5 ms·
Why is it not fair for an insurance company to charge you a higher premium if you are leading a lifestyle that statistically makes you more likely to have healt
by ams6110 14y ago
Why is it not fair for an insurance company to charge you a higher premium if you are leading a lifestyle that statistically makes you more likely to have health problems?
- Mz 14y agoInsurance theoretically spreads risk and operates on laws of large numbers -- in other words, the company is betting that if 500,000 people buy this policy, statistically it will only pay out on a relatively small number of them, thus covering operating expenses and turning a profit. But, for health insurance,* it tends to not really work that way. You don't get 500,000 completely random people buying the policy. People are more likely to buy the policy if they have reason to believe they will need/profit from it. So insurance companies try to account for that reality. I think it is a fundamentally broken system. * Car insurance, which is basically required across the U.S., seems to work a little closer to the way it is "supposed to".
- olefoo 14y ago1. You are making the assumption that the insurance companies models of what is and is not a risky lifestyle are correct. 2. For the same reason that your employer is not entitled to put cameras in your bathroom to make sure you aren't doing anything that might impact your job performance.
- 3143 14y ago1. All other factors being equal, insurance companies with more accurate statistical models will do better. 2.. Because many employees would choose to not work for such an employer, and this negative impact would outweigh the potential benefit? I haven't seen anything to suggest that people would choose not to be insured by a company that profiles its clients in this way.
- Cadsby 14y agoI think on a principled level, many are becoming concerned about the ever increasing volume of data being collected on all of us. It isn't necessarily about any particular subset of data, or all the plausible abuses of it, it's just the idea that some would rather not have every move they make being recorded and logged into a system they have no information on or ability to influence. More specific to insurance companies, the potential/plausible abuses to increase profit don't take much effort to ferret out. And to make matters worse the data they use will invariable flag a lot of false positives that you'll have little to no way of fixing. For example, my girlfriend regularly picks me up a pack of cigarettes on her way home from work. She usually uses her credit card instead of cash. Ok, now she's flagged in the system as being a chronic smoker and her rates get jacked up to holy hell. Except, of course, she's not actually a smoker and I'd be super skeptical about her ability to reasonably explain this to some random customer service rep over the telephone. Data mining usage habits rarely result in lower prices for people making positive, less risky choices. Non-smokers will probably be giving a trivial token discount, but unlikely anything more.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoData mining usage habits rarely result in lower prices for people making positive, less risky choices. This is because we live in an inflationary economy. Most prices go up. As a healthy guy, I'd like the price increases to be inflicted on the fattie smokers rather than me. Not that it really matters in the context of health insurance - the laws surrounding it are structured in such a way as to subsidize the fattie smokers at the expense of healthy gym guy, regardless of what info the insurance company has (and they will become worse in a couple of years, unless the supreme court stops it - good luck with that).
- nitrogen 14y agoAs a healthy guy, I'd like the price increases to be inflicted on the fattie smokers rather than me. I have a friend who agrees with you, and I am constantly dismayed at the willingness of people to throw their fellow human beings under the bus. There are better ways of improving total health than letting insurance companies screw more cash out of the more vulnerable members of society.
- 3143 14y agoYou're dismayed that some people believe the unhealthiest of the population ought to pay the largest share of healthcare costs? Maybe you disagree, but "dismayed" seems very harsh.
- sehugg 14y agoLiving your life according to contradictory actuarial tables cooked up by people running an anti-competitive market captured by government regulation? Sounds like fun.
- rogerbinns 14y agoIf you are going to charge people for what they use then it isn't insurance any more. That is the really silly thing in the US - the "insurance" system is really just a mechanism for obfuscating how much things cost. And if you want to start down the "lifestyle" road then why shouldn't people who have kids pay more (it is a choice too), or the people in LA (who are more likely to get skin cancer). And remember back in the 60s people didn't think cigarettes were that harmful. Soon we'll find out that fat is good, or bad, or was it salt? Do we get to retroactively charge and refund people as scientific evidence mounts up?
- ams6110 14y agoI guess I disagree to some extent. Insurance is designed to protect you from rare but catastrophic losses. It's not (originally, anyway) intended to step in and pay for reasonably forseeable expenses (routine health care, for example). A contributing reason that health insurance is so expensive is that people have been using it as a way to only pay 20% or less of expenses they know they are going to have. By the way, if you buy your own insurance, and you have kids, or want maternity coverage, you pay more.
- rogerbinns 14y ago> Insurance is designed to protect you from rare but catastrophic losses That is 100% correct. My point was that the US system of health "insurance" is anything but insurance. > ... that people have been using it as a way to only pay 20% or less of expenses ... That isn't the case. Ultimately the premiums paid by you and/or your employer as part of your "benefits" (foregone salary) will cover most of your expenses, otherwise it isn't a viable business model as pretty much everything involves an insurance transaction. The actual procedures really don't cost that much. It is the extra layers of obfuscation, administration, multiple parties etc that totally confuse what is going on. You should try buying your own insurance someday. It becomes obvious again how it really isn't insurance. I believe California health insurance now requires maternity coverage.
- mikeash 14y agoEven if it's fair, that doesn't mean we have to willfully help them do so.
- lcargill99 14y agoSo is salt still bad for you this week? Because you don't hire them to nag you, you hire them to finance certain forms of consumption. None of the numbers about even smoking have held up very well over time. "Lifestyle policing" is, like exercise mania, about vanity, not health. The exercise industry is there to pump up sports medicine spending while assuaging the Baby Boomer terror of death. Go look up which is faster rising, sports medicine or oncology. People have enough information about consumption choices to make informed choices. We should leave them be. But the point is you hire them, they don't own you. "The servant is the one that takes the money" - Lawrence of Arabia.