5 ms·
Should Sports Betting Be Banned?
- vitalurk 2y agoYes, the math understanding is not here at scale. It's strip mining a vulnerable populace. Of course it should be banned.
- nosefurhairdo 2y agoThe same argument could be made for alcohol, cigarettes, credit cards, luxury goods, lottery tickets, tattoos... If you banned everything that some percent of the population could use to harm themselves, you might be disappointed by what's left.
- orwin 2y agoTattoos?
- nosefurhairdo 2y agoTattoos can be extremely expensive; I personally know many people who struggle financially and spend what's left on tattoos. It sounds ridiculous, but so does blowing lots of money on sports betting.
- orwin 2y agoOK, thank you for your response, I learned something today.
- xhkkffbf 2y agoYes.
- waynecochran 2y agoYes.
- the_cat_kittles 2y agobased on empirical data, yes, its a net negative for us
- np_tedious 2y agoSo is sugar. Would you ban that? People have agency and choice
- the_cat_kittles 2y agoshades of grey and tradeoffs. gambling has a very clear and well studied negative effect on a small but sizeable percent of people and its not that great for everyone else. its my opinion were better off without it
- kelseyfrog 2y agoConsistency is overrated. Ban gambling
- idle_zealot 2y agoYou don't ban people from consuming sugar, you ban companies from mass-producing food with unhealthy amounts of it. It's about friction and incentives. If you want to buy a bag of sugar and bake a cake that's fine.
- wellthisisgreat 2y agoAbsolutely regulate sugary drinks like cigarettes
- np_tedious 2y agoI do think sugar should be regulated more and probably excised taxed, but banning is a different thing altogether
- wellthisisgreat 2y agoI meant you can buy it but the health hazards are plastered all over
- denkmoon 2y agoNo. Gambling is a part of a free society, just like drugs are. Gambling advertisements on the other hand, learn from Australia. Don't let it happen.
- starspangled 2y agoI don't necessarily disagree with your conclusion but I'd like to know how you arrived there. What makes gambling a part of free society but not gambling advertisements?
- reidjs 2y agoThe difference is self harm vs harming others. The distinction is that advertising may convince people who do not gamble to start gambling.
- addicted 2y ago1. Thats a criteria based on harm, not “free society”. 2. Gambling has massive harms on others. The family of the men who gamble (it’s usually men gambling on sports), including the minor kids who cannot leave the individual and are dependent on them, as well as broader society which now has to pick up the pieces for this individual and the people dependent on him.
- WalterBright 2y agoIn order to censor speech, to prevent leading the masses astray, the censor must hear/see it. Why isn't the censor led astray?
- cfmcdonald 2y agoI can't tell if this comment is really serious. In case it needs explanation, you don't ban gambling advertising by having a censor watch every ad and then decide which ones to allow. You pass a law that says "no advertising gambling" and then if someone does it, you prosecute them.
- m0llusk 2y agoHow about "Could sports betting be banned?" People are strongly motivated to do this and often spontaneously form networks to share bets. How exactly would the state put a stop to this? Even with really thorough access to all financial transactions it would be hard to prove what went on without direct testimony which is unlikely to be available.
- enugu 2y agoLegalized gambling with big enterprises running it and ads visible to most people, many of whom wouldn't usually gamble, should be orders of magnitude worse than informal networks. One may not get rid of the latter, but stopping the former has a very great value.
- hifromwork 2y agoInteresting question! Depends on how strong is your desire to ban it. The humanity has a long history of banning things, including certain plants, certain thoughts (for example, religious beliefs), certain ideas, certain symbols, certain pictures, and even certain numbers. I have a few ideas. Criminal groups are often broken by having a police infiltrate the group and collect the evidence. We could have police officers joining the gambling groups (the groups need to accept some people, so they have someone they can make bets with) and catching the perpetrators. I also don't think that - at least right now - gamblers use tor or sufficiently anonymous proxies, so it would be easy to get most of them by just observing network traffic. Also, significant money transfers between random private people are uncommon. You can find sets of people who often do transfers like this, and find the "gambler networks".
- drpgq 2y agoWhat's the gender ratios of sports gambling? 90% male? 95% male?
- wongarsu 2y agoIf I read the graphs in [1] correctly it's more like 70% male in Massachusetts. In fantasy sports betting it's 60% male [2] 1: https://commonwealthbeacon.org/by-the-numbers/poll-indicates-young-people-arent-betting-on-sports-as-much-as-feared/ https://commonwealthbeacon.org/by-the-numbers/poll-indicates... 2: https://thefsga.org/industry-demographics/ https://thefsga.org/industry-demographics/
- paulpauper 2y agoThen how about daytrading, crypto trading, lottery, horse betting, etc. the list goes on. There are no shortage of ways to separate people from their money. It's like those school soda bans. As it turns out, people can get their soda from many places, not just school.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoMaybe. Day trading is silly.
- theGeatZhopa 2y agoWhy is day trading is silly and what alternative would you suggest?
- basementcat 2y agoThere are some forms of gambling that may arguably be a social good. For example, car insurance is a wager by the car insurance company that a driver won't get in a car accident during the coverage period. Commodity speculators may serve as a counterparty for farm insurance derivatives. I’ve wondered if it could be possible to harness some of these "suboptimal" gambling behaviors into "socially good" gambling but I haven’t quite figured out how to do it. Maybe someone else here can do it.
- jruz 2y agoYou don’t ban anything, you make more attractive whatever behavior you want to promote, the paper thinks stocks are better so then make index investing a better alternative.
- Dalewyn 2y agoIndex investing isn't really gambling in the generally understood sense though, you just buy the whole haystack (or at least a haystack that's big enough) and ride it.
- WalterBright 2y agoSo much evil is done by people who are certain they know what is best for others, and therefore are justified in forcing it on them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Mainsail 2y agoI’m unsure but I’ll be honest in that I find it hard to understand how online poker is illegal in most states yet sports betting and the lottery are fine.
- from-nibly 2y agoBetter lobyists
- jmyeet 2y agoYes. Gambling is poison to both the individual and the sport. Gambling addiction is absolutely devastating. Gambling has the highest rate of suicide of any addiction [1]. Being able to gamble on your phone is way too accessible. Gambling of any sort is an awful industry but at least a physical casino has a higher barrier to entry than pulling your phone out. Here's something else you may not know: if you win too much on these sports betting sites, you can get banned [2]. Now, you might be tempted to say "casinos ban card counters in Blackjack", which is true. But sports betting is more like poker where the house takes a cut of any action, so by winning you're taking money from other players, not the house. So why do sportsbooks ban you for winning? Because it means other people lose and to create addiction you can't always lose. You have to sometimes win. For me, this absolutely destroys any argument that it is a "game of skill" (which matters for the legislation that legalized it). [1]: https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/local-news/problem-gamblers-have-highest-suicide-rate-of-any-addiction-disorder-studies-show https://www.news5cleveland.com/news/local-news/problem-gambl... [2]: https://www.elitepickz.com/blog/do-sportsbooks-ban-winners-and-sharp-bettors https://www.elitepickz.com/blog/do-sportsbooks-ban-winners-a...
- senectus1 2y agoI agree, but unfortunatley prohibition never works. I would suggest restricting the aboslute crap out of it. make it really hard to get into.
- hollerith 2y ago>prohibition never works. Sports gambling was prohibited in most US states during most of US history. It didn't "work" in the sense that it did not completely prevent sports gambling, but neither did it cause any major problems AFAICT.
- senectus1 2y agoit drove it underground, where the crime gang componenet got very rich and powerful. I would argue, you still havent seen the end of THAT effect. the money talks for a long time.
- habosa 2y agoThe constant pushing of sports gambling by leagues and broadcasters is well on the way to ruining sports themselves, so it might ban itself when there's nothing left to bet on.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: Legalizing Sports Gambling Was a Mistake https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659458 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41659458
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nmca 2y agoSports betting should be banned because knowing the outcome of sports games is in advance is not socially valuable. Gambling on many other things e.g elections, crime rates, ceo performance, etc should be allowed because predictions there are socially valuable.
- nosefurhairdo 2y agoThere are countless activities that could be deemed "not socially valuable". That is far too broad and subjective a metric to determine whether something should be banned.
- sneak 2y agoGovernment bans on a thing are a question of "should we use guns to prevent people from doing $THING?" Given that the use of violence is a rather extreme remedy to a perceived problem, there'd have to be a pretty compelling case to warrant pulling out a gun to stop people from doing something. That's what government bans are.
- antifa 2y ago> guns Except for the 300 layers of asking nicely, , formally giving warnings, issuing fines and citations, etc., yeah it basically is just guns threats violence and totalitarianism.
- bitshiftfaced 2y agoJust like the lottery, you can never really ban it. It just shifts to a shadowy, untaxed venue. The least bad law would be to put restrictions on advertising. I don't understand why people tolerate State-sponsored lotteries being able to advertise like they do.
- red-iron-pine 2y agoyes