5 ms·
Until the fragmentation problem is fixed, every new Android release only fills me with dread. Normally when new versions of frameworks or software that I use c
by javajosh 14y ago
Until the fragmentation problem is fixed, every new Android release only fills me with dread.
Normally when new versions of frameworks or software that I use come out, I like it. Except Android, because every new version of Android has lots of nice features that I won't be able to use and it is guaranteed to further fragment of the marketplace.
Android is the (old) Internet Explorer of mobile. I've never seen one application skew across versions so hard, or single-handedly fragment the space as much. (BTW kudos to MS for strongly encouraging their IE users upgrade).
What makes this perplexing is that Google has solved this problem with most of their other installed software offerings, Chrome particularly. There's basically only one version of Chrome (v 19 as I write this). Heck, even MS realized their mistake and is making efforts to roll up old IE users into the latest version. And of course Apple has done a fantastic job keeping all of it's users at the same iOS version.
I am well-aware of the OEM madness that drives Android fragmentation, and that you might think it's not "Google's fault" because of this. But I disagree. Google has vast resources and can basically do whatever it wants. If it wanted to require OEMs to build Android-upgradable phones, it could force them to do so. In fact, if they started doing this today you would hear loud cheers from around the world (and bitter complaining from the OEMs, but so what? There's a lot of money to be made and they'll get in line).
- drivebyacct2 14y ago> There's a lot of money to be made and they'll get in line The fact that that's not true is precisely why timely upgrades aren't done. Verizon and Motorola sold you that Droid RAZR. They get nothing from spending engineer time to update it. Also, what is this implication that Google is just being lazy or has some incentive to not have everyone running the latest OS. You really think Google so powerful that they can snap their fingers and make OEMs do what they want? Isn't the very existence (and initial struggle) of the Nexus line evidence against that?
- javajosh 14y agoApple gets "nothing" from engineering their upgrades to be backwards compatible. That is, if "nothing" means being incredibly successful. People are actually rather smart about things like this, and they know that the iPhone "just works" and will continue to work, and that is a huge competitive advantage. And long-term competitive advantage is one of the classic components of "maximizing shareholder value". So yes, publicly traded OEMs (which is all of them) are legally required to maximize shareholder value, and they are not doing that. P.S. I think you are a troll, based on this and prior discussions, and this is the last time I'm responding to you. I'd appreciate it if you'd not respond to my posts either. Thank you.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoI hope it's obvious that Motorola releasing the RAZR2 is more profitable than spending time working on software updates to the RAZR1 and I don't know why you insist on comparing Android OEMs to Apple when you yourself already point out that they have different goals and strategies by the nature of their products,
- jshen 14y agoI bought a droid x2 about a year ago. It was a top of the line phone a year ago, and I can't even get ICS for this phone. Here's what's going to happen to motorola's profits. I will never buy another phone from them.
- Xyzodiac 14y agoI bought the same phone, it's incredibly sad that OEMs do this.
- cookiecaper 14y agoFWIW you can get ICS on that phone, just not officially. If you aren't going to buy a Nexus, you have to accept the fate of sparse official/OTA updates if you're lucky enough to get any at all. This is the fault of carriers and the ignorant masses that prop them up. An alternative exists if you're interested; buy Nexus line.
- jshen 14y agoPlease tell me how to get ics . Btw, there have been nexus phones that have taken a while to get updates.
- Xyzodiac 14y agoWith loads and loads of bugs, dragonzkiller's CM9 ROM is incredibly alpha.
- jsz0 14y agoOnly by installing alpha/beta quality software from an untrusted source. Not an acceptable solution for most. You're right though about buying a Nexus. That's the only way you will have any chance of getting software updates. If it's not available on your country/carrier, and updates are important to you, do not buy an Android phone.
- jsight 14y ago91% of the Android market is covered by 3 major versions (2.2, 2.3, and 4.0). 72% is covered by just two major versions (2.3 and 4.0). This problem isn't quite as severe as its made out to be. Dealing with the diverse hardware ecosystem and implementation bugs are both much larger problems, IMO.
- TylerE 14y agoThat's like saying 91% of the Windows market is 3 major versions, XP, Vista, and Windows 7. 2.x and 4.x are very different beasts.
- mtgx 14y agoYes, it's exactly like saying that. Windows has several years between each version and each version still has like 30-40% each, so it's quite fragmented, too.
- taligent 14y agoIt is fragmented. But not in the developer sense. Microsoft has always been quite good in backporting their developer libraries. So even you did have users on XP you could simply bundle these with your app e.g. .Net, DirectX. Google may have to look at doing something similar for 2.3 users in particular.
- ephemient 14y agoYou mean like http://developer.android.com/tools/extras/support-library.html http://developer.android.com/tools/extras/support-library.ht... ?
- gardarh 14y agoThey are, with the Android Support Library: http://developer.android.com/tools/extras/support-library.html http://developer.android.com/tools/extras/support-library.ht... It provides support for features from Android 3.0 (namely fragments) for all versions down to 1.6. IMO it's essential for Android development.
- myko 14y agoI think attempting to strong arm OEMs with Microsoft's mobile offerings on the horizon could be a very bad move for Android.
- caf 14y agoIt seems to me that the easiest way that Google could do this would be to create a "Perfect Android" branding or similar, which has some tight rules around licensing - to qualify, a device would have to meet a set of minimum hardware specs and the manufacturer and carriers would have to sign up to providing timely updates to the latest version that Google produces over the next N years. Google, for its part, would guarantee that those newer versions for the next N years will run well on the minimum hardware specs agreed to.