6 ms·
Why Is Britain Poor?
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- onemoresoop 2y agoIs Britain poor or just the citizens?
- paulpauper 2y agoboth. everything is just so much more downsized compared to the US
- drumhead 2y agoThats the whole of Europe though.
- ForHackernews 2y agoAmerican giant cars and houses are kind of obscene and pointless. I realize others disagree, but as someone who has lived it I don't think the American lifestyle is aspirational.
- ta1243 2y agoThe American lifestyle certainly isn't, but compare Munich or Frankfurt or Berlin to Manchester or Leeds. Other European countries have their urban/rural problems - France has the Paris problem like the UK has the London problem, Germany has the East German town problem like Dresden and Leipzig, but Germany at least has Urban transport sorted. (Long distance is falling to bits mind)
- okasaki 2y agoEqually UK pseudo-adults in their 30s living in shoebox HMOs and spending an hour commuting on a shitty corona-bus for a trip that would take 10 minutes in a car isn't exactly great either.
- jedberg 2y agoAs my friend who works in British Government put it: If you remove London, the UK is about on par with Mississippi in terms of income and quality of life. People outside of London are poor. London banking and to some extent every other industry in London is basically carrying the entire country.
- gsky 2y ago[flagged]
- drumhead 2y agoIts a first class city with a second rate country attached to it. The problem is that outside of the London and the South East the rest of the country has a very begging bowl mentality. Its all about what government can give to them.
- tharmas 2y agoIt's attitudes like this why the UK is the way it is today. Shame on you.
- maxwellsdeamons 2y agoI wouldn't be surprised if this was true for most countries/states on this planet, also in the USA. Especially when the countries are as centralized as England and France. England without London loses like 20% of its population and probably even a higher percentage of its jobs. What is Mississippi if you remove 20% of it's population that lives in high-density urban areas?
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIt's not rural England that's poor, it's the non-London high-density urban areas.
- maxwellsdeamons 2y agoThis is not true for England https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_of_the_United_Kingdom_by_GRP_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_regions_of_the_United_... And it's not true for Mississippi: https://mdes.ms.gov/media/8639/pci.pdf https://mdes.ms.gov/media/8639/pci.pdf http://www.usa.com/rank/mississippi-state--population-density--county-rank.htm http://www.usa.com/rank/mississippi-state--population-densit... Relatively easy to disprove. The misinformation just fits the narrative better.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jmclnx 2y agoHad issues getting to the article, here is the archive https://web.archive.org/web/20240923160828/https://www.edwest.co.uk/p/why-is-britain-poor https://web.archive.org/web/20240923160828/https://www.edwes...
- gsky 2y ago[flagged]
- glenjamin 2y agoThis post is pretty much a paraphrasing of the "Foundations: Why Britain Has Stagnated" essay, which was discussed a few days ago and apparently ultimately got flagged. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600388
- csomar 2y agoIt has a different click-baity title: "Britain is poor". No Britain is not poor. Declining, maybe but definitively not poor.
- 4ndrewl 2y ago"The reason is that France ‘does a good job building the things that Britain blocks: housing, infrastructure and energy supply.’" Britain has roughly the same population as France, but France is approx 5 times the geographical area. This matters wrt building infrastructure. [edited to make clear the France is a larger country than Britain]
- drumhead 2y agoThe problem Britain has had in the last 30 years is that government was scared of offending Nimbys, so nothing got built. Not power infrastructure or homes. Even new airport runways. They're such a bunch of cowards.
- aetherson 2y agoYour pronoun antecedents got confused there, but just to be clear, France is 5x larger than the UK in terms of land area. I don't know that this really points in one direction or another. The UK might have more difficulty doing large projects due to being relatively "crowded" and having less free space, but on the other hand it might also benefit from needing to build less total mileage of road and rail, and for amenities which are mostly bound by the travel distance to them being needed in less quantity.
- 4ndrewl 2y agoFixed, thanks. Your point about total mileage of road/rail etc is interesting though isn't that contrary to the point the OP is making - building more stuff makes you richer?
- aetherson 2y agoBuilding infrastructure that gets productively used makes you richer, if the infrastructure costs less than the productive use of it. Spending more money for the same amount of infrastructure productivity is bad. There's no magic here where, ceteris paribus, spending more money on infrastructure is itself good.
- mempko 2y agoThe reason it's so poor is because for over 10 years it was run by a conservative government bringing austerity to the people, making them poor. They deliberately increased inequality. Inequality is a huge problem and it's disappointing this article ignores it and talks about private investment instead. It's rather silly. When the government doesn't spend, it makes people poorer. It's basic accounting.
- drumhead 2y agoPublic spending doesnt make countries or people rich. Its funded from taxes, which rely on economic growth, which we've had very little of since the 2008 reccession and banking meltdown.
- ForHackernews 2y agoWise public investment can absolutely spur growth: building trains, harbors, ports, school, hospitals, The Internet, etc. will pay off in spades and make society wealthier.
- drumhead 2y agoEconomic growth isnt that easy. "Build stuff and we'll be richer". We've grown as fast as France and faster than Germany over the last 5 years, but im sure they've spent more than we have on infrastructure.
- mempko 2y agoIt's not enough to look at averages. When growth happens, someone benefits. If you have a very unequal society, which the U.K. is, that benefit goes to only a few people. On paper it looks good, but the lived reality is different.
- retrac98 2y agoImportant detail - taxes don’t really fund anything. They’re just a means to control inflation. The government spends money and then taxes it back, not the other way around. The point here is tax revenue isn’t a blocker to smart investments in public services… Or at least it shouldn’t be.
- ForHackernews 2y agoPreviously flagged for some strange reason: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41600388 The people behind Foundations (and this author, since he's their buddy) are beating the same old drum: deregulation blah blah blah if only we cut the red tape and pave over everything with concrete then we'll all be rich! This essay is not that "groundbreaking" and their proposed solutions have been tried. We did Thatcherism! This feels like some right-of-center mirror of "True Communism has Never Been Tried(tm)". If only we deregulate even harder we'll be like America.
- BeetleB 2y ago> The people behind Foundations (and this author, since he's their buddy) are beating the same old drum: deregulation blah blah blah if only we cut the red tape and pave over everything with concrete then we'll all be rich! When it costs over a billion to build a mile of railway, you do have to wonder about how much red tape there is.
- mike_hearn 2y agoPeople make fun of the True Communism brigade because they're saying that if you did communism "right" the outcomes would be different to what actually happened. In this case people are saying that if you did Thatcherism again, the outcomes would be the same as what actually happened: the UK would catch up with the USA again, just like it did under Thatcher. So the comparison seems backwards. The essay writers aren't trying to claim Thatcher didn't do libertarianism correctly. It's easy to overlook how bad the situation was before Thatcher. Ed West has other articles where he talks about the situation in the mid 1970s. https://www.edwest.co.uk/p/the-worst-year-in-british-politics https://www.edwest.co.uk/p/the-worst-year-in-british-politic... in November 1973 ‘Heath announced his fifth state of emergency in barely four years. Floodlighting and electric advertising were banned; behind the scenes, the government began printing petrol ration cards. As the railwaymen voted to join the miners in pursuit of higher pay, it seemed that Britain was sliding into darkness. Offices were ordered to turn down their thermostats, while the BBC and ITV were banned from broadcasting after 10.30 at night. On New Year’s Day, with fuel supplies running dangerously low, the entire nation went on a three-day working week.’ As the new cabinet went to see the Queen, even the rooms at Buckingham Palace were unheated because of the energy crisis https://www.edwest.co.uk/p/britain-on-the-brink https://www.edwest.co.uk/p/britain-on-the-brink The capital had lost a million and a half people since its peak in 1939, and would continue its decline for another decade ... The country as a whole was haemorrhaging people, and in 1975 its population fell for the first time since records began. In the spring of 1974 applications for emigration to Canada went up 65 per cent, while New Zealand even felt compelled to put restrictions on people fleeing the old country. In 1950 Britain had 25 per cent of the world trade in manufacturing; by 1970 it was barely 10%, half of West Germany’s. Britain was now the second poorest country in the European Economic Community, and Tony Benn remarked that it was ‘heading for development area status in the EEC… with Germany more than twice as rich as we are.’ Robert Moss of the Economist wrote in February 1977. ‘The more I compare Britain with the countries that it still regards as it peers, the more I succumb to the uneasy feeling that [it] is becoming a Third World country.’ Britain had even become a cautionary tale, so that President Gerald Ford warned Americans: ‘It would be tragic for this country if we went down the same path and ended up with the same problems Great Britain has.’
- FridayoLeary 2y agoone point not discussed is the ongoing deconstruction of the middle class. They are the bedrock of any modern society and all really important and successful social changes start with a strong middle class.
- chiefalchemist 2y agoPerhaps one of the few positive benefits of British teenagers being hooked on TikTok is that, by viewing the lives of their contemporaries in the United States, they might come to appreciate just how poor their own country is. And meanwhile in America, we're propped up on debt. Federal debt*. Consumer debt. Thanks to such financial smoke & mirrors, our seats on the Titanic feel wonderful. Yes, thank gawd we're looking down. Thank gawd we're excessively TikTok'ing. Thank gawd no one can be bothered to ask, "How did we get here?" Thanks gawd we have "leadership" and politicians who don't dare own their role in putting us on the road to nowhere. * If you didn't catch the Steve Ballmer interview on Jon Stewart last week or so, highly recommended.
- taylodl 2y agoThat Steve Ballmer interview was excellent. It was a masterclass in how people seeing things differently can come together and talk things through. The sad thing is that American Corporate Media has gotten so bad I now have to resort to comedians to get insightful interviews and a "main street" perspective on the news.
- chiefalchemist 2y agoThe bit about servicing the Fed debt being the 4th largest line in the budget should have been a wake-up call for *everyone*. And that's just paying the interests, we're not even making a dent in lowering it. Those interest payments are services NOT being provided to taxpayers. But we're being told don't worry about it (i.e., the debt)? And everything is ok (with the economy)? That level of gaslighting is hard to stomach. Honestly, I didn't think Ballmer and Stewart disagreed all that much. Ballmer said, "I've got this data thing" and Jon's attitude was, "Great! But then how do we get off this crazy emotional-based cycle we're on now? Why is the media so shite?" The idea that the UK should be looking to the USA to envy its (faux) prosperity is a sad sick joke.
- taylodl 2y agoEven worse, that debt doesn't capture obligations such as social security. Reagan got us addicted to the heroin of debt after the Nixon Shock that effectively ended the Bretton Woods Agreement. Like all addicts, weening ourselves off our drug of choice isn't going to be easy. The pessimist in me sometimes thinks the Boomers are kicking the can down the road so the worst effects will be felt after they're in the grave.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI used to be (particularly around 2000) really interested in the history and literature of the time period 1965-1980 or so including the hippie phenomenon, Watergate, disco, inflation, etc. Lately though I took a look at https://www.amazon.com/Between-Two-Ages-Americas-Technetronic/dp/0313234981 https://www.amazon.com/Between-Two-Ages-Americas-Technetroni... and a conference proceedings about Brzezinski's ideas that came out in the next few years. Partially I wanted to roll my eyes at times because my interests have moved on but something that struck me was an essay by Paul Goodman which reflected a sentiment that was really common at that time to the effect that people were dogpiling into urban areas, that large cities were becoming unmanagable, that the exodus into urban areas had to be stopped, etc. This report was a relatively late one on the topic https://www.amazon.com/Dispersing-Population-America-Learn-Europe/dp/0815782144/ https://www.amazon.com/Dispersing-Population-America-Learn-E... which did not have any 1960s radical positioning but rather saw it is an almost universal political problem that the UK was too concentrated in London, France too concentrated in Paris, etc. All of these countries saw some need to do something about it. That kind of talk stopped abruptly circa 1980 when we got Reagan and Thatcher and competition between international economic centers seemed too fierce for, say, the UK to give up any competitiveness at all by dispersing its financial sector out of London. Today the message is overwhelmingly that people are more productive when they live in big cities thus it is an economic necessity for population to concentrate. There's a counternarriative now which is not positioned as a counternarriative that housing has become unaffordable in places with vibrant economies. As I see it is the old "large cities have become unmanageable" theme that's become crystalized. Right now it can seem like a political problem (e.g. existing residents, landlords, etc. profit from the current situation) but since growth is prevented through this mechanism there are many other problems we're not seeing (if California was adding as much population as it could could they afford infrastructure investments, could they handle environmental impacts, provision social services, etc.)
- mytailorisrich 2y ago> France is the most natural comparison point to Britain, a country ‘notoriously heavily regulated and dominated by labour unions.’ The UK is actually much more unionised than France is: 22% vs 10%. The difference is a culture of strikes, especially in public services and state-owned copanies, combined with a very high protection for strike action in France: The right to strike is actually in the French Constitution and requires neither recognised union nor ballot, but technically only to find another employee to agree with you.
- aftbit 2y agoOne anecdote from this article that shocked me was that French labor can kidnap their management as part of a strike action? That would get you thrown in jail here in the US, unless you happened to be a cop, in which case you can kidnap anyone you want.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoNo, they can't lawfully do that. And neither can they block roads, or seize and destroy trucks' cargo, etc. (which often happens) The issue is that the police (which in France is under government control) may be unwilling to intervene for political reasons. In the case of this "kidnapping" is must also depend on whether the police was called at all.
- aftbit 2y agoWhat do you call the "Overton window" of illegal behavior? e.g. In the US, you can pretty reliably speed at up to 10 mph over the legal speed limit without actually getting stopped or arrested. Similarly, you can probably get away with drinking beer in a state park, and nobody will report you to the rangers, even though it is illegal (at least in my state, YMMV). On the other hand, if you try to kidnap your boss, people will 100% call the cops, and anyone involved would be looking at sentences including multiple years in prison. In some stores in some cities, you can get away with small-value shoplifting without anyone really batting an eye, while if you try to steal a TV from Best Buy near me, you are going to get tackled. I'm curious what one might search to learn more about the range of illegal behaviors that are actually tolerated in any given society.
- zarzavat 2y agoBritain is one of the richest countries on Earth (21st in terms of GDP/capita, and many countries ranked above it are tiny ones). This compares favourably to its most similar neighbour, France (23rd), which also suffered the same economic shocks of WW2 and decolonisation. A more accurate title might be "Why is the US so rich?". The answer to this is simply that the US has profound natural resources, and the US did not have to engage in defensive total war during WW2 so all of those resources could be put to an economic purpose for the entire 20th century. The US never had to go through decolonisation because it long ago decided to exterminate the native people instead. Britain's wealth was tied up in far away colonial dominions that understandably wanted to take that wealth with them. Anyone who has seen more of the world than the US and Europe can appreciate that Britain is not poor under any meaningful definition of the word. It's an economically average medium-sized Western European country.
- BeetleB 2y ago> A more accurate title might be "Why is the US so rich?" The article has nothing to do with the US. > Britain is one of the richest countries on Earth (21st in terms of GDP/capita, and many countries ranked above it are tiny ones). This compares favourably to its most similar neighbour, France (23rd), which also suffered the same economic shocks of WW2 and decolonisation. And yet, as the article points out, the French populace and infrastructure is doing far better than the UK's. Everything you point out (decolonization, etc) is as true of the French as it is of the British. Yet, one of the major themes of the article is comparing the UK with France.
- ivell 2y ago>>Britain's wealth was tied up in far away colonial dominions that understandably wanted to take that wealth with them. Any citations on Britain's wealth being tied up? At least in case of India, it was reverse with Britain extracting wealth out of India for most of its stay. It is like saying a thief's money is tied up in the house they wanted to robe.
- ta1243 2y agoLand is the problem. The cost and the restrictions on it. The right like to paint this as "too much protection for newts", the left as rich pensioners not wanting solar to "spoil their view", but regardless the inability for us to JFDI is the root cause. Of course even when we can do it, the land owners extract all the value. While the working man paid for crossrail with a little input from businesses which benefited, the people that really benefited were London land owners, who saw their land near crossrail stations balloon in value even more.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoWithout arguing about the "right or wrong" of the whole thesis as it applies to Britain, as an American I thought this paragraph definitely held a good warning for the US: > Because only the best paid people can afford to move to the most prosperous cities, there is no longer general migration across the economic spectrum, as there was in the nineteenth century when it was the poorest people who were most likely to move to find better work. Today, this has created a situation where only the most gifted and educated people can afford to move to richer cities and stay there. Their less well-off peers are quite literally “left behind”, and compete with one another over a narrow pool of jobs, driving the wages down even further, making those places feel even more deprived. Most cities in the US have gotten insanely expensive, primarily due to housing costs. As someone who lives in Austin TX, I've seen it first hand with people in non-tech jobs just concluding that they can have at least an easier quality of life if they move to someplace cheaper. But Austin also should serve as a glimmer of hope, because since the peak of pandemic-house-price insanity of about early/mid 2022, house prices (and especially rents) have dropped considerably, bucking the national norm. The primary reason is that Austin and surrounding areas built a shit ton of housing (especially multi-family) starting right around 2020, with a lot of that coming online just in the past couple years. I think it's rare and usually a mistake when one tries to tie so many societal ills to a single cause, but in this case I believe doing everything possible to build a crap load of new housing in desirable areas is the #1 thing to do to fix so many of today's societal problem. Not a "cure-all", and I'm also not saying it's politically easy, but I think it would give the biggest bang-for-the-buck given that so much of are problems today are due to people becoming disillusioned that they can ever really afford a stable, comfortable, "opportunity-providing" residence. I've often said myself I feel lucky to have gotten on the "property train" early in my career, as without the increased equity value in my home I wouldn't be able to afford to buy here now.
- TMWNN 2y agoIn England, "the north" is seen as poor and "the south" is seen as rich, and the north is indeed much poorer than the south. In 1964, the Oxford Union debated "When going North, wogs begin at Barnet" <http://books.google.com/books?id=fGI3Bgy54OcC&lpg=PA15&pg=PA15#v=onepage&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=fGI3Bgy54OcC&lpg=PA15&pg=PA...>; while humorous, of course, it was based on a real perception in "the south" of "the north". In this video of northern Brexit voters <https://vimeo.com/172932182 https://vimeo.com/172932182>, people talk about "the south" as if it were a foreign country that they could never move to, with wealth their region could never hope to achieve. This is very different from in the US, where New Yorkers might similarly call anything west of the Hudson River <http://www.hoodedutilitarian.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/steinberg-newyorker.jpg http://www.hoodedutilitarian.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/...> "rural" or "the West", but, generally speaking, wouldn't make the distinction based on a perceived wealth gap. No New Yorker would claim that Dallas or Atlanta or Phoenix or Pittsburgh or Boise is "poor", nor would the residents of those cities concede that NYC is wealthier (as opposed to larger or more glamorous or more exciting). I've made this point elsewhere. Quoting myself <http://np.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/1eymi7/number_of_cities_larger_than_the_capital1425x761oc/ca579as?context=3 http://np.reddit.com/r/MapPorn/comments/1eymi7/number_of_cit...>: --- Consider the US's 10 largest metro areas <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_metropolitan_areas http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_metropoli...>: In order, NYC (~7% of the total US population), LA (~5%), Chicago (3%), DC, San Francisco Bay area, Boston, Philly, Dallas, Miami, and Houston. They comprise one third of the country's population and the list is overall a very balanced one: * 3 in the Northeast, 1 in the mid-Atlantic, 1 in the Southeast, 1 in the Midwest, 2 in TX, 2 on the West Coast * 5 in the Sunbelt, 5 not * 5 on the East Coast, 5 not * 5 on the East Coast, 2 on the West Coast, 3 in between Etc., etc. Now, consider this map of the UK <http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom#Demographics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom#Demographics> and this list of the largest UK urban areas <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_urban_areas_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_urban_areas_in_the_Uni...>. Note how, other than London, only one (Southampton/Portsmouth) of the top ten is below the Severn Wash line. Greater London is gigantic, relatively speaking, compared to its US counterparts--13% of the entire country's population (!)--and has no national peers the way LA and Chicago are real rivals to NYC. This causes a huge imbalance, wherein London 1) sucks up most of the capital and human energy that would otherwise supply cities south of the Severn Wash, and 2) sucks up much of the capital and human energy that would otherwise supply the country north of the Severn Wash. No region of the United States is grossly wealthier or poorer than others to the extent that the Severn Wash in the UK divides the poor north with the wealthy south. ---- The previous Conservative government mentioned forming a "Northern Powerhouse" <http://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/elections2015/election2015/12865823.Labour_would_damage_Northern_Powerhouse_vision__warns_Chancellor/ http://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/news/elections2015/ele...> to help relieve the above imbalance. Devolution can't be only at the home-nation level, though, because England is so much larger than the other three combined. If England wants Scotland to stay in the union, it will have to break itself up for unity's sake. Regional devolution will hopefully give the new states/provinces a chance to compete with Greater London on a more equal footing and, as in other federations around the world, come up with innovative, local-specific solutions to their own issues.
- _aavaa_ 2y agoNot one word about colonialism. Just economic navel gazing about productivity measures lacking all context of the major contraction in the British empire. "When my parents were born, Britain had been the richest country in Europe for a century". No questions as to why Britain was the richest country. No mention of India.
- amriksohata 2y agoBritain transferred trillions of wealth from India. India and China were the top 2 richest countries in the world before the Empire.
- _aavaa_ 2y agoYes, that's my point. You can't discuss why Britain isn't as well off as it used to be, without at least acknowledging where that past wealth came from.
- mytailorisrich 2y agoThey did not get relatively poorer because they were plundered. The UK and Europe became much richer thanks to industrialisation, etc while others stagnated in their "old" world. In fact, one reason for the current situation in the UK is that most of those old industries which were the foundation of the country's prosperity disappeared but were not always replaced.
- polotics 2y agoOh maybe you missed the analysis pieces from the Victorian era that explain very logically and with great authority why india can never be anything else than agricultural and backwards, and the looms are best placed in Great Industrial Britain? There was massive plunder, extermination of any that would raise their heads, and great damage imposed by the crown on its brown subjects. You just wait.
- Gud 2y ago“You just wait”?
- Esras 2y agoPositives upfront: I appreciate that the article is trying to describe a complex topic, and many of the issues described are shared by us here in the US. It does cite different statistics of other nations as comparisons, and calls out that access to jobs, ease of movement, and housing are all things that help make countries wealthy. Now for the downsides. I feel like this article maintains a tone throughout that I might describe as "dismissive nationalism." The comparison against France is preceded by a paragraph that, due to the framing, is presented as ludicrous, proceeds to describe all of the things France does better, and then somehow still makes the claim that Britain has "many advantages." Perhaps that's intended in a vacuum, but with how hard it's pushing for private investment (to the extent that it touts all that earlier infrastructure in Britain as "built by a total of 1,116 private companies" and that it describes the State's role as functionally just exercising eminent domain), it's hard to overlook. And while the underlying paper is discussing foundational, long-term effects, that there isn't a single mention of Brexit in the article feels stark in contrast to the conclusory statement by the paper's authors of "it is vital that Britain should once more have the strength and self-belief of 1939 with which to play its part in the leadership of the free world." --- I'm not an expert in economics (as my critique above might have clued you in), but I do think it's important to be careful in which experts you choose to listen to. I also don't know the biases that this particular publication or the underlying paper subscribe to. I may try read the Foundations paper (https://ukfoundations.co/ https://ukfoundations.co/ - it's not that long), but if this article is summarizing well and is all, then it feels "too shallow." What's the underlying mechanism that got them to that state? If the proposed solution is "allowing more private investment," then what about all of the social shifts that happened in the meantime? NIMBYism is brought up as "logical" given the incentives at one point, but I'd argue it's fundamentally a social issue, related to a perceived quality of life and a lack of perception of a larger group as being part of "your community." I digress. Thanks for sharing the link, and I hope others with more of an economic / politics background might have more fruitful critique.
- janice1999 2y ago> I may try read the Foundations paper (https://ukfoundations.co/ https://ukfoundations.co/ - it's not that long) > What's the underlying mechanism that got them to that state? It's the people behind the ukfoundations.co site who got Britain to its current state. The site is literally the work of Adam Smith Institute members whose Thatcherite neoliberal policies have dominated the UK since the 70s.
- alach11 2y agoWe have an amazing global experiment where we can watch different forms of governance succeed and fail. One of democracy's greatest failings is the slow creep of bureaucracy. The elevation of the self over society inexorably leads to a state where regulation and special interest groups strangle progress. Now watch as China scoops up more land to develop another 1000 miles of HSR...
- illuminant 2y agoSnakes in the grass. Despise not what you covet in another, for that is hypocrisy. Democracy's greatest failing is that it does not favor self solutions over public rigamarole. China isn't why Americans are ignorant, confused, and not the fountainhead of solutions. We have lost our way, turn from your incredulity to the path of the undeceiver.
- tharmas 2y agoJust compare the Banking systems in the UK to Germany and that will tell you everything you need to know. Germany has Community Banks that lend money to local entrepreneurs to make things. UK Banks (highly centralized and Big) only lend money to buy assets.
- tpoacher 2y agoA fine example of the Bulverism fallacy indeed. The article might as well have tried to explain why all senior citizens have syphilis these days.
- cykros 2y agoWhen your major export is financial services, the wealth doesn't typically spread around all that much. There are plenty of Britons that aren't poor; just look at the City of London. Building out the monetary and trade networks they did enabled them to buy their goods where the labor was a lot cheaper (and more abundant) than it was in Britain. Same reason Americans are poor -- ever since Wilson we've barely been effectively a separate country in the first place. The only big difference, and why Americans aren't quite as poor on average, is that America still has natural resources. Britain's got some oil, but not a ton else -- their resources previously came from their colonies.