5 ms·
Really, anyone with a 401k or similar investments has benefited from this. That's a lot of middle class folks. Your parents, your grandparents, and very likely
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Really, anyone with a 401k or similar investments has benefited from this. That's a lot of middle class folks. Your parents, your grandparents, and very likely you. It's far from limited to the super-wealthy.
- anotherhacker 2y agoNot quite. This behavior leads to firing of middle-class workers. John Deere just laid off 300 workers, moved the factory to Mexico, engaged in buyback, and gave the CEO a huge pay. So, yeah, it helps your 401k, but in the mean time you don't have a job. And if you do have a job, your salary is not increasing in line with inflation...
- TylerE 2y agoCompanies should be prohibited from doing buybacks for, say, 5 years, after any layoff.
- Ekaros 2y agoJust straight up ban them. Have to pay taxes on investment due to dividends? Well too bad for you.
- marcosdumay 2y agoJust tax them, they'll disappear.
- mulmen 2y agoTax what? The buy back? How does that work? The seller is already paying capital gains tax.
- marcosdumay 2y agoThat doesn't require that the government don't tax the profit that allowed the buyback. The US taxing almost no kind of corporate profit is an oddity, and they can carve more exceptions to any kind of reinvestment they decide.
- frikk 2y agoI recently learned that buybacks and short selling historically have not been legal, its only in recent history that they've been standard practice en large (1982 is when buybacks were legalized, I think)
- layer8 2y agoIt’s part of Reaganomics. Buybacks weren’t explicitly illegal beforehand though, it just wasn’t clear when they would count as stock price manipulation.
- joejohnson 2y agoThe 401k is an invention that is yet to prove its efficacy. The first 401ks were opened in 1978, so if you were entering the workforce then you’d be retiring this decade! So, we will see if this privatization of pensions really benefits us all or merely enriched a generation of asset managers while absolving the corporate and the government from providing pensions for workers.
- kbolino 2y agoTraditional pensions are fundamentally unsustainable endeavors under modern demographics. You cannot pay decent benefits to a growing retired population while collecting reasonable dues from a shrinking working population. As we've seen, all retirement funds, even the remaining pensions, have largely switched their investments to the stock and bond markets in the vain hope that this fundamental conundrum will be solved through moonshots and financial tricks. The 401(k) is just one piece of a much bigger puzzle.
- vineyardlabs 2y agoI agree with your general idea here but could it not be argued that pensions are just an abstraction on top of 401ks in the sense that if the demographics are shifting such that non-producers outweigh producers then you would expect the economy and business profits to suffer. These effects would cause broad slow growth or even reductions in business valuations, and therefore poor performance in investment accounts broadly.
- kbolino 2y agoYes, and I think that describes the past few decades in Japan (among other factors). Other options included pensioners taking a haircut and/or workers taking a paycut, neither of which is particularly palatable and still runs us into the ground eventually. Increasing corporate taxes could square the circle for a little while, but then corporations would slowly move more operations offshore, decreasing tax revenues eventually anyway. There's also the option of cutting other government expenditures, but eventually that stops working and at least some of the things that were cut can't stay un(der)funded forever. The only other (distantly) feasible idea I can think of would be, again with an eye to Japan (of the past), near-total isolation from other countries economically, but that would have an even more substantial stagnating effect.
- ryandrake 2y agoIt's a lot, but still it's only ~50% of US households[1]. So the other 50% are not benefiting at all from a rising stock market, except very indirectly (companies with happy earnings reports less likely to lay them off). And even that indirect benefit is not a given. 1: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scf/dataviz/scf/chart/#series:Retirement_Accounts;demographic:all;population:1;units:have https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/scf/dataviz/scf/chart...
- delfinom 2y agoYep. But I'm so extremely skeptical the "your 401k will always go up by 10%" argument is going to continue to hold for more decades. Eventually the blood they are squeezing out from companies and consumers will run out...
- gizmo 2y agoIf the US economy keeps growing then American businesses will do well and the stock market will reflect that. It’s hard to image scenarios where the American economy shrinks while other countries have growing prosperity.
- ok_dad 2y agoMaybe if prices doubled over a few years, housing was out of reach, and salaries were stagnant it would be harder to buy stuff and the economy would suffer. Whoops!
- oezi 2y agoIf the US economy grows 5% and stocks grow more, then there must be a reckoning coming at some point. If it is 5 years or 10, nobody knows.
- consteval 2y ago> It’s hard to image scenarios where the American economy shrinks while other countries have growing prosperity I don't understand this viewpoint - this seems like the obvious end result of the last 50 ish years of tomfoolery. The US doesn't make anything anymore, our economy is purely theoretical. We're lying on a huge scale and scamming, and that's how we have our economy. We gave up entire industries - and almost all of them - to foreign countries. China, Korea, Japan, Bangladesh and on and on. Yes, these companies are "American". In name only. All the capital, all the means of production - which is the actual "economy" here - is being held by not us. We literally just gave up our means of production. What we did then is made up a bunch of fake jobs to justify these companies in the US and to extract money from these developing countries. It's only a matter of time before they wisen up and realize they have all the capital. Granted, not all industries are like this. Just most.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nostrademons 2y agoOnly if it's still high when you go to retire. It probably will not still be high when you go to retire, because the very act of many people drawing on their stock portfolios to fund retirement will put downward pressure on stock prices. Ironically, if you happen to have made lots of money in the stock market over the last 10-15 years, your best strategy may be to retire now, mid-career, even if you don't have enough to last the rest of your life. Basically you're arbitraging the large labor force of today to fund your time off through high stock values. Then when the market crashes, the recovery will likely be in all-new firms in all-new industries, so you reinvent yourself to capitalize on the labor shortage then. Or even better, start one of those new firms and capitalize on all the workers who need to go back to work because they can't afford their retirements. You can't do that with a 401k, though, it'd have to be a taxable investment account that you can withdraw at will.
- sangnoir 2y ago401k's are a lot like a bunch of ranchers granting their herds 0.01% of their Cattle futures portfolios. Less hyperbolic - the existence of large pools of capital without a voice on the boards is partly responsible for the management-led short-termism mess we're in.