3 ms·
Google Will Track Your Location 'Every 15 Minutes'–'Even with GPS Disabled'
- Circlecrypto2 2y agoWhere is the investment into a real smart phone that protects your privacy. I'd pay a premium for this, especially if the manufacturing and resources used fair labor.
- robcohen 2y agoI'm very confident this just isn't possible. If you want something with 4G/5G, you just cannot get open hardware. Without open hardware this is a moot point. There are a number of projects where you can use RISC-V hardware with 2G and even 3G open source hardware, but calling them equivalent in any way to an Android or iPhone is a... stretch. I think the issue is the patents with the hardware needs to run out, but by then 6G or 7G will be out and you'll have the same problem. Anything with DMA that isn't closed source cannot be trusted. I'll die on that hill. Even with projects like PinePhone, the best they can do is a privacy switch that turns off the modem. It's just not good enough to take it seriously.
- JPLeRouzic 2y agoI don't think it's a question of open hardware: To send a phone call to your phone, the mobile network must know the BTS/eNodeB/GnodeB associated with your phone. While this is a large surface in rural areas and older technologies, it's not the same in urban/newer technologies. It could easily be associated with a given building. To protect our location, it would need something akin to a mobile proxy that would relay the communication but to my knowledge, there are no such things for mobile communications. And this is not really secure, it's just outsourcing security to another entity which may be be compromised. (I am quite rusty, but I was a telecom engineer)
- TheGlav 2y agoApple is the closest you get today. You can even pay a premium for it!
- BiteCode_dev 2y agoGiven apple was part of PRISM and, you only pay premium for the pr.
- aucisson_masque 2y agoI'm apple hater but you got to recognize they do better at privacy than Google. If you care about the NSA, then you better not have any phone. Whatever it's a android, iphone, grapheneos, anything. Israel blowing up pagers is a proof that nothing is impossible to them. But if you want to say fuck off to the big data harvester like Google, Microsoft, Facebook, and so on.. then apple isn't bad at all. You just got to deal with the usual apple bullshit, no side loading, repairability, thunderbolt charger, no headphone jack, etc.
- akimbostrawman 2y ago>do better at privacy than Google so instead of an actual improvement just settle for second least worst? ironically google pixels are 100 times more private than any apple device will ever be because you can securely run your own 100% controlled open source OS such as grapheneos.org which is an actual private as in feature not marketing OS.
- JPLeRouzic 2y agoA phone has several levels of software and hardware, the OS that the user knows is not in charge of communications, its main role is to interface the user to the computer inside the phone. The phone OS sees the phone communication hardware akin to the way it sees an Ethernet card. The phone communication hardware (named baseband modem) is also under control of the SIM and every time the mobile operator wants to change the behavior of the baseband modem it can through the Sim toolkit.
- OutOfHere 2y agoA degoogled phone with off-switches for wifi and GPS go a long way.
- pintxo 2y agoHow big is the market for that? I’d probably get one as well, but who else would?
- barbazoo 2y ago> Where is the investment into a real smart phone that protects your privacy. I'm just guessing it just doesn't make financial sense to develop one.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- prophesi 2y agoI imagine this isn't the case if you're running GrapheneOS on it? I think it would be safe to assume that the factory defaults on any Android would be phoning home whether it's Google, Samsung, or what have you.
- fmajid 2y agoThe Pixels' only redeeming quality is that they run GrapheneOS. Why you would run anything else on them eludes me.
- xd1936 2y agoDisingenuous article. The headline should be "Google Location Tracking is on by default in a brand new Google account and I don't like that". https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/3118687 https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/3118687
- crazygringo 2y agoYup, the article admits: > "Because the testing took place with a new, default account, the team did not test to see the effect that user changes to privacy and security settings might have." And bizarrely the article claims: > "You can’t say no to Google’s surveillance..." Well sure, you can't say no if you refuse to even look at the privacy and security settings. The "Even With GPS Disabled" part of the headline is particularly misleading, since location data often (even mostly?) comes from WiFi too. The idea that turning off GPS would disable location data isn't how location data works.
- nielsbot 2y agoThe real question would be: what tracking happens when you opt out of location sharing? Side note: I’ve opted out of giving Google my location on the web but when I search they still use my “approximate location” based on my IP and past searches. Trackers gonna track I guess.
- crazygringo 2y ago> Trackers gonna track I guess. I mean, it's a search engine. If you type in the name of a restaurant, you want to get the one in your area, not the one halfway around the globe. If you type the name of a store, you want to get their website for your country, not another continent. You don't want Google to know your location down to a resolution of meters, that makes sense. But it makes a lot of sense for a search engine to try to figure out your city and country from your IP address, at least.
- BobaFloutist 2y ago
- asimpleusecase 2y agoSo will the EU fine them for violation of GDPR?
- kklisura 2y agoI reckon they don't track you if you're in the EU.
- raxxorraxor 2y agoThey do if you have the wrong settings. The location of my SSID is know publicly and I guess it was shitty Android or Apple devices phoning home. Guess I need to switch wifi name and mac to something more common... But you have no defense against that if casual users regularly visit your location or just come near it.
- dotnet00 2y agoIs the location they're referring to supposed to be just the country code field in that screenshot?
- readthenotes1 2y agoGps coordinates
- dotnet00 2y agoThat's what they're claiming, but unless I'm blind, none of the fields in their screenshot are the GPS coordinates.
- techcode 2y agoSimply being connected to mobile (or wifi) network is enough to get your location - sometimes with pretty good precision. So if you're worried about NSA or the like - you better not have a mobile phone/device (or a car - because new cars sold in EU all have eSIM for builtin emergency calls) at all. And for particular first hand example - Xplora smart watch/phone got super confused when my kids school physically moved. New building has indoor sports/gym (I think it's basketball court size) on the top floor - and all the reinforced concrete means mobile reception can be hit and miss (even on 3/4G). Despite phone/watch never connecting to school (staff only) wifi. After move to new building - watch and parent app would regularly think/bounce location between old and new school buildings. When even 3rd party companies have a mapping between wifi/ssid and approximate geo location, you can imagine state sponsored actors have at least next order of magnitude.
- lxgr 2y agoProbably the school moved all of their Wi-Fi access points with it? These are often used for indoor positioning, even without any device connecting to them.
- crtasm 2y agoThere's public databases of SSID geolocation, e.g. https://wigle.net/ https://wigle.net/
- storyinmemo 2y agoIf your wifi client device can't find an access point, it goes around emitting every saved wifi network you've got. You can learn an awful lot from that.
- kioleanu 2y agoWe had the same experience with the Xplora watches: we moved 6km away and took the internet contract with us. Whenever the watch was inside the house, it would show it as being at the old address. Outside of he house and away from wifi, it showed the location correctly. I imagine this is an edge case
- vibrant_mclean 2y agoTrying to be private ironically just going to make it worse and make you stand out. Using a non-default OS, non-default browser, custom settings/blocklists will just make your fingerprint more unique. I use an android phone but just don't use any other google services - no search, no gmail, no default apps. I do most browsing in tor-browser, so google ads won't correlate with me.
- readthenotes1 2y agoI installed duck duck goes application tracking protection utility and was mind boggled at how many apps were tracking my location, battery level, etc on a regular and ongoing basis without notification because it is all through 3rd party ad networks. Even more concerning where the apps, like AT&t's and Fidelity, that do it just to make the money by reselling the data, not to show ads.