3 ms·
It's not a falsehood though. IP address is a reasonably reliable means of geolocation. Lawyers tend to be more comfortable with gray areas than engineers. Inten
by nradov 2y ago
It's not a falsehood though. IP address is a reasonably reliable means of geolocation. Lawyers tend to be more comfortable with gray areas than engineers. Intent counts for a lot in assessing legal compliance.
- lxgr 2y agoFrom a "best practice"/CYA perspective, sure. But I'm not a lawyer, and looking purely at the outcome of IP blocks (which is usually that regular people are inconvenienced, but the people such policies are actually designed to keep out just shrug and use a $5/month VPN), I can still say that it looks a bit silly.
- gsich 2y agoNo need for anticipatory obedience though. If whois says it's not Iran - who cares.
- lxgr 2y agoThis makes me wonder, though: Who started the IP checks? I think there's a high chance this by itself was anticipatory obedience, since it's fairly easy and cost-effective to do and it gives companies at least something to point at in case of a lawsuit. But my point is that all of this compliance theater does add up; every once in a while mistakes (as outlined in TFA) do happen. Even if they don't, almost free isn't the same thing as free – and some company will inevitably go even further, it'll set a precedent, and the cost to everybody will increase, with questionable benefit.
- saurik 2y agoBut it isn't a grey area: it simply doesn't work. It doesn't matter if it correctly identifies most people: it has to correctly identity most terrorists, and it simply doesn't do that, because if you are a terrorist you just keep rotating through IP addresses on cloud providers and VPNs until the entire service is burnt. It isn't that it sometimes doesn't work: it's that it doesn't work at all when it actually needs to work. We could argue that the services shouldn't let you do that in the first place, but the reality is that services currently do work like that, no one is trying to change that, and if they did try to change it we would all be even less happy with the resulting even-more-powerful surveillance state.
- nradov 2y agoWrong. At this level there is no compliance requirement to specifically identify "terrorists". And the sanctions against Iran, while partly based on state sponsorship of terrorism, aren't limited to just designated terrorist entities. Most services aren't required to blanket block all traffic from Iran. Only certain specific transactions are prohibited. But a lot of companies choose to block everything identified as coming from Iran (and other sanctioned countries) just to play it safe.