3 ms·
Most scientific and engineering research follows the same pattern: you spend a lot of time setting up an elaborate thingamajig to test a hypothesis, then you ru
by timr 18y ago
Most scientific and engineering research follows the same pattern: you spend a lot of time setting up an elaborate thingamajig to test a hypothesis, then you run the experiment, and spend months analyzing the data. Then you discover that you've failed. Lather, Rinse, Repeat. Data-mining research just uses computer software as the thingamajig, so maybe you do a few more failure cycles per unit time than the guys down the hall (who are building a nuclear accelerator to find the anti-bozon -- but hey, at least they get to play with lasers!)
As far as practical advice for someone contemplating a PhD in bioinformatics, mine would be: don't get a PhD in bioinformatics. There are no jobs, and a PhD is generally just a fantastic waste of time (unless you want to be a professor, and are comfortable with the numerous, well-documented drawbacks of that lifestyle). If you feel that you must explore the field, go far enough to get an MS, then quit.
I realize that's harsh, so I'll add some slightly softer, less-valuable advice: if you must get a PhD in bioinformatics, at least have the good sense to do it in a computer science department, so that you can go back into software when you find there are no jobs in bioinformatics. It's a dangerous mistake to get a PhD in bioinformatics from a biology department (ahem...do as I say, not as I do.)
Failing all of that advice, if you really, really want to be in bioinformatics, despite all good advice to the contrary, then make sure that you spend equal amounts of time at the bench and at the computer. If you want to be respected in the field, you have to have experimental results to back up your computer models, and the best way to do that is to run the experiments yourself. Run away from any program or professor who won't let you work at the bench.
- cowmoo 18y agoThank you for posting such helpful advice. I think the last part of your advice is the most helpful - that you need to really do wet lab benchwork, something I've tried to avoid during my undergrad, thinking that computers are the way of future and lab work is for suckers. But alas, in the realm of biology, the micropipetters and mice-killers win again. But I appreciate you for also being very adamant about the "dark side" of academia; it would have deterred me if someone else didn't also warn me once about the "dark side" of going corporate (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=66390 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=66390). I appreciate again your advice and will think it over very carefully when I decide as to what exactly I am going to do next.
- timr 18y agoGlad to help. I was being a little tongue-in-cheek, obviously, but I meant what I said. The job market is very bad for biologists of all disciplines right now, and computational biology isn't the discipline with the greatest demand. If you decide to go on, being able to work at the bench is essential to your career. But don't take my word as proof -- the Science Magazine Career forums are literally filled with sad stories of PhDs and post-docs in the biological sciences who can't get jobs. I wish it had existed when I started my program: http://scforum.aaas.org/ http://scforum.aaas.org/ (One more thing: I just read the link to the other comments, and I don't disagree with what they wrote. Most software jobs suck, too. But the key insight here is that most jobs suck -- there is no magic bullet to career happiness. The corollary to that insight is that you need to fail fast; you must quickly work through the things that suck, and find the things that don't. Because a PhD ties you to one thing for so long, it is almost the antithesis of failing fast. For this reason, I would not recommend a PhD to anyone, unless they explicitly wanted to become a professor, and knew exactly what they were getting themselves into. It's not the kind of decision that rewards indecisiveness.)
- davi 18y ago"...computers are the way of future and lab work is for suckers. But alas, in the realm of biology, the micropipetters and mice-killers win again." Doing biology is the only way to develop biological intuition. Sometimes this means pipetting and killing mice. Ernst Mayr speaks to this: "About two years ago, three years ago, for maybe the 20th time I went over the whole business of the species concept. What is a species? I looked at the major figures in the evolutionary synthesis, and I looked at Robzhansky and myself, and Huxley and Stebbins, all of us had reasonable species concepts, and the only person that had a species concept that I thought was quite absurd was the paleontologist G.G. Simpson. And then I said to myself, "Well, he can't have been a naturalist in his youth if he had such a peculiar, unworkable species concept." So I went to Simpson's biography and what did I find? I found that in college he was an English major. He had never been a naturalist as a youngster. He never collected anything, and he discovered geology in his senior year in college, and from there he went to stratigraphy and finally to paleontology. Not surprisingly, not having been a naturalist, he has no idea what a species is and he never had. I argued with him about the species concept year after year, but lacking that background, he was unable to see it, and that is the thing. Being a naturalist -- having had that background of being a naturalist -- gives you a view of nature that cannot be acquired just learning from books." (Go to bottom of http://www.achievement.org/autodoc/page/may1int-5 http://www.achievement.org/autodoc/page/may1int-5 for a video of him saying it while sitting next to E. O. Wilson.)
- Prrometheus 18y agoI'm trying to decide between a CS MS with a machine learning specialty or a bioinformatics specialty. Would you say machine learning is more employable? Bioinformatics probably interests me more.
- lliiffee 18y agoMy feeling is that, at the moment, there are a huge number of academic bioinformatics jobs available. (More than machine learning.) Be aware, however, that these academic jobs are probably not attainable with an MS, and the market tends to change quickly. In industry, my feeling is that machine learning is more employable. I think that a CS MS who is a great programmer and knows machine learning cold would have very good employment prospects.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]