5 ms·
Med Student Rescues Body Part From Airport Security
- andos 14y agoI was reading this like any other ordinary story. Then I got to this part: Amazingly, he doesn't do transplants anymore. Tracheas, he has decided, can be regenerated from scratch, using stem cells. It brought tears to my eyes. No amount of bad news can weaken the beauty contained in that little paragraph. This made my day, really.
- timr 14y agoThere are so many angles to this story that involve the tension between the forces of conservative thinking, and innovators who are trying to make the world a better place. Ignore the idiotic airport security problem, and you're still left with an amazing, improbable story about the world-changing consequences of an emerging technology that religious luddites keep trying to destroy. Only a few short years ago, our society was getting its collective panties in a knot over the ethics of stem cell research. The US president made a strong movement to kill that research in the womb (pardon the pun). At the time, nobody could convincingly enumerate the medical benefits of the work...because it was research. Now we're synthesizing body parts. Amazing. How many years of human life will be saved? There's no upper limit. "Pro-life", indeed. Save this story, and use it the next time you're in an argument with someone who wants to stop pure intellectual exploration in the name of vague, supernatural objections. (Edit: Yes, these particular organs are being synthesized from adult stem cells, not embryonic stem cells. But it's a distinction without a difference -- we cannot predict what advancements or understanding will come from any given line of research. The argument is greater than the adjective.)
- Turing_Machine 14y agoThese aren't embryonic stem cells. No one has a problem with adult stem cells (well, I suppose the folks who refuse all forms of medical treatment might).
- timr 14y ago"No one has a problem with adult stem cells." Untrue. There are/were plenty of groups who object to all stem cell research. Embryonic cells are just the most controversial segment. (Consider this thought experiment: take a fully differentiated human cell, and transform it such that it is capable of generating a embryo. Do you think this won't generate objections on religious grounds?) The heart of the debate is that our knowledge is pushing relentlessly against the darkness of superstition, and that makes some people uncomfortable -- just as every scientific advancement has made people uncomfortable. We're just in a sad period where these people have greater influence over our society's decisions.
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"There are/were plenty of groups who object to all stem cell research." Can you name a few? Thanks. To the best of my knowledge, no major religious group opposes adult stem cell research.
- timr 14y agoHow about bishops in the Catholic Church? http://www.lifenews.com/2006/08/23/bio-1727/ http://www.lifenews.com/2006/08/23/bio-1727/ 'Richard Doerflinger of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, an expert on bioethics issues, told the Associated Press the research "raises more ethical questions than it answers."..."It is widely believed that one cell of a very early embryo may separate and become a new embryo, an identical twin," Doerflinger told the Associated Press.' Here's another response to the same experiment, which better captures the root of the objections: http://cathnews.acu.edu.au/608/140.html http://cathnews.acu.edu.au/608/140.html '"Regardless of the speculated benefits, no human being, particularly the most vulnerable, should be treated as raw material which we can manipulate and manufacture," Mr O'Gorman said.'
- Turing_Machine 14y agoThat has nothing whatsoever to do with adult stem cells. Did you miss the part that was talking about embryos or what? Update: try this http://www.catholic.org/international/international_story.php?id=43670 http://www.catholic.org/international/international_story.ph... If you think the Catholic Church is opposed to adult stem cell research, you're simply misinformed.
- iwwr 14y agoWe are starting to see glimpses of the hidden costs of airport security. Consider just that by discouraging flight, more people end up dead on the (vastly more) insecure roads.
- vacri 14y agoStrange that the article title refers to a bit of high drama rather than "we can make replacement tracheas from scratch now!"
- marquis 14y agoIt is a sad day that speaks volumes about the world we live in now, that we encounter an article on such an important, ground-breaking topic, and it's titled 'Airport security refuses transport'.
- tvon 14y agoWhen was the world not like this?
- legutierr 14y agoApproximately eleven years ago.
- objclxt 14y agoActually, they would have been fine six years ago - the liquid ban only came into force in 2006. And the EU would very much like to lift the ban, because it's completely pointless - it's meant to be lifted on EU flights in April 2013. Except both the US and the aviation industry is heavily lobbying for the EU to scrap their plans, for 'security' reasons (if you were cynical you might suggest budget airlines and airports benefitted from a liquids ban, as people had to spend money in airports/on planes rather than bringing their own refreshments etc).
- tvon 14y agoMhm, I was more alluding to the media and sensationalist and misleading headlines, but I get your point.
- mikeash 14y agoIt's possible to have multiple news articles concentrating on different aspects of the same event. I bet there are other articles out there that concentrate on the medical research. Not everything out there has to cover only the most important stuff.
- jgamman 14y agoi think there's a lesson here in risk management. the obviously brilliant doctor failed to put care and attention into the mundane delivery part of the process. there are no small details. Jet Star is a low price, zero premium service. for the cash/time invested, they should have being going business class with a premium airline, a signed piece of letterhead and if possible, hired an airline rep to walk them in one airport and out the other. someone's life hung on the balance of a student knowing a pilot...
- tokenadult 14y agoPrevious submission, no comments: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4135224 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4135224 (Neither this nor the previous submission submitted the canonical URL, which helps the HN duplicated detector do its job.) http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4111691 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4111691
- catch23 14y agoI hadn't seen it before. Reposts are not necessarily bad, if there are no comments, nobody saw the post, thus a repost is necessary. Perhaps the de-dup mechanism shouldn't incorporate comment-less posts as part of its data set.
- adventureful 14y agoThe stem cell century accelerates.
- kba 14y agoMed student rescues body part? More like German pilot.
- kristianp 14y agoOr Med student who knows the right person.
- ajb 14y agoThe security professions need to learn a lesson which doctors have understood for some time now: treating everyone for a rare threat does more harm than good. Suppose there is a drug which prevents heart attacks, but due to side effects, rare reactions, or just plain error, causes damage to a small proportion of people. If you have a 50% chance of a heart attack, taking it would be a good bet. But giving the same drug to everyone would be a medical disaster. Any treatment you give to a broad population had better be extraordinarily safe. The rarer the threat you are trying to address, the more easily you can do more harm than good. Terrorism is rare.
- sausagefeet 14y agoI think there is a flip side of it too: Fliers need to make it clear that they are OK with the fact that if they want to be treated better, security will not catch all security risks.
- ajb 14y agoYes and no. Think of it this way: if you have a graph of security against cost, there is a line which represents possible tradeoffs of best security for a given cost. You are saying, we need to think about where we want to be on the line. I don't think we are even on the line.
- shod 14y agoThat's true when the risks outweigh the benefits, but it's not always true otherwise: we vaccinate everyone against smallpox to -keep- it rare! Unfortunately, the cost of removing this sort of security theater as a deterrent is invisible and hypothetical, whereas the benefits are obvious.
- nacker 14y ago"The security professions need to learn a lesson which doctors have understood for some time now: treating everyone for a rare threat does more harm than good." Nanny states need to learn this principle too: "First do no harm".