6 ms·
A single cloud compromise can feed an army of AI sex bots
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- missy13 2y ago[dead]
- bloopernova 2y agoThere seems to be continued demand for CSAM-related LLM chats. Apart from being a very depressing reflection of humanity, I wonder if we're simply seeing humanity as it is, or if the availability of CSAM pulls people into such crimes?
- pjc50 2y agoCSAM is probably the least available category of material on the Internet. Almost all but the most "free speech" diehard services consider it a bannable offence. It's very illegal in almost every jurisdiction and hugely unpopular with the public. The demand for it lurks nonetheless. CSAM is extremely illegal because making it is a crime against a child. Textual material describing fictional child abuse isn't quite in the same category. Deepfake material that purports to be of a specific real child may or may not be illegal depending on jurisdiction but really ought to be.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoWhy should it “really ought to be” if it is fictional? Isn’t it like the text material?
- otabdeveloper4 2y agoBecause the whole point of laws 'n shiet existing at all is to legislate morality.
- throwway120385 2y agoBecause making it legal creates a situation where someone makes real CSAM and then argues that it is an AI fake in court. And it's really not a pretty thing to require the affected children to testify as to what happened to them. It's also a gateway, stoking interest in the real thing.
- BobbyJo 2y agoNeither of these two arguments hold any water. I see them all the time, but they really just feel like justification after the fact, as both can be applied to such a large swath of information as to be useless. The first would require we outlaw generating depictions of any illegal activity. The second would require we ban undesirable men from legal adult content. I think it's ok if society, and our legislature, classifies the information as illegal, in isolation, with no useless A->B gymnastics. Thats pretty much what the law already does.
- ensignavenger 2y agoThe first would only require banning fictional depictions of heinous crimes against children (When the children look like real ones), as it is intended to protect children from having to testify to what happened to them. One could argue that adults shouldn't have to testify to being the victim of various terrible crimes either, but that is a different argument than what was being made.
- throwway120385 2y agoAdults are not children. We often afford special protections to children that we wouldn't afford to adults, because they aren't fully developed humans. Nowhere did I talk about adults or say adults shouldn't be required to testify to provide evidence. But I think children need to be allowed to be children. You can look at the law in some US states around crimes against children, and a lot of them do permit either CCTV or recorded testimony with the assistance of a child psychologist or similar. The law already treats children as different. It sound like you're arguing that they should be treated like adults in this specific instance? Slippery Slope is a fallacy if the person you're arguing with has no intention of going further than exactly what they've said.
- BobbyJo 2y agoCSAM is unique in that society, almost uniformly, classifies it as wrong, even when there is no relationship to any material harm. I think parent's argumentative basis is simply that the information itself is evil at face value, an the vast majority of people (in the U.S. at least) would agree.
- randomdata 2y agoThey would agree, or they would be afraid to disagree?
- BizarroLand 2y agoThere is some part of me that can rationalize that an AI is not a child and therefore there is no child abuse happening in the interaction, but that tiny part of my brain is shouted down immediately by the rest of my brain screaming, "PEOPLE ARE HORRIBLE. YOU CANNOT GIVE THEM THE OPPORTUNITY TO FANTASIZE ABOUT CSA IN A COMMUNITY AS PEOPLE WILL INEXORABLY ESCALATE INTO REAL LIFE CSA!" Even if there are people who can indulge in imaginary CSAM without ever bringing it into real life, those are not the people you can set the bar against. You have to set it against the average person and deduce from there what percentage of them when given free access to this material would be tempted into committing crimes. If that number goes up, your rule is too loose. Giving everyone unlimited access to this without judgement will almost certainly increase child sex crimes. Therefore it must be restricted.
- qball 2y ago>but that tiny part of my brain is shouted down immediately by the rest of my brain screaming Your gut feeling is simply wrong. General pornography availability and sexual assault are negatively correlated; you'll notice the former increased dramatically and the latter decreased dramatically over the past 20 years in Western societies where that is true. Despite what you might be led to believe crime rates were not increasing (well, before 2020 anyway).
- welshwelsh 2y agoWow. Honestly, no part of my brain is screaming about possible escalation, it's something I'm not worried about in the slightest. Why would someone risk their freedom and harm another person IRL by committing a serious crime, when they could get the same stimulation from a computer program? But let's say we do live in a world where fictional crimes often escalate to real ones. Suppose that playing DOOM increases the chance that an unstable person will buy a gun and shoot real people. Even in that universe, I would not be OK with laws that restrict me from playing DOOM, because that violates my freedom. I do not want the law to treat everyone as a potential criminal.
- iphoneisbetter 2y ago[dead]
- BobaFloutist 2y agoI'm far from an expert but last I checked the consensus was that attraction to minors is a disordered behavior, and if you feed it with (even fictional) visual depictions it increases the paraphilia. It might seem like a harmless outlet, but it doesn't actually function that way, and so it's better for everyone if it's just made illegal.
- qingcharles 2y agoTextual CSAM can be very illegal too: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/texas-man-sentenced-40-years-prison-running-child-obscenity-website https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/texas-man-sentenced-40-years-...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- wkat4242 2y agoI think the CSAM is mainly used for effect here, to make it sound more sensational. Of course it's one of the things uncensored models can be used for but it's calling out the extreme. Uncensored models are also required for normal adult erotic fiction and even to discuss many sexual topics, because the public models are so hypersensitive on this topic. They're mirroring American sensibilities which can be annoying here in Europe where we a are a lot more open about consensual adult sexuality.
- anon11100 2y agoA sensational truth. The sexy AI chatbot sites with community bots public are full of horrible stuff. A dispassionate AI will happily engage in genocide, or suicide, or snuff, etc.
- wkat4242 2y agoYeah I'm sure they can and are used for that sometimes but I doubt this is what most people are using them for. The problem is that AI bots are so heavily censored, and uncensoring them means removing all protections. By seeking the slighter things past the barrier, you will open it up to all kinds of things. But in my opinion the models are currently really too censored to be useful right now. For example, I partake in BDSM and sex-positive parties. All very consensual and adults-only stuff (you'd be surprised how big a thing consent is in BDSM) and all very legal and above board. I'm in a lot of chatgroups about these things but don't have time to monitor them, so I use a LLM to summarise them (a local one for privacy reasons, not just my own but the other group participants' as well obviously). But if I try to use a normal uncensored model like llama for it, it will immediately close up and complain about 'explicit' content. This is just BS. There should be models which are more open like this. I use an uncensored version of llama now which works great. And it's never recommending genocide, homicide or suicide. Because I'm not interested in those things and don't ask for it. I'm sure it can tell me but I don't want to know. Most of the people who need uncensored models will have these kind of usecases. Calling out the one extreme idiot is just sensationalism. It should really be possible to customise models' censorship rather than going for the strictest common denominator. If there are just a few public models that can create some normal adult smut incorporating all sexual practices that are legal, 99% of those current customers of these hacked-cloud-hosted chatbots will be very happy with that. And the mainstream AI industry will make more money. The problem is that they don't want to be associated with it which is aligned with American morale but not European. Sex is a normal part of life here (and the SexTech industry is growing rapidly).
- 123yawaworht456 2y agoAI hallucinations are not CSAM. the attempt to stoke a moral panic in this article (and the forbes article from january it's referencing) is baffling. you can go to any booru or hentai site and see far more graphic things than boring LLM slop, and it's all on clearnet, because terrible things are not illegal as long as they are imaginary (in all but the most ass-backwards jurisdictions). it reads like boomer bullshit about violent video games from 20+ years ago. "A Single Unattended Computer Can Feed a Crowd of Violent Teenagers. We left a computer unattended, and guess what? They were playing Doom on it! Just like Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold!"
- stonethrowaway 2y agoExcellent title Brian!
- rsynnott 2y agoThat's a hell of a headline. And yet really kinda buries the lede; this is much more disturbing than I was expecting.
- marcus12 2y ago[flagged]
- jchw 2y agoThere's a pretty big focus on LLM chatbots for taboo fetishes... I'm sure it's because it's disturbing but, am I the only one who sees that particular facet as an utter nothing-burger? Of all of the AI safety concerns, I think this is one of the least compelling. If an LLM veered into this kind of topic out of nowhere it could be very disturbing for the user, but in this case it's exactly what they are searching for. I'm pretty sure for any given disturbing topic you can find hundreds of fully-written fictional stories on places like AO3 anyways. I mean, if you want to, you can also engage in these fantasies with other people in erotic role-play, and taboo fetishes are not exactly new. Even if it is illicit in some jurisdictions (No clue, not a lawyer) it is ultimately victimless and unenforceable, so I doubt that dissuades most people. Sure it's rather disturbing, but personally I find lots of things that are very legal and not particularly taboo to be disturbing, and I still don't see a problem if people want to indulge in it, as long as I'm not forced to be involved.
- tcdent 2y agoReally hard to quantify the demand out there, since, thankfully, most of these people keep it out of my feed. But I have a feeling it's significantly more popular than we expect.
- orbital-decay 2y agoJust a reminder that AI safety is all of the following, and many other things: - Rogue AI scenario, which increasingly looks like a figment of collective imagination of certain extremely smart people who discovered religions in their tech tree - Instructions on how to make nuclear weapons (are they scraping classified materials now?..) - Geopolitical games (don't let the adversary have what we have, "for the benefit of all humanity" is a red herring). - Spam/manipulation/botting/astroturfing (legit one, not nearly enough attention paid compared to others). - Erotic roleplay (prudish/thought policing), disturbing erotic roleplay (arguably a nothingburger, division is understandable). Turns out if you shove all that into one huge category of AI safety, the term becomes overloaded and meaningless.
- gs17 2y ago> Instructions on how to make nuclear weapons (are they scraping classified materials now?..) Presumably, a "smart enough" AI could work it the physics out the same way humans did to write those classified materials. It's still not a realistic threat unless we're banning physics textbooks as well, AFAIK the barrier more is the materials and equipment required than the principles.
- ntshtpstr 2y ago[dead]
- jabroni_salad 2y agoChub seems to be implicated by the article but it seems to just be a repository of json files you can download, and the access they sell is for models that they appear to be hosting themselves. Their best one is only 70B? And 8k context is significantly less than what the big APIs would give you. But I guess 'people will steal your api keys off of github if you publish them in public' is not a very exciting article.
- dprk 2y ago[flagged]
- qualidea19871 2y ago[flagged]
- posting_mess 2y agoTangent, but related vaguely; If you can "picture a brown cow" in your mind can you picture "the unholy" in your mind? It seems logical that there is no universal constraint preventing anyone capable of picturing a brown cow from picturing the unholy, they just choose not to (or in some cases choose to). I guess as shown, restricting ML/LLM/AI pathways after the fact has a negative effect on intelligence. So I ask could you be word played into supporting the unholy by a good "sales person"? If you can are you intelligent a toll? What if you needed to for Science or safe guarding? "Is context enough and whats the context of the context" I guess im asking. The content depicted in the article is of course abhorrent. But how do you go about negating it when any intelligent being is likely capable of generating it internally?
- k__ 2y ago1. Many people aren't able to generating visuals in their mind. 2. We can't yet reliably extract the images from our mind and share them with others.
- SR2Z 2y ago> 1. Many people aren't able to generating visuals in their mind. Yes, but "picture a..." in this context is not specifically meant to talk about visuals. It means "recall the nature of..." and is a multisensory experience that is required for anyone to use language. The point here is that if you have a word, it refers to SOMETHING and porn-sensitive companies don't always want an LLM to recall it.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoThere's a significant difference between imagining CSAM in your head, and having it displayed on a monitor in front of you. If there weren't, movies, television, radio, theater & books wouldn't exist, since everyone would be rotating their own cow in their head for free.
- posting_mess 2y agoA more concise version of my question is; "How do we train large ML/AI systems to think generating the unholy is bad without hurting intelligence, given we know that applying some universal law (I.E RLHF) hurts the model". Trying to promote the exact opposite of "let them eat the unholy".
- missy12 2y ago[flagged]
- missy12 2y ago[flagged]
- ntshtpstr 2y ago[flagged]
- ziddoap 2y agoThe mention of CSAM seems to mostly be there to tug on emotions. Not really surprised, given it's a Krebs article. However, I am surprised Krebs didn't try to dox this "Lore" person. While the headline sure is nice, the article really just boils down to the same shit that has been happening forever. Bad people steal access to resources and then resell those resources. Nothing particularly interesting here that I can see. Side note: It is interesting how many new accounts are chiming in on this one. Telling us all the places not to visit. Subtle stuff!
- klyrs 2y agoSo subtle. The chans are known to invade whenever articles mentioning them are posted here. They get flagged a bunch and drag the articles off the main page quickly. This may be deliberate.
- red-iron-pine 2y agowhat do the chans have to do with it? it's not 2007 and GPT bots are a thing.
- joe_the_user 2y agoI actually hadn't notice Krebs producing hand wringing trash before. But this is "...one (of many) sex based chat services steal cloud cycles." (How many things steal cloud cycles... etc).: News at 11.
- ntshtpstr 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated source: https://permiso.io/blog/exploiting-hosted-models https://permiso.io/blog/exploiting-hosted-models (submitted by the researchers: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41731750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41731750)
- ck2 2y agoIf only there was some kind of software that could observe firewall traffic and automatically learn what is normal vs abnormal behavior and alert admin
- ThinkBeat 2y ago1) More hacking of AI service during the past 6 months. >No shit. AI services have rocked off the scale during the past 6 months. Of course, there will be an increase. 2) Evil super hackers jailbroke AI models to do bad things. >This involved asking the AI to imagine a hypothetical situation. 3) Hackers target organizations that accidentally expose their cloud credentials or key online, such as in a code repository like Github >Um that has been going on for a long long time.
- maest 2y agoAre AI sex bots so profitable that it's the most efficient way of converting compute to money? What happened to crypto mining?
- ziddoap 2y ago>so profitable I mean, they're spending other people's money to run the services, so yeah it's profitable. Crypto-mining still exists, but is a fairly distinct from this particular flavor of cyber crime. Different requirements, different logistics, etc.
- 15155 2y agoCommercial cryptomining is less profitable today than in any period in the past. Monero, the favorite of botnets, has been dominated by overwhelmingly stolen, below-market-value compute.