3 ms·
I'm talking about what libraries are allowed to do, the non-digital version of lending. It fails every fair use test, but they're allowed to do it. The only d
by Dylan16807 2y ago
I'm talking about what libraries are allowed to do, the non-digital version of lending. It fails every fair use test, but they're allowed to do it.
The only difference is whether technically copying happens, because controlled digital lending has the same results as a system that involves no copying. It doesn't have the common definition of copying where two people can access two copies at the same time.
If IA came first, and libraries came second, would we refer to libraries as having a technicality/exception that lets them be legal?
Though I suspect that if libraries were invented right now they'd be declared illegal.
- tptacek 2y agoNo fair use test applies to the lending of physical books, which do not create copies and are not governed by the Copyright Act.
- Dylan16807 2y agoThey don't have to pass the test, but they still fail it. Please look at what I'm actually saying instead of snapping off replies that don't address my point. (And yes I edited in another couple sentences but the part about libraries not copying was in the original version of both those posts.)
- tptacek 2y agoThey can't "fail" it; the test simply doesn't apply to them. "Fair uses" governs the legitimate creation of unauthorized derived works. Lending a physical book does not create a derived work. (You're fine editing; I edited too, just for clarity).
- Dylan16807 2y agoYou can still apply the elements of the test to them, and they fail every element. Let me try making my post a list of bullet points. * Libraries are allowed because technically it's not copying, and otherwise would be very illegal. Agree or disagree? * Controlled digital lending is only copying on a technical level, not in the traditional sense where more than one copy can be accessed simultaneously. Agree or disagree? * If CDL could somehow remove that technicality and do pure digital transfers, it would be fine. Agree or disagree? * A better version of copyright would ignore that technicality. Agree or disagree?
- tptacek 2y agoCopying has a specific definition under the law. Physical lending of books does not come close to meeting it. Applying any of the fair use tests to physical book lending thus does not make any sense. It's like applying the Central Hudson Test to my cooking of a grilled cheese sandwich: it's lawful, the government has minimal interest in regulating it, none of that matters because my sandwich isn't expressive. If your whole point is that we could tear down all of copyright law and replace it with a system that allowed IA CDL, then, sure. We could do a lot of things. I'm not really here for that argument (because there just isn't enough to nerd out about in it, not because I have any problem with the exercise). But as for the law as has existed in the United States for the last 50-odd years, I'm reminded of the words of a young Baltimore entrepreneur, who infamously said "you want it to be one way --- but it's the other way".
- Dylan16807 2y ago> If your whole point is that we could tear down all of copyright law and replace it No, no, not at all. In this situation I just want to change the definition of "copy" slightly. (And to point out that slightly different definitions of terms would make libraries illegal. There's nothing special about the current definitions. In particular they're not the most straightforward definitions at all. Again, none of this is about radical change, just looking at where small tweaks would get us.)
- tptacek 2y agoThere is no reasonable definition of "copy" that would make the lending of a physical book a copy. The word "copy" literally exists to differentiate other actions from that action.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> There is no reasonable definition of "copy" that would make the lending of a physical book a copy. But it could count as distribution. Copyright covers that. Library style distribution could be just as illegal as CDL style copying, by barely changing anything.