12 ms·
EU Commissioner Will Simply Ignore Any Rejection Of ACTA By EU Parliament
- moe 14y agoTruly the best democracy that money can buy... When voting doesn't work, perhaps we should try a kickstarter? Groupon?
- sasvari 14y agoand (european) politicians wonder about people's disillusionment with politics and lack of identification with the european union.
- shahidhussain 14y agoWe discussed this a little on Reddit[1] a while back, some of us fired off emails to our local MEPs on the topic, there was a small demonstration, but frankly we didn't make a loud enough noise to be heard. [1] http://www.reddit.com/r/unitedkingdom/comments/osobb/after_writing_to_my_meps_about_acta_got_a_letter/http://www.reddit.com/r/unitedkingdom/comments/osobb/after_writing_to_my_meps_about_acta_got_a_letter/ http://www.reddit.com/r/unitedkingdom/comments/osobb/after_w...
- Nursie 14y agoThe commission needs to be neutered before the EU can be considered truly democratic. The fact that this guy can come straight out and say he's going to ignore court rulings and the democratic will of the elected MEPs with no fear of reprisals, because he's not elected, yet he can hold so much power ... it's sick.
- paol 14y agoSadly the parliament is essentially a powerless organ by design. The problem is that the european commission accumulates both executive power and most of the legislative power, where the later should lie with parliament. The end result is that the parliament is basically a farcical attempt to give the appearance of democratic legitimacy to the EU legislative process, but the farce is transparent enough that it just ends up tainting the public perception of the EU institutions. There are political reasons for this arrangement of course, but I don't want to turn this into (more of) a rant. [EDIT: I end up going into that in this other post: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4161285 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4161285]
- Angostura 14y agoThe EP can impeach the Commission - unfortunately only the whole Commission rather than an individual Commissioner.
- rwallace 14y agoSounds like it's time for them to do just that - if this sort of open contempt for the democratic process and the rule of law doesn't qualify as adequate grounds, nothing does. What's the best channel by which to call for that action?
- Luc 14y agoThis is just sophistry now. The commissioner is playing the role he's supposed to play in the EU institutions, and I have seen no indication that he's done anything illegal or held the parliament in contempt.
- cabalamat 14y ago> I have seen no indication that he's done anything illegal or held the parliament in contempt He's said he will ignore the decisons arrived at by the democratically elected representatives of the people. That seems a pretty clear indication to me.
- BHSPitMonkey 14y agoWhat the parent commenter is saying is that he is technically acting within the legal bounds of his office. That is, impeachment will be impossible unless an actual violation of law is found.
- cabalamat 14y ago> That is, impeachment will be impossible unless an actual violation of law is found. The European parliament can't impreach the commission. What it can do is sack them (but all of them, not just one). No evidence of illegality is needed.
- beeneto 14y agoHe didn't say he'd ignore court rulings. He told the trade committee (which isn't a court AFAIK) that advising against ACTA wouldn't stop the European court of justice from investigating its legality.
- Nursie 14y agoHe mentioned that he would try to weasel his way around it - "If the Court questions the conformity of the agreement with the Treaties we will assess at that stage how this can be addressed."
- webreac 14y agoIn fact this guy clarified the rules he must follow.<br> Sadly, the parliament decision has no influence on his work.
- vidarh 14y agoThe alternative reading is that in the case either of the parliament or the ECJ rejects the current agreement, he will try to find a compromise that can get the approval of both. While it is possible that he wants to try to weasel a procedural end-run around rejections, what he's actually said does not provide any basis for jumping to that conclusion.
- s4ndb 14y agoDon't forget about the European Council, the third power base in Europe, by far the strongest, and by far the least public. Could use some serious neutering too. Of the three power bases, only the parliament is democratic, and it has almost no powers. I agree. The way we do politics in Europe, birthplace of democracy, is just sick.
- facorreia 14y agoEU is not supposed to be democratic.
- Kudos 14y agoAnd yet it has a democratically elected parliament.
- iuguy 14y agoWhich looks like a soap opera at best and has no teeth as all the decisions are made at the commission and council level. It also has precious little by way of financial transparency or accountability to the public it claims to represent.
- nickik 14y agoThats why the EU (in its current form) should never have existed.
- vidarh 14y agoThe issue here is that the EU currently is a de facto confederation. The EU parliament can not be, and is not, the supreme legislative body for the simple reason that the member states are still sovereign, with the ability to withdraw (though there are some legal questions in some member countries about how that would be possible). It is the same issue facing the US under the Articles of Confederation, where Congress was effectively powerless to do anything without full agreement of the states. However the EU "worked around" this in part with the Council and Commission functioning as a sort of an "office of the president" (consisting of heads of the member states and the head of the Commission and a separate Council president) and cabinet respectively, with power delegated from the respective governments of the member states rather than from the parliament. It is a "workaround" for the fact that a federal EU is currently entirely unpalatable to the electorate in most European countries to make the EU governable - ironically because people are worried about giving the EU more power, while the current arrangement is worse in that regard.
- cabalamat 14y ago> It is a "workaround" for the fact that a federal EU is currently entirely unpalatable to the electorate in most European countries I'm sure in every EU country, most voters would prefer it if the unelected commission couldn't overrule the elected parliament.
- iuguy 14y agoUnfortunately what most voters would prefer is largely irrelevant due to the current structure.
- vidarh 14y agoProbably. But the point is you can't do that in a binding way without having the national governments cede sovereignty through constitutional amendments, which instantly causes public uproar. E.g. under the UK constitution (yes, the UK has a constitution, it is just not codified in a single act) the UK Parliament is sovereign, to the extent that it can not even bind future parliaments. So without tricky constitutional changes (particularly tricky because parliament has pretty much "bootstrapped" its own constitutional powers in the UK into a position were giving them away again will need to be very carefully structured to stand up in court) it is pretty much impossible to grant the EU parliament any real power. This is part of why the current structure of the EU uses a web of treaties to bind the executives of the member states in various to seek the passage of local laws to implement EU directives, with convoluted measures to cajole the national legislatives to follow through. It's still not ironclad - plenty of directives languish in national parliaments for years before being implemented (or get implemented with inconsistent differences in different member countries) exactly because the EU has very few means to push it through - but it's a far stronger method than trying to tie the national parliaments with no constitutional support.
- RachelF 14y agoThe EU is not democratic. It goes to great lengths to avoid referendums by its subjects on whether they wish to be part of the EU or not. If they do have a referendum and the result is not what the EU wants, another is held.
- aerique 14y agoDepends on the member country. Here in The Netherlands after an unfavorable referendum we just renamed the issue, put a new cover on it and pushed it through without a referendum two years later.
- ajuc 14y agoI wonder if we could make some big demonstration in Poland just before the EURO 2012 semi-final matches. Or smuggle big banners to the stadium. But they are just going to ignore it, right. No accounatability whatsoever.
- mibbitier 14y agoGood news. Strengthens the case significantly for the EU to be abandoned.
- Jacqued 14y agoAnd where would that leave us ? Massive recession in Germany, Bankrupcy for the southern nations, a few hurt nations (France, Italy, others) closing their borders to try to survive on their own, and the UK surviving as a dependency of the US. With fascist parties triumphing everywhere around (they are already doing 20%+ in a lot of countries, there are even nazis in the Greek parliament now). And, of course, global economy hurting like never before, since a majority of it still happens in good ol Europe. Yup. Let's kill the EU.
- ajuc 14y agoWhich are these fascist parties in Europe? Seriously, I live in Europe and never seen any. In most EU countries propagating nazi ideology is criminal offense.
- gioele 14y agoSearch for "party" in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-nazism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-nazism , https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_neo-Nazi_organizations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_neo-Nazi_organizations and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-fascism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neo-fascism . Every European country has a nation-wide neo-fascist party and almost all the parliaments of south-Europe have MPs who publicly stated their fascist ideology. The latest to win seats in parliament is the Greek Golden Dawn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Dawn_(Greece) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Dawn_(Greece)
- johncoltrane 14y agoHe is taking an easy shortcut (nationalist == nazi) but his message stands: however you call it the ideological family to which once belonged the Nazis and their friends is making progress everywhere in Europe. The FN here, in France being the first example that comes to my mind but similar things happen in the Nederlands, in Spain, in Italy, in Greece, in Austria… We are far from the Germany-1933 situation, but we don't want it to come back do we?
- beeneto 14y agoSince I know techdirt always reports aggressively in favour of internet freedom I read the direct quotes first and the techdirt commentary afterwards. From just the quotes, Karel De Gucht doesn't seem to be saying anything underhanded, just that if parliament doesn't ratify ACTA it will be modified (presumably toned down?) and resubmitted. I don't think techdirt's message "The european government is a corrupt puppet!" is supported by the evidence in this article. Personally the fact that every committe which has reviewed ACTA has advised against it gives me hope.
- sasvari 14y agojust that if parliament doesn't ratify ACTA it will be modified (presumably toned down?) and resubmitted ACTA can't be modified anymore, it is signed (yet not ratified in the EU)! Edit: style
- beeneto 14y agoAh okay, so when he says "I would consider proposing some clarifications to ACTA" he's just blowing smoke - talking about making cosmetic statements about ACTA which would encourage parliament to ratify it, but wouldn't actually fix the abuse cases that come from the vague wording?
- yread 14y agoWhenever I hear a politician talk about "clarifications" alarm bells ring in my head. It basically means changing marketing not the facts.
- antninja 14y agoYeah, we remember how the constitution, which has been rejected by referendums, became the "simplified treaty": exactly the same text but with articles moved, rephrased, obfuscated. The polite way to describe the EU is as a very-indirect democracy.
- 14y ago
- Jacqued 14y agoWe clearly need to rebuild European Institutions from the ground up. I'm fully in favor of the European Union as a federal state but to achieve this it is mandatory for the European institutions to stop relying on country representatives or people who were just nominated and rely instead on elected people (and their representatives i.e. a prime minister for the European parliament for example), like in any proper democracy. It is also a clear sign that despite all the efforts put out in the last few years, associations and companies that are willing to protect Internet freedom are not spending enough money and energy on actually doing it. Not nearly as much as the dying copyrighted and closed content industry anyway.
- paol 14y agoI would love to see things move in this direction. Unfortunately we are in the minority (even among those who self-describe as pro-european).
- LaGrange 14y agoThe problem here is, that while it would increase the democracy of EU, it would also decrease perceived sovereignty of individual countries. A lot of progress in EU seems to be hampered by OMG NATIONAL IDENTITY, actually, and democratization is just one of those.
- ajuc 14y agoI don't understand, why having Commision that isn't elected makes EU members more suvereign? What would change for worse, if Commision was elected like Parliament?
- paol 14y agoThe commission basically represents the governments of the individual member countries. Because it has the most power by far of all the european institutions, this means that the governments in turn can exercise power at the EU level in a fairly unimpeded fashion. If the legislative power were transferred away from the commission to the parliament (where it should be, if EU governance were to follow the standard approach for separation of powers), the individual member states would lose a lot of control. Control they aren't at all interested in relinquishing, as you may imagine. And that's before even considering making the executive branch (the commission) directly elected.
- gorm 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_deficit_in_the_European_Union http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_deficit_in_the_Europ...
- tete 14y agoDescription of EU: Parliament: Good Commission: Bad
- msfd 14y agoThat guy was a shame when he was a minister of foreign affairs back in Belgium, creating multiple diplomatic incidents and controversies (with the Netherlands - calling the prime minister a mix of harry potter and a rigid bourgeois, the Congo, the jewish community, etc), it's no wonders he's a shame in the EU...
- seclorum 14y agoThis is why the EU is not in fact a democracy, but a benign totalitarian fascist state. Member states, do not, in fact, control the governing policies being enforced on them by their masters.
- apk17 14y agoAnd where do you think the people in the commission come from? National governments; what happens there is simply that stuff that couldn't be made to pass nationally gets readministered via the EU. Besides, the EU is not a 'state'.
- seclorum 14y agoWho voted for the EU President? (Nobody: He was installed by Heads of Industry from the member states..) >Besides, the EU is not a 'state'. Yup, and therein lies the problem.
- SagelyGuru 14y agoCome back Nigel Farage http://www.nigelfaragemep.co.uk/ http://www.nigelfaragemep.co.uk/ All is forgiven! Watch some of his videos laying into the commissioner(s) at the EU parliament. Quite amusing but it seems to be just what they need and deserve.
- spindritf 14y agoHis site seems to be down, here's a Youtube channel with recordings https://www.youtube.com/user/europarl https://www.youtube.com/user/europarl
- hipponax3 14y agoDo you realise that UKIP were about the only party that voted against the EU parliament's call to have the details of the ACTA negotiations made public?
- davidhollander 14y agoI'm not European but my understanding was that they literally vote no against everything as some sort of protest? Their statement if this is the correct vote you are referring to: "Whilst we as a group voted against the ACTA Resolution on Wednesday 10th March 2010, we did so on the principle that the ACTA Treaty itself should not exist in any form. It is a catastrophic violation of individual private property. Had we voted to support the Resolution, we would be recognising the existence of such legislation and on that basis we decided not to recognise the Treaty." http://www.ukipmeps.org/mypage_11_ExpVote.html http://www.ukipmeps.org/mypage_11_ExpVote.html
- digitalengineer 14y agoBrussels is starting to look like Moscow. Check out this old Russian Guy that lived through the rise of the Sovjets talk about the striking similarities: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=m41Tdl5mvdg http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=m...
- chris_wot 14y agoIf the GFC doesn't destroy the EU, then ACTA will. How unfortunate.
- yaix 14y agoThe problem here is that the voters in the Netherlands and in France have rejected the EU Constitutial Treaty in 2004 that would have given the EU Parliament much more power. The "replacement" Treaty of Lisboa did not go that far. But anyway, this is just negotiation what the dude is doing (although not very smart negotiation, imho). The ACTA is dead, it was rejected by a number of country governments, and the EU parliament will probably reject it too. Btw, the commission is elected, but not directly. It is elected by the governments of the member countries, each representing the people of each country. However, it would be nice to be able to vote for those guys directly. But, because of language problems (english anybody? France? Germany?) that is not (yet) practical.
- josteink 14y agoSomeone this determined to do something so wrong cannot be assumed to be neutral. This guy must be corrupt and on someone's pay-list. It would be in the EU's interest to start an investigation of Karel De Gucht to determine if this person is bribed and if these proceedings is a result of corruption. The EU would be wise to do so for its own business sake and before it's perception as a democratic body is tarnished in favour of a US-led corrupt legislative-body. If the EU loses its perception as democratic, chances are that the rich and populous democracies which funds it will be forced to stop doing so. If it's one thing the EU cannot afford right now, that is one of them.
- PotatoEngineer 14y agoHe doesn't have to be corrupt; he simply has to believe that ACTA is good for Europe. If he's trying to circumvent various obstacles in his way, it's because he thinks they're wrong.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat doesn't necessarily make it any better.
- jhdevos 14y agoEuropean commissioners have two undesirable attributes: * Far too much power * Low public visibility If they perceive their job as "governing this part of the world without paying much attention to what lesser people are saying", then that is partly because we have defined their job in that way. (And, of course, that will attract the wrong kind of people). Reform is needed.
- Joeri 14y agoHe's currently under investigation by the belgian authorities for tax evasion. But i doubt he's actually been bribed in this case. He's the sort of guy who genuinely believes ACTA is not only desirable but absolutely essential.
- iuguy 14y ago> It would be in the EU's interest to start an investigation Unfortunately the EU's track record isn't very good in this regard[1]. > If the EU loses its perception as democratic I can't speak for everyone but the EU is not a democratic institution (in terms of direct or participatory democracy) and some people understand this. > chances are that the rich and populous democracies which funds it will be forced to stop doing so. No, they're forced to fund it whether they want to or not. The entire Euro currency crisis persists because there is no organised or planned way for a country to leave the Euro. In any other situation the PIGGS would've left by now and could've inflated their way out. Instead the Eurozone countries in the north are stuck with the countries in the olive belt for better or worse and it's hurting all sides. Likewise, there is no documented and planned way for a country to leave the EU. [1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marta_Andreasen#Concerns_over_EC.27s_accounting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marta_Andreasen#Concerns_over_E...
- horsehead 14y agoFuck the man!! That's slang for "This guy is off his god damn rocker." People like this who have such blatant disregard for proper procedure should be castigated into humiliation.
- accountswu 14y agoThere have been protests or at least a discussion about it in Europe; Western Europe as well as Eastern Europe. The US has already signed it without much problem. Surely the majority of Americans would not have wanted their President to sign it, but now that it has been signed it would take a lot more effort to kill it. http://digitaljournal.com/article/318690 http://digitaljournal.com/article/318690 Op-Ed: Obama signed ACTA in violation of Constitution, say critics
- shellox 14y agoWell, the EU is already experienced with lobby work. It shouldn't be a big surprise for the most.
- mjwalshe 14y agoWith my wonk hat on sounds like an MEP needs to put up a motion of "no confidence" in this particular Commissioner. the MEP's aprove comissioners and therefore must have the ability to censue or remove them. as "The Parliament may also block certain Commission decisions where there has been a delegation of powers to the Commission and may repeal such delegation of powers." If a Commissioner directly states that they will ignore the will of parliment they deserve every thing they get