5 ms·
You don't need science fiction to find the bull case for OpenAI. You just have to think it stands to be the "next" Google, which feels increasingly plausible. G
by tptacek 2y ago
You don't need science fiction to find the bull case for OpenAI. You just have to think it stands to be the "next" Google, which feels increasingly plausible. Google's current market capitalization is in the trillions.
- azinman2 2y agoIn 2023 Google had $307.39B in revenue and $24B in profit last quarter (suggesting ~100B in profit this year). Meanwhile OpenAI is losing money and making no where near these sums.
- tptacek 2y agoFacebook got all the way to an IPO with business fundamentals so bad that after the IPO, Paul Graham wrote a letter to all the then-current YC companies warning them that the Facebook stink was going to foul the whole VC market in the following years. Meta is now worth something like 1.4T.
- yifanl 2y agoFacebook made it out by committing click fraud against advertisers on a massive scale, which I don't see as a viable path for sama (even ignoring any legal concerns) considering that openAI isn't a platform company.
- tptacek 2y agoLook, I don't care. At some point we're just arguing about the validity of big tech investing. I don't invest money in tech companies. I don't have a strong opinion about Facebook, or, for that matter, about OpenAI. I'm just saying, you don't need a sci-fi story about AGI to see why people would plow this much money into them. That's all.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tempusalaria 2y agoFacebook grew 100% and had 45% gaap operating margins the year before their IPO. Facebooks IPO financials were among the best financials at IPO ever OpenAI has negative 130% adjusted operating margins.
- tptacek 2y agoI don't think OpenAI is about to IPO.
- impulser_ 2y agoFB financials were incredibly good at their IPO. Revenue - 3,711 - 88% YoY growth. Net Income - 1,000 Cash - 3,908 Tell me how those are bad?
- fhdsgbbcaA 2y agoGoogle has also magnificently shit the bed with Gemini; their ads business is getting raked over the coals in court; they are a twice convicted monopolist; and are driving away top talent in droves. It reminds me of the old joke: Heard about the guy who fell off a skyscraper? On his way down past each floor, he kept saying to reassure himself: So far so good... so far so good... so far so good.
- riku_iki 2y ago> their ads business is getting raked over the coals in court only display ads business, which is a fraction of total ads revenue
- fhdsgbbcaA 2y agoIt’s all wired together.
- riku_iki 2y agodisplay ads probably wired to google infra, but google search + youtube + ads can exists on their own.
- starchild3001 2y ago[flagged]
- fhdsgbbcaA 2y agoProduct adoption counts, imaginary benchmarks don’t.
- starchild3001 2y agoTell me how Search AI Overviews aren't using Gemini?
- perryizgr8 2y ago
- notahacker 2y agoIn fairness, whilst Google did reach profitability early (given the VCs had got their fingers burned on internet companies in 1999, they didn't have much choice) its revenues were lower than OpenAIs at IPO stage. The IPO was both well below Google's original hopes and considered frothy by others in the Valley because at the time the impressive and widely-used tech, limited as a business argument seemed to totally apply to the company that did search really well and had just settled the litigation for cloning Yahoo's Overture advertising idea. And their moat didn't look any better than OpenAIs And much as AI hype irritates me, the idea that the most popular LLM platform becomes a ubiquitous consumer technology heavily monetised by context-sensitive ads or a B2B service integrated into everything doesn't seem nearly as fanciful as some of the other "next Googles". At the very least they seem to have enough demand for their API and SaaS services to be able stop losing money as soon as VCs stop queuing up to give them more.
- miohtama 2y agoUber has not had a profitable year from their core business during its life time.
- nitwit005 2y agoYou're kind of selling investing in Google instead, given that they're one of OpenAI's competitors.
- tptacek 2y agoIf you think Google wins and crushes them, sure.
- paxys 2y agoGoogle is a digital advertising company. OpenAI hasn't even entered the ads business. In the absolute best case they can take over a large chunk of Google's search market share, sure, but that still doesn't make it anything similar to Google in terms of finances. How do they start making the queries profitable? What do they do when their competitors (Claude, Gemini, Llama, Mistral, Grok and several others) undercut them on price?
- tptacek 2y agoThis subthread is full of people explaining why they don't believe OpenAI could successfully match Google's financial performance. Sure. I'm not investing either. My point isn't that they're going to be successful, it's that there are plausible stories for their success that don't involve science fiction.
- jt2190 2y agoPeople don’t seem to understand that investment portfolios are personal, that just because an investment doesn’t make sense for their portfolio doesn’t mean that it doesn’t make sense for anyone’s. Allocating a tiny fraction of a portfolio to high risk/high reward investments is a sound practice. When those portfolios are, say, large pension funds, the total sum to invest can be hundreds of millions. Dissenters should consider that their might be short plays, that if what they think is true they could make some money.
- mulmen 2y agoGoogle started as a useful search service then corrupted itself with ads. This is the same thing that Facebook and Reddit did. It’s not hard to imagine an LLM that provides “sponsored” responses. So it’s a long term bet but the idea that Google would lose to an LLM isn’t far fetched to me.
- gammarator 2y agoThe unit economics appear to be substantially different.
- __loam 2y agoDo you want to know how much traffic OpenAI has pulled off Google in the past two years? Because it's not pretty lol. It's definitely single percentage points if not less than a percent (can't remember the exact numbers). They're a rounding error compared to Google.
- electrondood 2y agoIs there a source for this data? I personally always use ChatGPT over Google.
- __loam 2y agohttps://datos.live/predicted-25-drop-in-search-volume-remains-unclear/ https://datos.live/predicted-25-drop-in-search-volume-remain... Love the use of the personal anecdote to refute my point BTW.
- riku_iki 2y ago> You just have to think it stands to be the "next" Google, which feels increasingly plausible. Google's current market capitalization is in the trillions. for this, in addition to "google" part, they also need to build "ads" part for monetization, which is also not trivial task.
- GiorgioG 2y agoTo someone that uses OpenAI's tools everyday and generally finds them to be genius morons, I disagree that it feels increasingly plausible they stand to be the next Google.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ants_everywhere 2y agoBut don't they need a moat? They're running against not only every major tech company with access to training data and also all the open source models. The models will have diminishing returns and other players seem better suited to providing value added features.
- trhway 2y agoyou don't need a moat during the gold rush. You need scale - largest number of biggest shovels with which the stuff to be shoveled the fastest. There is so much money right now to be sucked up from the world. We're talking valuations in AI at $100M+ per employee. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/uae-backs-sam-altman-idea-095907316.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/uae-backs-sam-altman-idea-095... >The models will have diminishing returns Wasn't that the going thinking before ChatGPT? And before AlexNet. Of course, we'll again be having some diminishing returns until the next leap.
- ywvcbk 2y ago> the stuff to be shoveled They are spending a lot on shovels but it’s not clear that there is that much “stuff” (consumer demand) to be shoveled. VC money can only take you so far, you still need to have an actual way of making money. LLMs might effectively replace Google but they are already a commodity. It’s really not clear what moat OpenAI can build when there are already a bunch of proprietary/open models that are more or less on the same level. That basically means that they can’t charge much above datacenter cost + small premium longterm and won’t be able achieve margins that are high enough to justify current valuation.
- mise_en_place 2y agoThe moat is a first-party integration with Windows, a third-party integration with iOS, and first-mover advantage. The discount rate still isn't very high; ~5% is the risk-free rate. 157 billion is a reasonable valuation.
- 2y ago
- BobbyJo 2y ago> Google's current market capitalization is in the trillions. 2 trillion. Approximately 13x OpenAI's current valuation. Google nets almost 100 billion a year. OpenAI grosses 4 billion a year. Wild numbers.
- tptacek 2y agoA private pre-IPO investment is a bet on where OpenAI will be 10 years from now, not where they are now.
- BobbyJo 2y agoYes, but they generally shoot for 5-10x. So they are betting on OpenAI growing gross revenue like 20x assuming their costs stay the same.
- tptacek 2y agoThe later the investment stage, the lower the expected multiple, but also I don't know that 20x is a crazy expectation to have about OpenAI? It might not happen, but people really fixated on that "might", which is not what venture investing is about.
- BobbyJo 2y ago20x isn't crazy, but its what they need just to reach parity P/E with Google (assuming their costs remain flat). In order for the investment to make sense they have to grow much much more than that to account for the extra risk, otherwise you're better off buying Google stock. If we throw out some conservative numbers, and assume costs will rise super modestly, you have to believe OpenAI's earning will grow 50-100x for the investment to make sense. They'd have to maintain their current growth rate for 5+ years, but I wouldn't be surprised if their revenue growth is already slowing
- scarface_74 2y agoBesides name recognition, what’s special about OpenAI at this point? I was prototyping some ideas with ChatGPT that I wanted to integrate into a MVP. It basically involved converting a users query into a well categorized JSON object for processing downstream. I took the same prompt verbatim and used it with an Amazon Bedrock hosted Anthropic model. It worked just as well. I’m sure there will be plenty of “good enough” models that are just as good as Open AI’s models.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> Besides name recognition, what’s special about OpenAI at this point? nothing
- dudeinjapan 2y agoIts also plausible they are the next AltaVista.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> which feels increasingly plausible. not really; ChatGPT may have the brand name but there are other offerings that are just as good and which can be incorporated into existing apps that have a captive userbase (Apple, Google, Meta). Why should I switch to another app when I can do genAI within the apps that I'm already using.