4 ms·
New California law requires one-click subscription cancellations
- yard2010 2y agoCan they also make it illegal to use evil methods such as making the CTA label "cancel" and mean "cancel the process, not your subscription"
- hcfman 2y agoReceive an E-mail, click on this link. What could possibly go wrong? Us common folk will never be smart enough to comprehend the wisdom of our leaders.
- chii 2y ago"please enter your credit card number to verify that you are you! include the 3 digit at the back for security verification!"
- novia 2y agoAfter moving to the Bay Area, I tried to do the old, "negotiate my bill with Comcast down by threatening to leave" trick, and instead it instantly cancelled my service. I was clicking around on the website trying to figure out how I could talk to the customer retention department when it happened. I think some companies have already complied with this law ahead of time.
- dspillett 2y agoOr perhaps they are/were being selective. If people on certain plans almost never hang around because of the extra steps and never move to a different product instead of leaving after taking to a rep, they might just let those customers go to save effort. This is particularly likely for services that were originally loss-leaders to get people in and the company makes nothing from them directly (or makes a small loss).
- whamlastxmas 2y agoThis is unlikely. A retention call is like fifty cents of labor costs for a decent chance at hundreds or thousands in continued profit
- noahjk 2y agoMy first thought was similar - assuming this is truly forcing websites to implement a “one-click” flow, I’m worried that people will accidentally unsubscribe without an easy way to pick up where they left off. At least an “are you sure?” button would be nice. (Although I hate companies who force me to choose a reason why I’m ending our relationship)
- beej71 2y agoI think a good compromise here is that if you click it, you land on a page that says you've unsubscribed with a resubscribe button on it.
- JusticeJuice 2y agoWhile I'm a bit dubious of how they'll define a 'one click' flow, this is a great move. Maybe auto-subscribing free trials can be banned next? I live in France, and they do everything possible to make subscriptions hard to cancel - I signed up to my gym online, but if I want to cancel it I need to send their headquarters a physical letter in the post, and expect a 4-6 week processing time haha.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoThere are a few services in Germany that you can use to cancel a wide range of things. They use exactly the right wording and channels with each of them. They'll send faxes, snail mail, etc. Take care of escalating, etc. Whatever needs doing. Kind of hilarious and sad at the same time that that is a thing.
- lencastre 2y agoDid you fax a blood sample to prove you are who you are when cancelling the service?
- JusticeJuice 2y agoI've seen similar services for France, I also find it hilarious haha.
- Semaphor 2y agoHuh, I thought the regulation that cancelling has to be possible the same way as signing up was EU-wide, but apparently it’s only in Germany then.
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoInteresting, I thought that was unique to the US. What I’m hearing is that Gym memberships are universally predatory. I’m a bit of a cynic and honestly I think Gym memberships somehow will find away to weasel out of this requirement.
- aneutron 2y agoAlso in France, curious which gym you are talking about. Went to the three _main_ commercial gym brands, and cancelling did NOT take more than a week including the letter arriving time in one case. The other two were online and with the branch staff.
- bugtodiffer 2y agoWhy do we need to regulate all this, I thought the market will do what customers want?
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoThat’s the biggest lie of capitalism. I do think in time it does work out largely in that direction but the windy road to get there is ripe with bear traps and pits of despair. To qualify that statement, if it doesn’t improve shareholder value, it doesn’t matter. And the worst CEOs will take the short term gain for their personal gain over what’s better for the company and thus customers long term.
- nikitaga 2y ago> in time it does work out largely in that direction To be fair, that's usually thanks to government interventions and regulations, not thanks to free market staying free. Markets fail for very known, very well described reasons. When they do, they rarely recover on their own, and the abusive rent seekers only become more entrenched with time (again, in the absence of regulations to curb that). In this startup community we see a lot of "disruption" (free-market-success) stories, but in the broader world, things don't usually work out that way, and when they do, it's often just to replace one rent seeker with another. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure
- SlightlyLeftPad 2y agoDefinitely, my intent wasn’t to hand wave away the role government plays there. The lag that is inherent in some regulatory departments though seems too long and it’s the working class that suffers to most. I think FAA and NASA are good examples of largely well-run departments while the SEC, EPA, and FDA appear to be largely a sham who really let corporations get away with literal murder to the detriment of the greater good. Things have to get extremely bad before they are able to do anything perhaps because their authority is stripped.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago
- PoignardAzur 2y agoThis obsession with regulating everything is why California will never have its own tech giants like Alibaba or ASML. Californian voters should just accept that an unregulated market is the only way to get any innovation at all.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoIs this serious? Do you know where most of the "FAANG" tech giants all hail from? Or where a bunch of VC's/accelerators are at? California is not left wanting for more tech innovation.
- lhoff 2y agonot the OP but pretty sure it was sarcasm and choosing ASML and Alibaba specially because they are based in countries that are not know for their lack of regulation.
- jbverschoor 2y agoAlibaba grew because of unregulated / taxfree and subsidized imported goods
- gwervc 2y agoSo not too unlike Amazon and its tax evasion schemes.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoRoger. Definitely some Poe's law here mocking regulation in earnest, so it's hard to tell.
- fragmede 2y ago> California will never have its own tech giants Might be quicker to name the tech giants that aren't in silicon valley
- andy_ppp 2y agoThey should do automatic un-enrolment if you aren't using services too...
- pintxo 2y agoAnd all this where the needed regulation is so simple: „one can cancel any subscription the same way it was started“. Started by clicking on a website? There must be an unsubscribe button. Sold at my doorstep? Next time your sales people try to sell me something, I can cancel with them. But I could also just go to any office/branch/shop and tell whoever works there that I hereby unsubscribe. You get the idea.
- izacus 2y ago> Sold at my doorstep? Next time your sales people try to sell me something, I can cancel with them. But I could also just go to any office/branch/shop and tell whoever works there that I hereby unsubscribe. Um, why though? If you bought it at the doorstep, you'll need to wait for 12 months before we come to your doorstep, whats this about "branches and shops"? You said "the same way" didn't you? ;)
- jstanley 2y agoIf they sold it at your doorstep I don't see why they shouldn't cancel it at theirs.
- falcor84 2y agoI'll one up you on that: every ecommerce company that ships to your door should also allow you to return the product via simple courier pick-up, with no more clicks required than the purchase.
- pintxo 2y agoOh, didn’t mention that because we (almost) have that here in Germany already ;-)
- AStonesThrow 2y agoThe trouble arises later on. Say five years down the road, or more. You've enjoyed this service but time to cut back. You forgot how you signed up. The website's different. The company was sold three times and changed domains. Worse, you're dead or incapacitated, and a loved one is trying to do this on your behalf. What needs to happen is a clear path working backwards from the bank charges to unsub. They're supposed to cram in enough info in the transaction line, but how many times is it a third-party with an all-zero phone number? Even worse are "discreet" or sensitive services such as porn, that are necessarily circumspect about the transaction details. That's why I really appreciate middlemen like PayPal. They've got a fantastic dashboard for recurring payments that puts control back in our hands (usually) and lets you simply override the vendor's autopay arrangement.
- verst 2y agoI'd be happy if Washington state even just had something matching the current CA Automatic Renewal Law (ARL) as amended in 2018 (e.g. online subscribers should be able to cancel online). Unfortunately we don't have this in Washington State. I can sign up for a recurring Seattle Times subscription online but cannot cancel or modify it online for example.
- whamlastxmas 2y agoYou can use a digital credit card like from privacy dot com, use CA as your address bc it doesn’t matter for those cards, and then get easy unsubscribe? You can also deactivate privacy cards in one click too
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- the_mitsuhiko 2y agoAustria requires consumer subscriptions to allow to be cancelled by email and the result has been a free website[1] that maintains a list of all the places you got to email to, lets you sign a cancellation letter with your government electronic id. I cancelled probably pretty much everything this way over the last 10 years and it has been great. [1]: https://www.online-kuendigen.at/ https://www.online-kuendigen.at/
- jhpacker 2y agoThere's nothing in the law that says one-click. It says, "A prominently located direct link or button which may be located within either a customer account or profile, or within either device or user settings." I think where the interpretation that one-click sub == one-click unsub is from this passage: "The ability to cancel or terminate an automatic renewal or continuous service pursuant to subdivision (c) or (d) shall be available to the consumer in the same medium that the consumer used in the transaction that resulted in the activation of the automatic renewal or continuous service, or the same medium in which the consumer is accustomed to interacting with the business, including, but not limited to, in person, by telephone, by mail, or by email." The idea being that one-click is a medium, which doesn't seem to be the intent here.
- Stem0037 2y agoI wonder how this will affect companies' retention strategies. They might need to focus more on providing actual value rather than relying on cancellation friction.
- valdrinNereth 2y agoThis is off-topic but, I really don't get why some of those websites are blocked for some countries. For example I'm trying to reach from Türkiye but it seems they blocked the access through here.
- lencastre 2y agoTry to cancel a Vodafone cable internet contarct in Germany. From the geography that gave you GDPR when will we have mandatory one-click unsubscribe, with clear cut explanations of will happen, additional costs if existing, and when the contract ends.
- gwbas1c 2y agoPersonally, I think this is the "wrong" fix. We should be targeting this law at the credit cards, not the companies: The credit cards should list all subscriptions in a single place on your credit card bill, and the credit cards should handle unsubscribe in a common, and consistent way.