3 ms·
> However, it's not fair use to copy material and redistribute it. You mean permanent copies, right? Then the IA doesn't disagree. They just want to loan out
by Dylan16807 2y ago
> However, it's not fair use to copy material and redistribute it.
You mean permanent copies, right? Then the IA doesn't disagree. They just want to loan out one digital copy while the original is locked up, in an attempt to emulate not making copies as closely as possible in a digital world.
> Furthermore, the creator should be able to determine the format of the release of their work. If someone wants to alter their work, they must do so in a transformative manner and not pass it off as the creator's work.
> Someone who makes a book with formatting specific to say a PDF, could be unfairly reviewed or judged by readers who borrowed distributed copies that are formatted to epub, for example.
I can get behind forced marking in some circumstances, but shifting between digital and physical should fall under first sale doctrine and the author should not have control over it.
- mminer237 2y agoThe law has no concept of a "temporary copy". How is the Internet Archive supposed to enforce that? Government DRM?
- Dylan16807 2y agoThe law was written a long time ago and it needs some clarifications and updates. Lots of temporary copies are already considered fair use. Every time you play a disc you make temporary copies, and nobody complains. And if playing a CD can just use copyright and no "government DRM", then so can lending an ebook.
- tptacek 2y agoClearly no, and we have two opinions now from federal courts explaining why. Maybe they can appeal it to the Supreme Court and get a 3rd, taking this question off the table categorically for the next 30 years.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> Clearly no Please don't do this. I'm not talking about what the law is, I'm talking about what it can be. You are not responding to my argument.
- tptacek 2y agoThe law we're talking about does not in fact date back to player pianos or s's that look like f's; it's been continuously refined all the way into the 21st century. So I think it matters a great deal what it actually says now.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> The law we're talking about does not in fact date back to player pianos or s's that look like f's; it's been continuously refined all the way into the 21st century. It has been partially updated but not enough. > So I think it matters a great deal what it actually says now. I never implied otherwise. A suggestion for change is by definition based on the current version.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoYour comment was in response to an argument about what the law is. This entire thread is about a court case, which deal with what the law is. You're in no position to accuse others of not responding on-topic.
- Dylan16807 2y agoI didn't accuse tptacek of being off-topic, I accused him of a non sequitur.
- Phiwise_ 2y agoDo you not know what "non sequitur" translates to or something?
- 2y ago
- LegionMammal978 2y agoFrom the Copyright Act: > "Phonorecords" are material objects in which sounds, other than those accompanying a motion picture or other audiovisual work, are fixed by any method now known or later developed, and from which the sounds can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device. The term "phonorecords" includes the material object in which the sounds are first fixed. So the version of the work traveling through the air is not in itself a phonorecord protected by copyright law: fair use is not even relevant for it. (However, copyright law does protect the phonorecord in the CD from being performed publicly.)
- Dylan16807 2y agoI'm not talking about the sounds, I'm talking about the perfect digital copies in the RAM chips of the player. And RAM is considered "fixed" by every interpretation I've ever seen.
- LegionMammal978 2y agoDo CD players tend to keep any more than a few seconds' worth in memory? If not, you could easily argue that any given segment is too short to contain copyrightable expression. But fair use is a very particular concept about the ultimate purpose of producing a copy, which I don't think would apply to any scenario along these lines.
- Dylan16807 2y agoSome CD players buffer a full minute or longer, and also samples have been considered copyright infringement even when they're a second long.
- LegionMammal978 2y agoClearly, it would be infringement if you buffered a minute of audio from CD into a player, then sold that player to someone else (without unpowering it) while keeping the CD for yourself. So I guess you might be right, and it could be fair use that allows it in the typical case (assuming it is allowed).
- tptacek 2y agoIt does not help the situation here that IA went to war with publishers in the US courts with a system that did not in fact enforce that invariant, but rather declared unilaterally that the pandemic justified them taking a single copy of a book and lending it an arbitrary number of times --- something cited in the opinion of the court, IIRC!
- Dylan16807 2y agoIt doesn't help. On the other hand the court doesn't seem to think the arbitrary lending makes a difference to copyright, does it? I was under the impression it's only mentioned as a knock against IA.
- tptacek 2y agoThis came up a bunch on the last thread we had about this. There's a saying among lawyers, "bad facts make bad law". Courts are going to render a verdict, usually, based on legal principles and with broad applicability. But they actual process they're going to use to make that decision is going to be heavily influenced by the facts of the case. So if you're making a run at a well-established feature of law --- say, "copyright law says you can't make copies of other people's stuff and distribute it without their permission" --- you want to go into that case with the absolute best facts you can possibly marshal. IA came to this case with a really bad fact pattern! I think a lot of different people could have told them they were going to lose, and especially that they were going to lose the appeal after they lost in the lower court. But they have no accountability mechanism. It didn't cost them anything to push the case as far as they could go, despite that doing so meant that the predictable result of their case probably dooms CDL under any fact pattern anywhere in the country. People are understandably grumpy.
- Dylan16807 2y agoDidn't they rope in enough libraries so they didn't actually overshoot on almost any book? The way they did that after the fact was cheeky but I don't think it's that bad of a fact pattern. Instead I think it was similarly doomed either way, and the real issue is that a lawsuit was triggered at all.