10 ms·
Pear AI founder: We made two big mistakes
- minimaxir 2y agoContext: PearAI evidently forked an OSS code editor, then later got funding from Y Combinator for it. (relevant discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41697032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41697032) As an aside, I'm starting to get annoyed with the "we moved fast and broke things, we're smol indie hackers" defense that has been popping up more lately in various contexts. The whole incident started because they got venture capital for their fork and were in a startup accelerator for several months: that's not moving fast or being indie.
- ActionHank 2y ago"We moved fast, stole someone else's work, claimed it was our own, sold it to investors, we're smol indie hackers, just like you uwu."
- yard2010 2y agoUwU
- enva2712 2y agoi agree with your sentiment, and them botching the license was clearly a problem, but at the same time i think a dev waives their right to be indignant about someone forking and commercializing their code when they provide a perpetual, irrevocable, commercial license to do so. if continue was GPL’d or something i would respect the uproar more
- jsheard 2y ago> PearAI evidently forked an OSS code editor, then later got funding from Y Combinator for it. More specifically PearAI forked the OSS code editor Continue, which was itself funded by YC, and got YC funding for it. Also the editor they forked is itself a fork of VS Code, but is not to be confused with Void Editor, which is a third YC funded VS Code fork with AI features. It's YC funded VS Code forks with AI all the way down.
- aniviacat 2y ago> OSS code editor Continue Are you talking about continue.dev? That's not an editor itself, nor is if a fork of VS Code; it's an extension for VS Code (and JetBrains).
- jsheard 2y agoMy mistake, I haven't used Continue and was led to believe they have their own VS Code distro. PearAI forked VS Code and forked Continues VS Code extension and smushed them together then. They also just wired Continues code up to Claude/GPT4 so the models aren't novel either.
- satvikpendem 2y agoMaybe you're thinking of Cursor, which did fork VSCode.
- hbn 2y agoAlso of note, someone linked a video from 3 months ago where one of the co-founders was talking about using both Cursor and Continue. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0OylwLzBQw&t=257s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0OylwLzBQw&t=257s Which I suppose isn't necessarily a gotcha, it's totally possible to be a user of software and figure out ways it could be improved. But the way they pitched themselves was they're building an AI code editor, whereas it seems like they're just making some changes to a free, open-source project. If I had any guess, the reason they got accepted is from their YouTube followings, and this was essentially a marketing experiment. These guys have audiences of young aspiring developers who could be potential customers if their favorite youtuber were to start claiming they "built" an AI code editor. Not a crazy idea but certainly doesn't smell of an attempt to make an honest and good product.
- bluelightning2k 2y agoWell said! That last sentence was very elegant.
- 2y ago
- bachmeier 2y agoI kind of see your point, but they're clearly learning on the job, and AFAICT the mistakes didn't damage anyone else too badly.
- winwang 2y agoimo, the way you first do something + your first responses to serious criticism are the most telling regarding character. because afterwards, you can just play the act of "we're sorry because the backlash was really big and we have to clean up".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dtquad 2y ago>they're clearly learning on their job They are experienced software developers coming from $300K jobs at Coinbase. As experienced developers they know the requirements in the Apache License 2.0. As former employees at highly regulated Fintech companies like Coinbase they know better than letting ChatGPT make up new legal texts. They are cynical manipulators hiding behind a made up fictive "careless Gen Z tech bros" image.
- Animats 2y ago> highly regulated Fintech companies like Coinbase Um.
- 4ndrewl 2y agoThey're VC funded software developers, gods in the image of mere mortals. There's probably nothing they are not experts in.
- dijksterhuis 2y ago> [they worked at] Coinbase I mean... crypto companies are well known for being chock full of decent and honest employees who aren’t zealots or bandwagon jumpers in any way, shape or form. Just like a lot of recently created “AI” companies.
- hcks 2y agoThis outrage talk is ridiculous, you don’t have the morale high ground to judge people, they didn’t break anything, taking VC money isn’t bad, the incident was caused by sore losers looking for drama, etc etc
- digging 2y agoThey very clearly did break something because a lot of people got upset and said they broke something, and then they admitted they broke something.
- raverbashing 2y agoSounds like YC could improve in their due diligence.
- rchaud 2y agoMaybe they hired the Sequoia people that vetted SBF.
- wg0 2y agoNo no who says we're smal indide hackers. It has to be that we're the genius god gifted visionaries fixated on a future for humanity that is invisible to mere mortal peasants hence mistakes are inevitable. That's in general not specific to any situation.
- open-listings 2y ago[dead]
- x0x0 2y agoThey appear to be 2 people. I kinda of think folks should cut two people, one of whom just publicly apologized, a little slack re: how buttoned up they are about licensing. Particularly when they appear to have started sharing source code before YC's investment, and the last time I spoke to an attorney who advises on open source licensing he was expensive.
- klabb3 2y ago> They appear to be 2 people. I kinda of think folks should cut two people, one of whom just publicly apologized, a little slack Reading the room, people are upset about grifters, scams and fakery in general. The outrage is obviously built up over seeing our industry decline to buzzwords, bait and switch, and general enshittification. This is just one particularly clear-cut instance of opportunistic grift caught in the act. It’s like that IoT juice press – it’s not that harmful, but it’s a symbol of what people hate.
- fwip 2y agoNah. YC should cut them. It doesn't take an expert to know that you shouldn't ask AI to generate legal documents for you.
- yard2010 2y agoMy bet is: this won't age well. It's like saying 25 years ago that it doesn't take an expert to know that you shouldn't put your credit card on the internet.
- fwip 2y agoWhether AI becomes capable of doing this 25 years from now has no bearing on the current idiocy of the founders.
- hbn 2y agoI'd take you up on that bet. The AI can get as good as you want, but the reason you get a human to write and verify legal documents is so there's someone accountable. Their own job and reputation is on the line if they're doing bad work. Unless the company providing LawyerBot As A Service and writing everyone's legal documents is going to take all accountability, but that's a massive liability.
- rchaud 2y ago> I'm starting to get annoyed with the "we moved fast and broke things, we're smol indie hackers" defense It's worse than that; this whole kerfuffle came to people's attention after the founder posted a brag tweet about leaving a $300k job at Coinbase to go YC. Only to claim ignorance about the license and everything else later.
- tmpz22 2y ago"Sorry officer I didn't know I couldn't just rewrite a license to whatever I wanted despite having ample access to legal resources. Yes officer I am a CEO. No officer I will not remain silent."
- Narhem 2y agoTerrifying, always afraid to touch unlicensed code. Tried to give most of my public code extremely open licenses because I’d assume some guy crawling the internet for a piece of code probably has enough stress in his life.
- s5300 2y ago[dead]
- jph 2y agoThis apology is well done. It's humane, humble, acknowledges specific wrongs that were social failures and technical/legal failures, and explains the fixes going forward. Whatever you may think of Pear AI, or startups playing too fast and loose, IMHO this apology sounds sincere and worthwhile.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- swyx 2y agoyeah exactly. mistakes happen, they were definitely too influencer-brained in the launch, but its how you handle the feedback that shows your mettle. still doesnt make pear an investable idea, but the founders showed some humility/ability to read the room here. conversely, people who dunked on -them- too much showed either their lack of knowledge on open source/startup norms, or their ability to disingenuously ignore that for internet points, and provided many opportunities to be muted.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ekabod 2y ago>mistakes happen Mistakes are made without intent. That's not the case here.
- threeseed 2y agoI think this comment is pretty disgraceful. Here is a clear as day example of a startup who were completely reckless and indifferent to (a) the principles of open source and (b) the concerns of the developer community. And instead of criticising them you've turned the tables and now the fault is with people like me who are doing this for internet points. Instead of defending what underpins the entire software industry and has contributed so much value to the world.
- drpossum 2y agoMaybe they should do a startup that offers apologies for screwing up fundamentals of a business project instead. That seems to be the tangible thing they can deliver.
- blitzar 2y agoIts just a prank bro.
- elicksaur 2y ago>dawg I ChatGPT’d the license Why would you believe anything this person says after that? Default assumption #1 is any writing they output is an LLM product and insincere. Assumption #2 their actions are taken with little thought or intentionality. He deleted the tweet, so link with pic (I don’t endorse the generational dig in this tweet): https://x.com/anothercohen/status/1840515897804623882 https://x.com/anothercohen/status/1840515897804623882
- keyle 2y agoYikes. I'm older and this kind of behaviour isn't new at all. The detrimental English usage however is.
- TRiG_Ireland 2y agoLanguage has been changing for as long as language has existed.
- blitzar 2y agoStrong grindset dawg.
- seanthemon 2y agoTruly our next sigma, no cap. Is it supposed to hurt using those words?
- blitzar 2y agoYou are really bringing the rizz.
- Etheryte 2y agoThis just completely blows my mind. Who in their right mind thinks that generating legal content without even proofreading it is a good idea? It would've probably been less bad if they omitted a license altogether. At the same time, wasn't it recent news that a company that touted AI-assisted lawyers turned out to be no lawyers and just an LLM? The world of today is weird to me.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI am not familiar with this product or person but this reads like a sincere apology to me. Does anyone closer to this controversy have an opinion?
- shombaboor 2y agothis says more about YC than this particular founder (lots of these types nowadays): i.e. their process, their due diligence, who is advanced from 1000's of applications.
- threeseed 2y agoYC now reminds me of those tech influencer frat houses. Where it's all about the hustle, founder mode, the scene and whatever you can get away with to make money and take advantage of people.
- shombaboor 2y agoi really used to be wowed by their products and see their immediately utility like stripe and dropbox. now everyone is going founder mode, become an influencer type first and be a (mostl likely AI) guru people might want to follow
- paxys 2y agoPeople look at the top 5 YC success stories and think every company they fund is of that standard. In reality they "graduate" 500-1000 startups every year. They aren't all winners. In fact I'd wager Pear AI is a lot closer to the norm in terms of quality and competency than, say, Stripe or Airbnb.
- svnt 2y agoI think it speaks to beginner mistakes on the part of the founders. There are some exceptions but the typical demo day is absolutely stitched together from other peoples’ work. The difference is most hide this fact, instead of working in the clear on “open source” without understanding that it is meant to be a contribution from you to the community, because to finance bros that sounds like a joke. The whole thing has gotten so washed out that they either thought that this is what people actually do, or they thought no one was going to look at their repo (for a coding product!).
- octopod12 2y agothere is a culture of "gaming" that is in fact promoted by YC. one of the questions they had was to show an instance where the founders "hacked" or "gamed" a system. ie, game the test, game the admission, game everything. and some folks see this as "hustle". eventually their own process gets gamed. gaming incentivises a culture of "pretension" - you dont know sh* but you fake it. fake it til you make it. copy code-repos, trample over licenses, whatever, who cares as long as you are getting ahead.
- zombiwoof 2y agoCry me a river on your 270k you left behind to pursue even more greed filled goals
- Erazal 2y agoThat’s not something I’d be putting forward either, anywhere. In my opinion, it’s just a way for them to be putting forward their “value,” which actually feels dishonorable.
- yieldcrv 2y ago> Our intention was to use the Apache 2.0 license like Continue uses …. we got this right in one of them and wrong in the other. We thought the license in the root repo wasn’t that important, so we just generated one that we thought was open. 99% of the people here would make this mistake. and to be accused of taking something if you are giving attribution would just be absurd OSS community has some lame and immature aspects These guys might have gotten defensive but its obvious how to communicate, to me
- jorams 2y agoI'm sorry but if you think 99% of people here would consider this an acceptable approach to licensing I think you have a weirdly low opinion of this forum: > We thought the license in the root repo wasn’t that important, so we just generated one that we thought was open. No part of this sentence makes any sense to anyone remotely informed about licensing.
- yieldcrv 2y ago“making the same mistake” doesn’t equal “considering it an acceptable approach” the reaction was attributing it to malice, when it obviously was incompetence that should have been 1 tweet or github issue opened asking them to change it, and it would have been corrected or not. firestorm if they didnt take it seriously instead of whatever all this drama was pre-emptively
- throw16180339 2y agoSpeak for yourself. I don't trust AI generated code, let alone a software license.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> 99% of the people here would make this mistake Doubtful. That said, some may. > guys might have gotten defensive Now you've lost me. It's fine to be legally naïve. But you should have the self awareness to know you're winging it. When someone gives you feedback, especially for free, it's a damning personality trait for the first reaction to be petulance.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rsp1984 2y agoIt was a well planned and executed publicity stunt: 1. Maximize attention on social media by being super obnoxious and arrogant ("dawg I ChatGPT’d the license") 2. 1 day later while the chatter is still going, write a mea culpa and take on the poor victim role ("grew up in a single mother household on government subsidies") 3. --> Repair most of the reputational damage but keep all the attention. None of this is illegal, but it's exploiting a system of mutual trust and I wouldn't want to live in a world where everybody acted like that.
- blitzar 2y agoP.T. Barnum once said, “There’s no such thing as bad publicity,” which is almost as good as Oscar Wilde’s version, who put it like this: “There’s only one thing in the world worse than being talked about, and that is not being talked about.”
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pilgrim0 2y agoThus is the new norm. It plays well with how the platforms distribute content. I have faith that history will not remember those.
- aeturnum 2y agoI think this is a fine...day 1 "oh man did we dog that one" kind of post. Yah, they really screwed up. In a disqualifying way. But they can recover and you'll only know if you keep following them. Certainly they could say more and be more reflective - should one use chatGPT for a license? There are so many more people they could apologize to in a specific way. I also believe this could be an inciting incident that leads them to think differently and approach things differently. They could also go right back to their old ways. But I think this is a pretty good day-one response.
- drpossum 2y ago"disqualifying" and "can recover" are mutually exclusive concepts
- wormius 2y agoIs it typical for VC to just throw money at projects without any sort of oversight/auditing of, oh jeez, IDK, Licensing/Legal issues? I suppose they figure they can just buy it out in court appeals or something if someone were to take a grievance up with that. How does Graham, et al justify this lackadaisical attitude... "You win some you lose some"? "It all comes out in the wash"? I guess if you got masses of money to throw away you don't particular care about the legal ramifications? It's just an entry in the books. How did YC not smell that as a flag, and why should anyone TRUST YC after such a misstep? Or other VCs, not to dish just on YC... How many other situations like this are out there? Are they going to work to verify licenses with all their projects? Or just wait til disaster erupts and someone finds out they done messed up (oh I know the answer based on the SV motto "ask forgiveness instead of permission"). I am slightly snarky with my attitude, but this is serious shit, and it matters, because the social contract matters, SV Homo Superior Morality be damned. This is the kind of attitude that leads to bank collapses, because they're so busy huffing greed and damn the consequences. In this case, it's obviously not nearly as catastrophic, but it gets tiring to see this attitude that they get to reap benefits while externalities? Those are for the little people to pay.
- wmf 2y agoTraditionally YC invested in the potential of the team, not the details. One purpose of the YC program is/was to fix minor issues including legal ones.
- drpossum 2y agoUsing a random number generator to write the legally binding license which you will be legally held to in a court of law is not a "minor issue" and not even something that's necessarily "fixable". I am not a lawyer, but I guarantee you running this strategy past any lawyer will at best get you laughed out of the room.
- wmf 2y agoPeople have come up with tons of clown licenses over the years and they didn't cause lawsuits.
- acaloiar 2y agoNitter tweet link: https://nitter.privacydev.net/CodeFryingPan/status/1840831339337302204 https://nitter.privacydev.net/CodeFryingPan/status/184083133...
- rsynnott 2y ago> We thought the license in the root repo wasn’t that important, so we just generated one that we thought was open. _Generated_? Oh, yeah, that’ll go well. Of all the comically inappropriate uses of LLMs I’ve heard of, _writing legal documents_ has to almost number one, behind perhaps only medical use.
- nlitened 2y ago[flagged]
- MOARDONGZPLZ 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stonethrowaway 2y agoFOUNDER MODE DAWG
- wg0 2y agoI'm wondering how and what's the investing criteria for YC. Maybe there's a billion dollar company in that or a sustainable business model because consumer hardwar may never be able to run LLMs. But I really don't know because otherwise I'm sure pretty stable, serious ideas with proven demand would be rejected outright.
- x0x0 2y agoI suspect the criteria is something like every engineer is going to end up w/ a subscription to some tool like this because the return on investment is so high. Saving 1 hour of work a month easily justifies spending $50. There's no clear winner yet, so let these folks -- who did work on dev tooling elsewhere -- take a stab at it.
- wg0 2y agoYeah if such a tooling is what you're building, YC is really really great for that. Some 4000 companies are your immediate clients. Well, most of them. And it is not like that another $50 a month is going to shorten the runway of any startup running it into ground. Rather, you now have company in your portfolio with paying customers right off the bat that it would not have otherwise or would have taken longer than usual.
- pilgrim0 2y agoIt’s a good theory. But in practice, it’ll become ever so easy to build something similar, and there’ll be numerous free options to choose from. Good enough free options. And quite probably the bigger fish will start buying the smaller, until it naturally becomes a monoculture. All major editors already have free AI extensions, including the legacy ones like Vim. The only subscription you might need is to the LLM. A way better bet would be to make a model over a specific programming language, you’d have unfairly superior end-to-end development quality and performance, plus a niche to cultivate. My opinion is that the age of general models will not last. You will never be able to run the most capable one on current consumer hardware, yet, you will be able to run a specialized model. All in all, it seems like this generation of AI products will be cemented as progress on AI interfacing, that it, the AIs UIs.
- anonzzzies 2y agoNothing wrong with forking, but I am confused that people who obviously do not understand the very simple practices of open source licenses (and if you don't understand; chatgpt does) can be expected to build anything. I don't mean the legal ins and outs of these licenses; I mean the root license 'we thought is not a big deal' and so on. This is so basic that I wonder if anyone actually spoke to them before transferring the money; to write code and make a good product, you need skills that vastly eclipse such kindergarten level license practices.
- MOARDONGZPLZ 2y agoI was just commenting about this yesterday on here. I am still aghast about some of the drivel that YC appears to be funding. Is this an anomaly or is scale causing them to vet companies less? Can I get more YC funding by forking Redis, adding OpenAI, and calling it an AI In Memory Cache?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mhuffman 2y agoCan I get more YC funding by forking Redis, adding OpenAI, and calling it an AI In Memory Cache? No. But, maybe if you call it RediAI
- newman314 2y agoSo I took a quick look at the codebase. Here are the commits from the founders: * https://github.com/trypear/pearai-submodule/commits?author=nang-dev https://github.com/trypear/pearai-submodule/commits?author=n... (71 commits) * https://github.com/trypear/pearai-submodule/commits?author=Fryingpannn https://github.com/trypear/pearai-submodule/commits?author=F... (21 commits) This is what got funded... I leave it to folks to decide if the changes to date are meaningful.
- nusl 2y agoIf that is indeed what got funded, those changes appear to be extremely minimal and benign and I can understand why people would have an issue with funding this.
- nojvek 2y agoChrome + Electron codebase is a gazillion lines of code. If someone builds an electron app and gets VC funded, is that somehow unethical? Lines of code is irrelevant. Only issue is if they are building on top of a codebase whose license they have violated.
- falcor84 2y ago> Lines of code is irrelevant. Let's take it to the extreme - how much would you fund a "tech startup" that doesn't have any of its own code at all, but rather just has its founder manually press buttons on a third-party tool's GUI? Note that I'm not asking whether it's ethical, or even if the service is worth it to a customer (maybe the founder really is good at pressing the right button at the right time) - but would you as a founder fund it, knowing that there's pretty much no barrier-to-entry whatsoever?
- lolinder 2y ago> Lines of code is irrelevant. Lines of code is a proxy for "how hard would it be for someone else to do what these guys are doing but better" and the answer here is "not very".
- 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Intermernet 2y agoMaybe, as a prerequisite for VC funding in the modern world, tech founders should have to show a functional knowledge of open source licensing. It seems to be the cause of a lot of grief in recent years.
- lccerina 2y agoIt would not have been a problem if they started small (like many open source stuff normally is) and someone would have noted their errors to them. On a small scale. Allowing them to learn. VC funding turbocharged yet another AI bullshit something-something right into a wall. Even more ridiculous: someone is giving money to a company that is essentially a patch/extra feature to an existing editor. Imho that is not a "company".
- Havoc 2y agoGood apology but yikes what a plan. Also not sure adding a few more features will do much to resolve the issue either
- nojvek 2y agoWhen you make code open source, with an open commercial license and someone takes that code to make money or funding, they don’t owe you anything. A license like MIT explicitly allows commercial use. If you don’t want other people to make money, don’t use an open license. If you want to make money, then charge people for it. Choose a license that aligns with your needs. Be prepared to sue if someone violates the license.
- lapinot 2y agoSure, but people don't owe them respect. illegal != immoral.
- ssijak 2y agoI don't understand all the outrage. I would even go as far as saying that Y Combinator knows that they forked that other editor and they are evidently thinking that there will be some big hits in this space and are shotgunning into different projects thinking at least one of them will hit big.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 2y agoThat’s on YC, if they are fine funding trivial forks of open source projects that doesn’t reflect good on them, but I don’t really see the issue here
- tomciao17 2y ago[flagged]
- tomciao17 2y ago[flagged]
- jer0me 2y agoThe editor they forked, Continue, is also funded by YC.
- byyoung3 2y agoOpenAI forked googles paper, started as open source, then went closed source. They are one of the most valuable companies in history.
- falcor84 2y agoThey didn't "fork" it, but rather implemented the ideas in it, that's science and engineering as intended. For open source software projects on the other hand, the intended behavior is contributing directly, and forking is a distant plan B.
- KaiserPro 2y agoImplemented a paper, yes. But without a dataset, its pretty much worthless.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tempusalaria 2y agoThe product OpenAI got mega traction with was based on the GPT series of papers, all of which were published by OpenAI and all of which are major advancements in research. Also OpenAI was founded before the transformer paper and spent most of their early years focused on RL style research and products - just look at what they published pre 2019.
- moojacob 2y agoI ran into this guy's youtube channel when trying to get a tech internship last year. He's a giant grifter — memorizing leetcode problems while failing his core cs classes at a prestigious university. I'm frustrated with my own career so seeing people like this (who are so unworthy?) get 270,000 jobs out of college and a half million dollars in funding for... copying code... make me want to quit the industry.
- herval 2y agotech is increasingly dominated by grifters, as they tend to sound more convincing than the classic hacker and are tend to have "fluid morals", which is important if your goal is to take a billion dollars from VC money by lying your way to riches, then become an investor in the next wave of <insert hype space here>. It's a self-selecting game.
- JohnFen 2y agoThis why I'm looking to get out of the industry entirely. It's reached the point where I no longer want to tell people what I do for a living. It's become embarrassing, and I tire of having to defend myself about it.
- talldayo 2y agoIt's not embarrassing if you write and ship free software. You can still operate in the software industry, succeed against corporate interests, and provide value to other developers without selling your soul to the devil. The fatalism of "all software is bad" is a tautology that seems correct, but is only validated by commercially successful (and often monopoly-abusing) businesses.
- JohnFen 2y agoBy "leave the industry", I mean not doing it for a living anymore. I don't mean that I'd stop coding. Software development itself is a joy that I'm not willing to give up as a hobby. I'm not saying "all software is bad" at all. I'm not even saying "all software companies are bad". I know that's not the case. What I am saying is that the industry overall, mostly due to the actions of SV-style companies, has become more bad than good and the general public is noticing.
- breck 2y agoGarry Tan in 2019: "we mock the scammers who build nothing real and get fake valuations." Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21296685 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21296685
- 361994752 2y agoApologies if this is a dumb question, but PearAI, Continue, and Cursor all seem like different versions of GitHub Copilot to me. Am I understanding that correctly? Why are we funding so many 'GitHub Copilot's?
- octopod12 2y agoHere is my theory. 1) management types who have never coded love the idea that coders can be replaced or minimized by said tooling. hence hey fund any and all projects. 2) coders excited by llms reach out to the nearest projects they can relate to, namely, code assistants, test generation assistants, doc generation, and generally any automation in the coding workflow. so, you will see a lot of me-too tooling.
- collingreen 2y ago"We" aren't funding anything. Venture capital is trying to fund companies that have the potential to grow their valuation many many many times over in a relatively short amount if time. AI is obviously very powerful and has the potential to change things quickly IF it turns out it can be good at important tasks that people will pay for. If someone finds a really good use case then they can scale that with essentially no problems until the vcs are fat and happy. Pouring money into AI garbo also feels like a hedge to investors when they see it as just funneling down to their other investments. Together these things end up looking like an attractive vc target so we see a ton of these "companies" that are a bag of prompts on top of a different company's code/model.
- e-clinton 2y agoCursor user and former Copilot user here. The difference is significant. Being able to use Claude alone is worth the switch, but the UI of these newer tools are far better than Microsoft’s implementation.
- 361994752 2y agoI'm really interested. Could you kindly elaborate?
- charliermarsh 2y agoThe piece of this apology that I have trouble understanding is this: > We thought the license in the root repo wasn’t that important, so we just generated one that we thought was open. The root repo already had an Apache license in it. If you thought it wasn't important, why replace it in the first place?
- DonHopkins 2y agoHis apology would sound more authentic and consistent with his previous communications if it were in all lower case with lots of kewl words like "dawg" and abbreviations like "lol" and missing punctuation like kids these days use in their text messages. Those capital letters and correctly spelled words and full stops come off as so passive aggressive. Otherwise it painfully looks like he tasked ChatGPT to generate his apology as well as his license.
- morpheuskafka 2y agoI think this comes from Github asking people to choose a license when they first create a repo, they may be just viewing it as some sort of automatic box to check when making a new repo. I think these guys honestly have no idea what a license even does or what copyright is, based on their other statements about it. I bet they don't even have any idea of the differences between GPL vs Apache/MIT/et al vs AGPL, SSPL, etc. and that's been discussed to death on here and all over the open source world.
- darkhorse13 2y agoI applied to YC in the last batch and got rejected. Not to sound like sour grapes, but it seems like YC loooves students from certain universities, which kinda sucks for us commoners who didn't go to these places. Not to mention the whole hype around AI is unbearable at this point. Seems very likely that deserving products/ideas are getting rejected because they aren't doing AI, or because their founders didn't go to Stanford. Oh well, that's just how it goes.
- risyachka 2y agoYep, thats how they work, there's a ton of data to back it up. Unless you are from few *US* unis, you have zero to none chance of getting in, unless you have significant traction already, in which case you may as well go to any investor and they will fund you. And if you are among those lucky few, they will fund you with the most shitty idea you have, or even without any at all.
- vertoc 2y agoI went to a state school (and not a prestigious one) and I got in ~a year after graduating, I don't think this is super accurate
- darkhorse13 2y agoI'm a solo founder and during the application process, I got 3-4 emails telling me to strongly consider finding a co-founder using https://www.ycombinator.com/cofounder-matching https://www.ycombinator.com/cofounder-matching. That's great, but just look at the profiles advertised on the front-page there: Harvard, Berkeley, MIT, etc. Nothing against them personally of course, but I really think this is the trend YC is going towards these days. It's the old school institutional prestige back, but this time it's blended together with SV startups.
- breck 2y ago> I got 3-4 emails telling me to strongly consider finding a co-founder A lot of YC's advice is terrible, such as their advice on finding a cofounder. You can easily tell when they give bad advice: ask them for their dataset. When they don't offer it, consider doing the opposite of what they tell you. Now, some of their advice is great, when it is data backed an easily testable like Jessica Livingston's "I don't know of a single case of a startup that felt they spent too much time talking to users." https://breckyunits.com/advice.html https://breckyunits.com/advice.html Now, what's a version of their "find a co-founder" advice that doesn't suck: "I don't know of a single case of a successful founder that wasn't building things all the time with many different people." Don't find a co-founder or two, find dozens of "building buddies" who you just build shit with. Every now and then you can form a legal entity and be "co-founders", but the more important thing is you just create stuff together.
- moralestapia 2y ago>We thought the license in the root repo wasn’t that important, so we just generated one that we thought was open. >"Only A players make it in this game"
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- focusgroup0 2y ago>write an apology that really sounds genuine and heartfelt. include some poetic turns of phrase, and be produced in the style of a viral tweet
- sandspar 2y agoIt's weird to see the feeding frenzy on these two guys. It's like watching piranas. It's brutal and savage in a primitive way, like watching chimpanzees engaging in cannibalism or something like that. It's basically the Two Minutes of Hate from 1984. Thousands of people with inner monologues consisting only of "PUNISH PUNISH PUNISH".
- 0xfama 2y agoas Garry Tan said that they invest in founders not their ideas. The cofounder is xCoinbase, Tesla and has some decent social following. That was enough for YC partners to say yes without indulging much into the technicalities of the business and idea.
- citizenpaul 2y agoAnyone defending these crypto scammers is the sucker they are looking for. I instantly disliked them from their announcement. Huge crypto bro scam energy. Even that aside I decided to give them a chance and look at their product. Oh its just a combined fork of two other products. Well even so I gave it a chance and installed it. Maybe they are just marketing? The product is incredibility underwhelming, just another bland AI "Me too" clone product. Then I see that they actually are crypto bros from coinbase....They have been drinking from the kool-aid mines of crypto too long their compass is gone. This is just them trying to shamelessly "value extract" one of the last bastions of real production. What creeps. Plus all the other drama they have been involved in ... They are the exact antithesis of the startup world. Poison in the well. I hope they fail because they deserve it and this community deserves better than being exploited.
- hbn 2y agoI don't know about outright crypto scamming (unless you consider working for coinbase to be crypto scamming), but I got the impression they're just trend chasers more than anything. They're into a branch of "software dev" youtube that has grossed me out for a while, where it's just promoting software development as an aesthetic. They relentlessly force buzzwords like "startup," "software engineer," "quit my job," and giant salary numbers into video titles and thumbnails. They do "day in the life of a software engineer" video that's usually just showing off the cushy lifestlye, and explaining something like a gRPC call in a way that makes it sound way more complicated than it is. I scrolled the guy's YouTube channel and seemingly he quits 6-figure jobs every few months if his video titles are telling the truth. His original tweet was using the exact same tactics as his video titling with bold words shouting "I QUIT MY $270,000/YEAR JOB AT TRENDY TECH COMPANY" that I think a lot of people outside of aspiring first-year CS students aren't falling for after we've been exposed to so much BS grifting out of silicon valley the past decade+.
- citizenpaul 2y ago>unless you consider working for coinbase to be crypto scamming I do. I don't believe anyone working in the crypto industry is anything other than a sociopath or incredibly naive. They clearly are not naive since they are pumping their own product with deliberate and IMO false intent. How many times do we have to watch bad actors with their hands in the cookie jar before its a pattern? >so much BS grifting out of silicon valley the past decade Yet here they are still getting money. The real downer is that every one of these people are draining limited money that could have gone to someone genuinely trying to do something.
- 11101010001100 2y agoI would like to thank the Gov of Canada for subsidizing this apology.
- stuckkeys 2y agolol "WE AR SORRRI"
- rootedbox 2y agoI've contributed hours / days of coding to continue.. so to say what PearAI did makes me furious. Is an understatement. This apology is even misleading of what they actually did. They didn't fork they copied and they changed the license. Fork properly keep attribution to all the developers who have worked on continue; and keep the license..
- keskival 2y agoThey didn't fix the licenses. Microsoft VSCode was originally MIT licensed, which PearAI is now relicensing as Apache, and has removed the Microsoft copyright clause in their root repo. Similarly, with their extension repo which they forked from Continue, they now have two LICENSE files, one from Continue, one from PearAI, both Apache. This could be argued to be almost correct, but it would be clearer if they did it correctly and had one LICENSE file there with both copyright clauses from both PearAI and Continue. Additionally they don't seem to use any contributor agreements, so people who contribute to their repos will maintain their own personal copyrights. That means that the copyright clauses on the licenses are technically invalid as the repos contain works from various individuals who have not given their permission to license their works in any way. Disregarding the legal aspects, what they are doing is morally clearly wrong as they are crudely exploiting the works of others without contributing back to them in any way.
- fakedang 2y ago270k USD job but couldn't hire a lawyer to fix their license situation.
- billmaya 2y agoToday, I am announcing my new startup...vimGPT. ;)