4 ms·
China is investing in Linux for one simple reason - they can have someone read the source code. A (low-level?) war is going on right now between US and China -
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
China is investing in Linux for one simple reason - they can have someone read the source code.
A (low-level?) war is going on right now between US and China - and the battlefield are the hardware and software that runs the world.
Can't read the code - then we don't trust that you aren't spying on us.
Unfortunately I doubt they will extend the same rights to their citizens.
On the Nvidia side, this is either the dumbest commercial move ever,(#) or they really do have quite a lot to hide in that code.
(#) Really I cannot imagine anyone turning down an order on 10 M PCs. Whats in that code base?
Edit: @virdah - thank you for pointing out the should-have-been obvious.
- anonymfus 14y agoMicrosoft provides Windows and Office source code for Chinese government since 2003 as part of Microsoft Government Security Program.
- __alexs 14y agoCan you compile a working system from that source?
- rbanffy 14y agoDoes the Chinese government compiles and builds their own version or they trust Microsoft will use the exact same source they have shown? In Brazil we had some interesting questioning regarding the security of electronic voting systems - in 2002, I was on the team that developed the WinCE version of the electronic ballot - we had the source for the application and some of the device drivers, but we didn't have the sources for the compilers, libraries and operating system. Any of those layers could harbor a known (or unknown) backdoor that could allow tampering with the voting data. I'm pretty sure my compiler was clean (I installed my development machine from my MSDN subscription CDs before the corporate IT folks could get their hands on it, so I imagine nobody could have sneaked into my house to place the CDs in my backpack)
- ImprovedSilence 14y agoWell, there's that, and the fact that China is notorious for reverse engineering, and basically just stealing the technology and making their own knock-offs. I don't blame Nvidia for not giving them the source code.
- lucian1900 14y agoMany experts have shown that hardware specs which are sufficient for writing drivers are entirely useless for making hardware, to someone already versed in the field.
- xutopia 14y agoSo where is my WinModem driver?
- lucian1900 14y agoYou must have misread. If one has enough info about nvidia hardware in order to make a driver for nvidia hardware, the same info is not enough to make your own nvidia hardware clones.
- wpietri 14y agoSounds like plenty to make drivers for your knockoff hardware, though.
- marshray 14y agoWhy would you want to make hardware which is compatible with open source Nvidia drivers?
- joezydeco 14y agoYou sure about that? Read up about ghost-shifts in semiconductor fabs. Bunnie tells a bit of the tale in his story about counterfeit SD cards: "Very low serial numbers, like very low MAC ID addresses, are a hallmark of the “ghost shift”, i.e. the shift that happens very late at night when a rouge worker enters the factory and runs the production machine off the books" http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=918 http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=918
- megablast 14y agoGovernments and Universities can already get access to Windows source. I think the difference is that China can write the source for Linux.
- obtu 14y agoSome governments have access to that source code, but it gives them no guarantees that what they run is faithful to it, and it doesn't let them replace the usual products with something audited. Even if they can compile something out of that source, I suspect they can't boot or run the whole thing, and they certainly can't distribute it.
- w1ntermute 14y agoUniversities are given access to Windows source? I'd never heard of this before. Do they give access to all accredited universities, or is there some other kind of restriction?
- gaius 14y agoSee http://www.microsoft.com/education/facultyconnection/articles/articledetails.aspx?cid=2416&c1=en-us&c2=0 http://www.microsoft.com/education/facultyconnection/article...
- w1ntermute 14y ago> Use of the Windows Research Kernel requires academic affiliation with an accredited institution of higher education and direct involvement in teaching and/or research, such as being academic faculty members, system or lab administrators or instructors, students enrolled in relevant undergraduate or graduate programs, or academic researchers working on faculty sponsored projects. As I thought.
- beagle3 14y agoWhen I was in University (some 16 years ago), that was already the case. However, you could only browse the source - some essential pieces were missing that made it impossible to build a working system from that code. Thus, you still have to trust that code you view is the code you run -- which is almost as bad as trusting documentation. > I think the difference is that China can write the source for Linux. I think the key here is that they are able to verify that the code they review is the code the run, by building the system. And, I'm aware of "reflections on trusting trust", but I'm sure that they have a clean-room bootstrapped C compiler capable enough of bootstrapping tcc or gcc and thus the linux kernel.