4 ms·
Fission radioactivity is the bad stuff that will be radioactive for millions of years and we don't know how deal with that. It needs heavy metals like plutonium
by fragmede 2y ago
Fission radioactivity is the bad stuff that will be radioactive for millions of years and we don't know how deal with that. It needs heavy metals like plutonium and uranium and when it goes wrong, they melt down and we all have a bad time. Fusion uses tritium and can be made from seawater and makes helium, and doesn't melt down in the same way, and the waste is relatively short lived.
- atomic128 2y agoSee discussion of dry cask storage here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41601833 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41601833
- pfdietz 2y agoDry cask storage is simple, relatively cheap, and forecloses no future option for dealing with waste. By the time the waste is so cooled off it is no longer self protecting from amateur diversion of plutonium -- maybe 300 years -- options should be greatly expanded for its disposal, including shooting it into space on dirt cheap extremely reliable launchers. In any case, setting the fuel disposal cost to zero still leaves fission uncompetitive, given the cost of building new nuclear power plants. This is especially the case if one imagines a nuclear powered world economy, which likely would have to resort to some flavor of breeder reactors. Reprocessing would be necessary for breeders, but that wouldn't make breeders cheaper than current burner reactors.
- roenxi 2y ago> Fission radioactivity is the bad stuff that will be radioactive for millions of years and we don't know how deal with that. We also don't know how to deal with lead and it will be poisonous until we figure out how to biologically re-engineer the human species. So far so good, we still use lead, you can buy the stuff by the kilo. This is a minor problem to the point where the people bringing it up aren't taking the situation seriously. The volumes are tiny and we can just dump it somewhere.
- alex_young 2y agoAround 2000 metric tons of nuclear waste are produced every year in the US. And that represents under 20% of electricity production. I do think there are ways to manage the problem, but tiny isn’t the word I’d use.
- roenxi 2y ago2000 metric tons! Wow! Look out, we're dealing with the big numbers there! Nearly up to 5 figures assuming we round it wrong. That is around 3 shipping containers. There is literally a risk of losing it in transit because the volume is so small. If you see 3 shipping containers in a field somewhere that might be a year's worth of nuclear waste. It is hard to get across how small that number is compared to 20% of the US's annual electricity production. The reason the problem hasn't been "solved" in the last however long reactors have been a thing is it is too small a problem to devote time to.
- texuf 2y agoExcept you can’t transport it. We built a giant cave for it in the desert and everybody agreed that the material was too dangerous to drive past people’s homes so we just leave it sitting around on site hoping a natural disaster doesn’t wash it away. I’m pro nuclear but we need to be honest with ourselves.
- roenxi 2y agoI mean yeah. They do leave it sitting around on site. Because it takes up no space, they can build a bunker to store it without adding all that much to the cost and there are idiots hyperventilating at the thought of transporting dangerous goods around. I'd imagine the nuclear people decided it wasn't worth the hassle. I feel ridiculous having to argue that volumes of material this small represent a real threat. If you wanted to move it we could. Split it up into little loads and put it in a stupidly over-engineered shielded truck. Goodness me this is not a real problem. They've been ignoring it for decades and the consequences are somewhere between nil and nothing interesting. There is nothing here to be honest about, there is no reasonable threat to debate. We transport explosives, we transport poison, we sometimes get massive port explosions that can level a district. Then we've got old mate claiming 2,000 metric tonnes of a relatively dangerous material represents a serious national problem. The absurdity of that is frustrating to deal with.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]