9 ms·
They need to crack down on companies that ruin hardware (or will one day ruin hardware) when they shut off their last cloud server. There's no excuse for an ap
by ryandrake 2y ago
They need to crack down on companies that ruin hardware (or will one day ruin hardware) when they shut off their last cloud server.
There's no excuse for an appliance to brick itself or lose functionality just because of the manufacturer's remote action. When I buy a device, I don't want a perpetual, tethered relationship with the manufacturer in order to work the device. I don't want it to ask the manufacturer for permission to run every day. I don't want it to be dependent on the manufacturer to keep it alive. I don't want to create an account. I don't want to log in to the manufacturer's servers. I don't want them to know my IP address or my home address. Leave me alone, I'm just not that into you!
A hardware device should work on day 10,000 just as it worked on day 1. If you as a company can't do that, you should not be able to sell the device (EDIT: OR at least you should be required to prominently mark the devices as "dependent on the manufacturer's servers")
- a2128 2y ago> OR at least you should be required to prominently mark the devices as "dependent on the manufacturer's servers" Right next to the prominent label about causing cancer in the state of California, presumably. I feel a notice wouldn't work here because the average consumer wouldn't understand the implications of depending on the manufacturer's servers or what it even means, plus every smart doorbell or whatever would just include it so it's not like it'd affect any consumer's choice
- benoau 2y agoLove it. This product may be revoked at any time. This product incurs $30 billion in annual fees. This product sells your usage data.
- ddingus 2y agoYeah. The features present at time of purchase may be changed, downgraded, or removed at any time.
- salawat 2y agoWith no obligation from the manufacturer to inform you of changes, and even if one exists in law, whaddya tonna do about it? We're doing the take it or leave it approach.
- ddingus 2y agoYep. Major turn off. I do not buy, unless forced. Just have no need for the hassles.
- matheusmoreira 2y agoWhenever I come across a thing that contains a "terms of service" or "license agreement", I refuse to read it and make the assumption it says the following things: > you own nothing > the company owns everything > you have no rights > you promise not to try and exercise any right you think you have > just in case you ever get it in your silly little head that you do have any rights whatsoever, you agree to binding arbitration with the firm we pay > you cannot do anything the company doesn't like > the company can do literally anything it wants whether you like it or not > the company is not responsible for anything ever > the company makes absolutely no guarantees about anything > but you agree to indemnify us in all possible circumstances
- ddingus 2y agoThat, sadly, is an entirely reasonable take on all this.
- consteval 2y agoYeah these labeling requirements only work if you operate under the assumption companies will be truthful. But if they're truthful, we wouldn't require labels in the first place, they'd just do them. So it's dead in the water.
- LorenPechtel 2y agoAnd such dependency should only be permitted if there is some essential function the server is providing. Unfortunately, for a lot of devices that's inherently required to get through the firewall--for example, my garage door opener. Since it's not accessible from the internet the app has to communicate with the company server, the same server the opener opened a connection to to listen for commands. There's also the grey area of remote kill. It should be required to be disclosed up front and the company should be required to put up a deposit with the FTC for a simple you-can-live server. If the company shuts down the FTC's copy is spun up and anything that hasn't been killed continues to operate.
- ryandrake 2y agoGarage door opener is a perfect example of a device that should NOT require a cloud service in order to operate. Think about how it works. I'm sitting in my house on my LAN, the same LAN that the garage door opener is on. I open the app to close the garage door. It sends a command out to some server on the Internet. Then the garage door, which is presumably polling the server at all times, receives the command to close from the server, and closes. Why on earth can't I just send the command directly to my garage door opener over my LAN? That should be the simplest mode of operation possible. I only need Internet connectivity if I somehow want to close my garage door from miles away!
- stackghost 2y ago... Doesn't your garage door opener send an RF signal to the receiver on the motor?
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoMany of them now go through the internet. My friend had me install the app, granted me access to his garage door from another country and revoked it later, all while still in that country. I'm pretty sure he's had it fail from right outside his house due to mobile network outages more often than he's used it from far away though.
- 2y ago
- galleywest200 2y agoAlternatively we could require companies open-source the server hardware if they choose to shut down their for-profit offering. Another option is to require companies go the Minecraft route where the "server" portion is always free to download and run but you need the paid client to actually connect to the servers to play the game.
- mindslight 2y agoIt shouldn't really matter whether a company discontinues their service or not, because the right way to address this trend is through antitrust enforcement against the bundling of device products with software service products. These two things should be distinct product offerings with independent markets, and devices should be straightforwardly configurable as to which specific servers/services to use (with openly documented protocols, of course).
- throwaway8481 2y agoI think the opposite side of this coin is that the company should clearly define the minimum lifetime of the product and it support, including what services they will provide upon its sunset (such as a partial refund and disposal if the product folds before that date). I want to make an informed decision, and like you I would shop for another product beyond this crap we subscribe to.
- jaggederest 2y agoThis is the same problem as packaging. I think we should have a designated escrow service for the disposal costs of packaging that is taken off the front end, similar to the pension benefit guarantee corporation. Imagine if there were a product support guarantee corporation which took, say, 4% of the cost of retail electronics sales, in order to guarantee their long term support.
- awaythrow999 2y agoDefining minimum support period is already required by law in UK and will also be mandatory in EU as of next year.
- shiroiushi 2y ago>including what services they will provide upon its sunset (such as a partial refund and disposal if the product folds before that date) This might be OK for a huge company like Google, but for many others, what good is it? If the product folds, it's probably because the whole company folded, and when that happens, you're not getting a refund, regardless of what any contract says.
- baq 2y agoWhy people like me buy iphones? Not because they've got the best hardware or have the best camera or the best apps (though they're pretty damn good at those), not because they are open for hackers (they're basically the worst), but because the manufacturer provides de facto support for at least 5 years after release. My kids all have iPhone 8s and they still get security iOS updates. Did they promise that anywhere? No. Did they kept on their unwritten and unspoken promise? Yes, for years now. Do you have to be Apple to do this? I don't know, would love it if the answer was no, but looks like everyone else treats this as cost and Apple treats it as value added?
- CivBase 2y agoDon't stop at hardware. If the software runs locally but connects to a server for some non-essential or non-functional feature, it should continue working after they shut that server down.
- nullc 2y agolocal network isn't enough because these things are usually driven by phone apps and google and apple make periodic API breaking changes and kick everything off the platforms that doesn't constantly update. So even if its not server dependent many IOT things will still become unusable rather quickly.
- apatheticonion 2y agoCouldn't agree more. A recent example - you buy a $1600 virtual reality headset (HP G2, specifically). A couple of years later the manufacturer drops support and Microsoft disables WMR capabilities. This bricks a perfectly functional, expensive, device. Personally, I feel the "right to repair" should extend to software. Why am I not allowed to revive an old mobile phone with a new OS version? Why am I not allowed to revive an old device by modernizing its hardware driver? Why can I not bring an old video game back to life? Yes source code is IP - but maybe an expiration system similar to pharmaceuticals should apply where, for instance, a regulator compels a companies to release the sources of their drivers & services when a product or service is no longer officially supported.
- doctorwho42 2y agoNeed some kind of public domain requirements on sunset code/software. Same as we need copyright maximums in the range of a generation (20 years). Having something come out of copy right 100 years later removes the cultural impact that putting a copyright into the public domain has. Primarily because everyone who was impacted by the original copyright is no longer alive. A prime example is steamboat Willie, aka Micky mouse og, really doesn't have any interest in doing much with it because it is culturally stale/mummified/dried out.
- vjk800 2y agoI think this would seriously tank the smartphone business. The reason why I have to buy a new phone every few years is basically sugarcoated planned obsolescence. If the software running my five year old Android phone was public domained, likely the community would keep my phone running for at least five more years. Not saying that this shouldn't happen, though. Just saying that people suggesting this sort of stuff should realize that the economic consequences for some businesses would be major.
- iSnow 2y ago>I think this would seriously tank the smartphone business Not so sure in reality. There's a lot to dislike about Apple and I won't go into it, but as an example, I like their support policy. They promise 5y and usually it's 7y. They do disable features on older phones via feature flags where the performance would not be up to it (like on-device AI lately), but this rather long support does not seem to impact their sales negatively. Arguably it works for them b/c people know they can resell their phones after 2y and still get a good price as buyers know they will get support. I am one who switched from Android/Sony precisely because of this. The same could be true for opening older phones as some Android makers do unlocking the boot loader and leave it to enthusiasts to port newer Android versions. Many phones get recycled to something different this way (controller for home automation) and would never reduce sales.
- matheusmoreira 2y agoThey should not be legally allowed to use the word "buy". They're actually renting out their products.
- Avamander 2y agoThis is the biggest thing IMHO. Same with games. Buy should mean buy.
- matheusmoreira 2y agoYeah it's especially bad with video games. One of the most dishonest practices I've ever seen. People amass "libraries" and "accounts" worth tens of thousands of dollars and the corporation can just take it all away for any reason at all including no reason. They don't like a little comment you made somewhere, banned, entire account deleted, "your" "property" permanently revoked, and unless some legal miracle happens that forces them to overturn it they won't even reply to you. They say "buy" but in reality it's a "licensing agreement" nonsense with a zillion lawyery rules nobody cares about or even reads. Judges should take one look at that and throw the whole thing out but they won't because the intellectual property industry is worth trillions of dollars which means they can buy laws that favor them via lobbyists. It feels like the world is unfixably wrong.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y ago"dependent on the manufacturer's servers" should also require that it let my install my own certs so I can MITM that connection and see what it's saying to the manufacturer's servers.
- lodovic 2y agoThe way it's sold, you buy all those services from the vendor, and need their device to get access. So either the device should be replacable at low or no cost, or you should be able to switch vendor.
- euroderf 2y agoSo then the new-business model is escrow for ensuring continuity of server-based services ?
- iSnow 2y agoI mean, I fully agree, but how would any jurisdiction even enforce this? If the manufacturer goes out of business, their cloud service will be shut down 90% of the time (exception is if some entity buys the bankrupt company to restructure it). No one has any incentive to keep a service running that makes no money. And I believe (not totally sure though) that IP is always part of the bankruptcy assets so probably insolvent companies are not even allowed to just open-source their stuff and allow configuration of the backend so users could set up community-servers and keep things running. Completely different are cases where companies continue to live but lock features behind new paywalls like Happiest Baby with their Snoo bassinet, invent fees to hinder re-sale like Peloton or cripple working hardware like Sonos did. Those make me unreasonably mad, not just because I already have too many subscriptions for things that improve my QoL but add up, but also because I do care about my CO2 and environmental footprint. I do not want to trash working devices just because they are now 2 years old. Companies should untether them if they think further cloud support is no longer viable and at the very least should support them for 7-10y.
- throwway120385 2y agoForce the manufacturer to release their source code for any server-side component of any product. Or API specifications and any HAB keys needed to boot new firmware on the device.
- jjk166 2y agoMake it a legal requirement that if they brick the devices they owe the purchaser a refund for the value of any parts of the hardware that are compromised, minus some depreciation schedule. Then they have an incentive to keep running that service even if it's not currently making them any money. If they go out of business, that obligation is the same as any other on the books - assets will be sold off to cover the debts as best as possible, or some other agreement reached. Patching some code so that the system isn't bricked when the server shuts down is almost certainly cheaper than giving everyone their money back.
- nonrandomstring 2y agoProducts configured this way are a combination of a "logic bomb" [0] and a "dead man's handle" [1]. Together they form a very nasty combo. Suicide bombers like release-to-make switches, so if you shoot them they at least complete part of their mission. Companies that create self-destructing products are thinking like this. They are binding their survival to that of their customers as human shields and saying "we'll take you with us". It's very disturbing psychology and having laws that allow companies to do it, even by hiding behind supposed technical ignorance, is a problem. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic_bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic_bomb [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_man's_switch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_man's_switch
- andai 2y ago>you should be required to prominently mark the devices as "dependent on the manufacturer's servers") Actually it's "we spy on you and reserve the right to brick your device at any time", which pretty much every EULA already covers ...
- brewdad 2y agoThat language needs to be in bold print on the consumer package not hidden in a shrinkwrap license inside the box or worse, online somewhere. Treat it like we do with food allergen labels. A standard location and plain language.
- thinkingtoilet 2y ago>When I buy a device, I don't want a perpetual, tethered relationship with the manufacturer in order to work the device. Then don't buy that device. I know this will be unpopular but there is an entitlement here. I want X, X comes with insane restrictions, instead of sticking to my principles I will buy X then complain about the restrictions. I agree it shouldn't happen, but I also don't buy anything that allows that to happen to me.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Supermancho 2y ago> Then don't buy that device Except when the device doesn't appear to be, but can be updated in a way that makes it obvious it does. Absolute statements like "all devices should be able to be jailbroken" or "I want things supported forever" or "just dont do x" are misguided. The world is more complicated, even on this issue. Any implemented solution will have holes and the world will be all the better for it. Progress requires things to die off.
- nullsmack 2y agoMany devices can absolutely be built in a way that they do not require a dumb remote server to work, but they're built that way anyways because the manufacturer is rent seeking. It can be damn near impossible to find equivalent devices that don't do that. It is absolutely right to get one and complain about absurd remote links that shouldn't be there in the first place.
- thinkingtoilet 2y agoIf you're financially rewarding them to do it, I honestly don't want to hear you complain about it. Company X is doing exactly what I paid them to do! What a nightmare!
- jjk166 2y agoIs it clearly advertised at time of sale that X comes with the insane restrictions? Is there a viable alternative to X without? What are the consequences if you don't make a purchase at all? There are some necessary conditions to fully consent to an agreement. If someone has a gun to your head and tells you to do something you don't want to do, it is not entitlement to comply but complain instead of "sticking to your principles".
- tivert 2y ago> When I buy a device, I don't want a perpetual, tethered relationship with the manufacturer in order to work the device. Yes, but all the manufacturers want you in that relationship with them, and the technology of "internet" has finally given them that ability. It's just a reminder that capitalism doesn't produce the best goods for consumers, it only produces the ones that are just not shitty enough that people keep buying them. No matter how good a product is, the market will inevitably enshittify it to optimally conform to market incentives.