4 ms·
Are they simply showing pricier offers, or are they showing the exact same offers but with the prices raised? The former is annoying but not inherently evil, bu
by eridius 14y ago
Are they simply showing pricier offers, or are they showing the exact same offers but with the prices raised? The former is annoying but not inherently evil, but the latter would be terrible.
- earl 14y agoThe former, and it seems to vary by location. from the article: [...] search results for hotels in cities including Las Vegas, Orlando, Philadelphia and Boston were the same for both Macs and PCs. A New York search turned up more expensive hotels for Mac users, but only after the first 20 listed. [...] A Mac search for a hotel in Miami Beach for two nights in July displayed costlier boutique hotels on the first page of results, such as Sagamore, the Art Hotel and the Boulan South Beach, that weren't displayed on the PC's first page. Among hotels appearing in both searches, some pricier options (such as the $212 Eden Roc Renaissance and the $397 Fontainebleau) were listed higher on the Mac. [...]
- dmfdmf 14y agoIn Econ, the latter is called differential pricing and there is nothing evil about it at all. http://www.pricingforprofit.com/pricing-explained/differential-pricing.php http://www.pricingforprofit.com/pricing-explained/differenti...
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThat depends on your moral code, of course.
- dmfdmf 14y agoWhich in turn depends on your view of Man.
- bigiain 14y agoWe knew that _downward_ differential pricing worked (in terms of increasing conversions) - a popup saying "Hi, you're a return visitor to our website, we can discount this room rate 10% if you book today) always increased conversions. We sure as hell _experimented_ to see if the decrease in conversions by bumping margins (and hence prices) up was worthwhile in terms of total profit. I'd happily make an argument that if the first is morally "OK" then so is the second…
- rwolf 14y agoYour phrasing here suggests that you work for orbitz or a similar company. Is that accurate?
- bigiain 14y agoSame field, but not since 2008. I was doing this in early 2001.
- hythloday 14y agoa popup saying "Hi, you're a return visitor to our website, we can discount this room rate 10% if you book today" always increased conversions. Did you also test a popup saying "Hi, you're a first-time visitor to our website, we can discount this room rate 10% if you book today"? :)
- excuse-me 14y agoIt't NOT differential pricing, that would be offering the same product top Mac users for more money. They are instead offerent more expensive hotels to Mac users - on the reasonable assumption that Mac owners are higher spenders compared to somebody connecting from a free PC in a public library.
- pbreit 14y agoI presume you were downvoted because the responder specifically referred to the "latter" description: "or are they showing the exact same offers but with the prices raised".
- rscale 14y agoI view the former as helpful, not annoying. Featuring semi-personalized offers saves me time and energy. With e-commerce it only makes sense to put the best-fit offers in the front of the store, for everyone involved.
- eridius 14y agoIt would be helpful if that is, in fact, what you want. Owning a Mac is correlated with having more disposable income available, but that doesn't necessarily mean you want to get a costlier hotel room. I would hope they use other data points too, not just using a Mac, to decide whether the user would be amenable to pricier offers.
- thwarted 14y agoOwning a Mac is correlated with having more disposable income available Or, owning a Mac may be positively correlated with having less disposable income, since the higher price of a Mac took more of your disposable income to purchase.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoIncome by definition is a flow of money, and buying a Mac is a one-time purchase with high barier of entry (hence need for higher income).
- tedunangst 14y agoThe article title is far less ambiguous than the HN title: "On Orbitz, Mac Users Steered to Pricier Hotels"
- el_presidente 14y agoHacker News shows more sensationalist titles to Hacker News users.