5 ms·
>they're just another startup playing the growth hacking game When is humanity going to start seeing some patches against these exploits? Is common sense still
by zahlman 2y ago
>they're just another startup playing the growth hacking game
When is humanity going to start seeing some patches against these exploits? Is common sense still in beta?
- LegitShady 2y agowhen the government regulates it. until then it will continue to the end of time.
- robertlagrant 2y agoThere are already laws for false advertising.
- mrguyorama 2y agoIn America? Barely. EVERYTHING can be called "puffery", which apparently makes it perfectly legal to make outright lies about your product, and if you instead merely pay someone who makes outright lies, apparently that's fine too if you didn't explicitly tell them to make those specific lies! In America, it is legal to call your uncarbonated soft drink "vitamin water"!
- glial 2y agoIdeally the legal system wouldn't be byzantine and prohibitively expensive for mere mortals to engage with.
- bell-cot 2y agoToo bad that the legal system is made of lawyers, whose interests run directly contrary to that ideal.
- digitaltrees 2y agoLegal systems becoming complex predates the emergence of lawyers. Lawyers have also led significant efforts to simplify the law. For example the American Bar Association has consistently created simple model statute frameworks that eventually are adopted. Law is complex because society is complex.
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> For example the American Bar Association has consistently created simple model statute frameworks that eventually are adopted. "Simple" is not an accurate description of typical model legislation. > Law is complex because society is complex. Law is complex because it's an evolved system influenced by politics and corruption. The extent of its complexity is not intrinsic and much of it is specifically a defense mechanism against public understanding, because the public wouldn't support many things in the status quo if they understood the workings of them, and the people who do understand the workings but prefer the status quo use this to their advantage.
- digitaltrees 2y agoYour description is not consistent with history. Politics and corruption are not outsized drivers of law. Especially case law built through the courts. It’s all edge cases. Try the example of drafting a standard apartment lease, over millions of transactions between landlords and tenants lots of edge cases emerge. So over time leases get more complicated. And then the law around interpretation and enforcement gets complicated.
- AnthonyMouse 2y ago> Politics and corruption are not outsized drivers of law. Especially case law built through the courts. It’s all edge cases. Case law is full of politics. How do you think courts resolve the ambiguities? If there was an objective standard for how to do it then judges could be replaced by computer programs. Judges are used instead because rigorous and consistent application of rules would lead to outcomes that are politically inexpedient, so judges only apply the rules as written when politics fails to require something different. > Try the example of drafting a standard apartment lease, over millions of transactions between landlords and tenants lots of edge cases emerge. So over time leases get more complicated. This is just a facet of how contracts and lawyers work. The law creates defaults that a contractual agreement can override, so each time the law establishes a default that landlords don't like but are allowed to change, they add a new clause to the lease to turn it back the other way. What they really want is a simple one-liner that says all disputes the law allows to be resolved in favor of the landlord, will be. But politics doesn't allow them to get away with that because what they're doing would be too clear to the public, so politics requires them to achieve the result they want through an opacifying layer of complexity.
- HPsquared 2y agoReminds me of the expression "in and of itself".
- gleenn 2y agoI think the same could be said software engineers. I don't engage with the general public about writing people's next brilliant idea because it's a hige waste of my time when I could be making FAANG bucks talking to people who know that I'm worth it. While I will alwatry to explain to my mom how the internet works etc, it's not economically justifiable to engage laymen tonsolve their probno matter how altruistic it may seem. I still have to pay the bills. How are lawyers any different?
- glial 2y agoLawyers are the interface between the public and the justice system -- which would exist whether software did or not. It's an access and equity issue: people with money have access to the legal system. People without largely don't.
- autoexec 2y agoI don't think anyone would argue that lawyers shouldn't get paid for their time, but in many cases their rates are excessive. When people's rights and freedom are at risk the cost should never be a barrier that most people can't afford to clear.
- freejazz 2y agoIs that your experience with traffic tickets?
- glial 2y agoSure - when I was a kid, I was speeding in a neighborhood (think 40 in a 30) and an annoyed cop charged me with reckless driving. The public defender recommended I plead guilty, pay a large fine and be put on probation for a year. I think a more expensive lawyer would have had different advice.
- freejazz 2y agoNothing about that sounds byzantine nor prohibitively expensive. Heck, you were provided an attorney for free.
- szundi 2y agoHuman lifespan is too short
- RankingMember 2y agoYep, need some way to image each new brain that comes online with some basics so it's not starting from 0 each time (and what basics to include would be a battle for the ages)
- imoverclocked 2y agoOof, no thanks. Part of our resilience comes from each generation observing and learning what the world actually is without all of the dogma from the previous generation. Instilling a set of basics is probably the worst thing we could do to fight against gaming humanity.
- RankingMember 2y agoI was more thinking (but didn't express) human history, not "do's and don'ts" but "this happened, draw your own conclusions".
- ruined 2y agoyou've just described public school
- dylan604 2y ago> Is common sense still in beta? Common sense has been deprecated. The system is just waiting for all of the modules with common sense preinstalled to sunset.
- antisthenes 2y ago> common sense still in beta? Common sense was relegated to a legacy feature status after "clout" and "fuck you got mine" were released. It will not see further updates and will be sunset shortly. Sorry for the inconvenience.
- notatoad 2y ago>When is humanity going to start seeing some patches against these exploits? i think that's called "consequences" and it's the subject of the article you're commenting on
- ratg13 2y agoYes, but the eternal cycle is: gain trust and then exploit trust. Some people gain enough trust that once they start to exploit it, that there often isn’t a mechanism to apply consequences. i.e. - politics
- zahlman 2y agoWhat I was getting at is: legal protections are good and necessary and all, but people try these things presumably because they work sometimes, and that fact bothers me. The idea that current generative AI tech - even if it were actually built to purpose - could actually fight for you in court, or output legal briefs that hold up to scrutiny and don't require review by a human expert, seems laughable to me. Law is definitely not a suitable field for an agent that frequently "hallucinates" and never questions or second-guesses your requests. There's so much that would have to go into such an AI system to be reliable, beyond the actual prose generation, that I certainly wouldn't a priori expect it to exist in 2024. If so many people are willing to take the claim at face value, that suggests to me a general naivete and lack of understanding of AI out there that really needs to be fixed. Aside from AI-related stuff, GGP mentioned "monthly subscriptions for services that most people need in a one-off manner". It's amazing to me that anyone would sign up for a monthly subscription to anything at all, without any consideration for whether they'd likely have a use for it every month.
- superfrank 2y agoNever? The term "snake oil salesman" has been around since the 1800s and that's effectively what most of these growth hackers are. I'm sure there are plenty of terms for the same practice of fraudulent marketing that predate that by centuries or even millennia. If you can hype people up enough about what you're selling and get them imagining how much better their live's will be using your product a certain number will buy into anything (in DNPs case, people imagine how much time and money they'll save on not using a lawyer). I wouldn't expect that to ever change.
- babyshake 2y agoNatural selection results in species succeeding that do some pretty brutal things. Natural selection also applies to religions, governments, and startups.
- bugtodiffer 2y agoHumanity isn't ready for communism yet :(