16 ms·
D&D is Anti-Medieval
- brudgers 2y agoGary Gygax himself says so. He describes the original D&D books as “Rules for Fantastic Medieval War Games” (on the cover) and “rules [for] designing your own fantastic-medieval campaign” (in the introduction). The original D&D books (before the Advanced series) did not describe a combat system. Instead, the rules of the wargame "Chainmail" were recommended (as was the map from Avalon Hill's Outdoor Survival for adventuring between dungeons). Which is to say, the context of Gygax's remarks was gone by the time D&D books showed up at the Waldenbooks in every local mall. D&D was literally a different game in the 1970's.
- brudgers 2y agoFor clarity, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chainmail_(game) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chainmail_(game)
- kagakuninja 2y agoI'm not sure what you mean here. I had the original books, the supplements, then "Basic D&D" and "Advanced D&D". The rules were the same, just repackaged. The original rules didn't "recommend" using Chainmail, they assumed you had a copy and knew the rules, which was a source of confusion for newbies. I remember being disappointed with AD&D as it was just the same old shit rules, with Dave Arneson's name cynically removed from the copyright. The next year I discovered Runequest, and later in College, Champions, and never looked back. I think by the 80s D&D was well known, and not just because of the TV show. This was before 2nd edition, which came out in 1989. I vaguely remember looking over 2nd edition, they tweaked a few things, but the core mechanics were the same. 3rd edition did shake things up a bit, and were the first version I considered worth playing.
- brudgers 2y agoI was talking about the original version of D&D that came in a box with three booklets and required Chainmail for combat. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungeons_%26_Dragons_(1974) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungeons_%26_Dragons_(1974)
- prmoustache 2y agoThe keywords are Fantasy / Fantastic. People let grow a lot of misconceptions about history based on media/cinema/games representation of antiquity, medieval or even renaissance time. But that is normal. I guess reality can be boring in comparison.
- jeltz 2y agoI would say it is often the other way round. Many fantasy worlds are more dull than real history due to the lack of imagination of the creators.
- A_D_E_P_T 2y agoThe only rational way to interpret D&D is not as medieval, but as a distant far-future post-post-industrial setting. Magic spells as ambient nanotech that's poorly understood and difficult to invoke -- hence the "Vancian" system which comes from Jack Vance's "Dying Earth" series. Magic items as remnant tech. Different "races" as the vast gulf of time has led to speciation. Gods as posthuman or artificially intelligent entities that have transcended the world but still keep an eye on it from time to time. And so forth. There's literally nothing medieval about it, but it could be 1,000,000 AD. Just think of their medical technologies in light of our era's! (All assuming, of course, that it's "baseline reality" and not a sandbox, as it was in Neal Stephenson's The Fall.)
- mglz 2y agoOr it might be a reconstruction of a broken world after the events of Ra (https://qntm.org/ra https://qntm.org/ra)
- tiborsaas 2y agoIf you haven't played Horizon Zero Dawn, I highly recommend it :)
- justinclift 2y agoThe follow on sequel was a bit hit-or-miss though. :(
- kombookcha 2y agoA very fun example of this theme is in the franco-belgian fantasy comic series Thorgal, which is set in a Conan-esque fantasy world with all the expected trappings, but in which the gods are highly advanced alien entities and magic is often framed as manipulating extremely complex and powerful heirloom technologies that the living have no frame of reference for as anything other than magic. The titular outsider hero falls from the stars in a little space pod as a baby and is raised by the local Viking-proxy culture ala Superman or Goku. Quite an engaging read if you're into this blend of sword and sorcery with background sci-fi elements. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorgal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorgal
- js8 2y agoWhat about other fantasy works that culturally influenced creation of D&D, like Lord of the Rings or Conan the Barbarian? Are those also anti-medieval?
- Ekaros 2y agoI think Conan the Barbarian is pre-antique. That is set in period somewhat before written history. So in sense it not anti-medieval.
- jccalhoun 2y agoI think a good argument for Conan being an American frontier series could be made. Especially Beyond the Black River which is about settlers fighting off natives.
- nerdponx 2y agoPopular on HN: https://acoup.blog/tag/lord-of-the-rings/ https://acoup.blog/tag/lord-of-the-rings/
- Perenti 2y agoThe original Conan story is set in the 4th century, but the earliest stories date from the 12th century. He settled Brittany/Armorica whilst fighting for the usurper Emporer Magnus Maximus. His name seems to relate to Conan the Barbarian (cutting down the men and cutting out the tongues of women) and Meriadoc Brandybuck the hobbit who swore to the House of Rohan. The House of Rohan were the Breton rulers who claimed descent from Conan. A coincidence? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conan_Meriadoc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conan_Meriadoc
- rsynnott 2y agoLord of the Rings, at least, isn't even _trying_ to be medieval, is it? Like, the shire seems vaguely 18th/19th century England, Gondor seems suspiciously Roman/Byzantine... I don't think Tolkien was going for "this is [whatever period], only with dragons", and even if he was, that period certainly wasn't medieval.
- 2y ago
- pjc50 2y agoD&D is what happens when you put pulp novels in an idea collider. The really big influences are Conan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conan_the_Barbarian https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conan_the_Barbarian and Tolkein, which are themselves very different styles, but there's also a magpie effect where anything that Gygax read and thought was cool got added in. Expecting "realism" and coherency from a fantasy world destroys the fantasy. But somehow projecting realism onto fantasy is a popular activity for fans.
- User23 2y ago> Expecting "realism" and coherency from a fantasy world destroys the fantasy. That certainly isn’t the case for The Lord of the Rings and the rest of Tolkien’s development of his world.
- Ekaros 2y agoDepends on what type of realism you are talking about. The details are very scant on for example how Shire is politically set up and how the farming in general work and supply lines and all such things.
- lupusreal 2y agoI wouldn't count sparse details as lacking realism. (I'm not defending the premise of LOTR being realistic.)
- lupire 2y agoSince the planet is covered with independently evolved farming communities, I think it's plenty realistic to allow one in a book.
- Ekaros 2y agoSo why are Bilbo and Frodo not spending all of their time on fields? Why are they not starving when coming back? What do the other hobbits trade food for, is there some trade for metal implements or something?
- master_crab 2y agoI can’t wait for this buzzkill to state that Warhammer 40K is “anti-future.”
- lou1306 2y agoThere is an entire ACOUP post [1] on what feudalism actually means, and it is a _lot_ more complex than "land in exchange of military glory for your overlord". Actually the "overlord" is surprisingly weak wrt. our current assumptions about the powers a "monarch" should have. [1]: https://acoup.blog/2024/07/12/fireside-friday-july-12-2024/ https://acoup.blog/2024/07/12/fireside-friday-july-12-2024/
- sklargh 2y agoViolence and the State in Languedoc, 1250-1400 by Justine Firnhaber-Baker is an interesting and in-depth investigation of this power-without-power dynamic.
- sevensor 2y agoThis was the first thing I thought of when I saw “dark age” in the post. If you want to get a historian spun up, start talking about dark ages and prepare to be educated.
- bnralt 2y agoDepends on the historian. The overly theatrical way some historians react to the term "dark age" is a bit revisionistic (and perpetual revisionism seems extremely popular among academic historians). And many get similarly spun up about the term "feudalism" as well.
- secstate 2y agoWhat is academic history other than repeated attempts at revision? History is literally the stories we tell ourselves about the past. There are facts there, but the arrangement of such facts will (and should) always be open to revision. Anyone claiming to have figured out the One True history of humanity should be viewed with extreme suspicion.
- bnralt 2y agoTrue, but there's a difference between being open to revisionism and actively trying to spin things in a revisionistic manner because novelty brings more clout.
- stolenmerch 2y agoIt's just campaign rules for Chainmail, their medieval weapon combat rules invented for the already existing Elastolin and Starlux figures. It was a system for wargamers much more interested in the weapon speed of pole arms rather than accurate political and social structure. They needed a world of treasure and magic to fuel the adventures, so a setting of accumulated Appendix N source material was pieced together into an entirely new setting.
- boccaff 2y agoDisclaimer: My view is based on D&D 3Ed. I think that the the game culture have changed into something where the DM (dungeon master) is just a enforcer of rules/npc builder. Most of the arguments in the text should be discretionary to the DM. If a DM chooses to enforce a "medieval" setting, the campaign will be medieval. "Knights mentioned", "any time select a land", well, I guess the DM can mention knights and not treat land as something that can be bought as long as you have money. It was very different playing a campaign in Forgotten Realms, Dragonlance or Greyhawk, or having a custom world built by a DM.
- davedx 2y agoI remember we once used ad&d rules to replay the Aeniad. That was awesome. Just use your imagination folks, it’s actually that simple! (Alcohol may have helped. And hindered.)
- ileonichwiesz 2y agoI can’t agree - if anything the role of DM has been expanding since Gygax’s day. The DM was explicitly an „arbiter” in classic D&D, a person whose role was mostly explaining/enforcing the rules and lightly tying the story together. The actual adventure was mostly determined by the setting (often premade) and by random tables (roll to see what’s in the room). In modern D&D, by contrast, the DM is often expected to do worldbuilding, write adventures, and do NPC voices.
- jghn 2y ago> and do NPC voices The steady increase of the performative acting style of play has been a key part of why I never picked the game back up. Reading that "do[ing] NPC voices" is a key part of the DMs job description doesn't help that stance of mine :)
- nox101 2y agoI played D&D with Lawrence Schick (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Schick https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Schick) in the 80s. He very much did NPC voices back then. It's what made playing with him as the DM amazing. I have always assumed since then, the best DMs can do NPC voices.
- curtisblaine 2y agoD&D is as medieval as Hollywood movies set in the middle ages are "medieval": the environment vaguely resonates with a middle-ages setting, but then you have high fantasy, epic kind of stuff (like kings fighting each other directly or pep-talking their soldiers to victory, football-locker style) that wasn't really a thing in the middle ages. That you don't have vassals and king is an implementation detail: you can totally play a game of D&D with vassals and kings, if you want. The real difference is overall "epicness", which is obtained at the rules level: if you are level 10, there's no way one (or ten) level 1 opponents can even touch you. This allows a storyline in which a small party of heroes can overthrow tyrants and slay dragons; in real life (especially in the middle ages) no matter how trained you are, a makeshift mace made of wood and nails swung by angry peasants can still end you quickly, especially if you wander alone, which means you can't get away from needing an army, a society, strategy, politics, etc.
- PaulHoule 2y agoWhen nobles did go into combat they were better equipped and protected. In warring states Japan, common foot soldiers would be armed with pikes (wood shafts with a sharp metal point) but nobles might ride a horse wearing mail armor and armed with an huge and asymmetrical simple bow and be further protected by their position in the military structure. This is more like Monster Hunter as you do not scale your ‘hit points’ by an order of magnitude but you do get gear and actual skills.
- curtisblaine 2y agoRight, but D&D exaggerates this mechanism to unrealistic lengths, in order to maintain the epicness of high fantasy. If you accumulate enough levels in D&D, you can destroy entire armies and tackle literal gods. Most of all, there's a limit (based on your AC and the enemies modifiers) under which lower challenge-rate enemies can't literally touch you (save maybe for critical hits), which is obviously not how it works in real combat. I remember there were "realistic" alternatives to D&D in the 90s, with thousands of detailed tables and the concept of hit zones, where any enemy could potentially even kill you with enough luck (say lucky hit to the back of your armored head from peasant with a spiked club), and you could always get maimed or crippled in some ways (because you wouldn't only lose HP when you get hit, you can break your foot or arm etc). Clearly, you had to have a much more cautious style of playing and you didn't have as much fun as in D&D, where the master would tailor a series of increasingly challenging but killable encounters until you got to destroy an epic, ridiculously powered villain at the end of the campaign.
- acomjean 2y agoI played a little informally in the 80s. Even young me knew it never seemed to be a realistic portrait of the past world, or claimed to be. Way too many dragons compared to the historical record. the monster manual seemed to be a mash up of monster from all over the place, including Greek myths. Some of the weaponry was midevil but it didn’t seem like it was at all realistic. Like many fantasy books. Not like some of the war games of the time that where more historical (axis and allies and diplomacy) Honestly if it was midevil, would it be fun? Who wants to play a game where you’re just farming. That would be such a grind and never be popular.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ajuc 2y agoD&D is theme park based mostly on modern-day USA with some Wild West influences. It's very obvious for people from Europe playing it :) The biggest thing is that in D&D most of population lives in towns & cities, and there are very few if any villages. I'm not sure Americans even understand the difference between a village and countryside. When D&D has people living in the countryside it's often American-style single-family farms in the middle of nowhere. That wasn't a thing. For actual medieval theme every small town should be surrounded by dozens of small villages with lots of people living in close proximity farming lots of small fields, and where one village ends - another starts. Most places shouldn't have enough people to sustain full-time inns and shops. Weekly or monthly markets were done instead so that the same traders could be reused between many places. The way D&D worlds are usually structured could only work if everybody has a magic car and food is abundant.
- michaelt 2y ago> The biggest thing is that in D&D most of population lives in towns & cities, and there are very few if any villages. In my experience most D&D settlements have to fit onto a two-page spread in a letter/legal sized book. So they've got space for an inn, a store, and maybe one or two places with things to advance the plot. A realistic town might need 300 houses for each inn, but there just ain't the space on the page.
- lupusreal 2y agoYeah, there's a lot of spatial and social compression. Bethesda RPGs are the same way, again for technical reasons.
- PaulHoule 2y agoWithout some of that the game would be unplayable or at least highly constrained. A 2 week ride on horseback would be a reasonable trip in that milieu but has to be compressed somehow; at best the group could meet and game out some encounters during that time period but that takes dedication, and if that was the way you rolled you’d also put them in a conference room for a long weekend to play the dungeon.
- mybrid 2y agoI grew up reading Tolkein and then playing D&D. It seemed to me along with everyone in our playing sphere that D&D was set in Middle Earth, not Medival Times. It wasn't long after the original release when the Gods & Demigods manual was released to help clerics have someone specifically to worship. I never ever thought this game was in any way trying to model reality. Then, of course, you have the various astral and god planes of existence. The only "setting" that makes sense to me for D&D is bringing Middle Earth and myths into a game setting.
- jncfhnb 2y agoI’m amused that people use the actual canon and not just asserting a god into existence
- Forgeties79 2y agoA lot of that is because the gods are usually part of some sort of pantheon or otherwise juxtaposed with other deities in some fashion. They have followers and creeds and lore and all these other elements that slot into the larger world. If you scoop them out, aside from just changing their name/look, you have to replace all of that in theory.
- jncfhnb 2y agoI find this surprising. I can barely get my players to learn the rules properly. I struggle to imagine people making lore accurate characters. One, because it’s a lot to learn. Two, because it’s specific and kind of dumb. We just use dnd canon at will to supplement but otherwise make everything up as desired.
- pdpi 2y agoDifferent strokes for different folks. Many people actively enjoy having a mass of written lore to consume, and prefer having a well-defined setting to act as a foundation to their stories. It's a safety net of sorts.
- 2y ago
- pinebox 2y agoI have long considered the relationship of OD&D to historical medievalism as equivalent to the vaporwave genre vs. music actually produced in the 80's.
- Symmetry 2y agoI'd say that (1) there's a lot more to the medieval period than just the high middle ages in England and France and (2) a world with orcs, owlbears, etc is going to tend to be more thinly populated than similar historical analogues, meaning finding unclaimed land becomes more plausible.
- cdrini 2y agoI mean, this is like saying "because DND has magic, and the real medieval age didn't have magic, that means DND is anti-medieval". It can be accurately described as "medieval" without replicating every element of actual medieval society. And there are enough medieval like elements in there that it strikes as a sufficiently resonant descriptor for me.
- Guthur 2y agoSorry did you read it, the point was there is literally nothing medieval/feudal except the fact that there are swords and pointy sticks.
- Guthur 2y agoIf you want to see an actual fantasy feudal setting check out Burning Wheel.
- cdrini 2y agoI did read it :) I disagree that not being feudal is enough to disqualify something as medieval. Loads of DND components are medieval, the timeframe, the architecture, the technology (excluding magic), the vague element of religion like cleric/etc. It's like a very blurry view of medieval times, with certain elements dropped out. But not enough elements removed to say that it's not based on medieval times; let alone anti-medieval!
- xbar 2y agoHuh? Gygax's own campaign was decidedly medieval and the rules were written before his milieu was published, so he left it as an exercise of the imagination for rule-book consumers to produce their own milieus until such a time as his could be published. The rules include descriptions of the possible selection of governmental structures. Technologically represented in the rules (aka weapon types) were decidedly medieval, as the author concedes. That it was left to the DM to implement bureaucracy does not mean that it was anti-medieval.
- helboi4 2y agoThere is a certain propagandistic line about capitalism that implies that it is the natural state of affairs and everything leading up to it was a proto-captialist society (see the myth of a barter society, which never existed). I wonder how much revisionist media like this that makes people associate medieval aesthetics with an economy that works like the American frontier aids that propaganda. Not that I think D&D is a purposeful piece of propaganda. Just that it unknowingly reinforces the brainwashing of the public into believing capitalism is an immortal and immovable default state of human being.
- PaulHoule 2y ago‘Capitalism’ is a term that was coined by its enemies, if it had its own way it would have no name but be the thing that “there is no alternative” to. Christopher Lasch’s Culture of Narcissism is about the 1970s (early middle Technetronic?) but also about the late 19th and the old pagan empires such as Rome and is popular in Japan as a critique of the Tokugawa era culture. I imagine urban people in cosmopolitan centers (like that university town Corinth that my namesake wrote a letter to) of an artisan or merchant or intellectual class would have very much liked a game like Dungeons and Dragons and would have come up with similar weapons tables, monster books, spell lists, theology, etc.
- helboi4 2y agoMerchants of course would have loved it since they were the few people living in a reality that would actually become capitalism. I disagree with your initial statement since there were obviously alternatives throughout history and countries that never fully bought into full trappings of capitalism. It is only our opinion that capitalism, heavily influenced by our education that lends us to believe that capitalism is the only way things can be.
- PaulHoule 2y agoMarkets, however, have always existed as long their have been towns, see Braudel.
- netbioserror 2y agoThis is to say nothing of the modern "baristacore" fantasy, which seems to be a projection of modern American urban life, with many of its social attitudes and creature comforts, into a fantastical set-dressing evoking a mixture of high-fantasy and medieval aesthetics. Like a fancier-looking version of the Columbia U bar scene. For recent examples, Dragon Age, Warcraft, and D&D itself are pushing further and further in this direction lately.
- busterarm 2y agoNever heard this term in the context of fantasy gaming, but I'm stealing it.
- baxuz 2y agoDid you coin this term? I can't find it anywhere online but I _LOVE_ it.
- lacker 2y agoI suppose this comment is inspired by the recent "Legends & Lattes", a fantasy novel winning various awards, starring a barista Orc... https://www.amazon.com/Legends-Lattes-Novel-Fantasy-Stakes-ebook/dp/B0B3755RV9 https://www.amazon.com/Legends-Lattes-Novel-Fantasy-Stakes-e... I haven't read it myself, but apparently it is big on TikTok. Perhaps for some HN readers this is the sort of thing they are looking for ;-)
- crooked-v 2y agoFor me, that book sits in a weird crux of interesting yet underwhelming. I think it suffers a lot from the implied quasi-D&D setting intersecting with modern assumptions. It has a lot of absentee worldbuilding that amounts to a blank space implying all the stuff you're already used to from the real world, instead of doing anything interesting with it being fantasy.
- WereAllMadHere 2y agoCan you go elaborate on this concept of baristacore? I'm guessing you mean something broader than Legends and Lattes?
- Pinegulf 2y agoNo, it's not "anti-medieval" it's medieval fantasy. Or in the words of the greats “Rules for Fantastic Medieval War Games”.
- pyuser583 2y agoD&D was highly customizable, so it was as medieval as you wanted. Some of the sourcebooks were extremely accurate in describing the Middle Ages. Others didn’t even try. I do like the articles core criticism: the goal of D&D is social advancement. D&D always was a Western at heart. A group of desperadoes going town to town taking up jobs and fighting the baddies.
- jeltz 2y agoWhen did that change? Because I have played since ADnD 2nd Edition and I do not think it has ever been highly customizable. Customizable? Yes, but not highly so.
- jghn 2y ago1e literally had examples on how to blend the game with other games such as Boot Hill, Gamma World, etc.
- jeltz 2y agoI never played 1e, I started with ADnD 2e.
- jghn 2y agoYeah, things started shifting with 2e and that shift kept going further and further. With Forgotten Realms it shifted from more of a pulp swords & sorcery to a medieval-ish Tolkien-esque environment. Over time it shifted from low fantasy to high fantasy. And not only did the theming start to solidify, but over time the tropes arguably became self-reinforcing.
- ourmandave 2y agoWe played all three but never combined them. They have guns and smoke powder in 5e and it just doesn't feel right. Game of Thrones with cowboys carrying torc grenades?
- ElectricSpoon 2y agoHaving read that, I really wish to back to being GM and trolling players by awarding them non-fungible plots of land as rewards. Then players get challenged since they failed to occupy the land, so at a later visit, they discover their plot occupied by squatters.
- Ekaros 2y agoOr coming back from year or two on adventure and wondering where is everyone and why there is tribes of whatever creatures around. Just to find that your peasants are really really angry for abandoning them and not doing your duty to protect them and moved to neighbour who is actually around to do their job.
- busterarm 2y agoThere are long term/generational campaigns that run like this. It's just that the majority of the playerbase is playing a different game, whether they're murderhoboing or badly copying Critical Role. And the murderhobo style is as old as D&D itself.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoIt can be a lot of fun if the players actually do occupy the land and start influencing the game world at a higher level than just adventuring all of the time It also gives them something to invest their hard earned treasure into that isn't just trying to buy more and more powerful magic items to minmax their builds
- creer 2y agoIt's actually very practical and useful. A common problem is absent players (their characters are busy trying to run their domain). Another common problem is too much money among the adventurers: easily fixed with costs of construction, required finery, and a constantly deficit-running domain. Sometimes it helps if one of the player has some form of authority over the others - set the adventure in or near their domain.
- NovemberWhiskey 2y agoI think I'm missing something here - what is "OD&D" in this context? Is this just some back formation for the original D&D once AD&D existed? Looking at the "Basic" D&D rules (red books), they don't cover characters up to the levels where they would be landowners etc. They only cover up to 3rd level. The "Expert" D&D rulebook (blue books) covers characters up to 14th level, and includes sections on strongholds and land ownership. Once characters are 9th level, they can gain land but the narrative is definitely rooted in feudal concepts (fighters get land from a higher lord, and their realm is a barony etc)
- amonon 2y agoI believe you are correct; OD&D is the holmes/moldvay/etc. books that existed before AD&D, but I'm not certain.
- cthalupa 2y agoNope, that is Basic/Expert, and eventually BECMI/Rules Cyclopedia. These were released in parallel with AD&D. In theory they catered to different playstyles, in practice it was largely to escape paying Arneson royalties. OD&D is the original 1974 release co-authored by Gygax and Arneson
- amonon 2y agoFascinating, thanks! One of the things I love about D&D is that there's so much historical density to it.
- hackthemack 2y agoWhat to call the many editions of D&D to differentiate them is a bit nebulous. Here is an article with an infographic at the end that explains what the community started calling the various editions. https://daddyrolleda1.blogspot.com/2024/06/editions-of-dungeons-dragons.html https://daddyrolleda1.blogspot.com/2024/06/editions-of-dunge... OD&D usually refers to the Original Edition that was first released in 1974. It consists of 3 little brown books. Direct link to infographic https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/a/AVvXsEi8QrcSdtdysn_nllSk2rKOZIzfAKr-nEvVwLvswBlXIbqn-hjemwZDUckNvMz_Yn4aep4O_t2jJakKXUg4jpgXl-psXNtfNRxThpgPV5W4APz6UXlaVNoG-BBDz7S4uiiAczh5_LUQaRTeRw-MysiuTw8Icz72PUCjslzBkeOg1thcy7MrRQN6DAN_lRYd https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/a/AVvXsEi8QrcSdtdy...
- drivingmenuts 2y agoI have seen the ruleset for Pathfinder where you can purchase land and titles, etc. and it is pitifully boring. I would be surprised if someone seriously into crunching the numbers behind real estate would be interested in a game based centrally on die rolling. I have also seen rulesets that tried to be more medieval and they were near unplayable. Someone who was serious about playing that sort of game is generally not the same kind of person who would play the more popular forms of TRPGs. I think there's not much about medieval life that is exciting enough to be able to make a sustainable ruleset for TRPGs. There's very little in modern society that is pro-medieval. Even the Ren fairs that so many people are into have almost nothing to do with recreating actual medieval life. Being pro-something does not always mean being anti-something else. Sometimes it means that a certain group just isn't interested. And in the context of modern TRPGs, medieval is a marketing term, not an actual descriptive term.
- busterarm 2y agoThere are plenty of campaigns out there that are politically oriented and traveling hobos aren't likely to get positive attention from the local lord or lady. Turns out that having a stake in local society is one of the best ways to get that positive attention, just following logically. Rules like these are for people playing the setting appropriately. But these days I think it's appropriate to assume that large numbers of roleplayers are doing so to play out chiefly their own fantasies and all of the modern sensibilities that comes with.
- jeltz 2y agoIn my country, Sweden, one of the most popular RPGs used to be Eon and that game i s much more medieval than DnD and it is very playable. I would argue more so than DnD, that that is subjective. And it was a very popular game so your guesses are wrong. There are also a whole bunch of the games which are semi successful which are more or less about medieval life, e.g. Pendragon. And then we have Warhammer Fantasy which is renaissance. DnD is mostly just big in the US due to historical reasons.
- pwillia7 2y agoOK so where is my high fantasy 4X feudal city state tabletop sim? Maybe HRE Tabletop lol. I'd play that if I could find a group of people insane enough to do it with me
- jowea 2y agoAs someone who could find such a thing interesting, I googled a bit and there seems to be some RPGs with more of that focus, although I think people mostly play video games for that: https://forum.rpg.net/index.php?threads/city-building-management-rpg.859198/ https://forum.rpg.net/index.php?threads/city-building-manage... https://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/ll6z4d/games_that_have_a_city_building_type_of_mechanics/ https://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/ll6z4d/games_that_have... https://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/2zazc9/rpg_systems_where_the_focus_is_on_city_town/ https://www.reddit.com/r/rpg/comments/2zazc9/rpg_systems_whe... And if you want people slightly less insane (lol), maybe a mixed game with management elements would be easier to swallow? The ASOIAF RPG, Pendragon and the Border Princes region for Warhammer Fantasy all have some type of feudal lordship elements in addition to the usual RPG fare for example.
- jerf 2y agoIf you get to a sufficiently-high level of "realism", D&D game mechanics and fuedalism can't coexist anyhow. All of human history prior to around the 17th century is based on the fact that a "military man" is within a certain range of power. You can have better or worse, like how the Roman empire had a more reliable way of getting more-per-soldier than the competition of the time, but in general throughout history, there's definitely a range on human power. Everything is so deeply based on that model that we can't even see it. Even as I describe this you may be going "yeah, but what about...", but bear with me for a second. In these style of games, though, there's generally exponential power growth. One level 20 warrior can take on an absurd number of level 1 warriors. With modern games being so much larger and more complicated it's not impossible to find builds where a level 20 (or 40, or 60, or 100...) warrior can defeat arbitrary numbers of level 1 warriors. Moreover, the leveling mechanics are such that the things you do to attain levels are only loosely correlated to the skills you obtain from those levels, e.g., why would killing a bunch of kobolds suddenly allow you to cast two fireballs instead of one? This breaks fuedalism in ways both subtle and gross. If the King is level 20 (or whatever), he has little to no utility for your Level 3 warrior's oath of fealty and the several dozen Level 1 warriors following him. In the real world every oath of fealty is some incremental boost in power and you may need everything you can get, but this oath of fealty is just a waste of your military's food. So what would it look like? Well, you may note I time-bound my claim above that soldiers were somewhat range-bound in capability. Clearly modern militaries are wildly disproportional in effectiveness per soldier. It's been that way ever since the gun became a practical military weapon and has generally gotten worse over time. And what do we see today? Broadly speaking, the people with militaries have power and offer nothing like feudalistic loyalty in return. Loyalty is a one-way street where the plebs are beholden to the militaries, but the only loyalty the militaries have back to them is mostly based around the fact the plebs are still the supply line, so you can't actually kill them all, but you sure can kill a lot of them if you need to in order to maintain power. If you feel this is an inaccurate summary of the modern West, look beyond the modern West; there's a lot more to history than just the modern West in the past ~300-400 years. And it is, of course, a single paragraph merely sketching a hint of a broad shape, not a PhD thesis; I'm well aware that this is a very fuzzy picture. But the point I'm trying to make is not a positive one about the details of the sketch I'm making here; it suffices simply to point out that A: we actually have much less balanced "power per person" in the real world (though not driven by "leveling mechanics") right now and B: the resulting social structures that have been semi-stable now for centuries look nothing like feudalism at all.
- AdmiralAsshat 2y agoCounterpoint: Why in god's name would I want to play a fantasy adventure in a "realistic" medieval setting?
- TillE 2y agoBecause Ars Magica is a really good game.
- jjkaczor 2y agoThank-you - I was searching for "Ars Magica" here in the comments - as it is the only fantasy RPG that I have ever seen come close to having the "feel" of actual "medieval" times, except - of course ... for the magic... (It is also the absolute best magic system out there!)
- thfuran 2y agoWhy should you hate the idea?
- pavel_lishin 2y agoRealism is a sliding scale. Some people prefer to count their arrows after every combat, some people prefer to go into a dungeon without even checking whether they have a backpack, much less whether it has any rations in it.
- jeltz 2y agoHaving tried it myself: because it can be really fun! More magic, more dragons, more princesses does not inherently make a story better.
- lyu07282 2y agoNot a tabletop but the Kingdom Come Deliverance video game has completely changed my previous very similar opinion. It's one of the best action RPGs of all time and it's historically accurate and realistic: https://store.steampowered.com/app/379430/Kingdom_Come_Deliverance/ https://store.steampowered.com/app/379430/Kingdom_Come_Deliv...
- dash2 2y agoMy favourite world was Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay of the 80s. It was explicitly early Renaissance, with analogues to France and the Empire, but also with the underlying darkness of the narrative that Chaos was sure to win in the end.
- VagabundoP 2y agoBritish fantasy RPGs in general have far more Jabberwocky (1977) in them than the American ones. Basically everything is covered in shit.
- kergonath 2y agoThat’s fine. I prefer grimdark to cartoonish settings, even if both tend to be a bit camp. Warhammer is better than Warcraft as a setting.
- VagabundoP 2y agoThey have a good amount of "not taking themselves too seriously" as well. The Enemy Within is a great read and I'm planning on running it one day, this has some spoilers about it, but is funny: https://www.reddit.com/r/warhammerfantasyrpg/comments/7hzz1l/classic_rant_how_james_wallis_ruined_my/ https://www.reddit.com/r/warhammerfantasyrpg/comments/7hzz1l... The original blog post is gone I think,
- kergonath 2y agoBrilliant! Thanks for the link. I did not play WRPG (though I know more than a bit of the lore from WFB and things like Mordheim) much but this resonates with some memories :) Some of the pages are on archive.org apparently.
- dadrian 2y agoOf course D&D is not an accurate picture of the medieval era. There's magic in D&D! There was not magic in the medieval era. What are we even doing here?
- shermantanktop 2y agoI don’t think they rolled dice to decide who won in combat either. I agree, what are we doing here??
- Hugsun 2y agoD&D claims to occur in the european medieval era where magic and fantastic beasts exist. The author's point is that it's not like that. It's a persistent capitalistic medieval themed wild west with no real power structures. The feudal power structures were a defining feature of the european medieval era. Of course it's fantasy and can be anything. The author is simply explaining that it says that it's theme is the european medieval era, while it has almost none of it's defining features.
- bigstrat2003 2y agoD&D is based on the popular conception of the medieval era. This has very little to do with the actual history that happened during the medieval era, despite sharing the same name. But D&D didn't invent the ideas it's building on.
- the_af 2y ago> Of course D&D is not an accurate picture of the medieval era I don't think that's what being stated in TFA. The argument is that there's nothing medieval about it (except maybe some of the weapons), contradicting Gygax's own assertions: > You can be forgiven for thinking that OD&D is a medieval European fantasy game. After all, Gary Gygax himself says so. He describes the original D&D books as “Rules for Fantastic Medieval War Games” (on the cover) and “rules [for] designing your own fantastic-medieval campaign” (in the introduction). As for this: > There's magic in D&D! You could devise a medieval society where magic exists. This is not what D&D does. That's the point.
- VagabundoP 2y agoBirthright[1] was a 2e setting all about managing your domain in a fantasy feudal setting. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthright_(campaign_setting) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthright_(campaign_setting)
- mlinhares 2y agoI was about to say that, how come no one mentions Birthright here? The usual D&D scenario might not focus too much on this but as you level you you can have something like that. Almost all high level campaigns I DMed would eventually see the characters form a retinue, groups, organizations (like the harpers). A lot of the novels also have this context for the powerful characters, so there's plenty of content out there where for you to be inspired.
- cortesoft 2y agoWas looking for this!
- waffletower 2y agoThis article reads like: "D&D is not like this other game I imagined! Why?" It is a pedantic, tunnel-vision diatribe that focusses upon Gygax's casual use of the word "medievel". While not explicitly built into the D&D system, the author completely misses the point that D&D has considerable flexibility to allow for many of the "glaring" medievel flavor lacks they didacticly emphasize.
- shermantanktop 2y agoI think of creative work, and most human endeavors, as frames within frames. The inconsistency of something like D&D is easily avoided by stepping out of the frame, and thinking of it as a sui generis creation of Gygax, or stepping further in and thinking of it as a game mechanic that leads to an experience of fun. But the geek habit is to stay inside the frame and obsess over how the premise should have been more explicit, the details more accurate, the rules more consistent. How does the tricorder work? What’s inside a Dalek?? Can you really clone a dinosaur using a chicken egg??? Let’s write a wiki page about our theories and then argue about it!
- dfxm12 2y agoI think in the context of a role playing game like D&D, you do want to stay within the frame because a unique & defining part of an RPG is the role playing. This is different from content you purely consume, like a TV series.
- shermantanktop 2y agoI'm not an RPG person - but when I've done it, every player is in fact both acting their character's role AND acting as player in the game. The elven mage character does not know that a DM exists, or that dice are being rolled; but the player does, and complains when the DM applies a rule inconsistently.
- swayvil 2y agoThat's how concentrating your attention goes. You pick a thing within your field of attention, center your attention upon it and narrow your attention until the thing fills your entire field of attention. Which gives you a new field of attention. Then you repeat the process. And so on. A kind of infinite shrinking of perspective. This is what artists, scientists and engineers do. It's a bit insane. It's the cornerstone of our civilization.
- creer 2y ago> sui generis creation of Gygax Isn't it the opposite? Gygax lived in a world of sword and sorcery books, short stories and pulp comics. If you want his model of "medieval world", it's more like that: you have independent characters galore, few concerns about overall world economics or power structure (aside from the immediate interference with the heros).
- agentultra 2y agoThere were other RPGs and settings with more historical influences than D&D. The "fantastic" was always a part of the D&D setting. The cultures that influenced D&D came more from 20th century Minnesota than any 13th century society.
- dagw 2y agoIf you want to role play in Medieval Europe, but with a smattering of magic and fantastical elements, then Ars Magica is the game you're looking for.
- lyu07282 2y agoIt's "romanticized middle ages", epic high fantasy, it's not supposed to be realistic or allegorical, it just provides a neutral canvas, on top of which the actually interesting bits are painted. The most interesting themes to me in D&D's forgotten realms were always mythological, immortality, the pantheon (the time of troubles etc.), divine and arcane magic, good vs. evil, destiny & prophecies etc. it has nothing to do with the middle ages. Kings are often literally background characters while the heroes fight against the world ending threats (like dark lords similar to Sauron, liches or ascended (demi)gods). But of course everyone's perspective on this is very different, which is a good thing imho. It only has very deep lore if it matters to you.
- jghn 2y ago> epic high fantasy In the early days it was much more of a low fantasy environment. The epic high fantasy angle grew over time.
- lyu07282 2y agoI'm a much younger D&D enjoyer so that makes sense then, everyone seems to have a different perspective on what D&D even is.
- cthalupa 2y ago> everyone seems to have a different perspective on what D&D even is. There's a variety of axis you could split it on, but if you wanted to look at the departure from low-fantasy adventurer's just trying to eek out an existence to the players becoming heroes going on epic quests, there's a pretty universally agreed upon point that really kicked this shift into overdrive, and it's the original Dragonlance modules. They weren't the first to position the game this way, but they were the first to really stick with the population. We started seeing more AD&D splatbooks that raised the power level of characters, the Companion rules came out for the Basic/Expert line that raised the power levels there, etc. AD&D 2E further embraced this, though you could still play the more traditional sword and sorcery style, but 3E largely cut off the original style of play completely.
- photochemsyn 2y agoGenerally fantasy role-playing relies on some historical input, which fills out the world. A game could be set in a place like 13th century Spain with a mix of influences from North African to Western European. Or it could be set in something like the Aztec Empire of around the same time period. The whole game is setup to be pretty flexible - you can project onto it whatever you want, within the basic ruleset.
- davidashe 2y agoHacker News, where a fun fantasy game with zero world-modeling ambitions is criticized as a failed medieval simulation by software engineers who know little about anthropology/sociology/history.
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoI'd expect nothing less from a crowd that's informed enough to reference Dunning-Kruger and Gell-Man effects but not self-aware enough to realize they themselves will still fall for them.
- leoc 2y agoSure: D&D is the American Dream. (Lizzie Stark said it in 2012 https://nordiclarp.org/w/images/a/a0/2012-States.of.play.pdf https://nordiclarp.org/w/images/a/a0/2012-States.of.play.pdf and I'd been saying it for the best part of a decade already at that point.) That's why Paranoia, a middle finger to the mores and expectations of late-'70s, rules-lawyer-era D&D, is a role-playing game about being, basically, a work gang of gulag prisoners in a totalitarian state; while Call of Cthulhu, another RPG from people who were sick of D&D, experiments a bit half-heartedly with ideas of cosmic despair and creeping personal ruin, and bigs up Cthulhu himself as an unbeatable grudge monster.
- teachrdan 2y agoCall of Cthulhu was notable for the fact that players' combat skills were inevitably their weakest.
- hibikir 2y agoIt's interesting to look outside the US, in countries where the D&D translations didn't come in a decade early: When facing Cthulhu, Paranoia, Rolemaster, Vampire and the like on an even playing field, D&D didn't really win.
- bovermyer 2y agoI know how the RPG hobby played out in Japan, but I'm unfamiliar with other countries' experience. Has anyone written about this?
- TacticalCoder 2y ago> But it’s worth taking a step back from the medieval-fantasy cliches that overran later D&D publications, and playing the original, more coherent setting: A swords-and-sorcery world, empty of government, where anyone can pick up a sword, become a hero, and live the American dream. "... empty of government ... live the American dream" That is the real fantasy: to believe that the USA is "empty of government". Or maybe the author considers the american dream is dead, because of too much government?
- golergka 2y ago> No one knows what “plate mail” is supposed to be. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_and_plate_armour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mail_and_plate_armour It's literally the first search result.
- Ekaros 2y agoLater edition: https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/Armor#content https://roll20.net/compendium/dnd5e/Armor#content There is Scale mail, Splint, Half-Plate and Plate... Which is quite range of different things that are mostly same concept, but to different degrees so it does get rather confusing when looking for real world examples.
- baxuz 2y agoReading this article, it seems to me that what the author thinks of when they say "D&D" is actually Forgotten Realms. Which is why I massively prefer Eberron, as the original setting makes no sense at all. Not that Eberron is without its faults but at least it's coherent and embraces what it is. https://www.dndbeyond.com/posts/279-welcome-to-eberron-an-introduction-to-a-realm-of https://www.dndbeyond.com/posts/279-welcome-to-eberron-an-in...
- coolsunglasses 2y agoI just finished posting a comment disagreeing with the author and I think you've nailed the problem with their argument more succinctly than I did. They're assuming "Forgotten Realms" and AD&D, not OD&D.
- kagakuninja 2y agoThe author was specifically referring to the original 3 book rules, which pre-dated Forgotten Realms by 13 years.
- pdonis 2y ago> the original setting Forgotten Realms was not the original setting of D&D. To the extent there was one, it was Gygax's Greyhawk campaign.
- baxuz 2y agoTIL. I thought that Greyhawk and Dragonlance came after Forgotten Realms!
- pdonis 2y agoThis Wikipedia article has a good timeline showing when the various D&D settings were first released: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungeons_%26_Dragons_campaign_settings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungeons_%26_Dragons_campaign_... Note that Blackmoor and Greyhawk, at least, were used by their respective creators/DMs (Dave Arneson and Gary Gygax) for quite a few years before being published. I suspect that's true of at least some of the other settings as well (Forgotten Realms was Ed Greenwood's campaign world before it was published--it looks like it was a D&D campaign world more or less from the release of AD&D 1st Edition in 1978).
- coolsunglasses 2y agoThis post takes the way D&D is played today to be how Gary and his contemporaries played D&D and it leads them to the conclusion that D&D is the opposite of medieval. As near as I can tell, patrons, village leaders, barons, and kings were very intentionally a part of the schema of a typical original D&D campaign. They used 1:1 time, players had multiple PCs, and you often led mercenaries into battle (cf. Chainmail rules being incorporated for this purpose) What's weird is the author appears to be au fait with some of original D&D (they mention Chainmail), but then they make claims like: >While you can create a barony, there is no way to level up and become a duke or King I mean, you definitely could, but it's a question of what the scope of the campaign is meant to be. That's between the DM and the players. Just because Gary Gygax didn't address every possibility explicitly doesn't mean it was considered and assumed to happen in some campaigns. >There’s no evidence for (or against) the idea that OD&D takes place in a dark age after a fallen Roman Empire analogue or during the death throes of a feudal kingdom. The magic system of D&D is largely based on Jack Vance's Dying Earth series which is a post-apocalyptic and exhausted Earth set in the far future. Between that and the _sheer number of ruins littered all over the landscape_, I would tend to think that there's plenty of room for a DM to weave a background history of a fallen empire into their setting. The author seems to expect Gary Gygax to have played the role of someone like Tolkien rather than what Gary Gygax actually was: a systems builder who was interested in designing systems for interactive games humans play together. >The monster descriptions of “men”, “elves”, and “dwarves” don’t suggest that the game is set in a European culture. What? Just because there are corsairs doesn't mean there isn't a strong Old World flavor to the elements of D&D's cast of cultures. Barbary pirates were a relevant force in European history. >OD&D is meant to be setting-free. The game’s referee is to create his or her own campaign, ranging in milieu from the “prehistoric to the imagined future” (with emphasis on the medieval, especially for beginners). This is an accurate statement. What the author's saying here fits better for AD&D than it does OD&D. There's some insight and reasonable points about D&D not being Feudalism Simulator 2024 (play Dark Albion if you want that) but they take the idea further than the facts on the ground can bear.
- bcrosby95 2y agoD&D was inspired by Sword & Sorcery novels, not history. And I wouldn't call it the "American Dream" - maybe the Wild West, which was a very short period in the history of the USA.
- gavmor 2y agoThis was a good read, and the author makes convincing points. Largely, I agree, but the author makes a mistake that's extremely common in the hobby: they presume that the author of the book is the authority of the game, whereas the presumption made by Gygax et al. was that the Dungeon Master was overflowing with ideas, and needed only some reference points to pin them down. One might as well refer to my garage toolbox as "anti-Cabinets" for containing no hinges. And these anti-Medieval fixtures from the text aren't even necessarily central to the experience. Hiring retainers is a hand-wave, a way to get back to the meat of the game: prying gems from the eyes of enchanted statues. I guess my point is that the most accurate possible exegesis of the Gygaxian canon misses, almost entirely, the heart of the game, which exists overwhelmingly at the table, and not in the book.
- pessimizer 2y agoI don't buy that the "heart of the game" is at the table. It's at the table where the game is being played, by the rules that the game sets up. In a way that no one had ever really played before, and a way everyone ended up playing since. You can barely call D&D anti-medieval; it isn't from a world of obsessing about Tolkien-style fantasy. It's Gygax coming up with rules for miniatures wargaming where players are individuals within a group rather than being entire sides of a war and moving armies, or being squad-level and choosing how to move squad members. That was the important part that influenced the entire world. All of the players were part of a single squad, and working (and cooperating) as individuals for their own benefit. These rules were then applied to Gygax's (and everybody else's) favorite fantasy novels. The thing that varied most about those novels was the idea of magic, so the only influence on his system from fiction that I recall is the stat-friendly Jack Vance magic, which would end up imposed onto other settings. But it's still fair to call the system anti-medieval as the article does because it was made for a competitive multiplayer tabletop game which was meant to progress over sessions, and the main aspect of its progression are stats. So it has to be as fair as possible, and you have to be able to accumulate indefinitely rather than die in the same place you were born with no more than your parents had. That's American myth, not medieval reality. There can't be a medieval system, because that would crush all of the characters, starting by burning all of the witches. If every character were a fighter trying to get ahead by fighting in an army, there's no D&D, because D&D is individual, not squad or army.
- WangComputers 2y agoACKS fixes this
- PeterCorless 2y agoThe author might make broad sweeping generalizations but the main point is true. A group of PCs is basically a democracy. Such D&D democracy makes roleplaying in strict social hierarchies pretty difficult. PCs will mouth off to kings or wizards or even deities. I clearly remember how such "D&D PC-ism" influenced the relative flopping of the early Star Trek RPG [FASA, 1982 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek:_The_Role_Playing_Game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek:_The_Role_Playing_Ga...]. The main reason? No one wanted to be ordered around by a Captain PC, or by other PC officers that outranked them. Players wanted to be "equals." (While Star Trek TTRPG did have fans and survived for a long while, it never really took off as many hoped it would.) Another reason, though, is that it did not satisfy the bloodlust of the typical "hack and slash" D&D fans (what are now called "murder hobos" — wandering bands of characters with no allegiances, no lords, no loyalties). These types of players couldn't just use the Enterprise's phasers to hold planets hostage and take all their loot. They couldn't just be space pirates. They thought the universe of Star Trek was "boring." In GDW's Traveller, by contrast, you could definitely (in due time) get a ship capable of hurling nukes at planets. You could be space pirates! Now that was "fun!" It is often difficult to get many D&D players outside of their modernisms and into a medieval mindset, or into any sort of realistic strictly hierarchical society (as shown, even in Science Fiction). I've run Pendragon for decades. It can misfire spectacularly if players refuse to put aside their modern mindsets and adopt the concepts of chivalry, feudalism, courtly love and faith (Christian or otherwise) that are central to its themes and historical source materials. I had a whole session in this past year where I went through the ancient Brehon marriage laws under late pagan/early Christian Ireland. (btw: It's a far cry from "Say Yes to the Dress.") D&D is more like a typical Renn Faire. A motley assortment of anything from ancient to nearly modern dress. A cross-time saloon of attitudes, weaponry, cultures and so on. What passes for society is made up from kit-bashed models. It rarely makes cohesive sense.
- isk517 2y agoThe Star Trek RPG might have done better if it was released today than in 80's. YouTube pen and paper role playing shows have lead to more people being interested in the actual role playing aspect and not just murder hoboing.
- beloch 2y agoIf you made a completely faithful and realistic medieval role-playing game, only sociopaths would play it. Even if such a game started players off in positions of enviable social status, the things they'd be required to do to maintain order would be so distasteful that only seriously screwed up people would want to continue playing. The obstacles set up by society in the way of going on any sort of adventure outside of a few strict avenues (e.g. a pilgrimage or crusade) would be so infuriating that even sociopaths would be hard-pressed. Medieval society is seriously alien. We can look back on their art, literature, architecture, etc. and see their humanity shining down through the ages, but we've carefully tended and cared for only the portions of medieval culture that still hold appeal. From top to bottom and in almost all respects, medieval society would shock and horrify us today.
- yyyk 2y agoWhat's mentioned here is trivially 'fixed', it's setting stuff which can filled in. The bigger issue is the magic system and description, especially combined with the very active divine system. D&D without it could be a zero-sum ignorant world like medieval times. The magic and divine systems transform it into an almost scientific world with magic replacing science. We can't easily 'fix' this like the setting stuff. To get a more static result, designers then need to introduce powerful enemies, limit magic to a few people so the results of research can make little social difference, and since that's not enough (the PCs must have access to magic and work against the enemies), introduce almost regular cataclysms. That's still not enough, since the attitude is still a modern one ('we can fix it with tech^W magic').
- 082349872349872 2y agocf "Papers & Paychecks": https://www.explorersdesign.com/content/images/2024/04/7f35addc-8af4-40a5-8efe-12f7ec492372_900x900.png https://www.explorersdesign.com/content/images/2024/04/7f35a...
- subjectsigma 2y agoI mean, did anyone really think D&D was an accurate representation of medieval life in any sense of the word? It’s interesting to talk about medieval life but the pretext for the article is flimsy. If someone really thought non-blood-relative peasants commonly traveled the land in autonomous groups earning money doing side jobs and largely ignoring the law, then I guess we needed this article, but…
- sfink 2y agoSure, but then why call it medieval at all? The term only fits if you define "medieval" as unspecified "olden times" (or circularly, "what D&D calls medieval"). The point, as I understand it, is that there are other terms that would fit the setting somewhat, and medieval does not fit the setting at all (save for in terms of technology). So if you're going to call it something, why medieval as opposed to Renaissance or post-feudal or wild west or Middle Ages anarchy or "the time of the murder hobos"?
- subjectsigma 2y agoCharitably: because of what you mentioned, it gives people an idea of the level of non-magical technology and helps build the world. Uncharitably: it sounds cool and most people won’t know better or even care
- Ericson2314 2y agoD&D is the fever dream of late medieval merchants, guildsman, and other proto-bourgeoisie. It's depopulated because of the black plague.
- DEADMEAT 2y agoPerhaps I'm oversimplifying things, but I have personally always assumed that using "Medieval" to describe D&D was almost entirely a reflection of the (non-magical) level of technology, and not anything societal or cultural.
- the_af 2y agoInteresting. The article does mention the aspect of tech/weapons to mention it's not particularly "medieval" either: > The D&D weapon list has a medieval feel to it, but partly that’s just because that’s what we’re expecting to find. In fact, it’s a sort of survey of (mostly) pre-gunpowder weapons. Most of the weapons and armor appear in ancient Europe and in Asia as well as in medieval Europe. Partial exceptions: Composite bows are mostly non-European, while longbows are associated with Europe. The halberd is basically a Renaissance weapon, and the two-handed sword appears in medieval Europe, India, and Japan, but not the ancient world. No one knows what “plate mail” is supposed to be.
- notjes 2y agoBut societal, cultural and political concepts and traditions are technology too.
- cthalupa 2y agoEarly D&D didn't really make any sort of assumptions about technology level, either. Arneson's campaign was heavily implied to take place in a post-apocalyptic future - Blackmoor was full of advanced technology, including nuclear powered flying cards, lasers, androids, etc. Gygax himself didn't lean into it as hard, but there were plenty of fairly gonzo modules that did include aspects of future and/or alien technology.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- DiscourseFan 2y agoWouldn't that lend credence to the author's claims? That it only appears to be a medieval society, but is instead something very different (a liberal capitalist world after grand social dissolution). After all, the two adventure/roleplaying game series that Bethesda is/was known for are The Elder Scrolls and Fallout, the latter, at least, explicitly taking place in a post-apocalyptic universe.
- paperplatter 2y agoNo, D&D is definitely set in medieval Europe except with magic added, and the mythical creatures are based on European fairy tales (albeit ones before the medieval era). The weapons are also medieval era specifically, with types of swords and armor that didn't exist prior and weren't used later. Maybe it doesn't represent feudalism, but this was the inspiration, not the USA. And macro economy isn't a focus in the game. If you want to make it fit, you could say the adventurers are not adhering to the system, rather they're rebels, nomads, or pirates.
- crooked-v 2y agoIf anything it's much more Renaissance than medieval, what with the prominence of aesthetic-defining heavy armors.
- paperplatter 2y agoI can see that, but plate armor was prominent in the later middle ages too, pre-Renaissance. And D&D has no gunpowder weapons, which were starting to be common in the Renaissance. Then again a lot of "medieval" movies/TV/games mix Renaissance stuff in.
- ender341341 2y agothe DMG has Pistols & Muskets, and there's also Laser Rifles in at least Rime of the Frostmaiden. They just tend to not get used cause they don't really fit in the rest of the setting.
- jghn 2y ago> and the mythical creators are based on European fairy tales My copy of Deities & Demigods had gods from mythology that came from all over the world. Not just European derived.
- creer 2y agoIt's the whole point of the fine article - that very little of actual medieval Europe is in there. It's only in there as a faint backdrop meant to provide some kind of "comon" image in the mind of the players. Exactly like the early sword and sorcery stories, or Conan comics.
- 24currynigger 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- sigy 2y agoI find the overall assertion to be grasping at a counterpoint. Particularly, 1. The reference to "Medieval" labeling goes all the way back to the beginning when D&D overall was nothing but a seed and an experiment. Modern materials do not come with the same presumptive labeling. 2. There is good reason to not include all the trappings of life in any particular era, as the core of D&D is a set of rules, and all the settings are simply versions of content that work on top of it. There are many such settings and they decidedly do not come from the same time and place. 3. Many of the arguments take the form of "It's not ..." wherein the thing that is not explicitly medieval is also not explicitly not-medieval. For example, it's easy to consider the texture of towns and villages as we generally see them in D&D as operating within the tapestry of an explicitly medieval (as the author describes) environment, or within any variation thereof as desired by the DM. Similarly you could also say "D&D does not explain how to make ice cream accurately." It was never _seriously_ about being medieval nor seriously about making ice cream.
- karaterobot 2y agoD&D is the rules system. You can bolt on your own setting, including a hyper-realistic medieval world. I GM'd that game, or its derivatives, for almost 26 years, and never really used their (frankly terrible) generic fantasy setting, since the fun part for me was coming up with our own world. There's nothing mechanically that prevents you from running a medieval game with D&D rules. There are better systems for it, but there's nothing stopping you. You just don't want to. I don't blame you for that. I don't want to run one either. Which may point us to why D&D is ahistorical: a realistic medieval game would be of limited interest to most people.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- calmbonsai 2y agoDuh. D&D has only ever had a “medieval aesthetic” going all the way back to “Advanced” 1st edition.
- Jiro 2y agoD&D isn't American history. It's fantasy fiction. The "American History"-like elements come from fantasy fiction, where someone like Conan could become a king and there are unexplored areas full of hostiles all over the place.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoCore d&d is lord of the rings and the hobbit, with much more powerful magic. Really the essence of the game is right in the name: dungeon crawl, fantasy creatures. Everything else is a bolt on. Personally I apply a rule that there is no way to "mass produce" magic effects. Each spell invocation is unique based on local conditions/environment, and enchantment of magical items is unique to the item, even if quantities, materials, shapes, etc is precisely identical. Otherwise magic is essentially more powerful than modern technology and medicine: infinite power generation, cure anything, raise dead, invulnerability, produce almost anything from thin air, know anything, teleport anywhere, and it would be inevitable that machines would be made to do so It is kind of like the navigators in dune, although that has a prohibition on computers, I believe that computers pre jihad couldn't compete with spice enabled navigator prescience. What was always funny to me as a teenager was the price tables for castles like barbicans, crenellations, etc: I had no idea what these were before the Internet. I knew towers, walls keeps. Castles themselves seem much useless in the age of dragons, flying carpets, disintegrate spells, and flying mounts. There's a reason the US military doesn't have castles for defense.
- jghn 2y ago> Core d&d is lord of the rings and the hobbit, with much more powerful magic. Originally it was much more Conan the Barbarian & other such pulp fantasy stories than LOTR.
- scelerat 2y ago"You can be forgiven for thinking that OD&D is a medieval European fantasy game. After all, Gary Gygax himself says so. " At various points (the original Dungeon Master's Guide, for example, page 88), he also has said it's expressly not a European Feudal game, and goes at length to qualify that, saying that it is only one of many sources of inspiration, and describes a number of political systems possible in a campaign and explains ways a variety of societies could be woven into it. So, yeah I suppose if you've only read a little about D&D you could be forgiven for thinking this, but there is a large body of in-game and supplementary official and fan-created rules and settings which should give no one the impression that at any point were game authors and players as a whole were going for feudal european verisimilitude (or opposing it, for that matter) Blog post is interesting but the title and initial setup is kind of a strawman
- Yeul 2y agoAs an atheist D&D always annoyed me, but it was created by Americans so nothing you can do about that.But it gets especially weird when everyone knows demons and hell exist. In reality our ancestors have always dealt with a silent god. Something that even in medieval society did not go unnoticed.