public.
- dspillett 2y ago> are testing these things out in the public?! Long gone are the days that they could afford to arrange proper pre-live-environment testing for anything like this. Even if much testing is done away from the live environment some testing period is still going to be needed before full roll-out (though this seems to be earlier stage testing than that).
- throwup238 2y agoAs far as I know South Pasadena is the only one that has converted their entire fleet to Teslas. It’s a small city in the middle of suburban LA with zero off roading and they borrow lots of resources from the Pasadena PD so the limitations probably aren’t that big a deal. There’s not a lot going on in the town so if someone is getting arrested half the officers on duty show up anyway. Other departments are running smaller trials or converting to more suitable cars like the F-150 Lightning mentioned in the article.
- xemdetia 2y agoEmergency vehicles are the kind of vehicles I don't really want electric yet. Power goes out when there are emergencies, and then what? They break out a bunch of beater crown vics? Also inevitably lithium packs are the last thing I want to bring more of to an emergency.. imagine bringing more lithium to a California wildfire when most fire depts struggle to extinguish packs in the most favourable conditions.
- vundercind 2y agoI read the requirements and concerns as yet another sign we need to split up traffic enforcement and ordinary policing. The cars writing traffic tickets and responding to breakdowns and minor accidents don’t need half this crap. We could get by with a ton fewer cops that way. (“What about car chases?” statistically they’re a terrible idea and we should stop doing them in almost all circumstances, so there’s little harm in losing the “tactical” capacity of your traffic enforcement cars)
- unsnap_biceps 2y agoI thought a majority of arrests are made during traffic stops, if you run and they can't chase, how do you expect arrests to happen? I'm not a fan of the current system, but I struggle to personally come up with a better one.
- vundercind 2y ago> I thought a majority of arrests are made during traffic stops Maybe, but what proportion of stops end in an arrest? A largish proportion of cop traffic enforcement & safety activity ends in a tow, but we don’t expect traffic enforcement cops to drive tow trucks. The traffic safety people can call out the regular cops if they need them. > if you run and they can't chase, how do you expect arrests to happen? Recording devices, reports, follow up. Chases are a public menace, especially when they do them over minor offenses, as is the case for the overwhelming majority of chases. Given the danger, I’d much rather anyone who’s not an active danger to life get away than a car chase occur. The evidence is pretty far on the side of “these are net-harmful”. Cops just like them a lot, so we keep doing them (many places do, anyway—some have all but eliminated them) Risk of added charges, potentially more serious than the original offense, means the majority of folks facing arrest won’t flee, anyway.
- falcolas 2y agoThere are three major sets of modification that I can think of which are done to a cruiser: - Light bars/electronics/sirens - Armoring - Ability to detain suspects The first is going to be required for every police or sheriff cruiser. The second will reduce casualties (arguably for both sides) in an armed engagement. Ideally required for any action which could create an armed engagement. Because a minimum of one side is always armed, every encounter can become an armed engagement. Huzzah USA etc. etc. The third is required if the police officer will ever respond to anything that isn't giving out a parking ticket. Traffic stops can include anything from an armed engagement down to a drunk driver or peaceful execution of an outstanding warrant. Then there's simple responding to calls, which can also include all of the above. The lack of ability to detain someone means you need (as stated in the article) more officers responding to an engagement.
- FerretFred 2y agoI can't help thinking that if/when the oil really starts to run out, the only vehicles that will be allowed to use it will be Emergency Services vehicles. I can't currently imagine (say) an electric fire truck, nor ambulance.
- falcolas 2y agoI can't currently imagine (say) an electric fire truck, nor ambulance. Why? The biggest problem I can think of is that they have a shorter range, but for a fire truck or ambulance the extra weight for longer range wouldn't really be an issue. The lower maintenance requirements might also mean ambulances won't be the shitshow that private ambulance companies make them right now. In the worst case scenario, I imagine there would be more priority for a vehicle which can provide power to on-scene electric vehicles, which is something frequently done for lighting up scenes even today. That said, I don't see these coming today or tomorrow. In a couple of years, though, we'll start seeing them more.
- r00fus 2y agoThose would absolutely be good options for EV conversion. What are you objections?
- danielodievich 2y agoAnother vehicle I've been paying some attention is the push to upgrade the US Post Office vehicles from the old boxy Grummans to the new duck nosed vehicle https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a62187981/usps-new-mail-truck-debut/ https://www.caranddriver.com/news/a62187981/usps-new-mail-tr.... I was really looking forward to those, but the other day I saw the mail lady driving one of the rebadged Mercede Metris minivans like that https://jalopnik.com/whats-the-real-reason-behind-the-post-office-removing-m-1845303888 https://jalopnik.com/whats-the-real-reason-behind-the-post-o.... We stopped to talk to the lady and oh boy did she give us a piece of mind! The pros were short - "softer seats and air conditioning are nice". The rest! Access to mail in back seat requires getting out of the car! If it rains there is no splash guard and you get wet. Being able to reach out of the window is difficult so one has to get out, again, getting wet and adding effort! The door is not a slider - it just opens out - so getting out while close to mailbox is harder. And so on. She stated that whoever chose THAT stopgap vehicle has never actually delivered mail. So it's good a police department tried these vehicles and was willing to talk about the results!
- r00fus 2y agoJust a note - the actual EVs are getting rave reviews and seem to be fully customized for postal delivery. https://www.reddit.com/r/electricvehicles/comments/1fflpg8/usps_longawaited_new_mail_truck_makes_its_debut/ https://www.reddit.com/r/electricvehicles/comments/1fflpg8/u...
- carlosdp 2y agoI feel like this is less a "Teslas don't work for police" as much as it's a "a small luxury mid-range sedan doesn't work for police". Like, of course it doesn't? Later in the article, it praises the F-150 Lightning (electric F-150 pickup truck) as a working solution for a police department, but seems to forget all the complaints about needing to charge and all that, which the F-150 Lightning also would have... Not the hardest hit piece, but it's definitely written in a way that sounds like "Tesla is shit, but Ford knows what they're doing so it's good", even though most of the complaints were more about electric cars than about Tesla specifically.
- xethos 2y agoFords history of working with the cops and saying "Here's what we have, what fits best as a base to modify, how can we meet your needs?" that is older than Tesla's founding The F-150 Lightning may not be dramatically better, but an OEM willing to work with you can make all the differnece in the world
- justin66 2y ago> "a small luxury mid-range sedan doesn't work for police". Like, of course it doesn't? "Mid-range sedan" is literally the description of pretty much everything every urban or suburban police department bought as a cruiser for many decades, until sports sedans (Dodge Charger) and mid-size SUVs became popular for the purpose.
- birdman3131 2y agoAt no point are they saying tesla's are bad. Just that they are not good for what police need them to do. I have no connection to police but I do own a 2015 ford Police Interceptor Utility (Essentially an explorer.) There are several features that are useful to police. Manual headlights. (Keep debating spending the ~$50-70 to upgrade to auto headlights.) The lights and horn do not trigger when you lock the car with the remote. Nor do lights come on when you open the door. (All of these are features to prevent drawing attention when you are idling on the side of the road.) Fairly tall sidewalls. I can go over a curb and not have any issue. The suspension is the best of any car / truck I have owned. It is rated for a 75MPH impact from the rear. (Fun fact. The full size spare tire is required to be in place to keep the rating. I have 4 switches on the steering wheel for accessories. (I assume stuff like lights and sirens.) There are some others like being able to disconnect the door locks from the back doors although mine were set to normal car when I got it.