4 ms·
Clearly no, and we have two opinions now from federal courts explaining why. Maybe they can appeal it to the Supreme Court and get a 3rd, taking this question o
by tptacek 2y ago
Clearly no, and we have two opinions now from federal courts explaining why. Maybe they can appeal it to the Supreme Court and get a 3rd, taking this question off the table categorically for the next 30 years.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> Clearly no Please don't do this. I'm not talking about what the law is, I'm talking about what it can be. You are not responding to my argument.
- tptacek 2y agoThe law we're talking about does not in fact date back to player pianos or s's that look like f's; it's been continuously refined all the way into the 21st century. So I think it matters a great deal what it actually says now.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> The law we're talking about does not in fact date back to player pianos or s's that look like f's; it's been continuously refined all the way into the 21st century. It has been partially updated but not enough. > So I think it matters a great deal what it actually says now. I never implied otherwise. A suggestion for change is by definition based on the current version.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoYour comment was in response to an argument about what the law is. This entire thread is about a court case, which deal with what the law is. You're in no position to accuse others of not responding on-topic.
- Dylan16807 2y agoI didn't accuse tptacek of being off-topic, I accused him of a non sequitur.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoDo you not know what "non sequitur" translates to or something?
- Dylan16807 2y agoHis comment, despite being placed as a reply to mine, did not address what I was arguing. I'm particular the "clearly no" does not work. The "clear" thing was not what I was contesting. And I want to state here that I don't want to relitigate anything in the original discussion. I'm only replying because you seem to misunderstand what this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41607486 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41607486 meant in the first place and I'm willing to explain in other wording what it meant.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoThis is a stunning lack of self-awareness.
- Dylan16807 2y agoDo you want to explain that in any way, or do you just want to be rude while you keep saying incorrect things about my comments? In particular, I never accused anyone of being off-topic. Early in this conversation I made a comment that shifted the topic slightly, but was also a reply to the argument in the parent comment. tptacek's reply to me was not a reply to the argument in my comment. It was arguing past me. Or I could say it was strawmanning me, but that makes it sound too intentional. I think that situation is pretty simple. It also seems pretty simple that you misunderstood my comment #41607486. What's your actual criticism, other than the incorrect idea that I accused tptacek of being off-topic, and other than vague petty snipes?
- Phiwise_ 2y agoThis game of repeating my argument back to me but worse has gotten old.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hollerith 2y agoYour argument is naive and a little absurd.