5 ms·

The waitlist for Indians to get a green card (i.e. second-class citizenship) is 134 years currently. By the end of this decade, it will touch 200. No regular In

The waitlist for Indians to get a green card (i.e. second-class citizenship) is 134 years currently. By the end of this decade, it will touch 200. No regular Indian going on a work visa to the US currently has any significant scope of ever being recognized a citizen. Think of that what you will, but the list of incentives an Indian has to bother integrating into American society is rather short.

p_l 2y ago
Cognizant, Infosys, etc. are also quite well known to avoid putting their H1B (or equivalent) in position to consider staying or have opportunity to stay.
wslh 2y ago
Genuinely asking as someone not deeply familiar with the complexities of Indian culture: India now has the largest population in the world, is the biggest democracy, and has significant potential for growth (e.g. reducing poverty). At the same time, we see Indian leaders in top positions in major U.S. companies, like the CEOs of Google (1st gen) and Microsoft (2nd gen). How do these factors all connect? What drives this mix of internal challenges and global success? I’m not naive in thinking that a few successful individuals represent an entire population, but I do see a signal there.
- kamaal 2y ago
  1. India has a low gdp per capita. What that means is quality of life for masses is low. That also means slum/ghetto like neighbourhoods. Even if you have the money you mostly stay in a gated community, sandwiched between those areas. So you want to leave ASAP and stay in the west. 2. The Indians in top leadership positions you see in tech firms are rare exceptions. To some extent they also come from fairly well off families and communities in India, who have social capital. Can afford cram school fees for Ivy league exams, money and ability to take loans to study abroad etc. 3. Any body who once makes non-trivial money or sees non-trivial career success instantly realises, given how big India is. Given its politics, and overall spending on Education, R&D, and the rate of industrialisation. The only hope for a good life for their, or atleast at their children is to move to the west. Basically people want to leave India, as fixing India is largely a long term, and also a nearly impossible project.
  - Eumenes 2y ago
    The Indians migrating to the US via h1b visas are not coming from the slums or ghettoes. Higher education to foreigners in the US is essentially an immigration scheme - they pay $60-$100k (+living expenses) for a useless graduate degree which only the rich can afford, then get funneled into consulting firms like Cognizant/Infosys on OPT/EAD visas before picking up their h1b for ~ 6 years. This pretty much gets you in the US for ~ 10 years before getting a green card. > The Indians in top leadership positions you see in tech firms are rare exceptions This is absolutely not the case. Despite being 2% of the population, Indians are way overrepresented in tech leadership positions (not just CEO/CTO). I recall in a meeting at a med size tech firm I worked at, the recruiting/HR department no longer considered Asians of any ethnicity a minority and lumped them in with white males.
    - Rinzler89 2y ago
      >recruiting/HR department no longer considered Asians of any ethnicity a minority and lumped them in with white males. Why does HR even need to keep track of ethnicities? Is this a US thing? Here in my EU country you're just employee/applicant #3215, that's it, nobody asks or enters your ethnicity anywhere to even be able to keep tabs on how many are of what ethnicity, since everyone is considered equal by default and judged exclusively on performance (in theory at least, in practice there are still biases, but tracking ethnicities won't fix that, since that's human nature). What you're saying would even be against the law here since then it opens the door to bias and potential discrimination.
      - deleted 2y ago
        [deleted]
      - bee_rider 2y ago
        > (in theory at least, in practice there are still biases, but tracking ethnicities won't fix that, since that's human nature) That’s what we’re trying to fix (or at least mitigate) in the US. You say it is just human nature, but we’re a pretty diverse country, so we have a strong incentive to proactively try and see if we can make it work.
- rsanek 2y ago
  [flagged]
  - thunkshift1 2y ago
    No more than usa’s
    - wslh 2y ago
      Yes, I think the democracy issues are more general.
- kylehotchkiss 2y ago
  The "upward trajectory" we're all so familiar with is not (yet) as big a part of their culture yet. (I believe this is changing... the chronically online young generation seem to be absorbing a lot more of international culture than their ancestors). The regulatory environment for any business is an absolute nightmare of hostile patchwork policies different in every city and state. When foreign companies come in, the government babus want to yell Imperialism! at every turn, which leads to 51/49 ventures being the way to go, which are overly bureaucratic. It brings me hope to see shark tank getting popular there. Not to say the hosts or the contestants have been as honest as they should be, but it shows a big shift in mindset since India's 80s/90s economic policies
ErigmolCt 2y ago
The absurdly long waiting times
raincom 2y ago
Produce kids on American soil. These kids can sponsor parents once a kid reaches 18 years of age.
- bongoman42 2y ago
  Or marry someone born outside of India, which lots of people are doing.
- rudnevr 2y ago
  that's what they actually do, yes. It's been a joke first, not anymore
nitwit005 2y ago
You may be right, but that has basically nothing to do with sidelining and firing non-Indians.
- dartharva 2y ago
  Of course it does. If it is all but definite that you are not going to stay, why would you not just optimize everything for your short-term comfort or preference, sacrificing long-term benefit?
  - nitwit005 2y ago
    People openly racist, and also happy to break the law, probably aren't going to integrate well regardless of policy.

p_l 2y ago

Cognizant, Infosys, etc. are also quite well known to avoid putting their H1B (or equivalent) in position to consider staying or have opportunity to stay.

wslh 2y ago

Genuinely asking as someone not deeply familiar with the complexities of Indian culture: India now has the largest population in the world, is the biggest democracy, and has significant potential for growth (e.g. reducing poverty). At the same time, we see Indian leaders in top positions in major U.S. companies, like the CEOs of Google (1st gen) and Microsoft (2nd gen). How do these factors all connect? What drives this mix of internal challenges and global success? I’m not naive in thinking that a few successful individuals represent an entire population, but I do see a signal there.

kamaal 2y ago
1. India has a low gdp per capita. What that means is quality of life for masses is low. That also means slum/ghetto like neighbourhoods. Even if you have the money you mostly stay in a gated community, sandwiched between those areas. So you want to leave ASAP and stay in the west. 2. The Indians in top leadership positions you see in tech firms are rare exceptions. To some extent they also come from fairly well off families and communities in India, who have social capital. Can afford cram school fees for Ivy league exams, money and ability to take loans to study abroad etc. 3. Any body who once makes non-trivial money or sees non-trivial career success instantly realises, given how big India is. Given its politics, and overall spending on Education, R&D, and the rate of industrialisation. The only hope for a good life for their, or atleast at their children is to move to the west. Basically people want to leave India, as fixing India is largely a long term, and also a nearly impossible project.
- Eumenes 2y ago
  The Indians migrating to the US via h1b visas are not coming from the slums or ghettoes. Higher education to foreigners in the US is essentially an immigration scheme - they pay $60-$100k (+living expenses) for a useless graduate degree which only the rich can afford, then get funneled into consulting firms like Cognizant/Infosys on OPT/EAD visas before picking up their h1b for ~ 6 years. This pretty much gets you in the US for ~ 10 years before getting a green card. > The Indians in top leadership positions you see in tech firms are rare exceptions This is absolutely not the case. Despite being 2% of the population, Indians are way overrepresented in tech leadership positions (not just CEO/CTO). I recall in a meeting at a med size tech firm I worked at, the recruiting/HR department no longer considered Asians of any ethnicity a minority and lumped them in with white males.
  - Rinzler89 2y ago
    >recruiting/HR department no longer considered Asians of any ethnicity a minority and lumped them in with white males. Why does HR even need to keep track of ethnicities? Is this a US thing? Here in my EU country you're just employee/applicant #3215, that's it, nobody asks or enters your ethnicity anywhere to even be able to keep tabs on how many are of what ethnicity, since everyone is considered equal by default and judged exclusively on performance (in theory at least, in practice there are still biases, but tracking ethnicities won't fix that, since that's human nature). What you're saying would even be against the law here since then it opens the door to bias and potential discrimination.
    - deleted 2y ago
      [deleted]
    - bee_rider 2y ago
      > (in theory at least, in practice there are still biases, but tracking ethnicities won't fix that, since that's human nature) That’s what we’re trying to fix (or at least mitigate) in the US. You say it is just human nature, but we’re a pretty diverse country, so we have a strong incentive to proactively try and see if we can make it work.
rsanek 2y ago
[flagged]
- thunkshift1 2y ago
  No more than usa’s
  - wslh 2y ago
    Yes, I think the democracy issues are more general.
kylehotchkiss 2y ago
The "upward trajectory" we're all so familiar with is not (yet) as big a part of their culture yet. (I believe this is changing... the chronically online young generation seem to be absorbing a lot more of international culture than their ancestors). The regulatory environment for any business is an absolute nightmare of hostile patchwork policies different in every city and state. When foreign companies come in, the government babus want to yell Imperialism! at every turn, which leads to 51/49 ventures being the way to go, which are overly bureaucratic. It brings me hope to see shark tank getting popular there. Not to say the hosts or the contestants have been as honest as they should be, but it shows a big shift in mindset since India's 80s/90s economic policies

ErigmolCt 2y ago

The absurdly long waiting times

raincom 2y ago

Produce kids on American soil. These kids can sponsor parents once a kid reaches 18 years of age.

bongoman42 2y ago
Or marry someone born outside of India, which lots of people are doing.
rudnevr 2y ago
that's what they actually do, yes. It's been a joke first, not anymore

nitwit005 2y ago

You may be right, but that has basically nothing to do with sidelining and firing non-Indians.

dartharva 2y ago
Of course it does. If it is all but definite that you are not going to stay, why would you not just optimize everything for your short-term comfort or preference, sacrificing long-term benefit?
- nitwit005 2y ago
  People openly racist, and also happy to break the law, probably aren't going to integrate well regardless of policy.