7 ms·
Please Don't Make Me Download Another App
- rcarmo 2y agoI’m more concerned about needing apps to configure appliances. Or your Wi-Fi router. Or even a KVM (https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2024/09/29/1900 https://taoofmac.com/space/blog/2024/09/29/1900). How many of those apps are going to be maintained for, say, five years?
- cmacleod4 2y agoCut the App Crap! If it can't be done on the web it's probably not worth doing.
- 28304283409234 2y agoStand down everyone. Stand down. There's no gun to the authors head. Nobody "makes" them do anything. They install apps out of their own volition. As you were.
- consteval 2y agoMany services do "make" you use an app if you want to get something done. For example, I parked in some part of Dallas the other day. I HAD to download an app to pay, there was no other way to pay.
- 28304283409234 2y agoThen do not use their service and move over to another one. The vast majority of service are (still) replaceable.
- pooingcode 2y agoIf Apple would play nice with PWAs we could effectively use that for 90% of apps. …But then that would mean they can’t take a chunk of companies’ profits so not likely to happen anytime soon
- barrysaunders 2y agoDear Mr President, there are too many apps nowadays. Please eliminate three. I am not a crackpot.
- paulmooreparks 2y agohttps://archive.ph/ggHxr https://archive.ph/ggHxr
- sys_64738 2y agoMy rule is never to download apps to my iPhone.
- aaronbrethorst 2y agoDon’t forget, you can read this article in the Atlantic’s official iOS app: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/the-atlantic-magazine/id397599894 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/the-atlantic-magazine/id397599...
- ProxCoques 2y agoNot downloaded that app, but does it deliver exactly the same features as the web app but just look a bit different? If so, I wonder whether anyone working in the respective web and app departments sometimes wonders why their company maintains two separate apps that do the same thing. I know I did. Edit: Oh, offline mode. Towering profits?
- october8140 2y agoYou can criticize something and be a part of it.
- aaronbrethorst 2y agoI built an iOS app that was on the App Store’s top ten paid apps list for a hot minute in 2008, and much of my career over the past 16 years has been focused on iOS app development.
- gruez 2y agoWould you rather have a publication that gags its journalists from criticizing its business practices?
- praisewhitey 2y agoBut you don't have to.
- Andrex 2y agoThere are a couple benign exceptions, but I've generally accepted the policy of only having first-party apps on my phone and using the browser to access anything else (even triggering desktop mode if I have to).
- matrix_overload 2y agoWell, the elephant in the room is that an app these days is a packaged version of a website with one twist: notifications. Unless you explicitly disable it via settings, it will try to get a small chunk of your attention every now and then. - Would you like to enable notifications to see when your EV finishes charging? - Yes. (in a couple of days when you're thinking about a completely different topic) - SPECIAL OFFER! 20% OFF THE FATTY FRIES IF YOU GET A CAR WASH FROM US!!! And that's everywhere. It pays off due to the scale, just like spam. It costs nothing to send an annoying notification to a horde of users, and even if 1% of the users go for it, it is still 5+ figures of revenue out of a handful of characters pushed to users' devices, and hours of human time wasted dealing with useless annoying distractions.
- ProxCoques 2y agoThe weird thing is that companies will pay for entirely separate engineering, product and marketing departments for their apps which duplicate their web apps in every way (or usually a bit less), not to mention being under the thumb of the app stores - all for the sake of notifications. I'm no bean-counter, but that seems very odd to me.
- aembleton 2y agoI wish Android would let me filter notifications and add rules to them. I know that you can switch off certain types of notifications, but thats only if the developer has added those in. For example Revolut uses one notification type and sends payment notifications and marketing through that same channel. So, I just don't use Revolut but it would be good if Android could let me set up keywords to block notifications.
- dqv 2y agoYou can do this sort of filtering with third party apps, which is why I'm probably going to be switching to Android pretty soon.
- smcleod 2y agoI don't understand why you'd have notifications enabled for any app that you don't need them from?
- dclowd9901 2y agoAll of this is… whatever. I think we make compromises. What kills me is I cannot… CANNOT view Instagram content on my phone without the app. I tried to actually send a link to my Instagram page to someone today and I literally could not obtain a link to my page anywhere in the web app. It simply would not allow me to do that. I could be missing something but every time I was in a logged in state on the web it was railroading me into the app. I almost deleted my account for that. I might still.
- LopovJack 2y agoOf course you can. I'm doing it for years now.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoThere is a way to get a link, my wife sends me Instagram links all the time. Unfortunately I don't know how to do it because I don't use Instagram.
- left-struck 2y agoIt’s not whatever it’s bullshit pushed onto those who have the least power to change things, driven by greed for money, attention and data.
- al_borland 2y agoYou probably need to hit a share button and then there is usually an option for a link. If not, choosing message or email will throw a link in there. I haven’t used the Instagram app in years, but that’s usually how it goes. If you don’t have the app installed, and aren’t logged in, there is about a 60/40 chance that the person on the other end will be able to see what is sent. And if it’s a video, they’ll miss the first bit of audio, because it defaults to muted, and it doesn’t let the user replay the video. They employs a lot of aggressive dark patterns to get people to create accounts, login, and use the app.
- wkirby 2y agoSo don’t. I can’t fathom what you’d need an IKEA app for. If you need an app for something brief but specific, delete it after you’re done. On the other hand, apps frequently work better with less clutter than the mobile website. It’s wild how many websites clearly aren’t tested on real mobile devices — usually just by shrinking a browser window and saying “looks good on mobile” then moving on.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoAnd just as maddening is that it goes both ways. So many websites (including technical blogs made by people who post here and should know better!!!) are the width of a damn phone screen, even if you view it on desktop. Lazy website development abounds, sadly.
- al_borland 2y agoThose websites would probably be better of the resources, time, and budget from the app were spent on the website.
- shpx 2y ago> If you need an app for something brief but specific, delete it after you’re done Amusingly, you've just described a web browser.
- somat 2y agoToo true, I was looking at solar charge controllers and after rejecting yet another otherwise nice looking one boldly advertising it's bluetooth communications my thoughts were viscerally negative. "I don't want bluetooth and an app, I want rs485 and a specification"
- zzo38computer 2y agoI agree, I also don't want bluetooth (nor other wireless communication) and an app, I want RS-485 and a specification (that is hopefully not too complicated).
- m463 2y agoThat is just about everything. No matter how compelling some product is, if I see something it is app-controlled, I just move on. Silly things. A heated coffee mug (app-controlled). An air purifier (app-controlled). A home generator (app-controlled). sigh. At costco the other day, there were gift cards for two movie chains ($50 for $39). One was just "take this card to the register", the other one was an app/website and more mess (and a hard pass)
- ascagnel_ 2y agoIf it requires a smartphone app, no thank you. But if it’s “smarts” are really just Matter/Thread the app is an optional front-end, I’m more willing to take the leap.
- eesmith 2y agoI see new apartment buildings with advertisements about app-controlled HVAC, and as a gift, an app-controlled coffee maker, and I think "nope, not for me."
- the_third_wave 2y ago> "I don't want bluetooth and an app," Me neither > "I want rs485 and a specification” I want ethernet and a well-documented API. Put the thing in its own network segment which does not connect to the outside world and you get to have an the advantages of a network-connected device without any of the disadvantages. No automatic updates taking away functionality, no chance for bad actors to hijack your devices but still all the possibilities offered by having direct network access.
- brikym 2y agoLoyalty cards and apps are awful. They're just a way for companies collect our data and 'segment' pricing aka discrimination which muddies those 'pricing signal' things hardcore capitalists like to mention when they talk about free market efficiency. To get the normal price now you have no choice but to hand over your data and dignity. These mechanisms should be banned.
- seehafer 2y agoYet again we see that Steve Jobs’ user interface instincts were right: he hated the idea of apps and fought putting them on the iPhone.
- harry8 2y agoCounter view: Steve Jobs instincts were about owning everything. Any app should (must) be bought from apple, as a subscription, while holding your data hostage, at their price.
- al_borland 2y agoThat’s not how the iPhone worked. All the apps were pre-installed when the phone was purchased. There were no additional downloads or subscription (other than phone service).
- harry8 2y agoYou're not seriously suggesting the multiple apple subscription services were brought in because 3rd party apps became a thing? The original iphone had zero market share on release. First one is free. Just like Appletv, applemusic, icloud storage, apple games subs.... If you think apple's approach has ever been anything else but abusing market power to maximise revenue I've got a bridge for you with microsoft written on the side. (MS are all like "We'd have been crucified for that, well not anymore!" And the race to the bottom of your wallet continues apace.)
- al_borland 2y agoYou said it was Steve Jobs’ instincts. He’s been out of the picture for 13 years, before most, if not all the subscriptions you mentioned. Those were Tim Cook looking to make up for the iPhone reaching market saturation. I was pointing out that Jobs’ instinct on the iPhone was web apps, because that’s what it launched with. The App Store was a response to customer demand and people hacking stuff onto it anyway. And of course, they looked to make money on it, as they are a business and it requires money to build and maintain the platform. As far as their approach only ever being abuse of market dominance, that simply doesn’t make sense. In the late 90s and early 2000s they didn’t have much of a market to speak of. There was no market to abuse. Apple has been around for decades with pretty famous ups and downs.
- whs 2y agoI wish I could use internet banking to replace bank apps. The banks are slowly shutting down their internet banking or requiring their app to perform face recognition. This is probably because online gambling and scammers were running automation on the website to move money quickly. The scammers moved on to cracking the mobile apps and instead of adding verifications the banks just start cracking down on debugging techniques like blocking VPN and debugging (or sometimes having Developer Option is enough to trip the block).
- tippytippytango 2y agoThe apps also don’t let you turn stuff off like the web does. I can disable shorts in most apps that have them. The app is a massive downgrade in functionality for me.
- novok 2y agoMost of this is the fault of apple and google. We could have native style apps that load in and out like webpages, and have them load in as parts that come in and out too! If we were using objective C, they might even be smaller to load than an equivalent web page. But we don't due to the app model being profitable as a choke point for the os makers. Web GUIs are worse on mobile than the equivalent app, and there are many things that just gated off that you don't get in the web guis, and thus everything stays as an app, while many apps would work fine as this kind of dynamically loaded native app without any 'store' you would need to go to, just a url you load. The android activity model especially lends itself to acting this way too. But app clips and google play features you may say. They are too restrictive and clunky, and google play features still need a base app to work.
- al_borland 2y agoTo be fair, it was the users and developers who asked for this when the original iPhone launched. Apple’s plan was to have web apps be the way forward for accessing anything outside of the pre-installed apps.
- HKH2 2y agoApp designers try too hard to be simple (or whatever it is they're trying to do), and the widgets are often useless or not the ones you want. I don't trust app developers to choose sane options, because they're trying to make an 'experience' or something. My homescreen has more links to webpages than apps, because they can give me info faster than apps/widgets. I don't have to see the news/ads/videos or 'what's new' modal windows like I usually have to with popular apps. (That said, open source apps tend to be far more sensible. F-Droid has got a lot of hidden gems.)
- laserbeam 2y agoI "love" that almost everything I want to see in a browser (content, shops) wants me to install an app, and almost everything I want to have as an app (tools, editors, email... MS Office is the biggest offender here in my books) wants me to be in a browser or is just a bloated packaged website with subpar UX.
- dzhiurgis 2y agoAll the llm providers are rushing to create desktop apps while File > Add to Dock is superior - you can change font size, pinch to zoom, cmd+f to search, your extensions work, you can open multiple windows... Both implementations somehow manage to suck up 100% of cpu when rendering fucking text tho.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoIt's wild to me that such a safe, pro-user-agency, extensible system is hated by so many for delivering rich experiences. I get that there are plenty of bad webapps too, that performance can be bad. And there's not enough highly visible open source efforts on local first & off-main-thread javascript to form the backbone of knowledge to inform mainstream webdev how to stay fast, responsive, adaptable, yet (I thought we would be so much further along at using these amazing capabilities by now!). But wow, it's still so wild to me that apps are so beloved by some. PWAs are also wild to me because they are "just" the web but without half the web's superpowers. No extensions, address bar, history, bookmarks, tabs (unless built specifically for it; wildly weird.
- Larrikin 2y agoIt's so boring to read comments on here about how everything could be a text displaying webpage. Internet everywhere in your pocket is a waste for toilet reading. But it's also frustrating how the ecosystem of Google and Apple, has stifled creativity in the space. We went to the moon with less computing power than a crappy PC in the 90s. People copying Google's model of basic functionally but with ads and Apple's overly protective but nearly useless permission model has ruined a technology that should be more revolutionary than it is. Some of it needs to be solved legislatively. I absolutely should be able to have my entire contacts list read by a random game app, and the only consequence be that I found all my friends who also play the game, with steep penalties for collecting and selling that data. But I should also be able to vet and use my mobile computer to put anything on it I want.
- al_borland 2y agoWhat is the vision you’re seeing that would be revolutionary from what we have today, with similar hardware?
- doctor_radium 2y agoIs this possibly the first pushback against "app culture" ever?? Then it's a long time coming. "App" has been my most hated word in the English language for at least 5 or 6 years. Myself, I never fell into the trap of using them, living in a rural enough area that the lifestyle doesn't require it. And if a company or service does require it, i.e. doesn't offer a web-based equivalent, I move on. Would love to see some deep dive reporting on what happens to the data after it's collected and how much money I'm actually worth to companies if I succumbed.
- LinuxBender 2y agoYou are not alone. I am also in a rural area and have never found a compelling need for an app. I use the phone for making calls and texting. If the phone required even one more millisecond of my time it would go in the hydraulic press. If anything I've gone the other direction. If I can't go into a building and talk face to face with real people then I am not interested in doing business. The exception at the moment is Amazon as local stores do not carry things I need but I have stocked up so I can nix that requirement soon. Even in that case I browse Amazon from a Linux desktop, not the phone. I have never browsed a site from my phone.
- elphinstone 2y agoThe nadir for me was a barbershop that required me to download an app to get a haircut. I told them they lost me as a customer and left.
- left-struck 2y agoOh man, the idea that they might only drop that after the haircut is done makes me cringe. What’s worked for me when businesses are insistent is saying something like “I only have my work phone and the security policy doesn’t allow me to install apps without contacting IT” That’s not true of course but if you’re going to play dirty so can I
- nickm12 2y agoRecently had to download an app to pay for parking at a public transit center. It made me really grumpy—fortunately I arrived early enough that I could figure that all out, but if the app download rigamarole caused me to miss my train. Not an app, but I also had to use my phone to check my luggage curbside at the airport. This was frustrating because I had to use a small screen to enter the details that were on my phone.
- matricaria 2y agoWasn’t this supposed to be solve by App Clips? [0] I used this only once or twice, and the idea kinda seems abandoned. [0]: https://developer.apple.com/app-clips/ https://developer.apple.com/app-clips/