6 ms·
The Founder Mode Tradeoff – By Kent Beck
- tbe-stream 2y agoThe founder mode binary is way too simplistic. There are examples of successful companies all over the founder mode spectrum. What level of "founder mode" is optimal depends on a lot of factors. For example: - size of the company - available people (at every level of the company) - type and number of products (is it possible to scale the work over different departments?) - qualities/personalities of the founders (trust me when I tell you, being micromanaged by a non-technical founder on a technical product is not effective) - type of business (for example; in aviation, you're going to need a lot of certification management) And you can execute poorly all over the spectrum, even when making the right choice on the level of "founder mode".
- steveBK123 2y agoPrecisely. The causation direction is reversed. A lot of whether "founder mode" or whatever the opposite works has more to do with the personality of the founder. Some founders are going to fail in either mode. Successful founders have their preferred mode but aren't succeeding because of the mode. I suppose if a successful founder was in some way forced (by who?) to use the opposite of their preferred mode they'd have more difficulty, but they still are likely to succeed.
- Waterluvian 2y agoPeople like Paul seem to have just so much to say about startups for such a long time that at some point it starts to feel like they’re coming up with stuff to have things to keep saying. The binary state is too simplistic. But it is largely the hook to make the post attractive and successful.
- tbe-stream 2y agoIt matches the popular sentiment among some engineers that professional management is useless or even harmful.
- nick3443 2y agoI feel this but how many long term successful companies exist with no professional management folks? Beyond Valve, are there more than a few existence proofs?
- tbe-stream 2y agoMy impression: there are very few and for good reasons.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoI'd say Valve isn't even that successful at managing. IMO they lucked into a huge market demand and did a competent job. Yet haven't managed to produce HL3 after several attempts. There are also some horror stories from former employees of a shadow hierarchy and popularity contests.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoNot exactly. Let's say I'm a founder. I am one with the vision of what we're trying to build. Can a professional manager do that better than I can? Can he/she make the calls about what's in or out of scope, or what the architecture needs to be, better than I can? No and no. So it's not that professional management is harmful, just that it's worse than the founder can do. And in a startup, that's likely true. But founders don't scale, and there comes a point in the growth of a company where it quits being true.
- sanderjd 2y agoYou may be right about the answer for any individual decision, but for the universe of all decisions, the answers are yes and yes, because any decision is better than no decision, and a culture where only the founder's decisions are good enough is a culture that has a massive bottleneck in its ability to make decisions.
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoIt depends on three things: how fast the founder can make decisions, how fast the managers can make decisions, and how many total decisions there are to make. Founders often can make decisions more quickly than managers. They can also revisit decisions more quickly than managers. If the company is small, the founders can be a win - especially with higher-quality decisions.
- cm277 2y agoAgreed; I dont remember the source but I much prefer the Marines → Navy → Police continuum. Some circumstances require a highly capable team with high communication, aligned goals and motives, who can take decisions individually or at a low enough level. Some circumstances require bureaucracy, process, external and internal controls. The dumb "Founder mode" discourse hides away two things: a) scale forces you to climb that ladder towards bureaucracy and controls anyway, b) it's scope-specific. You don't want to go "Founder mode" on phone support. Or accounts payable, or probably HR. There are specific objectives, projects and also circumstances that need a more hands-on approach. And honestly a "Marines" analogy where the team is tight and authorized to make decisions, is better than some micro-managing, coke-fueled "Founder mode".
- tbe-stream 2y agoIndeed, often a mix of both types of processes is needed within a company. For those who are not familiar with it, check out Jeff Bezos’ 1997 Letter to Shareholders on irreversible (Type 1) vs. reversible (Type 2) decision making.
- hiatus 2y agoCan you link to the letter you are referring to? The top few results of my search had no mention of reversible decision making.
- lelanthran 2y agoTry searching for 1-way vs 2-way decisions
- hiatus 2y agoHere is the 1997 letter to shareholders that I found: https://venturebeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/amzn_shareholder-letter-20072.pdf https://venturebeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/amzn_shar... edit: I think I found it: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000119312516530910/d168744dex991.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1018724/000119312516...
- conductr 2y agoIt amazes me how much people seems to want someone like PG to just give them a single one size fits all solution to all their founder problems. It just will never exist for any particular person/company/situation. The trick is to be aware of the differing modes and when to apply them. And also, knowing these things can be useful when receiving external advise (investors, advisors, etc) as far as evaluating whether the advise would even work for your situation. Where founder mode can be felt is when a founder has a "Vision" for their company, perhaps one that is difficult for others to see. They lean into the functional areas of their company that make strides into executing that vision and bringing it to reality. This is where they probably should exercise Founder mode. Other functions of the company may be support areas or lower impact areas towards realizing the vision, or just benefit from a particular domain expertise, this is where Manager mode likely comes into play. Although, I don't like the framing of "hire smart people and let them do good work" because it makes it sound like there are no goals or guardrails to what they are doing. The founder still needs to set expectations and monitor, and this even changes over time as next years goals for this team/individual will be different than this years. In any case, hiring good people is most likely still going to be important. I think in most cases even a founder with a great vision needs to be challenged by their employees (Founder asks for X, but Engineer makes a case for Y). You don't want to squash collaboration and morale. Although, if you're lucky enough to be an exceptional Founder then your employees will tolerate it, it's probably not a good strategy to bank on though.
- jppope 2y agoThough I think this article could be better, Kent is off in the right direction. Paul is unusually ambiguous about "founder mode" in his essay. Implicitly, he was saying that founders have a super power by not just letting good people do good work, that they (the founders) should involve themselves in decisions/discussions/work that professional managers should/could not. Many of us understand what he's going after, but he really didn't articulate it well. Kent basically makes that point in this essay by attempting to break it down and provide a more concrete foundation for the concept. My issue with both articles is that they are ignoring the curse of knowledge that these outlier founders have, and from that they are ruining their own paradigm... If you ask a top performing athlete how to be a top performing athlete its likely not going to be very useful advice if its directed at a novice. However in a conversation between those top performers there will be the nuance and the context to what they are trying to express that can make it true. I'm happy that Kent wrote this article, but I really think PG would benefit from revisiting his article to provide what he actually means to the rest of us.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hzay 2y agoHe meant that micromanaging and getting into details is good (not disparaging him here, fwiw I agree with him), but he didn't want to come right out and say it. Also, I think he's not yet sure what else it involves -- like the 100 ppl party thing. He just knows it's not delegation.
- gabesullice 2y ago> He meant that micromanaging and getting into details is good This isn't what I took away, but it may be that we're saying the same thing differently. My takeaway was that founders should 'trust, but verify'. And where they disagree/don't understand, they should question and pursue the truth of the matter rather than defer to experience.
- gwd 2y ago> I really think PG would benefit from revisiting his article to provide what he actually means to the rest of us. I read PG's article as explicitly saying, "I'm not going to talk about what Founder Mode is yet because nobody has any idea what it is. A whole bunch have us have only just realized that it's a thing, and it isn't X. Now that we know it exists, let's try to figure out what it is, rather than what it isn't." Most of the reactions I've seen so far seem to be implicitly assuming that if Founder Mode isn't X, it must be -X; that is, if it's not "Hire good people and let them do their jobs", then by logical necessity it must be "Hire mediocre people and run around micromanaging, countermanding orders, and generally undermining them." (Or maybe -0.5X, which is like X but more moderate: "Hire decent people and supervise them closely, occasionally countermanding orders.") I doubt very much that's at all what Paul, or any of the other people at the talk he mentioned, had in mind. It's a false dichotomy. The first step in breaking out of a false dichotomy is realizing that what you're facing isn't a dichotomy; the second step is figuring out what the other options are. Loads of people responding seem not to have made the first step yet. EDIT: The real goal of Founder Mode is probably to optimize for something completely different, which in some cases means deviating from the "Hire good people and let them do their jobs" guidance. But the point isn't to aim at deviation, the point is to aim at this other thing which might cause deviation. Micromanaging for no other reason than that you see other successful founders sometimes micromanage is just cargo culting.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- marcinzm 2y agoAs I see it, certain founders can function well in founder mode due to their knowledge, personality and luck in term of business positioning. Most can't. Most founders also won't make $100b companies. The latter type of founder trying to work in founder mode will make things much much worse and often result in going from a $1b exit to $0b exit.
- elawler24 2y agoThis is key. The founder that creates the next Airbnb or Stripe has some unique mix of ability, connections, and character that makes them uniquely suited to drive value for that specific business. The original article didn't read as carte blanche to be a micro-manager, but rather permission to continue caring deeply about the details.
- mergy 2y agoAppreciate the added depth around the addition consequences of founder mode. I worry that 'founder mode' will be taken as 'be an a-hole' v2 or something as v1 was to mimic the success of Steve Jobs. Being an a-hole was an aspect of Jobs but not the source of his success. Being an a-hole is not itself a gateway or required attribute for success as was the popular takeaway there. Micromanaging, buzzing around, and bypassing structure should not be the takeaway from 'founder mode' or you will have bad leaders excuse those tendencies and chalk it up to being in 'founder mode' after graduating from 'a-hole'.
- neilv 2y ago> Founder CEOs have 3 (at least) advantages that give them a unique ability to create value (i.e. increase the survival chances). [...] Incentives. Professional managers are also playing an iterative game, looking to their performance in this gig to set up their next gig. The Founder CEO is all in on this hand. I want everyone in an early startup thinking like this. Which also means it should be treated as the team's company -- not only that of the founders -- and there should be life-changing money and career growth for everyone if this is successful. (Not a pittance in ISOs, and not pushed back to scratch, practicing Leetcode hazing for the chance to work in the next someone-else's company.)
- talkingtab 2y agoGee whiz. I guess this is just confirmation that postings are simply fodder for each person's own conceptual model of the world. My reading of Paul's post was something entirely different. What I took away (as opposed to whether it was in the article or not ), what I took away was the idea that founder mode is about the rejection of orthodoxy and the triumph of what I call "original thinking". We humans can be the next best thing to lemmings. We do what we see people around us do whether and what we learn in class and from others who we think know something. Is that because we are lemming like or is it because it allows us to deal with the overwhelming chaos of the world? My best illustration of this: I had two friend who went to Nepal for two years. This happened a long time ago. They came back to the US and went to a market and nearly had nervous break downs. In Nepal, they had soap. One kind. In the US they had 200 kinds of dish soap alone. They had no idea which soap to choose, and that extended to almost every product they needed. Our follow instinct - if you see someone else pick up a kind of dish soap, get that - helps us deal with this overwhelming complexity and does well for us. Except when it doesn't. What happens when you are faced with something new? In lemming mode we tend to go wrong when something is new. Really new. Like networking was new. Or little mp3 players (you know - those things that became iPods then iPhones and all the little iPhone killers like the zune.) My take away then was about something completely different, although probably unrelated to either Paul's article or this response. If you are to be a founder, one of the biggest challenges will be to build an organization that does not descend into orthodoxy. [side note: I think founder mode is a misnomer because you can be an original thinker/doer without being a founder] [side note: There are really two situations where you want to be in original thinker mode: when there is something new or when the environment changes dramatically. We are in a time where the latter is true]
- tonetheman 2y ago[dead]
- Ozzie_osman 2y ago> I think Paul is essentially right but that the way he expresses his idea is shallow, ineffective, & prone to cause unneeded suffering. I agree with this so much. I'm a huge fan of PG and his essays have been instrumental for me since I was in college. But that Founder Mode essay was so shallow. It's not a dichotomy. You don't choose between "black box management" and tyrannical micromanager. You hire smart people. You give them some room, but not black box. You trust but verify. Sometimes you have to be involved in the details, sometimes you don't. It is extremely situational. But that's just management. You have to decide based on the situation how involved you need to be. So much suffering will result because of misinterpretation of that essay. Founders everywhere thinking "I knew it! I should never trust anyone. I should do everything myself". Yea, good luck with that, Steve Jobs. Note: I'm a founder, several times over. I've also worked at a FAANG and at mid-stage startups for other founders. Obviously I'm no PG, but I think I've seen multiple perspectives.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- musha68k 2y agoFWIW the whole "Founder Mode" storyline just sounds like the further extension of Elon Musk's radius of influence into the heart of SV outright. Of course there are upsides to having leadership that actually cares and is not afraid to get their hands dirty when they spot a problem wherever it may be. That's not new but I can fully get behind that. Outside of shareholder value, companies and their products actually could care much more, always. I'd wager Steve Jobs fell just more onto a spectrum there rather than this more discrete proposal. My guess is, this will likely follow the twitter->x trend we've been observing since 2022 – and as either investor or worker it will be even more about picking the character of a company.
- knuckleheads 2y agoLet's give founder mode the mathematician's treatment, generalizing it to something more well understood and then reexamining the specifics. To my ears, the discussion around founder mode can be heard as a discussion around a qualified principal-agent problem, where the principal is the founder and the agent is anybody and everybody else the founder has to bring on in order to further the founder's vision and desires for the business. >The principal–agent problem refers to the conflict in interests and priorities that arises when one person or entity (the "agent") takes actions on behalf of another person or entity (the "principal"). The problem worsens when there is a greater discrepancy of interests and information between the principal and agent, as well as when the principal lacks the means to punish the agent. The deviation from the principal's interest by the agent is called "agency costs". - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_proble... This isn't a conflict that can be escaped, only managed, something inherent within any large organization, notwithstanding the specifics of the startups in discussion here. Hiring employees is hard and costs money that could otherwise be spent on the business or dividends back to founders and investors, and if founders could avoid having to hire others, they would. But, founders having a limited amount of time and specialization, must hire others lest the business die on the vine as opportunities pass them by for lack of available people/time to perform the necessary labor to take advantage of them. The second and third sentence in that definition from Wikipedia is why I am writing this comment. Within the terms introduced above, I think PG is advocating that founder's should work harder to reduce agency costs by getting better at punishing their agents. Punish is a strong term here to use for sure! However, if you ask the agents, i.e. the employees of the founder, much of the behavior advocated by proponents of founder mode is punishment. Micromanagement of projects, subverting the established lines of communication, second guessing the details of the agents' work and opinions, all of these things are often seen by agents/employees as undermining their agency and feelings of security within the organization. Ask a product manager whether they actually want the founder to read and comment on all of the technical specs and reports the PM and their team produce and I imagine most of them would grimace. They would much prefer if the founder stuck to being given the "right" information by the PM and the founder presenting their feedback in the right settings/meetings. Going outside of that would restrict the agency of the product manager and might very much feel like a punishment. I've most often seen founders/higher ups get involved in a team's work directly and it was often as the result of the team fucking up and the "principals" feeling like they had to step in, do some light to heavy punishment through their involvement, and set things right. Punish is still a harsh word to use here, but there is a fundamental conflict of interest that can't really be escaped. I'll make the assertion that most employees do not directly share the founder's interest in making the founder wealthy. Employees have their own interests, whether it be working on something cool, furthering their own careers, getting their own slice of wealth, or just having a steady job while they live life outside of work. The founder wants tools to win the conflicts that occur between the founder's desire to increase their wealth and the employees sometime desire to do an action that, in the founder's opinion, harms the chance of that happening. To me, in my eyes, founder mode has been a implicit discussion of this conflict at the heart of the principal agent problem, with both sides talking past each other about the necessity and efficacy of common punishment techniques. Principals keep saying they need more ways to correct deviations from their visions and agents replying by saying that often times those corrections do more harm than good. Neither of them are wrong per se, but it does feel like a misunderstanding between the two groups that'll just cause more harm than good in the long run. Founders giving themselves leeway to indulge in punishing their employees for perceived deviations from the founder's interest will likely end in nothing worthwhile, while agents/startup employees resisting outright or implicitly any punishment/correction from the founder will likely cause the employee to get even more punishment. The ideal successful founder experiencing success goes through a rapid metamorphosis from exceptional individual contributor, to team lead of a small team, to team manager of a large team, to a manager of managers of many teams, to department head of many such managers, to chief executive officer of many hundreds or thousands. At each stage, the founder needs to learn how to correct and prevent their employees from deviating from the founder's desired outcomes. A lot of the replies from employees has been from within the context of their experience at the hands of founders who did not manage this transition and learning process well. The CTO that had to approve every pull request of the hundred person technical team, the CEO who had to interview every incoming employee and slammed the recruiting process to a halt, the founder who showed up to the team meeting and threw the product road map away and started over to the dismay of the engineering teams. Each time, the founder trying to keep the organization headed in the right direction, i.e. making the founder and the investors wealthy, but not really knowing how to do this well and fucking up in the process. MBA's have a set toolbox for how to punish at scale in very large organizations that has been refined over centuries. Founders have tried applying this to their startups and found them to be lacking, too heavy handed and lacking in refinement for the smaller scales they are often operating on. Eventually, the founder hopes that they might lead an organization successful and large enough that they might need to use such tools, but for now, they are stuck making it up on the fly while also trying to do literally everything else. Part of the discussion of founder mode to me has been around founders having a discussion about how to actually effectively make these corrections at various stages of growth of a business. I'll wrap this up by restating PG's point: the best founders know how to punish in ways that don't scale. The principal-agent problem will always be there, cannot get around it. My hope is that the discussion around founder mode is less about founder's giving themselves license to do whatever they feel like whenever they feel like it, and more around the development of a toolbox for founders to punish employees for deviating from the founder's goals that precludes what could broadly be considered abusive or ineffective.
- AbstractH24 2y agoI just told my wife about "founder mode," and she asked me 100% seriously if I was talking about an article from The Onion. For the win.