4 ms·

How the hell can you patent that. And it isn't even specific. That's just absurd... Also, it was filed on May 2, 2024. Seems to me like there's millions of ins

by Aeolun 2y ago

How the hell can you patent that. And it isn't even specific. That's just absurd... Also, it was filed on May 2, 2024. Seems to me like there's millions of instances of prior art in that case.

kabdib 2y ago
Anyone reading Nintendo patents should get used to "but, there's prior art!"
- londons_explore 2y ago
  I think they've realised that proving prior art is so expensive that most smaller companies won't be able to afford the lawyers fees to do so. That means that as long as you can sneak prior art past the patent examiner (fairly easy), you still get an effective business weapon.
71bw 2y ago
>Also, it was filed on May 2, 2024. >Palworld Release Date: Jan 18, 2024[1] [1] https://store.steampowered.com/app/1623730/Palworld/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1623730/Palworld/
- tourmalinetaco 2y ago
  And Palworld was announced at least two years prior, where this exact mechanic was shown.
slightwinder 2y ago
It's referencing older patents, being a continuation of a US-patent from 2022, and Japanese patent from 2021.
- Aeolun 2y ago
  That doesn't actually help, because Pokemon and its clones are two decades old by this point.
  - slightwinder 2y ago
    It's a hint that this patent is probably not a direct reaction to Palworld. And it means that we are lacking a significant amount of information regarding the whole history of these patents. Quite possible that they indeed have a trail of patents going back for decades, and this is just the latest addition.
jeffwask 2y ago
WB patent the Nemesis system which boiled down is "a system where bosses evolve and get strong based on player interaction'. A patent they have pretty much not used and prevented other games from developing similar interactions. Patents in gaming are weird and suck hard. They stifle innovation and growth. Games have evolved and grown on the backs of previous games forever.
- flockonus 2y ago
  Ironically "Gary" (the rival) in pokemon series is exactly that in many of the old games, he keeps getting stronger and challenging you like a boss!
- nazka 2y ago
  That’s so bad. You should be able to patent specific rules to protect your game or like board game and avoid people from copy pasting it. But you shouldn’t be able to patent such broad mechanics…
- silexia 2y ago
  Patents everywhere are weird and suck hard. They stifle innovation and growth. Human knowledge has evolved and grown on the back of other human knowledge forever.

by Aeolun 2y ago

How the hell can you patent that. And it isn't even specific. That's just absurd... Also, it was filed on May 2, 2024. Seems to me like there's millions of instances of prior art in that case.

kabdib 2y ago

Anyone reading Nintendo patents should get used to "but, there's prior art!"

londons_explore 2y ago
I think they've realised that proving prior art is so expensive that most smaller companies won't be able to afford the lawyers fees to do so. That means that as long as you can sneak prior art past the patent examiner (fairly easy), you still get an effective business weapon.

71bw 2y ago

>Also, it was filed on May 2, 2024. >Palworld Release Date: Jan 18, 2024[1] [1] https://store.steampowered.com/app/1623730/Palworld/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/1623730/Palworld/

tourmalinetaco 2y ago
And Palworld was announced at least two years prior, where this exact mechanic was shown.

slightwinder 2y ago

It's referencing older patents, being a continuation of a US-patent from 2022, and Japanese patent from 2021.

Aeolun 2y ago
That doesn't actually help, because Pokemon and its clones are two decades old by this point.
- slightwinder 2y ago
  It's a hint that this patent is probably not a direct reaction to Palworld. And it means that we are lacking a significant amount of information regarding the whole history of these patents. Quite possible that they indeed have a trail of patents going back for decades, and this is just the latest addition.

jeffwask 2y ago

WB patent the Nemesis system which boiled down is "a system where bosses evolve and get strong based on player interaction'. A patent they have pretty much not used and prevented other games from developing similar interactions. Patents in gaming are weird and suck hard. They stifle innovation and growth. Games have evolved and grown on the backs of previous games forever.

flockonus 2y ago
Ironically "Gary" (the rival) in pokemon series is exactly that in many of the old games, he keeps getting stronger and challenging you like a boss!
nazka 2y ago
That’s so bad. You should be able to patent specific rules to protect your game or like board game and avoid people from copy pasting it. But you shouldn’t be able to patent such broad mechanics…
silexia 2y ago
Patents everywhere are weird and suck hard. They stifle innovation and growth. Human knowledge has evolved and grown on the back of other human knowledge forever.