6 ms·
> If the answer is "they just don't get access anymore" or "a panel of their peers attests to them", your fantasy authentication system also needs a fantasy spe
by simonw 2y ago
> If the answer is "they just don't get access anymore" or "a panel of their peers attests to them", your fantasy authentication system also needs a fantasy species of sentient beings to serve as users, because it won't work for humans.
This has been my single biggest argument against blockchain/cryptocurrency stuff for years: the "lose your key, lose your wallet" thing is fundamentally incompatible with real users.
Humans need to be able to recover from their mistakes.
- j-bos 2y agoI don't know, we carried physical money for millenia. Humans managed that.
- iamthepieman 2y agoYou didn't lose your entire savings if you lost your wallet, usually.
- onethought 2y agoPerhaps micro wallets should be a thing where your wealth is distributed across many keys mitigating some loss.
- jakelazaroff 2y agoIf I’m having trouble juggling a single ball, why would it help to add more balls into the mix?
- ta_1138 2y agoAt which point I gained the problem of having to keep track of all of my microwallets securely, hopefully in a way that survives my phone being lost, a house fire, or my untimely death, leaving the wealth to inheritors. All while, at the same time, not ending up behind a single key that has access to all the information to those micro wallets. Quickly you end up in a situation that either starts to look like how financial companies keep their most high risk keys, or end up outsourcing the whole thing to something that quickly starts to resemble your bank. So ultimately it's just like cash: Fine for small amounts. Risky, but maybe livable for somewhat larger accounts, or a giant headache that will probably bite you when you start looking at lifetime savings.
- IggleSniggle 2y agoPhysical money is physically recoverable after lost
- onethought 2y agoNo it isn’t. No more than a wallet key. If I lose $1 note. It’s gone. If I recover it, then it’s no longer lost.
- MadnessASAP 2y agoA $1 note being a macro scale physical object enjoys a variety of benefits such as object permanence which provide a baseline level of recoverability. Whereas a wallet key l, being a number, enjoys no such protections. Of course you may choose to encode your wallet key on paper, metal, or stone granting it properties not unlike a note. However you have now compromised the security of your wallet as well it becomes no mere $1 note, rather it is a note that represents all or a significant fraction of your net worth.
- zmgsabst 2y agoYou can encode your bitcoin in wallets of predetermined size, spreading your risk. But you’re reinventing money with extra steps.
- Djdjur7373bb 2y ago> But you’re reinventing money with extra steps. But you gain some desirable properties over traditional money. Without crypto, you don't have frictionless and permissionless transfers of arbitrary value across international borders.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoThere's no fundamental property of the monetary system that prevents transfers of arbitrary value across international borders. There's just a large number of financial regulators, border guards, etc. who will throw you in jail if you carry a big block of gold across the border or accept a large wire transfer without filling out the necessary forms. In many countries, the laws governing those forms don't yet apply to cryptocurrencies, but I'm skeptical it will remain that way forever.
- blahedo 2y agoYes, by evolving banks to solve some of the problems of lugging around lots of cash and/or stuffing it in a trunk in your house. And assuming you are known at your bank and/or can (eventually) prove your identity there, you don't have the same "lost wallet" problem being discussed here.
- lolinder 2y agoMoney occupies physical space, so for most of history there was a pretty low cap on how much you could bring with you at once, which placed a cap on how much a single mistake could cost you.
- zmgsabst 2y agoThat cap has always and still does exceed the median worth.
- zaphirplane 2y ago> cap on how much you could bring Bring to where ? Are you mapping the crypto wallet concept to the physical wallet concept as a mobile storage concept ? All your money is the limit, however you store it.
- ekianjo 2y ago> there was a pretty low cap on how much you could bring with you at once, you didnt need to bring a case of cash to buy anything before the 20th century
- somenameforme 2y agoCurrency was traditionally made of precious metals which often gave them a rather high starting point of value. It also made them inflation resistant meaning the real value only grew over time. For instance in the Roman Empire an aureus [1] was worth 25 denarii (prior to inflation) and was about 2cm in size, so roughly the same size as a dime, made of pure gold. And a denarius was worth about a day's wages. So you could comfortably hold decades of wages in a small coin purse. And as inflation ravaged the Empire a single aureus gradually came to be worth thousands of denarii. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aureus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aureus
- presentation 2y agoThis is what transit payment cards in Japan at least do, you can tap to pay most places but there’s a cap of 20k yen you can add to your card, so there’s a cap to how much you can lose.
- School-Cotton 2y agoYeah and it sucked which is why we invented better solutions. What most bitcoin fans seem not to understand is that for the vast majority of people, transactions being reversible by authority figures is desirable.
- lelanthran 2y ago> I don't know, we carried physical money for millenia. Humans managed that. Yeah, but if I lose the physical 100$ I am carrying, that doesn't prevent me from accessing the rest of my cash stored elsewhere. I've never lost access to the rest of my cash stored elsewhere.
- alkonaut 2y agoYes and people quickly realized that there is an amount they don’t want to carry around. No one carries their life savings and few would even keep it in a safe in their house.
- paxys 2y agoBanks have been a thing almost as long as money.
- kibwen 2y agoAnd the notion of credit has been a thing even longer than both money and banks. You don't need to carry money around for every little transaction if people know you're good for it someday in the the future.
- verzali 2y agoDon't you need an idea of credit for money to work at all? You need to be able to trust that the shiny rock you give me today for my wheat will be worth anything tomorrow when I want some of your meat.
- rendaw 2y agoI've heard that a lot about cryptocurrency, but aren't there plenty of cryptocurrency users who have never lost their wallet and have good personal opsec? Maybe the issue is trying to force one solution for everyone.
- airstrike 2y agoThe claim that most humans are prone to losing keys isn't negated by the existence of some humans that have (so far) been able to keep their keys.
- wpm 2y agoThe issue in not trying to force one solution for everyone becomes a blocker when you intend on making some technology useful and essential to everyone, hence, no one seriously gives a damn about crypto anymore.
- rblatz 2y agoEven Bitcoin core developers, which should be well above average in understanding crypto and good opsec, have had their Bitcoin stolen.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nick3443 2y agoMaybe instead of a crypto brokerage holding your wallet, there can be a "key bank" which uses those more expensive methods of attestation and you can use it for recovery if you lose your key up to once per year or something. It would be like having your key written down in a safety deposit box at a local or regional bank.
- firesteelrain 2y agoThis is the same problem that you run into with secret zero and commonly discussed in context of HashiCorp Vault. At some point you need to store the unlock keys then you need another repository under RBAC to protect that repository. They say to print out the keys and store them offline on paper but how many own a Class 5 safe ?
- tasuki 2y agoHow many own a lot of books? Just... pick one.
- firesteelrain 2y agoNot following? Do you know what I meant by a Class 5 safe? https://www.norfolksafe.com/ https://www.norfolksafe.com/
- tasuki 2y agoI don't. And frankly I don't think a safe is a good place to store secrets. It is too conspicuous.
- firesteelrain 2y agoThese safes are certified for all kinds of sensitive (GSA recommends them for Classified use from what I have read) use and they are safe. Ideally, you connect Vault to a HSM if you need that kind of security that’s being described. HSMs are electronic safes
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> This has been my single biggest argument against blockchain/cryptocurrency stuff for years: the "lose your key, lose your wallet" thing is fundamentally incompatible with real users. This would make currency fundamentally incompatible with real users. Reality says otherwise.
- jacinda 2y agoCurrency in the real world has many, many backups. For example, if I forgot the PIN number to a very old bank account that I later find a long lost relative recently put hundreds of thousands of dollars into when they passed away, I have other avenues to recover access. They might be annoying or require work (getting an affidavit, multiple forms of ID, etc) but it's not irrevocable in the way that a strict definition of bitcoin is.
- xboxnolifes 2y agoA bank account is not currency. Cash is. You can still put cryptocurrency in a bank if you so choose.
- jjmarr 2y agoIt's a lot harder for the average person to lose 1 million dollars in cash than in Bitcoin because humans naturally understand the exchange of physical objects. If I have a duffel bag of money, it is obvious that physical possession of the bills means I can access its value. Anything negating that possession would cost me my money. I should probably keep it away from open flames and water; but it's not going to spontaneously combust. A thief would need to physically take the money in the duffel bag for me to lose the value. Meanwhile if I store Bitcoin on a USB drive the drive might randomly fail and I lose all my money (because I'm actually storing a key to access it) even though I still have the USB stick. The solution is to back up my key in multiple places simultaneously, which doesn't make sense to most people (how can money be in two places at once?) If I plug the USB stick into the wrong computer, someone can steal all my money (because they can find out what the key is) without me ever losing the USB stick. Virtually every human on Earth understands the notions of object permanence and that objects can be exchanged for other objects. This is intuitive from evolution and actual monkeys can comprehend physical currency.[1] I don't see how cryptocurrency can be on that level. [1]. https://www.zmescience.com/research/how-scientists-tught-monkeys-the-concept-of-money-not-long-after-the-first-prostitute-monkey-appeared/ https://www.zmescience.com/research/how-scientists-tught-mon...
- soerxpso 2y ago> the "lose your key, lose your wallet" thing is fundamentally incompatible with real users. You're allowed to store your key at the bank if this is an issue for you. It's less secure than memorizing it, but obviously equally as secure as your bank account is.
- throwaway290 2y agoIt is not equally secure, if bank loses you money you have recourse, if bank loses your key (a fire, a flood) it's gone.
- perceptronas 2y agoYou can store it in two or N places. Or bank can do this for you.
- throwaway290 2y agoMore places is more opportunities for the baddies to get it.
- kriops 2y agoShamir it.
- sulandor 2y agoplease wrap the whole thing as a trustworthy product
- cooljoseph 2y agoI don't understand why this was downvoted. In case it's not clear: (S)he's saying to split the key into multiple shares that can be used to reconstruct the key if you have a large enough quorum. Then store each share in a different place. As long as you don't lose too many of the shares, you'll be fine. And one baddie is NOT enough to get the key.
- cortic 2y ago>> If the answer is "they just don't get access anymore" or "a panel of their peers attests to them", your fantasy authentication system also needs a fantasy species of sentient beings to serve as users, because it won't work for humans. >This has been my single biggest argument against fiat currency stuff for years: the "lose your money, lose your money" thing is fundamentally incompatible with real users. Humans need to be able to recover from their mistakes. And yet, for the very longest time, it was the default position for humans.
- comprev 2y agoIf you accidentally burn cash you cannot recover it. The paper in your hand isn't replicated in another place. Humans have been unable to recover from mistakes since day zero
- dotancohen 2y agoFor at least 12,000 years, humans have been getting very good at holding on to physical things. Digital things, not so much. I'm a professional in the field, yet I've lost digital data in the past few years. Normal users who work in other fields? Lost cause.
- depaya 2y agoThat is a funny example to use because the US Government has a service specifically designed to help you in that situation: https://www.bep.gov/services/mutilated-currency-redemption https://www.bep.gov/services/mutilated-currency-redemption Yes obviously if your money is completely burned then it's gone, but that is generally pretty unlikely to happen. Losing your digital key is many orders of magnitude more likely to happen in my opinion. And there is - by design - absolutely no way to get it back. That makes using blockchain for anything serious completely untenable in my opinion.
- andresgottlieb 2y agoIt doesn't need to be completely burned to be gone: "No redemption will be made when (...) Fragments and remnants presented which represent 50% or less of a note are identifiable as United States currency but the method of destruction and supporting evidence do not satisfy the Treasury that the missing portion has been totally destroyed" Not that unlikely, in my opinion.
- mvitorino 2y agoAccidentally burning money is a very low probably event. Forgetting passwords or any type of memorized secret is the most likely default outcome, and chance only increases with time passing.
- sealeck 2y ago
- drdaeman 2y ago> [...] the "lose your key, lose your wallet" thing is fundamentally incompatible with real users. Humans need to be able to recover from their mistakes. Maybe it's my memory playing tricks, or I've only seen the good articles, but I believe nearly every single article about setting up a self-managed crypto wallet had stressed out the importance of having a backup. Serious ones had even explained the 3-2-1 rule. Then the hype came, with it came scams and pumps-and-dumps and NFTs and whatever, and crypto became a clusterfuck that a lot of people didn't want to touch. Yuck. That's probably the one thing cryptocurrency communities undeniably got right. Quite unlike the Passkeys, where I've yet to see any official or semi-official demo site that even has a flow for adding a second token (some actual sites do, but not the demos). We should start teaching basic backup strategies in schools. It's not some advanced rocket science, and it's a knowledge that's useful to anyone who deals with information (that is, literally anyone participating in the modern society). Also, this user unfriendliness is extremely temporary, because computers and Internet are new (at the scale of societies), and there are plenty of folks who had only started to use them later in their lives. After you lose some file or account (ideally, as a kid, so it's not something serious) you start to understand the old adage about those whose do backups and those who don't do them _yet_.
- antifa 2y agoHow many forms of backup survive "the government threw you in prison for years?" Even Gmail will refuse to authenticate a correct password with "we couldn't verify it was you" if you never binded your account to a phone and just got out of prison 3 years later.
- drdaeman 2y agoUh, well, in context of crypto - your (self-owned) crypto wallet totally would work. As for email... Sure, I guess it depends on the service and their policies. But here's an anecdote. A few years ago, I've managed to log in in to a completely forgotten 10+ years old email account, finding its password in an old backup. It worked. ¯\(ツ)/¯ If an user cannot log in with a valid credentials, without brute-forcing them, after some years of absence, it's absolutely the service's fault. Of course, in the modern world, customer issues mean nothing so anything goes. But -quoting GP post - when designing a "fantasy football" alternate authentication system for the Internet, this probably shouldn't be a thing.
- mercenario 2y agoWith current currencies you don't have an option, you HAVE to give your money to banks and accept its consequences, like losing privacy, risk of have it frozen, etc. With cryptocurrencies at least you have an option, you can leave it at a custodial wallet that can manage some of the security for you or you can have a non-custodial wallet.